Fox News Video Clip Attacks Catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter OregonCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

OregonCatholic

Guest
I may be just me, but I find this video offensive!

The intereviewer seems to insinuate that because a town is Catholic, it is mean, cold, restrictive, and unconstitutional too?

It appears that you are violating the constituion now if you do not make condems available to college students.

Anyway, interested to see if others are reading it the way I do.

Here’s a link to past in your browser:

foxnews.com/video2/player05.html?030306/030306_fnl_monaghan&FNL&%26%2392%3B%26%2339%3BAve%20Maria%26%2392%3B%26%2339%3B&acc&Only%20on%20FOX&-1&exp

If the link doesn’t work, then try this: Go to foxnews.com, then go to free video, then go to “only on fox” and then there should be a clip inthere about Ave Maria.
 
I agree with you. I found the guy doing the interview to be rude.
The think the idea of the town sounds nice though.
 
The interviewer could have done a better job, but to say that the “video clip attacks Catholics” is a stretch.

I’m so excited about this town and school!
 
40.png
qmvsimp:
The interviewer could have done a better job, but to say that the “video clip attacks Catholics” is a stretch.

I’m so excited about this town and school!
I’m excited too…

But think about this…the interviewer asked if the town would allow gays to live there, allow unwed mothers to live there, allow divorced mothers to live there, would they control what the retailers were selling…all of these items assume that the Catholic Church is intollerant of all of these people and wouldn’t even want them living in their “Catholic town” if Cathlics had their way…the underlying assumption that would prompt these questions is that the Church is full of bigots…did you notice the interviews posture as he threw out differnt classes of people Monaghan wouldn’t allow into Catholic town? Did you notice how he kept talking over them? The Catholic Church is not the Taliban that looks down on people, unwed or otherwise…our Founder hung out with a pretty rough crowd himself!

I’m sure that if anyone insinuated to people living in a Jewish or Muslim area of a large city, that if they had their way unwed mothers or divorced mothers would be cast out…I’m sure that group would be offened at the presumptions of the questions.

In an age where the Church is constantly under attack, we have to be alert to these types of accusations. If the interviewer thought the Church was full of nice loving people, he never would have asked if the Catholic Town would allow in certain types of people or not…he has us mixed up with the Taliban.

🙂
 
40.png
OregonCatholic:
I’m excited too…

But think about this…the interviewer asked if the town would allow gays to live there, allow unwed mothers to live there, allow divorced mothers to live there, would they control what the retailers were selling…all of these items assume that the Catholic Church is intollerant of all of these people and wouldn’t even want them living in their “Catholic town” if Cathlics had their way…the underlying assumption that would prompt these questions is that the Church is full of bigots…
I disagree with you here. Neither the questions nor the underlying assumption are assuming Catholics are bigits. The questions are to allow Monaghan to answer the anti-catholic critics. Remember, that’s why Monaghan was there - to clear up misconceptions and anti-catholic hesteria.
40.png
OregonCatholic:
did you notice the interviews posture as he threw out differnt classes of people Monaghan wouldn’t allow into Catholic town? Did you notice how he kept talking over them? The Catholic Church is not the Taliban that looks down on people, unwed or otherwise…our Founder hung out with a pretty rough crowd himself!

I’m sure that if anyone insinuated to people living in a Jewish or Muslim area of a large city, that if they had their way unwed mothers or divorced mothers would be cast out…I’m sure that group would be offened at the presumptions of the questions.

In an age where the Church is constantly under attack, we have to be alert to these types of accusations. If the interviewer thought the Church was full of nice loving people, he never would have asked if the Catholic Town would allow in certain types of people or not…he has us mixed up with the Taliban.

🙂
I agree with you here. The interviewer became a little rough during the interview, but I wouldn’t say it rose to the level of bigotry. A good interviewer will ask the critics’ questions, even if he doesn’t believe they’re valid concerns. The important thing is that Monaghan was allowed to answer them.
 
Rudolph Murdock at least gave up Fox News. That was courageous of him to do because no other wealthy man would have done that at that time in history. Most are too politically correct. Murdock is getting older so it gets difficult.

If you have ever read the Boston Herald, you will realize his newspaper is pretty liberal but not as bad as the Globe. Also Fox Searchlight gave us the Kinsey movie last year along with Sideways etc.

WHO OWNS WHAT…Site on Rudolph Murdock

72.14.203.104/search?q=cache:X_s6ZPuuEHMJ:www.cjr.org/tools/owners/newscorp.asp+fox+searchlight+owner&hl=en&gl=us&ct=clnk&cd=1
 
So, what was the answer to the reporter’s questions: would this particular Catholic town be open to non-celibate homosexual couples?
 
The Reporter was looking at this through the eyes of the World which is darkness. It is a great idea and these Men and whomever else is involved are going to have to stand up to much more abuse like this because it is going against the Worlds views on what is right and wrong. Keep them in your prayers.
 
40.png
Ahimsa:
So, what was the answer to the reporter’s questions: would this particular Catholic town be open to non-celibate homosexual couples?
Yes.
 
Catholic towns are not new to Florida. St. Leo goes back 100 years or more and was just in the local news.

**Tampabay ****
With no Jovita, future of St. Leo not so rosy
By MOLLY MOORHEAD and HEATHER URQUIDES
Published March 20, 2006
Code:
        ST. LEO - A weak 8-iron off the 11th tee at Lake Jovita Golf and 
        Country Club can sail clear out of town. It's only 100 yards. 
        It's an oddity that gives duffers something to shoot for and, more 
        significantly, a symbol of the fragile existence of Pasco's second 
        smallest town.
        No signs on the golf course mark the border between the town of St. 
        Leo and unincorporated Pasco County. No dotted line through the 
        neighborhood declares one house in town and its neighbor outside it.
        But these are weighty distinctions to some Lake Jovita residents, 
        namely the ones whose high-priced homes are in the city limits of 
        St. Leo and subject to costs of extra government.
        They are pushing town leaders to let them out so they can also 
        become part of unincorporated Pasco County.
        Their taxes would instantly decrease, along with revenues for the 
        town's modest budget.
        St. Leo Mayor James Hallett and other officials are researching ways 
        to deny the residents' contraction petition. But it's likely to come 
        down to a public vote, or two.
        That's because three Lake Jovita residents are running for Town 
        Commission in the April 11 election. If they win, they would have a 
        majority on the five-member body and could vote to approve the 
        petition, triggering a referendum.
        "Both portions of the town have looked at the numbers and see it's 
        going to be a close call," Hallett said.
        * * * 
        St. Leo, population 916, has no grocery store, no fast-food joint, 
        no shopping to speak of. It's rare to see a home for sale, except in 
        Lake Jovita. The most prominent landmarks are a college, a monastery 
        and an abbey.
        The town, with neighboring San Antonio, was founded more than a 
        century ago by a judge from Arizona named Edward Dunne who sought a 
        place where Catholics could freely practice their faith.
        Until recently, some longtime residents thought their secret 
        hideaway might be preserved forever. But progress arrived about 
        eight years ago in the form of the upscale Lake Jovita Golf and 
        Country Club.
        The development, on the eastern edge of the lake, centers on a 
        gorgeous golf course that opened in 1999. The winding cul-de-sacs of 
        luxury homes filled in around the course without regard for town 
        boundaries. About 100 of Lake Jovita's 900 properties are in the 
        town.
        As development plans moved forward in the late 1990s, Town 
        Commissioner Richard Christmas opposed allowing houses built on 
        smaller lots.
        Trending toward suburbia, he warned, would change the town forever.
        * * * 
        John Fantone saw inequities when he moved to Lake Jovita, in St. 
        Leo, five years ago with his wife, Linda. Some residents, like 
        Fantone, pay town and county property taxes. Others pay only county 
        taxes. The difference in the services they receive, Fantone says, is 
        negligible.
        He took a seat, unopposed, on the Town Commission in 2003, with a 
        mission to fix that problem by bringing Lake Jovita under one 
        governmental roof. He led discussions about annexing the entire 
        development into the town.
        They went nowhere.
        "Their (residents') response was "That sounds nice, but it doesn't 
        make economic sense for us to do that,"' Fantone said recently. 
        "They would see that the return on that tax wouldn't be economically 
        to their advantage."
        He was the first and only Lake Jovita resident to serve on the Town 
        Commission.
        Now a private citizen, he is leading the charge to again try to get 
        his neighborhood under one roof.
        This time, though, the roof would be Pasco County.
        [Last modified March 20, 2006, 00:36:17]
**
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top