Fictional Novels

  • Thread starter Thread starter Augustine3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Augustine3

Guest
Hi Everyone

For some reason I’ve got this idea in my head that fictional novels detracts us from focusing on living a saintly life. Every time i pick up a novel I think “maybe I should be reading scripture or some spiritual book or just pray instead of wast8ng my time on this novel”. I just find novels very relaxing and interesting.

I don’t know of any saints that spent their recreational time reading novels. Can some someone please set the record straight or knock some sense into me…
 
You have to remember that many Catholic saints lived during times when most people couldn’t read and books were not readily available, and the limited printing resources of the time were more likely to be putting out important books on history, religion or philosophy than some fiction work, so reading novels was not something that one could just nip on down to the bookstore or library and do. Also, a lot of Catholic saints were priests and/or members of religious orders, and as such had extremely limited leisure time for reading for pleasure or doing anything else for pleasure. Finally, when people composed biographies of the saints in past eras, their leisure activities were probably not considered very important, so a saint may well have read some novel but that fact wasn’t considered important by their biographer and wasn’t captured.

Having said that, St. Thomas More probably read novels, as he himself wrote one called Utopia. More was a member of the privileged class in England and wasn’t a priest or religious, which taken all together meant he could read, had the money to acquire books, and the time to read them for enjoyment.

He’s not a saint yet, but Blessed Pier Giorgio Frassati’s favorite book was Dante’s Divine Comedy, which is fiction.

St. Pope John Paul II highly praised Henrik Sienkewicz’s novel Quo Vadis? He also wrote a fictional play called The Jeweler’s Shop.

I’m pretty sure that St. Edith Stein read a few novels during her long life as a student and academic, before she finally entered a convent.

Again not a saint, but Bl. Pope John Paul I’s book Illustrissimi has him giving his views on dozens of authors like Mark Twain and literary characters like Pinocchio. It’s obvious he read a lot of fiction to be able to write the book.

Pope Francis’ favorite book is reportedly a novel, The Betrothed by Alessandro Manzoni.

Please also remember there are a lot of novels that are considered “great Catholic novels” such as Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited, Greene’s The Power and the Glory, and Undset’s Kristin Lavransdatter.

I hope this is helpful. But I also think you need to look at why you feel you need to deny yourself a little pleasurable rest break doing something you enjoy. If the novels you read aren’t containing anything that would lead you personally away from God, then it’s not harmful to spend some time relaxing and enjoying one,
 
Last edited:
When you read novels, perhaps read spiritually edifying things?

But as long as it is at least neutral it is OK, but I feel like you’re not one to settle for Ok
 
I read clean novels only. I read Catholic or historical fiction as well as the Sherlock Holmes series. If something immoral happens to come up, I skip the pages.
 
Here’s the thing. Why stop at questioning reading novels as a time you could be spent reading about God? TV, sports, playing games, hobbies… They all take time away from reading about God.

I don’t think God objects to people reading novels or engaging in other things for relaxation or enjoyment, so read away. 🙂
 
Last edited:
fictional novels detract us from focusing on living a saintly life.
This is nonsense. Fictional novels are a wonderful pursuit, intellectually, emotionally and even spiritually. Good books inspire, lead us to virtue, allow us to explore deep concepts, provide a refuge in times of stress and can even be good for our health. Of course, novels which lead us to sin are another story altogether. Pornographic novels in particular pose a vile harm. Yet novels which don’t lead us to sin should never be abandoned, rather treasured like the riches they are. Even Jesus Himself employed stories in His ministry.
“maybe I should be reading scripture or some spiritual book or just pray instead of wast8ng my time on this nove
There is an appropriate time for us to enjoy good and healthy hobbies in life. God calls very few of us to lives of such extreme penance that require giving up fictional reading. Indeed, many novels can bring us closer to God and inspire us to holiness.

Philippians 4:8 “For the rest, brethren, whatsoever things are true, whatsoever modest, whatsoever just, whatsoever holy, whatsoever lovely, whatsoever of good fame, if there be any virtue, if any praise of discipline, think on these things.”
 
Last edited:
LOL i just wanted to emphasize I’m reading fiction as oppose to spiritual reading
 
Looks like my post was deleted from this thread. It was harmless and quite helpful I thought.
 
this idea in my head that fictional novels detracts us from focusing on living a saintly life. Every time i pick up a novel I think “maybe I should be reading scripture
I think this is known as religious scrupulosity. Trying too hard to live a saintly life. From my perspective, we need to give ourselves a break. Then we can come back fresher.
One way around this issue is too choose appropriate novels.
A book like “To Kill a Mockingbird” has a very saintly main character in Atticus the lawyer.
Moby Dick is another suitable one in my opinion.
If you like fantasy, “Lord of the Rings” most people would say has a Christian theme.
Any Charles Dickens novel has not only moral characters but humorous ones as well.
 
When you read novels, perhaps read spiritually edifying things?

But as long as it is at least neutral it is OK, but I feel like you’re not one to settle for Ok
Novels, plays and other fiction can be very spiritually and morally edifying. Shakespeare has a great deal to teach about the human condition, as does Dickens. They interlace it with humour and drama, of course, but the lessons are there.

Same with novels such as Faremheit 451, which teaches the pitfalls of overmuch censorship, and Brave New World, which argues against replacing religion with godless science.

My personal love is history - whether fictionalised or not. We can learn much from seeing how peoples of the past tackled the moral issues common to every society.
 
Last edited:
Novels can give us examples of good lives. I learned to practice patience under difficulties from some of Jane Austen’s heroines.
Michael O’Brien’s novels are inspiring and helpful.
I write dystopian novels from a Catholic perspective, in the hope that someone looking for answers will stumble across them and find them helpful.
 
You may skip the novels such as Love in the Time of Cholera & A Song of Ice and Fire etc…
 
Works of fiction can be as inspiring as non-fiction. They are, in a sense, a work of creation from the mind of the author. I find the best solution is a mix up of reading materials. I also try to steer toward authors whose works I find consistently uplifting, or mentally challenging. One of my favorite authors is Dean Koontz because his consistent portrayal of the strength of weakness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top