Show Me Your Ways by Hillsong is in 3/4 (waltz) time
Could be sung as Show Us Your Ways, if you have a live band. It isn’t the Bible set to music, but the sentiment is what I would think you’re looking for. That could be very nice.
Another possibility is “Make Us a Prayer” by Rita Springer
*Make me a prayer, let my prayers be a cry
Humble my heart so that you may draw nigh
Cause me to stand and cry out for this land
Cause me to be one who’s set free
To stand, as a house of prayer
Make us a prayer, let our prayers be a cry
Humble our hearts so that you may draw nigh
Cause us to stand and cry out for this land
Cause us to be a people set free
Who stand as a house of prayer*
When you narrow the selection down, try to dance to your selections before you make a final choice. You’re going to find some have a tempo and emotion that suits the two of you better than others.
If you have your heart set on a song from the Bible, I’d find the 5-6 passages you’d find the most appropriate and see if they have been set to appropriate music or inspired songs that would work for you. I think that will be easier that running through all the hymns you can find set to the right meter to see if they sound like your first dance as a married couple.
