Genesis is not a mythical legend

  • Thread starter Thread starter Stephentlig
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Stephentlig

Guest
Hey folks, at my college of mater dei in dublin, below is exactly whats happening in our lectures, we are being taught that the book of Genesis is just all legend and mythical. Is there anyone on this forum who encountered the same type of heresy? :confused:

Pax Christi
Stephen
catholicscomehome.org/answers-scripture.php

''I had a theology teacher who told me that adam and eve were just myths, and that the rest of Genesis was all just legends…is that what the church teaches?"

"Absolutely not! The Church has always taught that Adam and Eve were real people and were the first human beings from whom all other human beings are descended. In 1950, Pope Pius XII, in Paragraph 37 of an encyclical entitled Humani Generis, states, “…the faithful cannot embrace that opinion which maintains either that after Adam there existed on this earth true men who did not take their origin through natural generation from [Adam] as from the first parent of all, or that Adam represents a certain number of first parents.” In other words, the Church teaches that all humanity descended from Adam and Eve. They had to be real for that to happen.

Paragraph #38, states: “This [encyclical], in fact, clearly points out that the first eleven chapters of Genesis…do nevertheless pertain to history in a true sense…” Again, Adam and Eve are not myths, and the rest of Genesis is not legend. They are history in a “true sense.”

Paragraph #39: “Therefore, whatever of the popular narrations have been inserted into the Sacred Scriptures must in no way be considered on a par with myths or other such things…” Can it be stated any clearer than that?

And listen to what the Catechism says, Paragraph #375, “The Church…teaches that our first parents, Adam and Eve…” No mention of a myth here.

Paragraph #404: "By yielding to the tempter, Adam and Eve committed a personal sin. Someone please tell me, how do myths commit personal sins?

Adam and Eve are not myths. Genesis does not contain myth or legend. That is Church teaching. Challenge anyone, who teaches differently, to produce their sources from a magisterial document. They cannot do it. They can, however, produce countless books and articles by “theologians”. Not good enough."
 
Sodom and Gomorrah are found, dated, and existing. Whats missing is a sign saying this is Sodom or this is Gomorrah. Yet archaelogy and geology place them in the correct time and place? Sodom and Gomorrah were found in 1962. Then revisited in later digs in the 80’s and 90’s.

You can research this. Much info out on this.
 
yup, thats pretty much what she is teaching. Its enough to turn ones stomach. What is there that has been done about it if anything at all? Are we to all sit and wait for it to pass? because its been taught in primary, secondary and university schools all over the globe. :eek:
 
I respect those who believe in the Bible literally but I have come to the place where the first eleven chapters of Geneis appear to me to be mostly myth with a little history thrown in.
Code:
Let me illustrate with the Noah story. Probably there was a major flood in the Near East, which eventually was exaggerated into a flood covering the whole earth. However, how could Noah get two of every animal into that ark, how could the ark of the given dimensions hold them all, and how could they feed and clean up after them for the 150 days that the waters remained on the earth? Even more important to me, I can't believe that our loving God, who believes in forgiveness and justice, would drown everybody on earth except for the eight indicated - Noah and wife, three sons and wives. Keep in mind the Ten Commandments and the Sermon on the Mount for starters. Think of all the innocent children and the unborn who would have been murdered by God.

 No. Sorry, I can't believe that.

 Does that mean that the first eleven chapters are lies? No. I regard them as parables with moral messages of importance. But can we really believe that God punished mankind by giving it different languages because they built the Tower of Babel? If that were true, how about our skyscrapers, spacecraft, etc.? 

 All sorts of other problems.

 As for the rest of Genesis, basically the stories of the four patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Joseph, I have come to view them as some legitimate history mixed in with considerable folklore. 

 Besides all that, if you become a serious student of the Torah, the first five books, you will find that there are four distinct styles of Hebrew - often referred to as the J, E, P, and D. J - uses Jehovah. E uses Elohim. P is liturgical, priestly. D is Deuteronomic. Etc. This is not the place to go into further detail, but it shows that different men authored these books rather than just Moses, as tradition teaches (The Books of Moses). Why would you find word of Moses' death and burial in Deuteronomy if the five books were written by him? And if Moses wrote them, would he describe himself as the meekest man on the face of the earth (Numbers 12: 3)? I don't think so.

 Christianity loses educated, thinking people if it expects them to believe the unbelievable. On the other hand, if you can actually accept all such stories as factual, fine. I have tried but simply can't. And I don't believe that Christians should be required to believe them literally.
 
St.Paul exhorts Timothy in scripture that ‘‘all scripture is inspired’’ the greek for which is theopneustos, it literall means ‘‘all scripture is God breathed’’ therefore just as God breathed life into adam and eve, so too does he breath life into his scriptures and God ‘‘who never lies’’ ( titus:12) I’m sure does not teach that there is anything ‘‘mythical’’ about his scriptures. Or that it conveys some truth but not all of it is true.

It is not a human expression of how things happened, it is a divine expression/account of how things happened. God worked with the free will of prophets to accomplish his word. at the end of the day, it takes faith to believe in scriptures and what the church teaches. I dont claim to have greater faith than anyone on this forum, but there you have it.

If you cant demonstrate using magisterial documents then dont bother demonstrating it isnt worth it.

“It is not an easy thing for a soul, under the influence of error, to be persuaded of the contrary opinion.” ( St.Irenaeus )
 
Hey folks, at my college of mater dei in dublin, below is exactly whats happening in our lectures, we are being taught that the book of Genesis is just all legend and mythical. Is there anyone on this forum who encountered the same type of heresy? :confused:

Pax Christi
Stephen
catholicscomehome.org/answers-scripture.php

''I had a theology teacher who told me that adam and eve were just myths, and that the rest of Genesis was all just legends…is that what the church teaches?"

"Absolutely not! The Church has always taught that Adam and Eve were real people and were the first human beings from whom all other human beings are descended. In 1950, Pope Pius XII, in Paragraph 37 of an encyclical entitled Humani Generis, states, “…the faithful cannot embrace that opinion which maintains either that after Adam there existed on this earth true men who did not take their origin through natural generation from [Adam] as from the first parent of all, or that Adam represents a certain number of first parents.” In other words, the Church teaches that all humanity descended from Adam and Eve. They had to be real for that to happen.

Paragraph #38, states: “This [encyclical], in fact, clearly points out that the first eleven chapters of Genesis…do nevertheless pertain to history in a true sense…” Again, Adam and Eve are not myths, and the rest of Genesis is not legend. They are history in a “true sense.”

Paragraph #39: “Therefore, whatever of the popular narrations have been inserted into the Sacred Scriptures must in no way be considered on a par with myths or other such things…” Can it be stated any clearer than that?

And listen to what the Catechism says, Paragraph #375, “The Church…teaches that our first parents, Adam and Eve…” No mention of a myth here.

Paragraph #404: "By yielding to the tempter, Adam and Eve committed a personal sin. Someone please tell me, how do myths commit personal sins?

Adam and Eve are not myths. Genesis does not contain myth or legend. That is Church teaching. Challenge anyone, who teaches differently, to produce their sources from a magisterial document. They cannot do it. They can, however, produce countless books and articles by “theologians”. Not good enough."
They are not myths in the true sense of the word. Adam and Eve were the first humans, but if this is some bash upon theistic evolution, please stop. Adam and Eve were the first humans, and fell to Satan’s temptations.

I know all Scipture is inspired by God. But if the writers of the Bible had said that the earth was round, that God guided evolution, if God USED ANYTHING that he created to perform miracles, the Bible would have been seen as crazy talk.

Think about it, if you believe in the literal seven days of creation, what would the Bible have to contain, to convince you that theistic evolution is the most likely cause? Oh, and it can’t be using today’s modern scientific words, becuase when the Bible was written, they wouldn’t have understood that.
 
They are not myths in the true sense of the word. Adam and Eve were the first humans, but if this is some bash upon theistic evolution, please stop. Adam and Eve were the first humans, and fell to Satan’s temptations.

I know all Scipture is inspired by God. But if the writers of the Bible had said that the earth was round, that God guided evolution, if God USED ANYTHING that he created to perform miracles, the Bible would have been seen as crazy talk.

Think about it, if you believe in the literal seven days of creation, what would the Bible have to contain, to convince you that theistic evolution is the most likely cause? Oh, and it can’t be using today’s modern scientific words, becuase when the Bible was written, they wouldn’t have understood that.
redratfish, what are you going on about? :confused: and how is your response relavent to the fact that the Church teaches or does not teach that the book of genesis contains mythical legend? scratches head

I’m not saying that God reveals everything to us in the Bible for that would render me to be protestant. as for the six literal days of creation, the church teaches that they were indeed six literal days, but thats a topic for another thread and not this one. Keep in central and focused to the issue and discussion at hand redratfish.
 
The Church doesn’t teach a literal six day creation. Mythology is the correct term to describe the creation stories in Genesis. Scripture doesn’t exist to teach scientific or historical truth, but theological truth. The Church respects these distinctions.
 
Hey folks, at my college of mater dei in dublin, below is exactly whats happening in our lectures, we are being taught that the book of Genesis is just all legend and mythical. Is there anyone on this forum who encountered the same type of heresy? :confused:
My area of interest are the two sole parents of the human species known as Adam and Eve. I am amazed at the variety of misconceptions, doubts, and attacks against this primary truth from both outside and inside the Catholic Church. While I have not attended lectures per se regarding demoted Adam and Eve, a few posters have indicated directly or indirectly where erroneous ideas have come from. My heart breaks when sincere posters have a hard time figuring out what to believe about their own religion in regard to Adam and Eve and Original Sin.

Blessings,
granny

Our first parent Adam was the apple of God’s eye.
(example of reality and figurative language)
 
The Church doesn’t teach a literal six day creation. Mythology is the correct term to describe the creation stories in Genesis. Scripture doesn’t exist to teach scientific or historical truth, but theological truth. The Church respects these distinctions.
Yes it does teach that the six days are literal and I have Catholic apologist John Salza ( www.scripturecatholic.com ) to back me up on that.

Mythology is not the correct term as I’ve just posted above in my original post, the church does not use this term. Granny there is no confusion I can see plainly that the church teaches what she teaches. Many purported practicing Catholics seem to want to believe in their heretical novelties and views of scripture, none of which are the churches view.
 
I respect those who believe in the Bible literally but I have come to the place where the first eleven chapters of Geneis appear to me to be mostly myth with a little history thrown in.
Code:
Let me illustrate with the Noah story. Probably there was a major flood in the Near East, which eventually was exaggerated into a flood covering the whole earth. However, how could Noah get two of every animal into that ark, how could the ark of the given dimensions hold them all, and how could they feed and clean up after them for the 150 days that the waters remained on the earth? Even more important to me, I can't believe that our loving God, who believes in forgiveness and justice, would drown everybody on earth except for the eight indicated - Noah and wife, three sons and wives. Keep in mind the Ten Commandments and the Sermon on the Mount for starters. Think of all the innocent children and the unborn who would have been murdered by God.

 No. Sorry, I can't believe that.

 Does that mean that the first eleven chapters are lies? No. I regard them as parables with moral messages of importance. But can we really believe that God punished mankind by giving it different languages because they built the Tower of Babel? If that were true, how about our skyscrapers, spacecraft, etc.? 

 All sorts of other problems.

 As for the rest of Genesis, basically the stories of the four patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Joseph, I have come to view them as some legitimate history mixed in with considerable folklore. 

 Besides all that, if you become a serious student of the Torah, the first five books, you will find that there are four distinct styles of Hebrew - often referred to as the J, E, P, and D. J - uses Jehovah. E uses Elohim. P is liturgical, priestly. D is Deuteronomic. Etc. This is not the place to go into further detail, but it shows that different men authored these books rather than just Moses, as tradition teaches (The Books of Moses). Why would you find word of Moses' death and burial in Deuteronomy if the five books were written by him? And if Moses wrote them, would he describe himself as the meekest man on the face of the earth (Numbers 12: 3)? I don't think so.

 Christianity loses educated, thinking people if it expects them to believe the unbelievable. On the other hand, if you can actually accept all such stories as factual, fine. I have tried but simply can't. And I don't believe that Christians should be required to believe them literally.
See post #3.
 
Hey folks, at my college of mater dei in dublin, below is exactly whats happening in our lectures, we are being taught that the book of Genesis is just all legend and mythical. Is there anyone on this forum who encountered the same type of heresy? :confused:

Pax Christi
Stephen
catholicscomehome.org/answers-scripture.php

''I had a theology teacher who told me that adam and eve were just myths, and that the rest of Genesis was all just legends…is that what the church teaches?"

"Absolutely not! The Church has always taught that Adam and Eve were real people and were the first human beings from whom all other human beings are descended. In 1950, Pope Pius XII, in Paragraph 37 of an encyclical entitled Humani Generis, states, “…the faithful cannot embrace that opinion which maintains either that after Adam there existed on this earth true men who did not take their origin through natural generation from [Adam] as from the first parent of all, or that Adam represents a certain number of first parents.” In other words, the Church teaches that all humanity descended from Adam and Eve. They had to be real for that to happen.

Paragraph #38, states: “This [encyclical], in fact, clearly points out that the first eleven chapters of Genesis…do nevertheless pertain to history in a true sense…” Again, Adam and Eve are not myths, and the rest of Genesis is not legend. They are history in a “true sense.”

Paragraph #39: “Therefore, whatever of the popular narrations have been inserted into the Sacred Scriptures must in no way be considered on a par with myths or other such things…” Can it be stated any clearer than that?

And listen to what the Catechism says, Paragraph #375, “The Church…teaches that our first parents, Adam and Eve…” No mention of a myth here.

Paragraph #404: "By yielding to the tempter, Adam and Eve committed a personal sin. Someone please tell me, how do myths commit personal sins?

Adam and Eve are not myths. Genesis does not contain myth or legend. That is Church teaching. Challenge anyone, who teaches differently, to produce their sources from a magisterial document. They cannot do it. They can, however, produce countless books and articles by “theologians”. Not good enough."
I’m certain you took your professor out of context. Perhaps she or he was simply stating that it is quite all right for you as a catholic if you are one to take certain accounts from the book of Genesis in a non literal manner.

The entire book is quite a different thing than the key events in it that we now understand better with evidence that tells us it was not literal in all the accounts.
 
I’m certain you took your professor out of context. Perhaps she or he was simply stating that it is quite all right for you as a catholic if you are one to take certain accounts from the book of Genesis in a non literal manner.

The entire book is quite a different thing than the key events in it that we now understand better with evidence that tells us it was not literal in all the accounts.
The faithful cannot depart from the unanimous interpretation of the Magesterium of the Church. the church does not teach that we are to take the book of Genesis in a non literal manner. There is only some symbolism in Genesis such as Gods work and rest, for God does not literally labor or tire. But thats it. The faithful cannot embrace the idea that anything contained in Genesis is mythical or legendry. Paragraph #39: “Therefore, whatever of the popular narrations have been inserted into the Sacred Scriptures must in no way be considered on a par with myths or other such things…” Can it be stated any clearer than that?
 
The faithful cannot depart from the unanimous interpretation of the Magesterium of the Church. the church does not teach that we are to take the book of Genesis in a non literal manner. There is only some symbolism in Genesis such as Gods work and rest, for God does not literally labor or tire. But thats it. The faithful cannot embrace the idea that anything contained in Genesis is mythical or legendry. Paragraph #39: “Therefore, whatever of the popular narrations have been inserted into the Sacred Scriptures must in no way be considered on a par with myths or other such things…” Can it be stated any clearer than that?
I have no idea who is teaching you Catholic theology, but I would consider getting a properly trained theologian to correct your misunderstandings.
 
I have no idea who is teaching you Catholic theology, but I would consider getting a properly trained theologian to correct your misunderstandings.
I have strawberry Jam, and many properly trained theologians and doctors of the faith such as John Salza and Dr.Robert Sungenis and also catholicscomehome.org have done that for me. Its all there. Not one theologian has demonstrated their belief that the story of Genesis was mythical using the Sacred Magesterium of the Church.

Ireland and the universal Church is at the moment is investigating this spiritual abuse within these alleged catholic colleges that claim to carry the catholic stamp. Archbishop timothy dolan is coming next month and his first port of call is my college ‘‘Mater Dei’’ I’ve sent him a letter already expressing my concerns and confirming whats going on behind its doors. I’m spending a lot of money that I dont have to attend college, I have a right to get the catholic doctrine in its fullness. I wonder what he will find. They are also teaching a heresy known as ‘‘Higher criticism’’.
 
** What Does The Catholic Church **Teach about Origins?
(pdf version)

  • God created everything “in its whole substance” from nothing (ex nihilo) in the beginning.
    (Lateran IV; Vatican Council I)
  • Genesis does not contain purified myths. (Pontifical Biblical Commission 1909[1])
  • Genesis contains real history—it gives an account of things that really happened. (Pius XII)
  • Adam and Eve were real human beings—the first parents of all mankind. (Pius XII)
  • Polygenism (many “first parents”) contradicts Scripture and Tradition and is condemned. (Pius XII; 1994 Catechism, 360, footnote 226: Tobit 8:6—the “one ancestor” referred to in this Catechism could only be Adam.)
  • The “beginning” of the world included the creation of all things, the creation of Adam and Eve and the Fall (Jesus Christ Mark 10:6]; Pope Innocent III; Blessed Pope Pius IX, Ineffabilis Deus).
  • The body of Eve was specially created from a portion of Adam’s body (Leo XIII). She could not have originated via evolution.
  • Various senses are employed in the Bible, but the literal obvious sense must be believed unless reason dictates or necessity requires (Leo XIII, Providentissimus Deus).
  • Adam and Eve were created upon an earthly paradise and would not have known death if they had remained obedient (Pius XII).
  • After their disobedience of God, Adam and Eve were banished from the Garden of Eden. But the Second Person of the Trinity would subsequently pay the ransom for fallen man (Nicene Creed).
  • Original Sin is a flawed condition inherited from Adam and Eve (Council of Trent).
  • The Universe suffers in travail ever since the sin of disobedience by Adam and Eve. (Romans 8, Vatican Council I).
  • We must believe any interpretation of Scripture that the Fathers taught unanimously on a matter of faith or morals (Council of Trent and Vatican Council I).
  • All the Fathers who wrote on the subject believed that the Creation days were no longer than 24-hour-days. (Consensus of the Fathers of the Church)
  • The work of Creation was finished by the close of Day Six, and nothing completely new has since been created—except for each human rational soul at conception (Vatican Council I)
  • St. Peter and Christ Himself in the New Testament confirmed the global Flood of Noah. It covered all the then high mountains and destroyed all land dwelling creatures except eight human beings and all kinds of non-human creatures aboard the Ark (Unam Sanctam, 1302)
  • The historical existence of Noah’s Ark is regarded as most important in typology, as central to Redemption. (1566 Catechism of the Council of Trent)
  • Evolution must not be taught as fact, but instead the pros and cons of evolution must be taught.
    (Pius XII, Humani Generis)
  • Investigation into human “evolution” was allowed in 1950, but Pope Pius XII feared that an acceptance of evolutionism might adversely affect doctrinal beliefs.
 
I thank God for your post buffalo, you are a little light within this discussion God bless you.

I pray that many misguided catholics will embrace their faith instead of ripping it to pieces and questioning it. ⭕)😃
 
I have strawberry Jam, and many properly trained theologians and doctors of the faith such as John Salza and Dr.Robert Sungenis and also catholicscomehome.org have done that for me. Its all there. Not one theologian has demonstrated their belief that the story of Genesis was mythical using the Sacred Magesterium of the Church.

Ireland and the universal Church is at the moment is investigating this spiritual abuse within these alleged catholic colleges that claim to carry the catholic stamp. Archbishop timothy dolan is coming next month and his first port of call is my college ‘‘Mater Dei’’ I’ve sent him a letter already expressing my concerns and confirming whats going on behind its doors. I’m spending a lot of money that I dont have to attend college, I have a right to get the catholic doctrine in its fullness. I wonder what he will find. They are also teaching a heresy known as ‘‘Higher criticism’’.
Sungenis? Isn’t he denying scientific facts that all Catholics are allowed to believe? Regarding the Sun?

Isn’t he considered a fringe thinker and not an authority on science? Hasn’t he been debated and lost time and time again by his very own Catholic brothers in apologetics?

If you are a Catholic in union with Rome, and not in a schimatic sect of her, then you shouldn’t be using him as a defense on scientific matters.
 
Sungenis? Isn’t he denying scientific facts that all Catholics are allowed to believe? Regarding the Sun?

Isn’t he considered a fringe thinker and not an authority on science? Hasn’t he been debated and lost time and time again by his very own Catholic brothers in apologetics?

If you are a Catholic in union with Rome, and not in a schimatic sect of her, then you shouldn’t be using him as a defense on scientific matters.
Quote me a magisterial document that says we are to believe in heliocentrism and I’ll get back to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top