For the young and easily aroused

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stylus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Stylus

Guest
The problem of getting easily aroused is what I struggle the most with. All other serious sins are so easy to know if you either commited them or did not.

In the case of last night, I was having a somewhat sad conversation with an older man who is in love with me. We were discussing our agreement of being just friends. Although I do not want to be his girlfriend I am attracted to him and at this moment I wanted to take his hand to comfort him. Maybe when I’m older this wont affect me in the same way, but I knew that just taking his hand would get me aroused. At first I deciding against it, but then a minute later he took mind and I put my hand on his. I did become aroused from it and then wondered if I had done something wrong. I don’t think it should be so easy to commit a sin especially doing something so decent as taking his hand. But it’s been on my conscience nontheless.

Did I sin?
 
In the end, only you will know the answer to your question, but here are some things to think about in formulating the answer:

In the incident, did you suspect that you would become aroused, but proceed anyway?

Did you dwell on the arousal, once it occurred?

Feelings and emotional reactions can surprise us all – at any age. They are not in themselves sinful, but unless properly handled, they can lead to sin. Remember St. Paul’s admonition on anger : be angry, but do not sin.

Perhaps this is something to bring up the next time you go to confession? Even if it be not a sin, there is nothing to lose, and grace to be gained, by bringing it before God in the Sacrament of Reconciliation.

Blessings,

Gerry
 
This si where I start to say “Who cares?”, quite frankly; when the “sin” is something so natural it actually takes an effort contrary to natural human reactions and emotions to not do it, and in fact it may be impossible not to do it. Arousal is something the human body does. When spirituality and bodily science clash I err on the side of the human body.
 
40.png
Stylus:
The problem of getting easily aroused is what I struggle the most with. All other serious sins are so easy to know if you either commited them or did not.

In the case of last night, I was having a somewhat sad conversation with an older man who is in love with me. We were discussing our agreement of being just friends. Although I do not want to be his girlfriend I am attracted to him and at this moment I wanted to take his hand to comfort him. Maybe when I’m older this wont affect me in the same way, but I knew that just taking his hand would get me aroused. At first I deciding against it, but then a minute later he took mind and I put my hand on his. I did become aroused from it and then wondered if I had done something wrong. I don’t think it should be so easy to commit a sin especially doing something so decent as taking his hand. But it’s been on my conscience nontheless.

Did I sin?
Interesting post, as I have been thinking of something along similar lines as well - basically, putting oneself in a situation where this particular unwanted physical reaction may occur.

I don’t have an answer for you, but one thing is clear - it appears you did not intend to become aroused - it was an unwilled act, that is, an undesired consequence of touching this man’s hand. If you had touched the man for the purpose of becoming aroused, I don’t think there would be any question that such would be sinful. But in this case that does not appear to be the case.

Sorry if this is not terribly helpful, as I am struggling with scruples in this area as well. My mind says “It’s not a sin,” but my scruples say “It might be.” Terrible quandry! 😛
 
40.png
Stylus:
The problem of getting easily aroused is what I struggle the most with. All other serious sins are so easy to know if you either commited them or did not.

In the case of last night, I was having a somewhat sad conversation with an older man who is in love with me. We were discussing our agreement of being just friends. Although I do not want to be his girlfriend I am attracted to him and at this moment I wanted to take his hand to comfort him. Maybe when I’m older this wont affect me in the same way, but I knew that just taking his hand would get me aroused. At first I deciding against it, but then a minute later he took mind and I put my hand on his. I did become aroused from it and then wondered if I had done something wrong. I don’t think it should be so easy to commit a sin especially doing something so decent as taking his hand. But it’s been on my conscience nontheless.

Did I sin?
It would only be a sin if you consented to the arousal, if you were doing all that you could to resist it, then it would not only not be sin, it would be possitively virtuous. But even if it were a sin, it would be venially sinful at the most.
 
40.png
Liberalsaved:
This si where I start to say “Who cares?”, quite frankly; when the “sin” is something so natural it actually takes an effort contrary to natural human reactions and emotions to not do it, and in fact it may be impossible not to do it. Arousal is something the human body does. When spirituality and bodily science clash I err on the side of the human body.
So, I take it you don’t think highly of self mortification and self discipline? Should we just let our desires roam wherever they want? By resisting what seems to be even a minor attachment, we strengthen the will and the mind. Are we human beings or are we monkeys? Gods or beasts? God has gifted us with the choice. We can direct our passions toward noble ends or we can consent to all of them and live like pigs. The choice is ours. Much of liberal ideology is just this attempt to make the world such that we can live like pigs without having to be bothered by consequences.
 
40.png
DreadVandal:
So, I take it you don’t think highly of self mortification and self discipline? Should we just let our desires roam wherever they want? By resisting what seems to be even a minor attachment, we strengthen the will and the mind. Are we human beings or are we monkeys? Gods or beasts? God has gifted us with the choice. We can direct our passions toward noble ends or we can consent to all of them and live like pigs. The choice is ours. Much of liberal ideology is just this attempt to make the world such that we can live like pigs without having to be bothered by consequences.
I didn’t say she should sleep with the man. But she can’t help having a natural bodily reaction.
 
40.png
Liberalsaved:
I didn’t say she should sleep with the man. But she can’t help having a natural bodily reaction.
Correct, but she can with the will, either consent to or resist the bodily reaction. That is where sin lies, in consenting with the will to what the body feels rather than resisting it.
 
Stylus, that’s a good question.

I gather that you would not have reached for the man’s hand on your own, because you knew you’d be aroused.

But then he took your hand, and you did become aroused, though you certainly didn’t want to.

“Twenty-twenty hindsight” tells me that you should have just taken your hand back. Then you would be sure you did not sin.

But that’s easier said than done. I’ve “been there, done that,” and it just ain’t that easy, is it? 😉

If my memory is working for once, I think you have a problem with scrupulosity, don’t you? If you’ve been working on it with your confessor, you might ask him if you need to confess this. I’m sure he knows you better than any of us. Actually, that advice is still good even if I remembered wrong.

I do have some general advice, though.

Break off your friendship with this man. Or, at the very least, tell him that he is not to touch you at all - and break off the friendship the first time he breaks the rule.

Now for my nasty suspicions… I admit up front, I don’t know the guy!

You are still quite young, aren’t you? I have the impression that you’re in high school; am I right?
  1. There are predators out there that know just how to arouse your sentiment and pity, and use it to seduce you. This ain’t book knowledge - it’s from my attendance at the school of hard knocks. It worked on me; don’t let it work on you.
  2. in general, older men who like young women, like young women. In other words, they will dump the young woman once she shows signs of maturity. Mental or physical, maturity turns them off.
  3. Even if my suspicions are groundless, and he is perfectly sincere, it still might be better to stop seeing him. It would be doing him a kindness in the long run. Letting him continue the friendship lets him keep his hopes up. And every “sad conversation” wears on your resistance.
There, advice from your old aunty roo, who has “been around,” as they say.
 
40.png
Stylus:
I don’t think it should be so easy to commit a sin especially doing something so decent as taking his hand. But it’s been on my conscience nontheless.
If by ‘becoming aroused’ you mean the same thing that a man might mean by that phrase, then you must be one of the most easily aroused women around! You did not sin. Feelings and emotions are not sins. But I will agree with Ruthie, that for your own emotional well being, you should be cautious about letting any particular man manipulate your emotions, especially if you are very young.
 
This sort of fall into the near occasion of sin area. IF we know certain situations can easily lead us to sin. then we are to avoid those situations as much as possible.

IF we purposely do not avoid these situations then we are guilty of sin, but not necessarily a mortal sin. Holding someones hand does not constitute grave matter as so is not a mortal sin. Just be aware that arousal can easily lead you into mortal sin. so that would be reason enough for you to avoid this situation again. (I would think dating would be okay if neither of you are married. IT would be tough to date and never hold hands)

More important is both of your life’s situation, IF either one is married to another person, then even arousal can be a very serious offense against one’s marital vows. No married person should hold someone else’s hand except in a gesture such as a hand shake or non sexual situation. Arousal would certainly be considered a sin against chastity.
 
The same thing has been bothering me. I know I should try to avoid the “near occasion of sin” but does that mean avoiding arousal (and therefore probably avoiding close contact–i.e. dancing, holding hands, etc.–with a girl)? Forgive me if this sounds conceited, but I’m not the type of person to go off and masturbate just if a girl arouses me. I would try to ignore the arousal. Even though I know the arousal would probably only pester me and not lead me into serious sin, should I try to avoid it anyway, on pain of sin?
All this to say: I sympathize. You should bring this to the Ask An Apologist forum; it would help a lot of us, I think. 😉
 
This happens to me too. For example, I am in the shower and I know that washing my genitals would get me aroused but I do it anyway because I need to wash them. That’s when I think I’ve sinned because I knew that would arouse me. Help please! Are these cases sinful?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top