God cannot be God without Man

  • Thread starter Thread starter MiserereMei25
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Without man, God would be completely unknown except to the angels. Without the angels He would be completely unknown to any of His creation. Seems like He had to create some sentient being to recognize Him as possibly to exist. It’s a shame He didn’t provide any proof. All He gave us was speculation that He exists. That’ not very good evidence of certainty.
 
God is love. Love is outwardly directed. There was never a time when God was not creating, and then changed to begin creating. Rather, creation has been eternally willed by God. As St. Thomas Aquinas says in book 1, Chapter 76 of his Summa Contra Gentiles:
…If, then, someone wills separately the end and the things ordered to the end, there will be a certain discursiveness in His will. But this cannot be in God, since He is outside all motion. It remains, then, that God wills Himself and other things together and in the same act of will.

[5] Again, since God wills Himself always, if He wills Himself and other things by different acts it will follow that there are at once two acts of will in Him. This is impossible, since one simple power does not have at once two operations.

[6] Furthermore, in every act of the will the object willed is to the one willing as a mover to the moved. If, then, there be some action of the divine will, by which God wills things other than Himself, which is diverse from the action by which He wills Himself, there will be in Him some other mover of the divine will. This is impossible.

[7] Moreover, God’s willing is His being, as has been proved. But in God there is only one being. Therefore, there is in Him only one willing.

[8] Again, willing belongs to God according as He is intelligent. Therefore, just as by one act He understands Himself and other things, in so far as His essence is the exemplar of all things, so by one act He wills Himself and other things, in so far as His goodness is the likeness of all goodness.
In Summa Contra Gentiles Book 2: CREATION Chapters 12, 13, and 14, St. Thomas Aquinas speaks further on the idea that something is said of God in relation to creatures.

Summa Contra Gentiles Book 2: Creation, Chapter 11

It is not that God is contingent on man, but rather that man, made in the image of God, is the lovingly visible, creative outpouring that flows from God.

Without man having been created by God with free will and the ability to freely come to know Him, love Him, and serve Him in this life, or to reject Him and to live only for our own desires, God as we know Him would not be the same.

Again, God is not contingent on us; but rather we and all creation are the logical results of His eternal willing of both Himself and all of creation through a single, loving, and eternal act of will.
 
Last edited:
God has promised that He will be with Man and not fail him nor forsake him. Therefore, God, because He always keeps His promises, cannot be God without Man.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top