G
Genesis315
Guest
Yes, but only those subject to the Church’s jurisdiction (ie anyone who has been baptized, but for all intents and purposes, just Catholics). What you’re thinking of would be called a temporal penalty, “civil” is not the right word since we’re not dealing with the civil government (although in some eras, the civil government helped enforce the Church’s decisions).Does the Church have a right to punish people who disagree with them?
I am talking about civil penalties, like house arrest.
Here’s the current canon:
Code of Canon Law:
vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P4U.HTMCan. 1311 The Church has the innate and proper right to coerce offending members of the Christian faithful with penal sanctions.
Can. 1312 §1. The following are penal sanctions in the Church:
1/ medicinal penalties, or censures, which are listed in ⇒ cann. 1331-1333;
2/ expiatory penalties mentioned in ⇒ can. 1336.
§2. The law can establish other expiatory penalties which deprive a member of the Christian faithful of some spiritual or temporal good and which are consistent with the supernatural purpose of the Church.
§3. Penal remedies and penances are also used; the former especially to prevent delicts, the latter to substitute for or to increase a penalty.
Note, the offender can be deprived of a “spiritual or temporal good.” Depriving one of freedom would be a deprivation of a temporal good. We see this when an offending member is sent to a monastery for a life of penance, for example.