First Dates

  • Thread starter Thread starter Inquiringperson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just curious, and a serious request: do you have references of this clear and consistent teaching of the church with regards to the husband being the head if the family? I would like to understand this more, Besides just St Paul’s admonition to wife’s being submissive to their husbands. Maybe a reference to the catechism or a Papal document?
A good place to start is the duties of a husband and the duties of a wife which are explained in the Catechism of the Council of Trent.

Pax and God bless.
 
A good place to start is the duties of a husband and the duties of a wife which are explained in the Catechism of the Council of Trent.

Pax and God bless.
What’s wrong with a post-Trent Catechism, e.g. the latest edition coming out in this century?
 
What’s wrong with a post-Trent Catechism, e.g. the latest edition coming out in this century?
I didn’t say there was anything wrong with it. The two complement each other, and one aides in understanding the other. You can’t fit the entire faith in a book- in either book- some topics are addressed more in depth in one or the other. For this particular question, Trent addresses it more directly.

Pax and God bless.
 
What’s wrong with a post-Trent Catechism, e.g. the latest edition coming out in this century?
It’s also worth noting that the CCC endorses the Catechism of the Council of Trent (aka Roman Catechism) as a most sure guide to the faith, and references numerous times.

Pax and God bless.
 
Yeah, but looking at Elisabethan language catechisms with an unprepared mind makes people think the wife can’t go shopping for groceries without asking her husband’s permission to leave the house. Or at least there is such potential. If we looked at mediaeval sources, we’d probably find some “lord and master” feudal language.
 
I would ask you to consider that a wife is bound by obedience to her husband unless he tells her to do something that is sinful. So, if the husband asked his wife not to leave the house and go grocery shopping, as long as it wouldn’t be sinful to obey, the wife must obey.

While reading older documents in isolation can give a skewed understanding of the faith, the same is very true of reading modern documents in isolation.

There is no “best by” date on Church teaching like a carton of milk at the grocery store. It doesn’t expire after so many years.

Pax and God bless.
 
I would ask you to consider that a wife is bound by obedience to her husband unless he tells her to do something that is sinful. So, if the husband asked his wife not to leave the house and go grocery shopping, as long as it wouldn’t be sinful to obey, the wife must obey.

While reading older documents in isolation can give a skewed understanding of the faith, the same is very true of reading modern documents in isolation.

There is no “best by” date on Church teaching like a carton of milk at the grocery store. It doesn’t expire after so many years.

Pax and God bless.
Logged on the computer this morning and read this post. Then I saw that Sharia Law is now in effect in Libya. Ironic? Sad? Both.
 
I would ask you to consider that a wife is bound by obedience to her husband unless he tells her to do something that is sinful. So, if the husband asked his wife not to leave the house and go grocery shopping, as long as it wouldn’t be sinful to obey, the wife must obey.

While reading older documents in isolation can give a skewed understanding of the faith, the same is very true of reading modern documents in isolation.

There is no “best by” date on Church teaching like a carton of milk at the grocery store. It doesn’t expire after so many years.

Pax and God bless.
Church teaching is the same in its basic substance but expression can be more perfect or less perfect, and to a certain extent it does actually answer the need of its time or place (e.g. we don’t quite have knights and lords any more, let alone slaves, and we’ve never had a samurai or brahmin class).

A husband ordering his wife around would be violating her rights as a person, ultimately her dignity, and at some point she would have the right to demand better treatment (if you look up the old sources, you will find passages on how the husband is to honour his wife as the lady of the house), in fact, she might have an obligation to admonish that sorry sinner of her husband getting drunk on power.

There’s no easy justification of a theory on husbands having free reign ordering wives around, sorry. 😉

Nor is there any monastic-like precept of obedience, just to clarify. It doesn’t get to the point there is in monasteries or armed forces. This is not an officer-soldier or superior-monk relationship. Nor a parent-child relationship, as was specifically disclaimed by 19th century papal teaching (despite having been the social norm in the middle ages).

In fact, while the husband does have certain head of family prerogatives, including perhaps some final say in decisions, I very much doubt he can actually give a proper command to his wife legitimately. Especially not when it’s on his say-so and his whim. In fact, for him to do so would be grossly disrespectful, and sinful. Apart from his being an idiot. IMHO that kind of behaviour would justify separation.
 
Church teaching is the same in its basic substance but expression can be more perfect or less perfect, and to a certain extent it does actually answer the need of its time or place (e.g. we don’t quite have knights and lords any more, let alone slaves, and we’ve never had a samurai or brahmin class).

A husband ordering his wife around would be violating her rights as a person, ultimately her dignity, and at some point she would have the right to demand better treatment (if you look up the old sources, you will find passages on how the husband is to honour his wife as the lady of the house), in fact, she might have an obligation to admonish that sorry sinner of her husband getting drunk on power.

There’s no easy justification of a theory on husbands having free reign ordering wives around, sorry. 😉

Nor is there any monastic-like precept of obedience, just to clarify. It doesn’t get to the point there is in monasteries or armed forces. This is not an officer-soldier or superior-monk relationship.
👍
 
It’s also worth noting that the CCC endorses the Catechism of the Council of Trent (aka Roman Catechism) as a most sure guide to the faith, and references numerous times.

Pax and God bless.
Well, I read that, thanks for the reference. It also tells wives not to were gold or to plait their hair. A few other thoughts come to mind:
  • First of all, St Paul also tells husbands to love their wives as Christ loved the Church, a tall order. He does not tell wifes to love their husbands. It is safe to assume that wives should love their husbands. So maybe it is also safe to assume husbands should also be submissive to their wives, each with their own sphere of family authority.
  • I grew up in a very Catholic community, large families, traditional households. I never remember witnessing any absolute dominance in authority by the husband. It always seemed to be a joint excersice of authority. And that has been my experience in our family.
  • consistent teaching? Well it is not in the new catechism. Perhaps there was a some flavor in the Trent catechism that is based on the time it was written as to what it stressed.
  • The stressing of wifes being submissive to husbands never seemed to come up much until I came upon this forum. It has made me think about it quite a bit, as most Church teaching is readily and apparently reflected in the lives of the devout, but not this one seems rather hidden. I think there is a definite over reaction to the modern feminism movement, and this over reaction is not necessarily healthy.
  • If this is the teaching, it certainly does not seem to be an absolute;as there are husbands who are wholly derelict in their duty and I suppose the Church supports the wives taking a leading role in the family in those circumstances
This may be the ONE teaching of the Church which I have a little trouble with. I can accept it, but certainly not to the level stressed by some on this forum. It is, at the very least, a very nuanced teaching that I will admit to not fully understanding, but I also would say that those who place such emphasis on it do not fully understand either.
.
 
Basically, Saint Paul told slaves to be diligent and obedient, not that they had a right to protest, refuse to do any jobs in such conditions, and claim voting rights. This didn’t stop the Church from being opposed to slavery. We now can’t got to St. Paul’s letters to compose a justification to restore slavery. I don’t think we will find a single theologian seriously claiming a person can own another person as property, or that a person kidnapped and sold into slavery has no right to attempt escape.

Saint Paul also forbade that a woman should have authority over a man. There aren’t female priests now but somehow we have had female queens, feudal ladies, politicians, doctors, professors, teachers (including religious matters), heh, in fact, there have been female monastic superiors having authority over male members.

Getting too literal isn’t good. Nor is reading all sorts of things out of a text that weren’t its basic intended sense.

The very same epistle also says “submit to one another”, although there’s no clear command for husbands to “obey” wives. I would easily construe that “one another” as a universal call to be forbearing, make concessions, not seek personal elevation over others, not assert authority without a good reason, put others’ needs before one’s own, regardless of one’s station (or the station of his neighbour). Apparently, JP2 went further and actually saw a direct link between “submit to one another” and “wives submit to husbands”. It doesn’t take a lot to notice that husband and wife leave their parents and form one flesh, cleaving to each other. It hardly seems appropriate in such circumstances to create a relationship based on command authority. I believe a husband trying to push his wife around would be sinning more than she could (if at all) sin by telling him to go away and learn some manners. Ordering around and issuing commands is not the way things are supposed to be happening in marriage (even if there might be some obligation for wives to “obey” husbands, as in heed their decisions as family heads).
 
This current discussion would be a great topic in another thread. The OP is a middle schooler that asked an innocent question about first dates. I feel bad for the kid, he just wanted a perspective on dating, not this heavy conversation.
 
This current discussion would be a great topic in another thread. The OP is a middle schooler that asked an innocent question about first dates. I feel bad for the kid, he just wanted a perspective on dating, not this heavy conversation.
Poor kid! I think he might be contemplating joining a monestary right about now!

My DH and I went for cappuccino and cannoli on our first date. I was 25 he was 27.
 
This current discussion would be a great topic in another thread. The OP is a middle schooler that asked an innocent question about first dates. I feel bad for the kid, he just wanted a perspective on dating, not this heavy conversation.
Don’t worry about it. I’m already a little mature for my age. Besides, I want to marry this girl I like because she’s a great Catholic and that would be good for our children.
 
The family is a church hierarchy- the domestic church.

That aside, it’s been the clear and consistent teaching of the Catholic Church that a husband is the head of his family, and parents hold authority over their children.
That is only partially correct. CCC 2217 states that “obedience towards parents ceases with the emancipation of the children”, so a parent’s authority over adult children is limited. In CCC 2230, when referring to relationships between parents and their adult children, it states that parents should not exert undue pressure in the choice of a profession or spouse, but that does not prevent them from offering “judicious advice”.
 
Church teaching is the same in its basic substance but expression can be more perfect or less perfect, and to a certain extent it does actually answer the need of its time or place (e.g. we don’t quite have knights and lords any more, let alone slaves, and we’ve never had a samurai or brahmin class).

A husband ordering his wife around would be violating her rights as a person, ultimately her dignity, and at some point she would have the right to demand better treatment (if you look up the old sources, you will find passages on how the husband is to honour his wife as the lady of the house), in fact, she might have an obligation to admonish that sorry sinner of her husband getting drunk on power.

There’s no easy justification of a theory on husbands having free reign ordering wives around, sorry. 😉

Nor is there any monastic-like precept of obedience, just to clarify. It doesn’t get to the point there is in monasteries or armed forces. This is not an officer-soldier or superior-monk relationship. Nor a parent-child relationship, as was specifically disclaimed by 19th century papal teaching (despite having been the social norm in the middle ages).

In fact, while the husband does have certain head of family prerogatives, including perhaps some final say in decisions, I very much doubt he can actually give a proper command to his wife legitimately. Especially not when it’s on his say-so and his whim. In fact, for him to do so would be grossly disrespectful, and sinful. Apart from his being an idiot. IMHO that kind of behaviour would justify separation.
Thanks for the comments. I pretty much agree with everything you say, and if you think of it as a rebuttal to my earlier post, then I didn’t explain myself clearly enough.

The husband-wife relationship is NOT the same as an officer-soldier, superior-monk, parent-child relationship. That is very true.

As to the question of whether or not a husband telling his wife what to do “violates her rights” it would depend on (A) what did he tell her to do and (B) how did he tell her?

There is no for anyone in authority to order someone to commit a sin, on that point alone it’s clear I’m not advocating “free reign” for anyone to order people around.

You say that husband has final say in decisions, yet you say that he can’t give a legitimate order. The two ideas are in conflict. There is a disagreement, the husband makes a final decision, he tells the wife to abide by his decision. That is an order.

The husband’s role is one of responsiblity and service, not one of bullying and ego. The Catholic ideal is for the husband and wife to model themselves on the new Adam and the new Eve- Our Lord and Our Lady. Mary is the perfect Queen, she obeys the every command of the Lord. The Lord is the perfect King, denying no request of His Lady.

Pax and God Bless.
 
Thanks for the comments. I pretty much agree with everything you say, and if you think of it as a rebuttal to my earlier post, then I didn’t explain myself clearly enough.

The husband-wife relationship is NOT the same as an officer-soldier, superior-monk, parent-child relationship. That is very true.

As to the question of whether or not a husband telling his wife what to do “violates her rights” it would depend on (A) what did he tell her to do and (B) how did he tell her?

There is no for anyone in authority to order someone to commit a sin, on that point alone it’s clear I’m not advocating “free reign” for anyone to order people around.

You say that husband has final say in decisions, yet you say that he can’t give a legitimate order. The two ideas are in conflict. There is a disagreement, the husband makes a final decision, he tells the wife to abide by his decision. That is an order.

The husband’s role is one of responsiblity and service, not one of bullying and ego. The Catholic ideal is for the husband and wife to model themselves on the new Adam and the new Eve- Our Lord and Our Lady. Mary is the perfect Queen, she obeys the every command of the Lord. The Lord is the perfect King, denying no request of His Lady.

Pax and God Bless.
So is the husband like a King, and the wife an important adviser?
 
So is the husband like a King, and the wife an important adviser?
Why quote one term directly, but ignore the other I used?

The husband is called to be a King and the wife is called to be a Queen. The Catholic meaning of Kingship is quite different from the earthly one. This is why Christ was mocked with the sign that read “King of the Jews” on the cross. Men could not believe that a King would do what he did- live a life of love, service, and sacrifice, including the sacrifice of his life on the cross. They expected a conqueror at the head of an army who would amass a fortune and live in a palace. That is not what Catholic men are called to, they are called to be like Christ. Likewise, the Queen of the universe, the most perfect woman, was not wealthy or powerful in an earthly sense. She was and is supremely loving and virtuous.

Our culture tends towards error on both sides of what the married relationship is supposed to be. We see:

-Wives running the family because the husband doesn’t care for his duties and refuses to live up to them.
-Husbands abusing their family as a tyrant because they don’t live out the most important aspect of Kingship- love.

If husbands loved their wives as Christ loved the Church, there would not be many women who refused their husbands obedience.

Pax and God bless.
 
This current discussion would be a great topic in another thread. The OP is a middle schooler that asked an innocent question about first dates. I feel bad for the kid, he just wanted a perspective on dating, not this heavy conversation.
I’m happy to see that the OP responded to this suggestion with interest in where the conversation has led.

The only reason to date- a first date, a 2nd date, a 1000th date, is that you are discerning a marriage vocation, so understanding marriage is central to making prudent decisions regarding dating.

Pax and God bless.
 
Don’t worry about it. I’m already a little mature for my age. Besides, I want to marry this girl I like because she’s a great Catholic and that would be good for our children.
Well then I hope you take the current conversation with the understanding that you’re getting only one or two points of view of what makes a good Catholic marriage, and there are many more points of view that haven’t been stated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top