Friend proposing after a few weeks

  • Thread starter Thread starter phil8888
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

phil8888

Guest
Hey guys, I’m not sure your opinion of this. My friend who is in his early 30s, has over the years dated a number of women. He told me his longest relationship was 5 years. He recently split from his girlfriend of about a year. Anyway, he met a new girl in the middle of last month. He texted me to say he was thinking of proposing over Christmas, so in about a week or so.

I just told him good luck and God bless. Just wanted to hear what you guys thought about it. He did not mention a date for his wedding or anything.
 
I just told him good luck and God bless. Just wanted to hear what you guys thought about it. He did not mention a date for his wedding or anything.
If you are thinking he is in a rebound relationship and there could be issues, well, that might be true. Having said that, I also agree with the other posters. You wish him the best and be there for your friend through whatever may ensue and never, no mater what happens say, “Yeah, I thought there might be problems…” Just support and sympathy, as called for.
 
Hey guys, I’m not sure your opinion of this. My friend who is in his early 30s, has over the years dated a number of women. He told me his longest relationship was 5 years. He recently split from his girlfriend of about a year. Anyway, he met a new girl in the middle of last month. He texted me to say he was thinking of proposing over Christmas, so in about a week or so.

I just told him good luck and God bless. Just wanted to hear what you guys thought about it. He did not mention a date for his wedding or anything.
My concern would be that this is a “rebound” reaction, depending on how recently the last relationship ended. But I would not bring this up unless you are very close to him.

But sometimes a person could “know” after a few weeks. There are very happy, successful marriages that start this way.

“Good luck and God bless” sounds like a good response from a friend. 👍
 
Hey guys, I’m not sure your opinion of this. My friend who is in his early 30s, has over the years dated a number of women. He told me his longest relationship was 5 years. He recently split from his girlfriend of about a year. Anyway, he met a new girl in the middle of last month. He texted me to say he was thinking of proposing over Christmas, so in about a week or so.

I just told him good luck and God bless. Just wanted to hear what you guys thought about it. He did not mention a date for his wedding or anything.
He had a relationship for 5 years and never proposed? That’s pretty sad. 😦 Why spend that much time with someone you aren’t going to marry??

Even a year…so he invests 5 years in one woman, then 1 year, and then wants to marry someone he just met? Wow.

Yes, I’d tell him good luck and let it go.
 
It really depends on the situation.

My husband and I started dating on Dec 4, 1993, and I knew by Christmas that he was the man I wanted to marry, and he knew he wanted to marry me, too.

However, we had been friends for 5 years and had worked side-by-side in youth ministry. We skipped over all the dumb things that people do in the beginning of a relationship - pretending to like a certain food or activity to so as not to offend the other person, for example. Or artificially prettying yourself up. Because we’d been friends and workers together, we had a very honest relationship. We felt free to disagree with one another and still came away respecting each other.

We did not get engaged until March 4, 1994 and we married on June 4, 1994. Still very, very happy 17.5 years later. Still a great relationship with lots of communication and the freedom to have differing opinions (although we strive for unity on all the important stuff).

So, if this fellow has known the lady for quite some time, and neither of them are carrying excess baggage (divorce, children from a previous relationship, etc.), then it might be just fine. If, however, he really just met her and they hardly know each other, it would behoove him to wait.
 
Ok, forgive me for going against the grain, but if this were a friend, friend I.e someone I actually cared about and was more than just an acquaintance, I would engage him in a conversation over such e serious decision. Not to dissuade him necessarily but at least to give him an outsider’s perspwctive and pose the right questions to ensure he knows what he’s getting into and why.

Honestly, if I were to confide in a close friend that I want to do something that will be a turning point in my life, I would love to hear more than, “good luck, God bless”. Then again, you’re probably a guy and don’t like getting into relationship talk:D

On the other hand, if this is actually a distant friend , then, what you said is enough.

Generally, while I do believe you can know very early on if you found your spouse or not, I would, as a woman, still be a little creeped if the guy popped the question within weeks. But maybe that’s too much secular brainwashing about “not being ready”
 
Ok, forgive me for going against the grain, but if this were a friend, friend I.e someone I actually cared about and was more than just an acquaintance, I would engage him in a conversation over such e serious decision. Not to dissuade him necessarily but at least to give him an outsider’s perspwctive and pose the right questions to ensure he knows what he’s getting into and why.
Same here.

If you have a reason to believe that he is eager to settle down with the first girl who comes along, then please have a conversation with your friend. Of course, it can be that he has learned his lessons and has come to a point where he knows what he wants and is making a good decision.
 
I knew in a couple of weeks that I was going to marry my wife. 9 months before this I had broken up with a girl that I dated about 3 years. So I believe that this is entirely in the realm of possibility that he knows that this girl is right for him. If you have have doubts, why don’t you go get burgers or some guy activity and talk to him.
 
I would suggest that he might consider entering into a time of courtship. That would mean that he and she will be seriously discerning whether they are to get married. This could be an exciting time, and at some point, being engaged could begin a new exciting time.
If I was in that situation, dating someone a very short time, I think I would freak. Really.
 
Hey guys, I’m not sure your opinion of this. My friend who is in his early 30s, has over the years dated a number of women. He told me his longest relationship was 5 years. He recently split from his girlfriend of about a year. Anyway, he met a new girl in the middle of last month. He texted me to say he was thinking of proposing over Christmas, so in about a week or so.

I just told him good luck and God bless. Just wanted to hear what you guys thought about it. He did not mention a date for his wedding or anything.
Since I don’t know him, I can’t judge him. I can say though I have a friend (near my age and I’m 31) who had absolutely no boyfriend and seemingly no prospect of one. By the following Christmas she was married and pregnant with their first child. She is a woman I completely respect and do not believe made an imprudent decision.

Where I get suspecious is when people make decisions based purely off of emotions. There is a difference between being niave about romantic love and following your heart, and being at an age where you know what you want, find it and don’t waste your time with it.
 
Let’s see what the answer is, before we start thinking anything. :cool:
 
Since he didn’t ask you and he’s old enough to make these decisions, your response was just fine. If you know him well enough to realize that he was asking what you thought, though, it would have been OK to invite him to talk about how he knew so soon that this was the right one. You can’t say that he’s wrong, but it’s OK to invite him to tell you why he knows he’s right.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top