I think you’re missing the point. A community may take you with a GED or a HS diploma. However, let’s say that you’re someone like me. I wanted to study theology. To do so, I had to get a BA in philosophy, then go on for the M.Div, STL, STD etc. Yadda Yadda Yadda.
I had to go to CUA for my BA. At the time, CUA did not admit students with a GED. I don’t know if ths is stil the policy. The point is that the religious community cannot make policies for the colleges and schools to which they send their friars. Therefore, if you cannot enter a tertiary school, you will be limited in the number of ministries in which you can engage. That’s the point.
In my community we have a brother who has one year of college. He is a catechist and a very good one. However, he cannot be a DRE, because this diocese requires that DREs be certified teachers. To do that, you must have a degree and the right number of education courses.
He has a lot of philosophy and theology under his belt. The formation program is 7-years. But he does not have the degree to hold the position of DRE, which he should hold, because he’s good at it.
It’s good that you’re looking now. It’s important that you take in the whole picture. What kind of minsitry would you like to work in? What is required for that particular ministry? Even a friar who is a cook has to learn to cook. Some actually go to technical institutes to study cooking, carpentry, mechanics, electricity and so forth.
It is also good to look at each Franciscan community according to its ministry, not just the color of the habit. Habits come and go. I’ve lost track of how often the Franciscan family has modified and changed it’s habit.
As to your comment about 60 friars to a house, that’s not exactly true. This was a phenomena of the late 19th century until the mid 20th. The numbers have not gone down that much. However, the return to the early life says that the friars shall live in fraternities, not in priories and monasteries. Those big houses have been disbanded and the friars assigned to small communities. Ideally, the community should be between 3 and 20 men. Houses of formation and houses of study are usually more populated, because you pull men from all over.
You seem to have many preconceived notions about the religious life for someone so young. You need to get past them or you will be very disappointed. Remember, you are joining us, we are not joining you.
Fraternally,
Br. JR, OSF