Getting through the holidays with non-Catholic family

  • Thread starter Thread starter dei_gratia15
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You are not alone. I’m a new Catholic (confirmed as a college senior this year) dealing with a similar family situation this Christmas. It’s hard when I feel like I’m putting others out to accommodate my mass schedule… I will pray for a peaceful resolution between you and your family. Please pray for me, too.
 
I deal with my elderly mother the Baptist this way: I say I am going to Mass and then I tell her what time I will return. By giving her my estimated time of return she can make plans. If she expresses displeasure I repeat firmly what time I will be back.

Don’t forget to mention that you enjoy attending Mass!
 
I really hope you’re right about this. We discussed it this afternoon and they said they didn’t want me traveling to the midnight mass tonight because of the distance and how dangerous the roads are right now. I can understand this as honestly it’s also a concern of mine. I invited them but they firmly declined and I said I was going to the only morning mass there is tomorrow and I hope they’ll respect my decision in the morning and not try to stop me from leaving. When I said I would go Christmas morning though they accused me of “abandoning them” on Christmas and not following our usual Christmas traditions (that don’t include mass) so I’m concerned as to how the morning will play out. I’ve stayed calm the whole time I’ve been discussing it with them but I still feel like I’m the one causing the “drama” on Christmas and this is a little upsetting. 😦
I suppose in my family situation I tend to be the assertive one and my other family members are more pliable (or just very respectful) so I never get any arguments.

Either way, just think to yourself what’s the worst that you ought to expect. Are they going to shun you because you go to Mass on Christmas Eve / Day? It doesn’t seem like it. If they complain, just respond with charity and tell them that Mass is very religiously important to your life now.

Gl. I think you’ll be okay.
 
. When I said I would go Christmas morning though they accused me of “abandoning them” on Christmas and not following our usual Christmas traditions (that don’t include mass)
With all dues respect I don’t think this is a religious issue. Sounds like your parents just don’t accept your growing up. Seriously, if you didn’t convert but had a girlfriend and said ‘I will be going to my girlfriends for an hour’ would they accuse you of abandoning them? I suspect they will.

Praise God you are now practicing the faith and will have the grace to cope with the family dynamics
 
With all dues respect I don’t think this is a religious issue. Sounds like your parents just don’t accept your growing up. Seriously, if you didn’t convert but had a girlfriend and said ‘I will be going to my girlfriends for an hour’ would they accuse you of abandoning them? I suspect they will.

Praise God you are now practicing the faith and will have the grace to cope with the family dynamics
Honestly they don’t care what else I do. It only seems to matter when I’m going to mass. Christmas is really just a materialistic holiday in my family and they are not accepting of any religion at all so I didn’t expect them to be ecstatic when I converted but I also wasn’t expecting to be cussed out for trying to attend mass on Christmas. I did make it to mass this morning thankfully so now it’s just getting through the next couple of weeks. But I’m going to focus on enjoying Christmas for now and the reason for the season and keep praying it gets better!

Merry Christmas!
 
You are not alone. I’m a new Catholic (confirmed as a college senior this year) dealing with a similar family situation this Christmas. It’s hard when I feel like I’m putting others out to accommodate my mass schedule… I will pray for a peaceful resolution between you and your family. Please pray for me, too.
Thank you very much! I will keep you and your family in my prayers!
 
Honestly they don’t care what else I do. It only seems to matter when I’m going to mass. Christmas is really just a materialistic holiday in my family and they are not accepting of any religion at all so I didn’t expect them to be ecstatic when I converted but I also wasn’t expecting to be cussed out for trying to attend mass on Christmas.
Welcome to the church and merry Christmas!

I’m sorry things are tough, but I’m afraid it is all very common with family members who are anti-religious. I faced the same when I converted in my late teens. Some family members took it very personally and I was regularly insulted because of my faith during family visits.

Things might change in the future, but they also might not. Jesus did warn us that people will reject us and families will be split over this question.

Having said that, never be the one to respond in anger and with hostility. It is admirable that you are respectful and kind even though they are not. Always keep it that way to please our Lord.

I’m afraid I have no better advice on how to handle this situation, I just wanted to say that I sympathise. God bless.
 
Check with your diocese, New Year’s Day is not a Holy Day of Obligation in my diocese.
There is an obligation to attend Mass on New Year’s (Solemnity of Mary, Mother of God), except in years when the holy day falls on a Saturday or a Monday.
 
…They think it’s ridiculous just to go to church every week so these other “random days” will not make any sense to them and I fear they are going to think (like they do every week) that I am simply choosing to not spend time with them and spend time somewhere else.
Do you invite them to come with you? It would be a bit harder for them to think you’re looking for an excuse to get away from them if you were always inviting them to come along. For instance, if you say, “Would anyone like to come to Mass with me this weekend? We could go at 5:30 on Saturday night, at 8:30 or 10:30 on Sunday morning, or at 7 pm on Sunday night.” If they decline the invitation, then you ask if one of those times would work better for them as the time that you go by yourself, freeing up the rest of the time to spend with them. (It would be an act of charity to make it a point to attend Mass at the time that is best for the rest of your family, even if they are not going with you.)
 
Do you invite them to come with you? It would be a bit harder for them to think you’re looking for an excuse to get away from them if you were always inviting them to come along. For instance, if you say, “Would anyone like to come to Mass with me this weekend? We could go at 5:30 on Saturday night, at 8:30 or 10:30 on Sunday morning, or at 7 pm on Sunday night.” If they decline the invitation, then you ask if one of those times would work better for them as the time that you go by yourself, freeing up the rest of the time to spend with them. (It would be an act of charity to make it a point to attend Mass at the time that is best for the rest of your family, even if they are not going with you.)
I do invite them most of the time but every time they make it known that they’re not interested in going to church and say whatever hurtful things they can think of in an attempt to stop me from going and inviting them usually results in an even greater scene than if I just go on my own. I try to make the times as convenient for them as I can but the local parish is very small and typically only has one vigil mass time and one morning mass time on Sundays and holy days of obligation.
Welcome to the church and merry Christmas!

I’m sorry things are tough, but I’m afraid it is all very common with family members who are anti-religious. I faced the same when I converted in my late teens. Some family members took it very personally and I was regularly insulted because of my faith during family visits.

Things might change in the future, but they also might not. Jesus did warn us that people will reject us and families will be split over this question.

Having said that, never be the one to respond in anger and with hostility. It is admirable that you are respectful and kind even though they are not. Always keep it that way to please our Lord.

I’m afraid I have no better advice on how to handle this situation, I just wanted to say that I sympathise. God bless.
Thank you for sharing with me. It is comforting to know I am not alone in this. I hope things have gotten better for you and I will remember your family in my prayers.
 
I do invite them most of the time but every time they make it known that they’re not interested in going to church and say whatever hurtful things they can think of in an attempt to stop me from going and inviting them usually results in an even greater scene than if I just go on my own.

Thank you for sharing with me. It is comforting to know I am not alone in this. I hope things have gotten better for you and I will remember your family in my prayers.
Happy New Year! Thank you for the prayers, I appreciate it.

Things have got better over the years. But I also learned to respond in a way that makes people aware that I don’t put up with rudeness anymore. It has been just over 20 years since my conversion. I have a family of my own so this is now a completely different story.

As for the above, just don’t invite them. They perhaps see it as some kind of an insult or bait. Go to mass and offer this suffering for their conversion. Sometimes we can’t avoid suffering, so let’s at least put it to good use. You are doing great 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top