Glances toward women

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic555
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Catholic555

Guest
As I try harder than ever before to banish impure thoughts and look to God, is it considered a sin if you catch yourself looking at a regular picture of a girl in a news article or on the street? Right when it happens, I pray for them and ask for Jesus to deliver me from temptation. I would assume that “involuntary” glances are not mortal sins? Thanks and God bless.
 
You want to avoid all images that draw you to lust. If just looking at a girl who looks pretty and is wearing nice, modest clothes draws you to lust, that’s a more serious problem than I’ve ever had. There is a difference between admiring a girl’s beauty and feeling lust. For instance, if I just glimpse a pretty face on the street, I might take a few moments to admire it. That doesn’t create any sinful thoughts in me; I’m not thinking about sex or dehumanizing her at all. But if I see a girl in a bikini, that’s a different story. So I look away immediately when I see her, but not if I see the pretty and modestly dressed woman. That’s my approach, anyway. I’m not saying it’s the best.
 
I don’t think you’re sinning at all. You are handling it the right way by correcting your thoughts as soon as you can. Don’t worry. You cannot help what pops in your head. We would all be in trouble. It’s what you do about it that matters, and you are not dwelling on it. You are handling it the mature way. Keep it up. 👍
 
Involuntary glances are not sinful in themselves. It depends what you do in the ensuing moments. It sounds like you are doing the right thing, turning to prayer and Jesus.

It all deals with the constant battle of the spirit versus the flesh. The spirit looks upon a body and sees it as God’s creation, neither ugly nor beautiful. The flesh looks upon a body and sees it as an object of ugliness or beauty. The spirit and body present their cases to the mind. This is where your free will comes in. You must make a decision to follow the will of the flesh or the will of the mind.
 
Whatever is a proximate occassion of sin, you do what is necessary to avoid it. Whatever is necessary. 🙂

‘The saints were particularly cautious not to look at persons of a different sex. St. Hugh, bishop, when compelled to speak with women, never looked at them in the face. St. Clare would never fix her eyes on the face of a man. She was greatly afflicted because, when raising her eyes at the elevation to see the consecrated host, she once involuntarily saw the countenance of the priest. St. Aloysius never looked at his own mother in the face. It is related of St. Arsenius, that a noble lady went to visit him in the desert, to beg of him to recommend her to God. When the saint perceived that his visitor was a woman, he turned away from her. She then said to him: “Arsenius, since you will neither seen or hear me, at least remember me in your prayers.” “No,” replied the saint, “but I will beg of God to make me forget you, and never more to think of you.”’

. . . Hence, to avoid the sight of dangerous objects, the saints were accustomed to keep their eyes almost continually fixed on the earth, and to abstain even from looking at innocent objects. After being a novice for a year, St. Bernard could not tell whether his cell was vaulted. In consequence of never raising his eyes from the ground, he never knew that there were but three windows to the church of the monastery, in which he spent his novitiate. He once, without perceiving a lake, walked along its banks for nearly an entire day; and hearing his companions speak about it, he asked when they had seen it. St. Peter of Alcantara kept his eyes constantly cast down, so that he did not know the brothers with whom he conversed. It was by the voice, and not by the countenance, that he was able to recognize them.

St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori

This too much for you? Better it than sin…

Consider this:

The indulgence of the eyes, if not productive of any other evil, at least destroys recollection during the time of prayer. For, the images and impressions caused by the objects seen before, or by the wandering of the eyes, during prayer, will occasion a thousand distractions, and banish all recollection from the soul. It is certain that without recollection a religious can pay but little attention to the practice of humility, patience, mortification, or of the other virtues. Hence it is her duty to abstain from all looks of curiosity, which distract her mind from holy thoughts. Let her eyes be directed only to objects which raise the soul to God. St. Bernard used to say, that to fix the eyes upon the earth contributes to keep the heart in heaven. “Where,” says St. Gregory, “Christ is, there modesty is found.” Wherever Jesus Christ dwells by love, there modesty is practiced. However, I do not mean to say that the eyes should never be raised or never fixed on any object. No; but they ought to be directed only to what inspires devotion, to sacred images, and to the beauty of creation, which elevate the soul to the contemplation of the divinity. Except in looking at such objects, a religious should in general keep the eyes cast down, and particularly in places where they may fall upon dangerous objects. In conversing with men, she should never roll the eyes about to look at them, and much less to look at them a second time. . .

“It is not,” says St. Francis de Sales, “the seeing of objects so much as the fixing of our eyes upon them that proves most pernicious.” “If,” says St. Augustine, “our eyes should by chance fall upon others, let us take care never to fix them upon any one.” Father Manareo, when taking leave of St. Ignatius for a distant place, looked steadfastly in his face: for this look he was corrected by the saint. From the conduct of St. Ignatius on this occasion, we learn that it was not becoming in religious to fix their eyes on the countenance of a person even of the same sex, particularly if the person is young. But I do not see how looks at young persons of a different sex can be excused from the guilt of a venial fault, or even from mortal sin, when there is proximate danger of criminal consent. “It is not lawful,” says St. Gregory, “to behold what it is not lawful to covet.” The evil thought that proceeds from looks, though it should be rejected, never fails to leave a stain upon the soul. Brother Roger, a Franciscan of singular purity, being once asked why he was so reserved in his intercourse with women, replied, that when men avoid the occasions of sin, God preserves them; but when they expose themselves to danger, they are justly abandoned by the Lord, and easily fall into some grievous transgressions.’

St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori

‘To abstain from sinful actions is not sufficient for the fulfillment of God’s law. The very desire of what is forbidden is evil.’

St. John Baptist de la Salle
 
As I try harder than ever before to banish impure thoughts and look to God, is it considered a sin if you catch yourself looking at a regular picture of a girl in a news article or on the street? Right when it happens, I pray for them and ask for Jesus to deliver me from temptation. I would assume that “involuntary” glances are not mortal sins? Thanks and God bless.
A wise priest once pointed out to me that there is a difference between lust and temptation.
 
I would assume that “involuntary” glances are not mortal sins?
Depends on how long is your involuntary glance. If it takes more than 5 seconds then you’re in trouble 😉

But seriously, the key verse to keep in mind would be :* “but I say to you that everyone who looks at a woman with lust for her has already committed adultery with her in his heart.”* (Mt 5:28). Is it possible to admire the appearance of a woman with unadulterated, purely innocent admiration? I say yes, and that would be exemplary. Adam and Eve took of the fruit, and they became conscious of their nakedness. Thus it is very difficult for us today because of our sinful nature. So, I would go for all 4 of the advises above.
 
Shin, a while ago, I was reading St. John of the Cross’s “Ascent to Mount Carmel,” and in it, he described how one must resist having any desires for anything, how one must be absolutely purified of all desire except for God alone. Reading that chapter was very trying for me as it was so intensely demanding that every single thought be perfectly submissive to God, that we have 0 attachment to the world.

Then a Carmelite instructor told me that this was referring to Catholics in the “way of the perfect,” that it was the call to the most sublime piety for those that are the most advanced in the Christian walk. It is not something all Christians are called to bend themselves to now, prior to our having the grace of the perfect which would enable us to accomplish this.

I reckon that the same is true of the writings of the saints you have just brought up. This may be something in the “way of the perfect,” and I’d add that beyond that, it may be something that not everyone is called to.

It’s not like we always sin when we look at a woman. We don’t. Jesus was fine with looking at women and I read nothing in the Bible implying any of His disciples or apostles averted their eyes from looking at modestly dressed women either. There were women in the company of disciples who went with them wherever they went. It would have been difficult for this to work out if the disciples were constantly trying to not look at them. Also, the Wedding at Cana proves Jesus was fine with looking at His Mother, and He is recorded as talking with even loose women like the woman at the well. He spent time with the prostitutes, for the sake of their souls, and many other holy men have done this as well, like St. John of the Cross. St. John of the Cross spent a whole lot of his time with prostitutes for the sake of their souls, even though their lewd and coarse behavior was undoubtedly a frequent temptation to sin.

From St. Faustina’s Diary, I gather she was perfectly fine with looking at men (though not lustfully), as it’s an exhaustive account of her thoughts and piety, and in it one can read how she often encountered men. There is no indication she always averted her eyes. St. John of the Cross goes to great lengths in “The Ascent of Mount Carmel” to describe how every single thought must be pure, but he never says, at least as far as I remember, that one must not look at anyone of the opposite gender. I don’t remember ever reading this in St. Therese of Lisieux’s piety either, and I know it wasn’t in St. Teresa of Avila’s. She was always meeting various men for the sake of expanding her reforms of the monastic movement. Blessed Teresa of Calcutta was there with love for both men and women. Pope John Paul II, who will probably be declared a saint in time, was very often meeting with women in the practice of his Christian duties. He never tried to avoid them, any more than Jesus did.

Not all the saints practiced the particular form of piety you brought up, that of not even looking at someone of the opposite gender. Jesus Himself says that the one who looks at a woman lustfully sins, not the one who looks at a woman and that’s it.

I won’t criticize the form of piety you brought up, Shin. God may well have called these saints to do that and it might even be the normal practice in the way of the perfect – I personally doubt it, but I don’t know. It is clear that the saints’ motive was pure when they committed themselves to this, though. For their motive was to avoid occasions to sin, and their course of action in seeking godliness was radical, which is very meritorious.

The only criticism I will make is that I doubt St. Arsenius was doing God’s will when he rejected his visitor without so much as a prayer on her behalf.

But I will say that I seriously doubt this form of piety is something all Catholics, at all stages of their spiritual lives, are called to practice. Many of the saints never practiced it, even though they were in the way of the perfect.
 
If I understand the point of what you are saying, I do not like to hear of ‘instructors’ counseling mediocrity in love of Christ if that is what was counseled. That is counseling lack of love of Christ.

Jesus Christ calls all men to be perfect, in the sense of moral perfection. 🙂 He has stated it plainly. You must be perfect. There are no options there.

In Heaven everyone is perfect. If you do not aim to love God as perfectly as possible in this life, you may well go to Hell for aiming for less, which is simply sin in any case.

So it seems off the mark to approach the statements of the saints in this fashion if I understand you correctly. 🙂

That said the method of achieving this may vary for person, and state in life. Each person has different vulnerabilities, though that are not all that must be paid attention to – the example for others is important too. The keys that I wished to communicate above was that you do whatever is necessary, and that focus is the fundamental to this.

Whatever is necessary, as in, however extreme, however displeasing or unreasonable it seems to the eyes of worldly folks, you do it. It is your soul at risk, and God’s pleasures, not some convenience or human respect, which deserves none.

And you are not alone when you do this, the saints are your models. If the world is your model that is a problem. 🙂

St. Padre Pio healed one blind man, and left another blind for his entire life. The one he healed, the other he did not. The other he told to be cured would send his soul to Hell.

Isn’t it better to be blind than go to Hell? Does it sound unreasonable that simply because you were blind or not you would go to Heaven or Hell? But Christ has said it Himself. And it is true. I think Heaven would have many more people than the relative few it has in it compared to Hell, if a great many more people were born blind.

In some ways in life, without blinding ourselves physically, we can be effectively blind to things, because we do not look, and if it is before us, we do not see, in mind or in sight.

And so, we avoid the near occasion of sin, and we lose focus – and we break bad habits and memories, so that we no longer focus, think or default to the desire of the world, the pleasures and the flesh. And since we are coming out from being cripples because of these sinful desires the medicines and treatments can and do force us to do things differently and prevent us from doing some things.

What do they prevent us from doing? Whatever brings us into a near occasion of sin. And so I think the examples above give a clue as to what has to be done and may in some cases be what has to be done or the near equivalent of it. 🙂

Perhaps not always, but perhaps too.

I have my doubts about Pope John Paul being declared a saint, amongst others, he spoke much in general but not in specific as what needed to be done, and did not do and did do a great deal that causes much trouble. Saints more do good all in all, rather than appear as quite so tragically flawed figures at best.

I think St. Arsenius could be a key saint for you. He could help you more than the others, because he could be a saint for conversion. St. Arsenius puts the first commandment first, and the second second, rather than reversing them. If you learn to understand why he did what he did instead of reject it that will help you a good deal.

There are many things that the saints quoted here teach… They teach modesty of the eyes, humility in the face of God rather than proudly taking risks, they teach avoiding the near occasion of sin, they teach reliance on God, they teach looking away and out of the corner, rather than focus.

And I think focus is the key here, what is beheld is beheld without beholding. And they give no material for the devils to work with, in their memories. If they do not remember or think about what tempts them, they avoid the near occasion of sin, and remember and think about God who is what all must be seen through if it is seen.

Not focusing that is a great key. 🙂

Avoiding the near occasion of sin, absolutely necessary. Whatever it may be.

‘You must strive with all possible care to please God in such a manner as neither to do nor behold anything, without first consulting Him, and in everything to seek Him alone and His glory.’

St. Alphonsus Rodriguez

‘To abstain from sinful actions is not sufficient for the fulfillment of God’s law. The very desire of what is forbidden is evil.’

St. John Baptist de la Salle
 
Dear Shin,

I do not believing that gazing on beautiful women modestly clothed is an occasion to sin for me. When I look at them, I do not think of them sexually. I am attracted to their beauty, but to my knowledge, there is not any lustful thought occurring. If there was, I would follow the saints you brought up and avert my eyes even from this.

I brought up several examples in my last post of saints who did not practice this particular form of piety. I do not condemn the piety you brought up or criticize it. I might end up joining it myself. I don’t know. But the fact that many saints lived differently suggests it isn’t a necessary part of Catholic living for everyone.

As for our difference regarding the “way of the perfect” I mentioned to you, I think this could use some more explaining. The Catholic mystical life passes through three stages for the saint. The stages are the Purgative, then the Illuminative and finally the Unitive (or Perfect). These stages are a process of development, of ever deepening unity with Christ.

While St. Bernard of Clairveux was living in the Unitive way of perfection, he tried to bring his students up its slopes to join him. He insisted on their practicing the most rigorous mortifications and purgations of desires, insisting on them cutting away all indulgence so sharply that the way was too steep for them and they often left him in despair. Finally, an angel from the Lord appeared to St. Bernard in a vision and told him that he was trying to make them join him in an instant in a place God had taken him to in a journey that took years.

The vision deeply impressed St. Bernard and he came out of it filled with gentleness. He changed his methods radically, giving his pupils easier lessons first, lessons of ethics they were able to master, and as they moved closer to God through these, they slowly became more capable of handling his rigorous teachings, and as they did, he gave them these too to practice.

Someone in the Way of the Purgative is not already in the Way of the Unitive and cannot do everything that people in the Way of the Unitive can do. They do not have sufficient grace or unity with God . . . though they should seek it! As St. Teresa of Avila says, “put aside your little works; stop walking and run! Then the way will be shorter and you will spend less time in the difficult places.” We need to pursue God hard, but it is not required that we have everything at once. Growth in the spiritual life is like growth in the body. We start small and grow larger slowly over the course of years (or sometimes in an instant through a supernatural miracle, as St. Francis de Sales points out). If we stop growing larger, we will eventually fall away from God, but if we keep growing and blooming at the natural and best speed, we will receive Him in His fullness of grace.
40.png
Shin:
I have my doubts about Pope John Paul being declared a saint, amongst others, he spoke much in general but not in specific as what needed to be done, and did not do and did do a great deal that causes much trouble. Saints more do good all in all, rather than appear as quite so tragically flawed figures at best.
I think this is far too harsh an assessment. Pope John Paul II brought about the downfall of the USSR through his impact on Poland and the power of God. He also was shot and forgave his attacker. He spoke the truth against contraception, abortion and the desire of women to enter the priesthood. He was a pillar of apostolic truth and lived gracious love.
 
40.png
Shin:
I think St. Arsenius could be a key saint for you. He could help you more than the others, because he could be a saint for conversion. St. Arsenius puts the first commandment first, and the second second, rather than reversing them. If you learn to understand why he did what he did instead of reject it that will help you a good deal.
Perhaps you are right. I believe that if you are right about this, St. Arsenius will correct me. I have prayed to him as you just recommended. Here is the Bible passage that comes to mind, describing the situation you brought up from St. Arsenius.
Luke 10:27-37:
27He answered: " ‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind’; and, ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’"

28"You have answered correctly," Jesus replied. “Do this and you will live.”

29But he wanted to justify himself, so he asked Jesus, “And who is my neighbor?”

30In reply Jesus said: "A man was going down from Jerusalem to Jericho, when he fell into the hands of robbers. They stripped him of his clothes, beat him and went away, leaving him half dead. 31A priest happened to be going down the same road, and when he saw the man, he passed by on the other side. 32So too, a Levite, when he came to the place and saw him, passed by on the other side. 33But a Samaritan, as he traveled, came where the man was; and when he saw him, he took pity on him. 34He went to him and bandaged his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. Then he put the man on his own donkey, took him to an inn and took care of him. 35The next day he took out two silver coins[e] and gave them to the innkeeper. ‘Look after him,’ he said, ‘and when I return, I will reimburse you for any extra expense you may have.’

36"Which of these three do you think was a neighbor to the man who fell into the hands of robbers?"

37The expert in the law replied, “The one who had mercy on him.”
Jesus told him, “Go and do likewise.”
I personally think the woman St. Arsenius met was the man injured on the road in need of help (the woman came a long way for guidance and prayer, so she was serious and wanted help in her spiritual life). St. Arsenius was the Levite – the man of God – who passed the injured man by on the other side of the road for fear of becoming unclean.

St. John of God loved the whores and spent huge amounts of time with them for the sake of their souls. Their lewdness and coarseness certainly put him at risk of becoming unclean but he took the risk for their sake. He was the Good Samaritan who took the injured man to the inn and bandaged his wounds, pouring on oil and wine and giving coins to the innkeeper to look after him. He brought healing.

Now please note that I am NOT judging St. Arsenius’ whole life or ministry. I have the greatest of respect for him. I cannot tell you how much I approve of and praise him. He was, and is, a truly amazing man of God. I am thrilled that the Church canonized him and am fully convinced he is a great saint in Heaven, very humble and loving of God and his neighbor, only not on this particular occasion.

St. Arsenius teaches me deeply through his life how to show true humility and abandonment of self. He brings great glory to God in Heaven.

I thank God for St. Arsenius and humble myself before both. I have passed the injured man lying on the side of the road before too. Only a couple weeks ago, a couple elderly gentlemen and I met a man who was somewhat mentally imbalanced and held extremely strange, wild opinions. I held aloof from him while the elderly Catholics I was with, men that are more mature Christians than I am, talked with him with great love and generosity. And a few months ago, a very kind Christian woman came to me asking for money to feed her children and I turned her away. I have passed the injured man on the side of the road many times, and I pray God may help me to do better.

St. Arsenius is a much greater man than I and in his life was infinitely closer to God. Yet I do believe he was in the wrong on this occasion. I don’t think he would mind my holding that opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top