A
Abu
Guest
The perennially confused Leela now promotes that anything consensual is moral – so no one is subject to a higher power and we are all just animals, and the moral worth of an action is determined solely by its utility in providing happiness or pleasure – no permanent moral principles which transcend the practical and technical order.Leela
In my view, bestiality is immoral because it simply cannot be consenual. See? I’ve given a reason for my moral view rather than just saying that it is immoral because it is immoral. Now, why is homosexuality immoral?
“There is significant convergence in philosophy toward the view that the human spirit is a self-creative process which fashions itself out of its relations to the world.” (Dewart, Religion, Language and Truth, p. 121). It is the selfist doctrine of subjective self-morality and self-worship.
The exposure here of the chaos which is known as “process thought” or “process theology” is reminiscent of Nietzsche’s “death of God” and the remaking of reductionist values for man and for religion, in order to sanitize sodomy. Since there is no such thing as absolute truth, everything is allowable.
The lack of fidelity and abuse characteristic of homosexual relationships is symptomatic of the lack of those very elements which could make it a natural sign of the union of persons – another fact against the fantasy of “marriage” apart from the inability to have and form children with a mother and a father.
But the natural moral law is “a law that is in principle accessible to human reason and not dependent on (though entirely compatible with and, indeed, illumined by) divine revelation.” (The Clash of Orthodoxies, Professor Robert P George (Princeton), 2001, p 169).
Man is capable by his own activity of acquiring what is lacking and developing what is already possessed to fulfill his nature. So man can know his incompleteness; he can see what he is now and discover the direction of fulfillment by scrutiny of his own nature in body, mind and spirit – to achieve himself fully. As a free agent, he has an obligation to achieve himself fully, and this bond of obligation is the natural law. All that is knowable about man through psychology, history or any of the sciences is relevant to the natural law, is part of the natural law. The natural law is outside of man’s control because created by God in man’s nature.
[See Fr Paul M Quay, S.J., in *Why Humanae Vitae Was Right, Ignatius 1993, p 21-4]
The natural law says that if you want things to prosper, you have to use them in accord with their nature. If you want to grow good tomatoes, you have to treat tomato plants in accord with their nature. You have to give them sunshine and water and fertilizer and a good soil. It is something that man can discover by the basis of his own reason.
The inability to procreate and form children with a mother and father, the lack of fidelity and the abuse have no counter in the myopia of homomania.