Friend entering the Church, but disagrees with its teachings

  • Thread starter Thread starter waanju
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

waanju

Guest
Sorry, the long first paragraph is an introduction of sorts, to give context.
So I have a dear friend who has just started RCIA. She was raised without a religion really. Though she would have called herself “Christian” if asked, she was rather more agnostic. She saw my rosary a few years ago and old me that she had been given her grandmother’s after the funeral (the only Mass she’d ever been to) and would I show her how to use it? Delighted, I did, and talked a little bit about why it’s important. A few months later, she was going to go to her new boyfriend’s (Catholic as well and a friend of my family’s) house for dinner. She asked me to teach her the before meals prayer (which she had seen him say with us at my house) so she would know what to do. I wrote it down for her. After a few weeks passed, she asked to go to Mass with me. She’d gone with me once before when I’d asked her, but hadn’t shown any interest since. She began going with my family every week, for about three months (her boyfriend and her broke up after a month, which sort of dispelled my worry that she was going to impress him). She expressed a desire to take communion, and when I told her that in order to do that, she would have to be a member of the church, she said she’d been thinking about it and she wanted to be Catholic. She began asking me some questions, signed up for RCIA, and, even though I think her initial reasons were a little off (wanting to feel close to grandma, impressing a boyfriend’s parents, and not being the only one over age 8 to not receive) I think she’s being drawn to the church by the Holy Spirit.

Recently, though, I’ve started to worry. She disagrees with the church on a lot of things. She’s VERY pro-gay marriage, was pretty active in the Gay-Straight Alliance in highschool, cheered on gay marriage legalization, wants to go to a “pride parade” ect. She also doesn’t see the problem with birth control. She recently started taking the Pill (even though she’s not sexually active!) and when I asked her why (expecting acne ect to be the answer) she said so that when she found someone that she wanted to have sex with, she could. So basically, she disagrees with the church on gay marriage, contraception, and pre-marital sex. I think most of this was caused because she is rather easily influenced (quite a bit actually, especially by novels/movies), and she’s spent her whole life (or at least the two years we spent together in high school) being taught that gay-marriage is “tolerance” and “diversity” and that pre-marital sex is “healthy” and “okay” as long as you’re being “responsible” and “safe” by using contraception. At least she sees that abortion is wrong!

My main question is this: what should I do? Should I confront her directly and risk turning her away? Should I wait to see if her RCIA class covers this? Should I bring it to the attention of her catechist, so that she will know to include these teachings? Should I tell my mother (who I’m not 100% sure fully supports the Church stance on gay marriage… and MAYBE not on contraception) who is my friend’s sponsor?
I really regret not teaching her these things before when they initially came up, but I was so excited that she was showing interest in the church that I didn’t want to “scare her away” with hard stuff so early.
 
When I joined the Church I had similar opinions as your friend. Perhaps it would have been better for me to wait, but even though I disagreed on these issues I still knew the Church had it more right than anybody else. I did have several people approach me about my views and they were very kind, but they couldn’t answer my objections. Part of that I’m sure was my own arrogance, but within a few years I finally heard what I needed to hear and I was in a position to hear it.

More powerful though were the prayers said for me.
 
Sorry, the long first paragraph is an introduction of sorts, to give context.
So I have a dear friend who has just started RCIA. She was raised without a religion really. Though she would have called herself “Christian” if asked, she was rather more agnostic. She saw my rosary a few years ago and old me that she had been given her grandmother’s after the funeral (the only Mass she’d ever been to) and would I show her how to use it? Delighted, I did, and talked a little bit about why it’s important. A few months later, she was going to go to her new boyfriend’s (Catholic as well and a friend of my family’s) house for dinner. She asked me to teach her the before meals prayer (which she had seen him say with us at my house) so she would know what to do. I wrote it down for her. After a few weeks passed, she asked to go to Mass with me. She’d gone with me once before when I’d asked her, but hadn’t shown any interest since. She began going with my family every week, for about three months (her boyfriend and her broke up after a month, which sort of dispelled my worry that she was going to impress him). She expressed a desire to take communion, and when I told her that in order to do that, she would have to be a member of the church, she said she’d been thinking about it and she wanted to be Catholic. She began asking me some questions, signed up for RCIA, and, even though I think her initial reasons were a little off (wanting to feel close to grandma, impressing a boyfriend’s parents, and not being the only one over age 8 to not receive) I think she’s being drawn to the church by the Holy Spirit.

Recently, though, I’ve started to worry. She disagrees with the church on a lot of things. She’s VERY pro-gay marriage, was pretty active in the Gay-Straight Alliance in highschool, cheered on gay marriage legalization, wants to go to a “pride parade” ect. She also doesn’t see the problem with birth control. She recently started taking the Pill (even though she’s not sexually active!) and when I asked her why (expecting acne ect to be the answer) she said so that when she found someone that she wanted to have sex with, she could. So basically, she disagrees with the church on gay marriage, contraception, and pre-marital sex. I think most of this was caused because she is rather easily influenced (quite a bit actually, especially by novels/movies), and she’s spent her whole life (or at least the two years we spent together in high school) being taught that gay-marriage is “tolerance” and “diversity” and that pre-marital sex is “healthy” and “okay” as long as you’re being “responsible” and “safe” by using contraception. At least she sees that abortion is wrong!

My main question is this: what should I do? Should I confront her directly and risk turning her away? Should I wait to see if her RCIA class covers this? Should I bring it to the attention of her catechist, so that she will know to include these teachings? Should I tell my mother (who I’m not 100% sure fully supports the Church stance on gay marriage… and MAYBE not on contraception) who is my friend’s sponsor?
I really regret not teaching her these things before when they initially came up, but I was so excited that she was showing interest in the church that I didn’t want to “scare her away” with hard stuff so early.
Does she want to know what the Church teaches on these things? Then you may be able to help her. Eventually, if she becomes Catholic, she will need to agree to what the Church teaches, so it could be that she will not join, considering her beliefs.
 
Does she want to know what the Church teaches on these things? Then you may be able to help her. Eventually, if she becomes Catholic, she will need to agree to what the Church teaches, so it could be that she will not join, considering her beliefs.
She’s never asked me what the church teaches, so I don;t know if she wants to know. However, I’m kind of worried that she ASSUMES the Church is okay with gay marriage or that it’s “optional” because, when I was a naive little 15 year old who didn’t quite understand why. I never said the church supported gay marriage, but she may have taken my personal support at the time as in keeping with the church’s beliefs. Also, I’m afraid that my silence might be seen as approval? Should I just wait?
 
She’s never asked me what the church teaches, so I don;t know if she wants to know. However, I’m kind of worried that she ASSUMES the Church is okay with gay marriage or that it’s “optional” because, when I was a naive little 15 year old who didn’t quite understand why. I never said the church supported gay marriage, but she may have taken my personal support at the time as in keeping with the church’s beliefs. Also, I’m afraid that my silence might be seen as approval? Should I just wait?
If RCIA studies the Catechism I think it will be covered. Once that study begins it could be a good opportunity to inquire. I think issues about sexuality are difficult today because of the widespread belief in relative morality (i.e., defined by each society at a particular time) and the secular teaching in schools.

I think you can speak out, personally, on the topics at any time.
 
Sorry, the long first paragraph is an introduction of sorts, to give context.
So I have a dear friend who has just started RCIA. She was raised without a religion really. Though she would have called herself “Christian” if asked, she was rather more agnostic. She saw my rosary a few years ago and old me that she had been given her grandmother’s after the funeral (the only Mass she’d ever been to) and would I show her how to use it? Delighted, I did, and talked a little bit about why it’s important. A few months later, she was going to go to her new boyfriend’s (Catholic as well and a friend of my family’s) house for dinner. She asked me to teach her the before meals prayer (which she had seen him say with us at my house) so she would know what to do. I wrote it down for her. After a few weeks passed, she asked to go to Mass with me. She’d gone with me once before when I’d asked her, but hadn’t shown any interest since. She began going with my family every week, for about three months (her boyfriend and her broke up after a month, which sort of dispelled my worry that she was going to impress him). She expressed a desire to take communion, and when I told her that in order to do that, she would have to be a member of the church, she said she’d been thinking about it and she wanted to be Catholic. She began asking me some questions, signed up for RCIA, and, even though I think her initial reasons were a little off (wanting to feel close to grandma, impressing a boyfriend’s parents, and not being the only one over age 8 to not receive) I think she’s being drawn to the church by the Holy Spirit.

Recently, though, I’ve started to worry. She disagrees with the church on a lot of things. She’s VERY pro-gay marriage, was pretty active in the Gay-Straight Alliance in highschool, cheered on gay marriage legalization, wants to go to a “pride parade” ect. She also doesn’t see the problem with birth control. She recently started taking the Pill (even though she’s not sexually active!) and when I asked her why (expecting acne ect to be the answer) she said so that when she found someone that she wanted to have sex with, she could. So basically, she disagrees with the church on gay marriage, contraception, and pre-marital sex. I think most of this was caused because she is rather easily influenced (quite a bit actually, especially by novels/movies), and she’s spent her whole life (or at least the two years we spent together in high school) being taught that gay-marriage is “tolerance” and “diversity” and that pre-marital sex is “healthy” and “okay” as long as you’re being “responsible” and “safe” by using contraception. At least she sees that abortion is wrong!

My main question is this: what should I do? Should I confront her directly and risk turning her away? Should I wait to see if her RCIA class covers this? Should I bring it to the attention of her catechist, so that she will know to include these teachings? Should I tell my mother (who I’m not 100% sure fully supports the Church stance on gay marriage… and MAYBE not on contraception) who is my friend’s sponsor?
I really regret not teaching her these things before when they initially came up, but I was so excited that she was showing interest in the church that I didn’t want to “scare her away” with hard stuff so early.
Let her RCIA facilitator handle her objections. She will receive an education on Catholic Doctrine there and can decide if she really wants to join the Church.
 
My main question is this: what should I do?
*Gently. * No one has ever given her moral direction before. The Holy Spirit is at work, so, I think, for instance, when she says she is on the Pill in case she finds someone she wants to have sex with, I think I’d share what’s in my heart which is: “I really hope you don’t do that to yourself. You’re very special and deserve so much more.” I don’t think I’d let these things pass, but I think I’d always affirm her in love and pray for her, oh so constantly.

But mostly I’d ask the Holy Spirit y to please guide my words and actions.
 
Let her RCIA facilitator handle her objections. She will receive an education on Catholic Doctrine there and can decide if she really wants to join the Church.
Okay. Do you think it would be helpful if I mentioned my concerns to her RCIA facilitator (who I happen to speak with regularly because she was my sponsor)
 
*Gently. * No one has ever given her moral direction before. The Holy Spirit is at work, so, I think, for instance, when she says she is on the Pill in case she finds someone she wants to have sex with, I think I’d share what’s in my heart which is: “I really hope you don’t do that to yourself. You’re very special and deserve so much more.” I don’t think I’d let these things pass, but I think I’d always affirm her in love and pray for her, oh so constantly.

But mostly I’d ask the Holy Spirit y to please guide my words and actions.
Okay, that’s kind of what I’ve done with regards to the sex related things. Thanks for the advice!
 
Let the RCIA unfold as it ought to do. The Rite of Welcoming takes her from a casual inquiry status to a serious inquiry status, but she can leave anytime she wants to. Your friend won’t be asked to completely commit until just before Easter. She can also decide to stay in inquiry for another year to continue to sort things out.
 
Let the RCIA unfold as it ought to do. The Rite of Welcoming takes her from a casual inquiry status to a serious inquiry status, but she can leave anytime she wants to. Your friend won’t be asked to completely commit until just before Easter. She can also decide to stay in inquiry for another year to continue to sort things out.
Okay. and she decided to leave inquiry right away because she didn’t have any questions.
 
Okay. and she decided to leave inquiry right away because she didn’t have any questions.
I take it that she is un-baptised (you said agnostic) so not instructed in the faith. The next phase of RCIA after inquiry is Catechumenate, so she should get Catechesis there.
 
I take it that she is un-baptised (you said agnostic) so not instructed in the faith. The next phase of RCIA after inquiry is Catechumenate, so she should get Catechesis there.
Yeah. Her older siblings were baptized in a Baptist church, but her parents never bothered with her. I guess I’m just sort of worried that the RCIA Catechesis will be “lacking” because my confirmation Catechesis at the same parish was…
 
Okay. Do you think it would be helpful if I mentioned my concerns to her RCIA facilitator (who I happen to speak with regularly because she was my sponsor)
I wouldn’t interfere. Your friend sounds like she is outspoken and has some strong opinions which she will probably let known in RCIA. Don’t be too concerned, RCIA facilitators have seen and heard most if not all of it before and are trained. Many converts come into the Church with reservations or doubts about some Doctrines and have had their misconceptions shattered. Let this be her/his experience.
 
I wouldn’t interfere. Your friend sounds like she is outspoken and has some strong opinions which she will probably let known in RCIA. Don’t be too concerned, RCIA facilitators have seen and heard most if not all of it before and are trained. Many converts come into the Church with reservations or doubts about some Doctrines and have had their misconceptions shattered. Let this be her/his experience.
Okay thanks. I just don’t want her to never know and for it to be my fault. I want her to have the truth!
 
Okay thanks. I just don’t want her to never know and for it to be my fault. I want her to have the truth!
You are a good friend. You have allowed the Holy Spirit to work in you by showing her to the CC. Pray for her. 👍
 
Your friend must either accept the teaching of the Church or stop pretending being a catholic.

There are plenty denominations of christian nature that support her vision on these issues.

if she doesnt share the Church view then she cant identify herself as a catholic.
 
I have never sat in on an RCIA program, but are these issues dealt with sufficiently in these meetings to answer her questions?
 
Okay. Do you think it would be helpful if I mentioned my concerns to her RCIA facilitator (who I happen to speak with regularly because she was my sponsor)
Butt out. Let the Holy Spirit handle.
 
I have been an observer of RCIA when my husband was entering the church, find out if it is possible for you to observe, chances are you wil be allowed. I asked many questions of clarification myself, you could do the same if you are willing and able to attend. So many say to just let the holy spirit do His work, but we are part of The Body of Christ, and we are called to also teach the truth. God Bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top