I
ilovekittens
Guest
My seven-year-old, first grade son will be receiving this sacrament in a few months. My question is, why does the Church recommend this sacrament at such an early age? I don’t know if 6 and 7 year-old kids, especially my son, are really capable of sinning. He is no angel, but I think whatever wrong actions he takes are largely based on impulse rather than conscious reflection and deliberate decision. When he shoves his sister because she has his toy, that is basically an act of impulse and wrong, but I don’t think could objectively be called by anyone a sin. I don’t think people can really commit sin until the brain is fully developed and they are capable of making deliberate, rational decisions. That “wiring”/myelination of the brain isn’t fully complete until the late teen years, I think, which seems a more reasonable age to offer this sacrament.
I suppose one could argue that receiving and learning about this sacrament is a way of promoting a sense of right/wrong morality at an early age, but I still don’t really believe that any wrong action committed by someone so young could rightfully be called a sin.
What say you?
I suppose one could argue that receiving and learning about this sacrament is a way of promoting a sense of right/wrong morality at an early age, but I still don’t really believe that any wrong action committed by someone so young could rightfully be called a sin.
What say you?
As a convert, when I came into the Church, I looked upon my general confession as a real watershed. In doing my examen, I dismissed the advice I had heard that “childhood doesn’t belong here” and realized that the petty, petulant, and impulsive sins of my childhood were not somehow “different” from the sins of my adolescence and adulthood but had actually seeded the ground.