"From Henceforth All Generations Shall Call Me Blessed"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Teflon93
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Teflon93

Guest
Luke 1:48:

48For he hath regarded the low estate of his handmaiden: for, behold, from henceforth all generations shall call me blessed.

Why again do “Bible-believing” Protestants object to calling Mary “blessed”?

Why do they not do so?
 
Luke 1:48:

48For he hath regarded the low estate of his handmaiden: for, behold, from henceforth all generations shall call me blessed.

Why again do “Bible-believing” Protestants object to calling Mary “blessed”?

Why do they not do so?
The vast majority will tell you that she was truly blessed to bring Jesus into this world. They will then tell you that she is absolutely not worthy of veneration (which most will consider worship) because she was nothing better than any of us.

Most have a lack of knowledge of the fundamental truth of the word kecharitomene, the definition and character of Grace, and the theology of heaven, hell and purgatory. They do not understand that when we die we do not cease to exist, we simply go to be with God. We are still alive, just alive with God.

FSC
 
I saw a post on another message board from a Protestant that said, in all seriousness:

“Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee” … I don’t see that anywhere in the Bible.

Perhaps it’s just an issue of them not wanting to see things even though they do read it. I know before I converted I saw things the way I wanted to see them and as I grew more and more in the Catholic faith it was like things were opened up to me that I had never seen before. Bible verses I’d read hundreds of time meant something new or ones I’d just skipped right over before took on whole new meanings.

ChadS
 
Many of the ones that don’t call her blessed do not do so because Catholics call her that.
 
I was the EXACT way ChadS. I was always told WHAT to read in the Bible. Never HOW to read it. Curse that Gutenberg Press! And praise it at the same time! Heh.
 
I saw a post on another message board from a Protestant that said, in all seriousness:

“Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee” … I don’t see that anywhere in the Bible.

Perhaps it’s just an issue of them not wanting to see things even though they do read it. I know before I converted I saw things the way I wanted to see them and as I grew more and more in the Catholic faith it was like things were opened up to me that I had never seen before. Bible verses I’d read hundreds of time meant something new or ones I’d just skipped right over before took on whole new meanings.

ChadS
Quite right—when I was a Protestant, John 6 just somehow never seemed to make the Scripture’s greatest hits list. I recall being shocked when I was pointed toward the words of the Hail Mary in the Gospel.
 
Sacred Scripture often confirms what belongs to Tradition by the use of words (blessed) and expressions (kecharitomene) employed by the authors through the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. These help us to understand what God really has in mind to tell us. And they sometimes meaningfully extend beyond the primary context as is the case with prophecies. Mary spoke prophetically when she proclaimed: “Behold, from now on all generations will call me blessed” (Lk.1:48). Many Protestant commentators have said that what Mary means by being blessed (makaria) is that she has been favoured by God to be the mother of Jesus. In its primary fulfilment the prophecy is true. Unless Mary is the mother of our Lord, there is no reason for us to rejoice in Mary’s happiness together with her on account of this pre-eminent favour. Yet we are still left with the prophecy’s secondary fulfilment which is actually alluded to in the following verse: “The Almighty has done great things for me.” What Mary is alluding to has yet to be realized in the future and is connected with the present moment and her state. The original word makarizó (μακαρίζω) in the given context literally means “to be pronounced blessed as a result of enjoying benefits or privileges that extend from being the mother of our Lord by God’s grace.” Thus the great things God has done for Mary are blessings that rest on the Divine Maternity which in itself is a blessing of the highest honour any woman could ever receive by the gratuitous grace of God. However, the future generations which pronounce Mary blessed are not merely paying her honour for having been chosen to be the mother of the Lord. As we have seen, the Greek word for “blessed” is more than an honorary term. It refers to how one stands in their personal relationship with God. The secondary fulfilment of Mary’s prophecy is found in these benefits and privileges that extend from her Divine motherhood which future generations of the faithful shall acknowledge as blessings that by virtue of her maternal right exclusively belong to her in the order of grace. And these privileges are also connected with Mary’s association with her Son in his work of redemption for which other reason she was chosen to be his mother. Jesus was not made by a woman only to acquire his flesh and blood from her.

Protestant scholar Donald G. Dawe in his exegesis of this verse concurs that the Greek word for “blessed” is “more than a polite honorific term”. In his work The Assumption of the Blessed Virgin in Ecumenical Perspective, he informs us that this same word was used in Patristic literature to characterize the martyrs. “The highest expression of this blessedness was in the possibility of their ascension into heaven to dwell in the immediate presence of God.” (cf. EWTN). In other words, they weren’t simply blessed for having died for Christ in faith. In the same vein, when Jesus says “Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God,” the highest expression of their blessedness is seeing God. Thus Mary’s divine motherhood is not the highest expression of her being blessed in the eyes of future generations. This verse is vital to the Catholic dogma of the Assumption. In this verse we not only see her role in the Incarnation, but also the final consummation of salvation in Heaven. In Mary’s case, this final consummation would be her assumption into Heaven. This is something all generations shall especially rejoice in for Mary’s sake alone, since the Assumption is one of the privileges she has been graced with for being the Mother of God. The future generations shall not pronounce Mary blessed for simply having died and gone to Heaven. This is the blessed hope of all the faithful who die in the state of grace. The redemption of our bodies is a divine truth which has already been made manifest by the resurrection of Christ. But Mary is speaking prophetically about herself in particular. There is a secondary fulfilment that exclusively applies to her which is her Assumption body and soul into Heaven pending our own resurrection. Mary is the one person whom by all the other faithful is pre-eminently pronounced blessed. She has been granted this privilege that no other Christian shall ever receive, not only because she is the mother of our Lord, but also because of the other associated benefit extended to her - that being the Immaculate Conception.

PAX
:heaven:
 
Seems that it goes back to the interpretation of the 2nd commandment. They have a genuine fear of praying to or worshiping someone other than God.

I have a protestant acquaintance who would never step in a Catholic church for fear of seeing the crucifix, which is in violation of the commandment in their eyes. I respect them for it. I mean, they are consistent, and it makes some kind of sense. So you really have to go all the way back there if you want to address the issue of worshiping Mary and help them from that point.
 
Seems that it goes back to the interpretation of the 2nd commandment. They have a genuine fear of praying to or worshiping someone other than God.

I have a protestant acquaintance who would never step in a Catholic church for fear of seeing the crucifix, which is in violation of the commandment in their eyes. I respect them for it. I mean, they are consistent, and it makes some kind of sense. So you really have to go all the way back there if you want to address the issue of worshiping Mary and help them from that point.
What would your acquaintance have to say if you told him or her that Catholics adore the divine Person who is hanging on the crucifix and not the image itself?

PAX
:heaven:
 
What would your acquaintance have to say if you told him or her that Catholics adore the divine Person who is hanging on the crucifix and not the image itself?

PAX
:heaven:
She is not worried about what Catholics do, she is worried about what SHE would do. The act of walking in to pray while she can see a crucifix and a statue of Mary feels like SHE is committing a sin against the 2nd commandment. There is a lot of misunderstandings that have to be corrected and they go pretty deep. In the mean time I think you have to respect the way it makes them feel.
 
I saw a post on another message board from a Protestant that said, in all seriousness:

“Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee” … I don’t see that anywhere in the Bible.

Perhaps it’s just an issue of them not wanting to see things even though they do read it. I know before I converted I saw things the way I wanted to see them and as I grew more and more in the Catholic faith it was like things were opened up to me that I had never seen before. Bible verses I’d read hundreds of time meant something new or ones I’d just skipped right over before took on whole new meanings.

ChadS
I don’t see this being answered. The reason that they don’t see that the Bible says Hail Mary full of grace is because Protestant versions of the Bible don’t say that. How about that? Their Bibles were translated to say she is blessed. Go online to sites that show bible verses from different versions side by side. I don’t recall if it was Luther or someone later that made this change. But I recall reading that the change was made to support their views on the matter.
 
…for, behold, from henceforth all generations shall call me blessed. [Luke 1:48]

Why again do “Bible-believing” Protestants object to calling Mary “blessed”?
They don’t object. Once a year, many protestants persuade a 14-year old girl to put on a blue gown and play Mary in a Christmas pageant.

Wouldn’t you agree that this is what our Blessed Mother had in mind when she spoke this prophecy? Wouldn’t you agree that this annual theatrical performance is the natural and obvious meaning of this prophecy?

You don’t REALLY imagine that Our Lady meant to suggest that we would think of her for the other 364 days of the year, do you? Surely, we are usually expected to IGNORE her.
 
They don’t object. Once a year, many protestants persuade a 14-year old girl to put on a blue gown and play Mary in a Christmas pageant.

Wouldn’t you agree that this is what our Blessed Mother had in mind when she spoke this prophecy? Wouldn’t you agree that this annual theatrical performance is the natural and obvious meaning of this prophecy?

You don’t REALLY imagine that Our Lady meant to suggest that we would think of her for the other 364 days of the year, do you? Surely, we are usually expected to IGNORE her.
But Catholics are encouraged, if not expected, to formally acknowledge Mary on her solemn feast days. Protestants pronounce Mary blessed solely for having been chosen to be the mother of Jesus, if not the Mother of God. Meanwhile they fail to acknowledge the higher expressions of Mary’s blessedness which extend from the Divine Maternity, that being her Immaculate Conception and Assumption body and soul into Heaven. Finally, the Magisterium encourages daily private devotion to our Blessed Mother, which include Marian prayers and antiphons. So it isn’t true that we are usually expected to ignore her. Remember Mary is the Mother of the Church. Can a child be with his mother only one day of the year and hope to survive? All the graces we receive from Jesus come primarily through Mary, our Mediatrix. Since we depend on her as vulnerable children in our constant battle with the dragon, we mustn’t ignore her daily presence among us in the Mystical Body of Christ, but seek and find refuge in her. Our heavenly Mother does not expect us to recite the Rosary only on Christmas Day.

"The teaching of the Second Vatican Council presents the truth of Mary’s mediation as “a sharing in the one unique source that is the mediation of Christ himself.” Thus we read: "The Church does not hesitate to profess this subordinate role of Mary. She experiences it continuously and commends it to the hearts of the faithful, so that, encouraged by this maternal help, they may more closely adhere to the Mediator and Redeemer."98 This role is at the same time special and extraordinary. It flows from her divine motherhood and can be understood and lived in faith only on the basis of the full truth of this motherhood. Since by virtue of divine election Mary is the earthly Mother of the Father’s consubstantial Son and his “generous companion” in the work of redemption "she is a mother to us in the order of grace.“99 This role constitutes a real dimension of her presence in the saving mystery of Christ and the Church.”

Pope John Paul ll, Redemptoris Mater (38)

PAX

:heaven:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top