Flu vaccine and animal testing...?

  • Thread starter Thread starter onthenarrowpath
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

onthenarrowpath

Guest
As a non-Catholic, I rarely contribute anything more to these forums than my random opinion about certain subjects. When I have a question, I always use the Search function so as not to bother anyone unnecessarily. But I can’t find any information on this subject, and my mother - who is a practicing Catholic - asked me about this earlier today, so I’m asking on her behalf:

Is it morally acceptable to refuse a flu vaccination on religious grounds? A lady my mother was talking to last night stated she works in a local hospital that has required its entire staff to be vaccinated against the H1N1 virus, or risk losing their jobs. The woman does not want to be vaccinated and claims her refusal is based on religious reasons. The woman says she is Catholic, and I had to tell my mom that I’d honestly never heard of a church teaching that stated a Catholic must refuse the flu vaccine on religious grounds. The woman states her refusal is based upon the fact that the vaccine is tested on animals…or something like that. I told my mom that I think the church would be opposed if the vaccine was tested using embryonic stem cells, but I don’t know if it would be the same situation if the testing was done on non-human cells, or animals themselves. Can anyone give me any insight on this? Thanks!
 
Some Catholics act more like pagans, and talk about animal ‘rights.’ There is nothing in either Catechism or Magisterium that would compel Catholics to refuse a vaccine on grounds of animal testing.
 
Sailor is correct.

I would add that, though there is nothing explicit in Church teaching that would necessitate people to refuse vaccinations on these grounds, it is possible that this woman is attempting to apply general moral principles in this specific circumstance. Thus, it is not really a matter of “The Catholic Church forbids it; therefore, I cannot do it.” Rather, it is a matter of her own conscience that is formed by Catholic moral principles. So one might still consider it to be “religious reasons” even though it’s not mandated by the Church.

This is not to say that the woman in question is necessarily doing a good job of applying Catholic moral principles to this specific situation, but I’m sure she at least believes she is doing so. Personally, I’m more concerned about the levels of mercury in the H1N1 vaccine than I am over whether or not it has been tested on animals. 🤷
 
Thanks for the responses. What you’re saying is pretty much the same thing I told my mom…that I didn’t know of any specific Catholic teaching about it, but it was possible the woman didn’t want to violate her own conscience on the matter. I just wasn’t sure if the church would recognize that as the “religious grounds” the woman spoke of.
 
As a non-Catholic, I rarely contribute anything more to these forums than my random opinion about certain subjects. When I have a question, I always use the Search function so as not to bother anyone unnecessarily. But I can’t find any information on this subject, and my mother - who is a practicing Catholic - asked me about this earlier today, so I’m asking on her behalf:

Is it morally acceptable to refuse a flu vaccination on religious grounds? A lady my mother was talking to last night stated she works in a local hospital that has required its entire staff to be vaccinated against the H1N1 virus, or risk losing their jobs. The woman does not want to be vaccinated and claims her refusal is based on religious reasons. The woman says she is Catholic, and I had to tell my mom that I’d honestly never heard of a church teaching that stated a Catholic must refuse the flu vaccine on religious grounds. The woman states her refusal is based upon the fact that the vaccine is tested on animals…or something like that. I told my mom that I think the church would be opposed if the vaccine was tested using embryonic stem cells, but I don’t know if it would be the same situation if the testing was done on non-human cells, or animals themselves. Can anyone give me any insight on this? Thanks!
Sorry to read of your problem onthenarrowpath. The question of the use of animals by man has reached extremes these days, from genuine animal welfare activism to ‘animal rights’ activism. Let us begin with God Himself Who allowed lambs to be sacrificed to Him. God clothed Adam and Eve in animal skins. St John the Baptist wore a camel skin. Jesus told the Apostles to pull many fish aboard where the ‘sufficated’ to death.

But if you torture an animal that is considered sinful. The thing is to be able to tell the difference, the genuine use of animals for man’s use and benefit and the misuse of them in ways we all would abhor.

Perhaps your mother feels the testing of vaccines on animals can have adverse effects and this bothers her. Whether it does or not is impossible to judge as we do not know how ‘conscious’ an animal is of anything other that its instincts. The Church is neutral on the matter so there are no grounds to refuse the vaccine on religious grounds.
Her employers are perfectly entitled to make the vaccine a condition of employment. If it puts others at risk at her workplace then it is only right she retires or gets vaccinated. Given the world is subject to original sin now and there are so many things happening in it regarding animals, we cannot change it all, only look after those things that we encounter personally. Tell mom we know how she feels but not to carry the burdan with her in life. I suppose we can pray that He looks after these animals as He probably does in His infinite compassion.
 
I might add that General Electric considers the lives of lab rats to be of MORE value than human embryos. They are proudly announcing that they’ve switched from experimenting on lab rats to human fetal cells.

This is just so wrong on SO many fronts I am rendered speechless.
 
I might add that General Electric considers the lives of lab rats to be of MORE value than human embryos. They are proudly announcing that they’ve switched from experimenting on lab rats to human fetal cells.

This is just so wrong on SO many fronts I am rendered speechless.
That’s appalling! Where did you hear that?
 
Appalling indeed, and it gets no traction in the media:
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
GE says “Who needs Lab rats? We have human stem cells!”
I wish I was joking:
General Electric has announced that it will use embryonic stem cells provided by Geron Corporation for the purpose of testing toxic effects of drug treatments.
The rest of it here.
 
Part of the problem is that the morality of requiring people to be vaccinated the way that hospital is is suspect, but there may be few legitimate grounds for employees refusing. So the woman may be looking for a way to make her own moral conviction “legitimate” in the eyes of the hospital authorities. And her own conscience on this may well be related to her understanding of Catholic teaching on the proper use of animals.
 
But the Catholic teaching on the use of animals does state that medical research is a legitimate use.

Or would it be preferable to go the GE route?
 
As a non-Catholic, I rarely contribute anything more to these forums than my random opinion about certain subjects. When I have a question, I always use the Search function so as not to bother anyone unnecessarily. But I can’t find any information on this subject, and my mother - who is a practicing Catholic - asked me about this earlier today, so I’m asking on her behalf:

Is it morally acceptable to refuse a flu vaccination on religious grounds? A lady my mother was talking to last night stated she works in a local hospital that has required its entire staff to be vaccinated against the H1N1 virus, or risk losing their jobs. The woman does not want to be vaccinated and claims her refusal is based on religious reasons. The woman says she is Catholic, and I had to tell my mom that I’d honestly never heard of a church teaching that stated a Catholic must refuse the flu vaccine on religious grounds. The woman states her refusal is based upon the fact that the vaccine is tested on animals…or something like that. I told my mom that I think the church would be opposed if the vaccine was tested using embryonic stem cells, but I don’t know if it would be the same situation if the testing was done on non-human cells, or animals themselves. Can anyone give me any insight on this? Thanks!
What the woman says is totally wrong.

The teaching of the Church:

CCC 2417 God entrusted animals to the stewardship of those whom he created in his own image. Hence it is legitimate to use animals for food and clothing. They may be domesticated to help man in his work and leisure. **Medical and scientific experimentation on animals is a morally acceptable practice if it remains within reasonable limits and contributes to caring for or saving human lives. **
 
The woman may put compromised peoples lives at risk if she works with patients during the early days of getting the flu when the risk of contagion is high. It might not always be obvious to a person that they have the flu at first. She ought to get vaccinated or take time off and go out somewhere and catch the actual flu itself, after recovery she may have immunity from it.

This is not medical advise and I will not accept any liability etc., etc.
 
Thank you for all your responses…it’s been a big help. I’ve forwarded some of your responses to my mom, including the reference in the Catechism. She’s going to meet with the woman again next Tuesday at her Bible study, and has also said she may speak to the deacon about this.
 
STOP!!!
Before you go back to this woman with the information you have gathered thus far, Catholics SHOULD refuse the H1N1 virus unless absolutely forced to take it!

The H1N1 Virus vaccine contains trace elements of human DNA because it is developed by using human diploid cells. Human diploid cells are lung tissue harvested from two aborted fetuses, named, inhumanly, WI-38 and PRC-5. The church has investigated the use of human diploid cells and finds it morally reprehensible, that anyone who develops such a vaccine is considered morally equivalent to someone who commits a sin of abortion, and that anyone who does not resist taking such a vaccine is guilty of material support for abortion.

If the woman is ultimately FORCED to take the vaccine or lose her source of livelihood (or if NOT taking the vaccine would directly threaten the wellbeing of others), then she may take it, but she should still raise objection to taking it first in order to exaust all other avenues of NOT profiting from the abortion of a human fetus. The vatican report can be found here: cogforlife.org/vaticanresponse.htm
 
STOP!!!

Before you go back to this woman with the information you have gathered thus far, Catholics SHOULD refuse the H1N1 virus unless absolutely forced to take it!

The H1N1 Virus vaccine contains trace elements of human DNA because it is developed by using human diploid cells. Human diploid cells are lung tissue harvested from two aborted fetuses, named, inhumanly, WI-38 and PRC-5. The church has investigated the use of human diploid cells and finds it morally reprehensible, that anyone who develops such a vaccine is considered morally equivalent to someone who commits a sin of abortion, and that anyone who does not resist taking such a vaccine is guilty of material support for abortion.

If the woman is ultimately FORCED to take the vaccine or lose her source of livelihood (or if NOT taking the vaccine would directly threaten the wellbeing of others), then she may take it, but she should still raise objection to taking it first in order to exaust all other avenues of NOT profiting from the abortion of a human fetus. The vatican report can be found here: cogforlife.org/vaticanresponse.htm
Correction to this: two of the six varients of H1N1 vaccine contain human diploid cells, so she can take the vaccine after checking the ingredients sheet for the particular varient and being assured that it is NOT one of the types containing these cells.
 
STOP!!!
Before you go back to this woman with the information you have gathered thus far, Catholics SHOULD refuse the H1N1 virus unless absolutely forced to take it!

The H1N1 Virus vaccine contains trace elements of human DNA because it is developed by using human diploid cells. Human diploid cells are lung tissue harvested from two aborted fetuses, named, inhumanly, WI-38 and PRC-5. The church has investigated the use of human diploid cells and finds it morally reprehensible, that anyone who develops such a vaccine is considered morally equivalent to someone who commits a sin of abortion, and that anyone who does not resist taking such a vaccine is guilty of material support for abortion.

If the woman is ultimately FORCED to take the vaccine or lose her source of livelihood (or if NOT taking the vaccine would directly threaten the wellbeing of others), then she may take it, but she should still raise objection to taking it first in order to exaust all other avenues of NOT profiting from the abortion of a human fetus. The vatican report can be found here: cogforlife.org/vaticanresponse.htm
Thanks for that link! Very good to read. I do think you’re overstating the CDF’s response, however. In the realm of moral theology, material cooperation can be illicit, but it can also be justified. In this particular case, they refer to those doctors or parents who use these vaccines as carrying out “very remote mediate material cooperation”.

Yes, we should use moral alternatives if available. And, yes, we should exert pressure on the pharmaceutical companies to develop these moral alternatives and cease from pursuing immoral avenues. However, the CDF also says:

“As regards the diseases against which there are no alternative vaccines which are available and ethically acceptable, it is right to abstain from using these vaccines if it can be done without causing children, and indirectly the population as a whole, to undergo significant risks to their health. However, if the latter are exposed to considerable dangers to their health, vaccines with moral problems pertaining to them may also be used on a temporary basis. The moral reason is that the duty to avoid passive material cooperation is not obligatory if there is grave inconvenience. Moreover, we find, in such a case, a. proportional reason, in order to accept the use of these vaccines in the presence of the danger of favouring the spread of the pathological agent, due to the lack of vaccination of children.”

So, the question is whether or not there is a moral alternative and whether or not this particular virus poses a “considerable danger” to health (and thus a “proportional reason” exists to take the vaccine). I think that, in this case, Catholics may look at the evidence and come to different conclusions.
 
So, the question is whether or not there is a moral alternative and whether or not this particular virus poses a “considerable danger” to health (and thus a “proportional reason” exists to take the vaccine). I think that, in this case, Catholics may look at the evidence and come to different conclusions.
I would consider the fact that the average american has nearly five times the chance of dying from the common flu that they do of dying from H1N1 to be a good indicator that “considerable danger” is not of eminant concern for the majority of Americans… especially since viable alternatives exist within the american market (hence there is absolutely NO reason whatsoever for anyone to take a varient containing human diploid cells)
 
I would consider the fact that the average american has nearly five times the chance of dying from the common flu that they do of dying from H1N1 to be a good indicator that “considerable danger” is not of eminant concern for the majority of Americans… especially since viable alternatives exist within the american market (hence there is absolutely NO reason whatsoever for anyone to take a varient containing human diploid cells)
I agree.
 
Correction to this: two of the six varients of H1N1 vaccine contain human diploid cells, so she can take the vaccine after checking the ingredients sheet for the particular varient and being assured that it is NOT one of the types containing these cells.
Pease bear in mind that we are not banned from taking this vaccine.
Extract from the article you posted:

QUOTE

As regards the diseases against which there are no alternative vaccines which are available and ethically acceptable, it is right to abstain from using these vaccines if it can be done without causing children, and indirectly the population as a whole, to undergo significant risks to their health. However, if the latter are exposed to considerable dangers to their health, vaccines with moral problems pertaining to them may also be used on a temporary basis. The moral reason is that the duty to avoid passive material cooperation is not obligatory if there is grave inconvenience. Moreover, we find, in such a case, a. proportional reason, in order to accept the use of these vaccines in the presence of the danger of favouring the spread of the pathological agent, due to the lack of vaccination of children. This is particularly true in the case of vaccination against German measles15.

In any case, there remains a moral duty to continue to fight and to employ every lawful means in order to make life difficult for the pharmaceutical industries which act unscrupulously and unethically. However, the burden of this important battle cannot and must not fall on innocent children and on the health situation of the population - especially with regard to pregnant women.

UNQUOTE
 
I would consider the fact that the average american has nearly five times the chance of dying from the common flu that they do of dying from H1N1 to be a good indicator that “considerable danger” is not of eminant concern for the majority of Americans… especially since viable alternatives exist within the american market (hence there is absolutely NO reason whatsoever for anyone to take a varient containing human diploid cells)
Not to threadjack much, but I never get flu shots, my BIL always does, he usually gets sick anyway, I seldom do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top