G-d Abhors Human Sacrifice

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zahava
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Shalom alakeim, Zahav, and thank you for the pointers. You are welcome, in turn, for my attempt to observe the etiquette of Jewish piety within a Catholic forum.

I take your decision to focus on linguistic niceties as implicit concession that the substance of my post was weighed by you and found not wanting.

All the best, vacath
Vacath, when religious Jews say in casual the Almighy - we say or write Elokim. We change the h to a k.

instead of saying G-d we say HaShem / the name
In our prayers we say Adonai instead of the name we can never pronounce (YKVK) again I have typed K instead of H
 
Gabriel, please give your source from TaNaCH for your last 3 statements above.

etc, etc. etc…
When I need a good laugh I often turn to RASHI to read. Bottom line, you miss the fact that Abraham offering up his Son is a type. But, when you read someone else’s mail it is no surprise that you misread it.

A “sacrifice” has no free will in the matter, a lamb can not tell the priest No, don’t do it, and then run away to save its life. But, in the case of Jesus it does not qualifly as a sacrifice in that sense because frankly Jesus had a choice at all times,

John 10:17
The reason my Father loves me is that I lay down my life—only to take it up again.

Matthew 26:53
Do you think I cannot call on my Father, and he will at once put at my disposal more than twelve legions of angels?

What you miss is that Jesus lays down his life of his own free will, that is how the soilder throwing himself on the land mine or gernade applies. Jesus and the Soilder both choose to give their life so that others may live.
 
Why does the Ancient One demand the death of so many nations in the Old Testament?

Why are the laws so specific as to killing non-Jews and Jews for various offenses (see Leviticus and Numbers)?
Simple: the Almighty knew that those nations He commanded Israel to wipe out were evil. Again, read the Hebrew Bible - I suggest the Artscroll Stone Edition Chumash.
Sondra, you do NOT understand the Eucharist.
True
Study the Catholic scripture and midrash (early Church Fathers) and you will better understand that your reference article and assertions are without merit.

The promise God made to Abraham was for “all nations.”

The history of that stubborn-necked people and the Prophets God sent to them to keep putting them back on track ended with God (as Man) among us (Emmanuel).
Midrash - Early Church Fathers? You are mistaken, Rbt.

What is the Midrash?
by Rabbi Mendy Hecht

A. “Midrash” means “exposition.” The Midrash (or Medrash) is probably the most referred-to collection of explanatory works on Tanach, next to Rashi. The Midrash, or Midrashim, fills in the gaps behind the oft-times sketchy, skeletal narrative of the Torah, Nevi’im and Ketuvim. It adds meat to its bones, telling us things we otherwise would never know, mainly the dialogues between the Torah’s figures and details of their lives. As such, the Midrash is a vital, true part of the Oral Torah.

B. Here’s a great definition of “Midrash” by the late great Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan, author of The Living Torah: “…a generic term, usually denoting the non-legalistic teachings of the rabbis of the Talmudic era. In the centuries following the final redaction of the Talmud (around 505 CE), much of this material was gathered into collections known as Midrashim.” So, “the Midrash” is like “the dictionary”–there are many dictionaries, each compiled by a different party at a different time.

The Midrash fills in the gaps behind the oft-times sketchy, skeletal narrative of the Torah… It adds meat to its bones, telling us things we otherwise would never know…

C. The Midrash consists of a large number of individually written books on various sections of Tanach, or on the entire Tanach. A prominent example of a Midrash is the Midrash Rabbah, which adds critical details to the five books of the Chumash. There is also the Midrash Tanchuma on the Chumash (written by Rabbi Tanchuma, a Talmudic sage), the Yalkut Shim’oni, the Midrash Agadah… and Avot D’Rabbi Natan, Mechilta, Midrash Hagadol, Pirkei D’Rabbi Eliezer, Sifra, Sifri and many more. Each elaborates on all or part of the Written Torah. None, however, should be taken lightly: unfortunately, the misconception exists that midrashim are mere tales or legends. They are not, and the assumption that one can write their own book of Biblical fiction on the assumption that the authors of the Midrash did the same is the most tragic result thereof.

How can I study Midrash?
  1. Study Torah
Midrash is part of Torah, and thus studying Midrash is studying Torah. How do you study Torah? See “What is Torah?” first, and then I’ll see you back here.
  1. Go Shopping
Perhaps the most popular Midrashic publication is what might be dubbed “Midrash for Dummies”: a terrific five-volume, English-language translation of Midrashic commentary entitled The Midrash Says. (There is also The Little Midrash Says, a large-print format of same, just for kids.) Pick up your set at any Jewish bookstore. When you do, don’t skip the fabulous Foreword.
  1. Remember What you’re Doing
Like “Kabbalah,” there’s a lot of confusion out there when it comes to “Midrash.” So here’s a golden rule you can’t go wrong with: don’t rely only on books - go to classes. And since 99 percent of Midrash is on “the Bible” anyway–Tanach–go to a basic Torah class, where your instructor will bring the text to life with ample samplings of Midrashic teachings. Visit Chabad.com for your nearest one.
Only Orthodox assert what you repeat. Reform does not.

Which Jew is the better informed?
Reform Jews are NOT Torah observant. Therefore, the Orthodox Jew is the better informed.
 
When I need a good laugh I often turn to RASHI to read.

What you miss is that Jesus lays down his life of his own free will, that is how the soilder throwing himself on the land mine or gernade applies. Jesus and the Soilder both choose to give their life so that others may live.
When I want to cry for the people that choose to believe that they must believe in a man for salvation instead of listening to what the Almighty says, I think back to my family and friends who are in Christianity and my heart breaks.

What you miss, Daniel. Is that G-d’s “salvation” for Jews and righteous nonJews (those that follow the 7 Noahide Laws) has never changed nor will it. Pray to the Almighty without ending your prayer in "J’s " name - Live a moral life - guard your tongue from evil - , etc G-d said choose life so that you may live. Boruch HaShem, Torah is life (you will find King David saying these exact words). The handbook for how to live a righteous life.
 
Gandal, do you know why He commanded that these men, women, children, and yes infants be wiped out? This is why I said in my other post to you that you should learn Hebrew. Answers to the above is there.
Are you saying that we can’t know why he did that without being able to read Hebrew? :rolleyes:
My answer to you: Yes, G-d is against human sacrifices.
and therefore, yes, He is against human sacrifices offered by us humans
That doesn’t really doesn’t really answer my argument.
 
Shalom alakeim, Zahav, and thank you for the pointers. You are welcome, in turn, for my attempt to observe the etiquette of Jewish piety within a Catholic forum.

I take your decision to focus on linguistic niceties as implicit concession that the substance of my post was weighed by you and found not wanting.

All the best, vacath
Alakeim Shalom, Vacath.

You have made me smile. Thanks. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top