God referred to as "Herself"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Demetra2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Demetra2

Guest
Recently in our church bulletin in a section dedicated to scripture study, God was repeatedly referred to as “She” and “Herself”. The point of the study was to discuss the feminine nature of God which I understand, however, I did not feel comfortable with actually referring to God as a ‘she’. I did some research and Cardinal Ratzinger discussed this and also did not approve od referring to God as “She”. I asked the priest about this and he said that he would forward my email to the author but did not give his opinion. There has been no reply from the author either. Should I be concerned about this? I feel that if Jesus wanted us to refer to His Father in the feminine He would have made that abundantly clear. I also wonder if the author’s real point is to make a case for women in the priesthood.
 
Recently in our church bulletin in a section dedicated to scripture study, God was repeatedly referred to as “She” and “Herself”. The point of the study was to discuss the feminine nature of God which I understand, however, I did not feel comfortable with actually referring to God as a ‘she’. I did some research and Cardinal Ratzinger discussed this and also did not approve od referring to God as “She”. I asked the priest about this and he said that he would forward my email to the author but did not give his opinion. There has been no reply from the author either. Should I be concerned about this? I feel that if Jesus wanted us to refer to His Father in the feminine He would have made that abundantly clear. I also wonder if the author’s real point is to make a case for women in the priesthood.
Hello,

For me, Jesus was a man, so God is reffered to a ‘‘He’’.
Maybe, like you said, the author wanted to make a case for women in priesthood.
 
Jesus referred to God the Father. Only Jesus has a gender, but if Jesus had wanted us to refer to God the Father in any other way I am sure it would be in the scriptures.
I would not infer any intent into the brochure other than what is stated directly.
A small prayer for discernment for your parish would not go astray.
 
Personally, I never bought into the whole feminist movement. I have always liked women for being women. In the same manner, I see no reason to confuse the Father with a mother.
 
Personally, I never bought into the whole feminist movement. I have always liked women for being women. In the same manner, I see no reason to confuse the Father with a mother.
I’m with you except for your apparent confusion in the belief that feminism’s goal is to prevent women from being women…I’m not sure what that means, but I think it is detrimental to any argument against feminism because of its paternalistic and condescending tone.
 
I’m with you except for your apparent confusion in the belief that feminism’s goal is to prevent women from being women…I’m not sure what that means, but I think it is detrimental to any argument against feminism because of its paternalistic and condescending tone.
Feminism as it exists today has rejected the predominant distinguishing characteristics about womanhood in favor of a false “equality” in which there are no true distinguishing features between the sexes. Modern feminism reject maternity in favor of career, and looks down on those women who are called to be mothers. They actively denounce anything and anybody who claims that there are difference between men and women that extend beyond physical appearance. Modern feminism is, in short, a plague on reality which seeks to replace Truth with false beliefs about the nature of the human person. It has nothing to do with being paternalistic or condescending, feminism as it acts today is simply wrong and embraces evils.
 
Recently in our church bulletin in a section dedicated to scripture study, God was repeatedly referred to as “She” and “Herself”. The point of the study was to discuss the feminine nature of God which I understand, however, I did not feel comfortable with actually referring to God as a ‘she’. I did some research and Cardinal Ratzinger discussed this and also did not approve od referring to God as “She”. I asked the priest about this and he said that he would forward my email to the author but did not give his opinion. There has been no reply from the author either. Should I be concerned about this? I feel that if Jesus wanted us to refer to His Father in the feminine He would have made that abundantly clear. I also wonder if the author’s real point is to make a case for women in the priesthood.
Referring to God as “She” or “Mother” would count as heresy I’m pretty sure. Knowing nothing else except this one particular insert into your church bulletin I would say that it is probably an agenda-driven item to argue for female priests or unorthodox understandings of God, but it could be due to a lack of knowledge or understanding of Church teaching on the matter. You would know what the specific case most likely is better than the rest of us.

As others have said, Jesus revealed God in masculine terms such as “Father” and “Son.” Obviously Jesus’ revelation is final and should be accepted by the faithful as binding. However, there is a rational point to be made for considering God in masculine terms and it has to do with the fundamental difference between masculinity and femininity which, in essence, regards the flowing of one nature out of the masculine and into the feminine. God plays the spiritually masculine role in relation to humanity which plays the spiritually feminine role. God is who He is and who He revealed Himself to us to be and we are in a position to accept His objective nature. We don’t have the luxury of pouring our being into Him to make Him into whatever we want Him to be (that would be relativism). Pagans and pantheists have a tendency to regard their nearest equivalent of God as being feminine, such as with Gaia and Mother Nature, because God isn’t an objective reality in nature but something that’s different for each person. Each person can make of God whatever they want to make of Him (or Her as they would say I guess). Whatever makes you feel good. Catholicism and ancient Judaism reject this understanding.

Maybe this argument will be helpful for you since the reply is usually that the masculine understanding is unfounded and came out of a chauvinist society and Jesus didn’t really mean “Father.” I don’t know if you’re familiar with the Catholic philosopher Peter Kreeft, but he gives an excellent talk on this subject along with why there can never be women priests called Women and the Priesthood.
 
With all of the Scriptural and traditional emphasis on God as Father, it can be hard to remember that, as pure spirit, God is neither male nor female - and truly beyond all of our attempts at definition. At the same time, it is said that God has attributes which are both masculine and feminine. Julian of Norwich was one in particular who called God both Father and Mother, and I doubt it was indicative of a feminist agenda from the 14th century! “Our heavenly Mother Jesus cannot allow us that are His children to perish.” A statement from Dame Julian like this sounds confusing, but it is perhaps meant to take us out of our complacency regarding the nature of God - so many of us like to think we have the Divine all figured out!

I think one of the reasons people refer to God as “She” these days is for the supposed benefit of those who have a negative relationship with their own father or men in general. I’m not sure how helpful this really is. I am still inclined, with the Church and most all of Christianity, to call God “Father”, remembering at the same time that He (She?) is so much more. More than I can ever know!
 
For what it’s worth, there is this short answer:
Ask An Apologist - Ought Catholics to refer to God as Mother?
Father Serpa says the answer is no, because Jesus said so.

I know I have seen a more theologically reasoned response (by reasoned, I mean appealing to the inquisitive student or philosopher)… I just can’t remember where.

In the Catechism, I have not found anything that says it is wrong to think of God as Mother, or even to address God as “Mother.” Maybe it’s in there, but I couldn’t find it. I did find the following passages:
239 By calling God “Father,” the language of faith indicates two main things: that God is the first origin of everything and transcendent authority; and that he is at the same time goodness and loving care for all his children. God’s parental tenderness can also be expressed by the image of motherhood, which emphasizes God’s immanence, the intimacy between Creator and creature. The language of faith thus draws on the human experience of parents, who are in a way the first representatives of God for man. But this experience also tells us that human parents are fallible and can disfigure the face of fatherhood and motherhood. We ought therefore to recall that God transcends the human distinction between the sexes. He is neither man nor woman: he is God. He also transcends human fatherhood and motherhood, although he is their origin and standard: no one is father as God is Father.
and
370 In no way is God in man’s image. He is neither man nor woman. God is pure spirit in which there is no place for the difference between the sexes. But the respective “perfections” of man and woman reflect something of the infinite perfection of God: those of a mother and those of a father and husband.
and
from 2779 The expression God the Father had never been revealed to anyone. When Moses himself asked God who he was, he heard another name. The Father’s name has been revealed to us in the Son, for the name “Son” implies the new name “Father.”
and of course Jesus referred to God as the Father, and asked us to pray to Our Father.
 
“Herself”? NO! This deliberate ruse has been pushed on the faithful by agenda driven female activists and “not in charge” parish priests. It should not have been published in the church paper under a teaching column of spirituality. Talk about this with as many other parish
members in a clear, educated manner by referring to the Catechism of the Catholic Church,
(the real one) and trusted sources like EWTN. There is a great difference between entering into deep theology and purpose driven activism. This has been a recognized attempt to worm in heresy. Next there will be an announcement inviting leaping dancers in swirly veils to celebrate their womanhood at Mass. Nausea all over again.:egyptian:
 
When I was growing up in the Diocese of Saginaw, we would often pronounce the “Saginaw Blessing” on people who were celebrating special occasions. The blessing was the blessing given in Numbers (May the LORD bless and keep you, etc.), but was sung twice through. The first time through, all the pronouns were given as masculine, the second time through, all the pronouns were given as feminine. Apparently, this was promoted by the bishop at the time, Most Rev. Kenneth Untener. The reasoning the diocese used for using the blessing in that manner was because “John Paul I stated that God is both a mother and a father to us”. Of course, the diocese also decided that the line “and became man” in the Nicene Creed should be stated “and became human”.

I honestly believe that this has more to do with trying to be “Politically Correct” than anything.
 
Feminism as it exists today has rejected the predominant distinguishing characteristics about womanhood in favor of a false “equality” in which there are no true distinguishing features between the sexes. Modern feminism reject maternity in favor of career, and looks down on those women who are called to be mothers. They actively denounce anything and anybody who claims that there are difference between men and women that extend beyond physical appearance. Modern feminism is, in short, a plague on reality which seeks to replace Truth with false beliefs about the nature of the human person. It has nothing to do with being paternalistic or condescending, feminism as it acts today is simply wrong and embraces evils.
I am disgusted with modern feminism in that it counts abortion as one of its sacraments. That said, my grandmother and her sister were suffragettes who campaigned for the right of women to vote.

I think that the chief characteristic that distinguishes women from men is femininity and not motherhood. There are a lot of women who are not mothers but that does not make them less of a woman.
 
Feminism as it exists today has rejected the predominant distinguishing characteristics about womanhood in favor of a false “equality” in which there are no true distinguishing features between the sexes. Modern feminism reject maternity in favor of career, and looks down on those women who are called to be mothers. They actively denounce anything and anybody who claims that there are difference between men and women that extend beyond physical appearance. Modern feminism is, in short, a plague on reality which seeks to replace Truth with false beliefs about the nature of the human person. It has nothing to do with being paternalistic or condescending, feminism as it acts today is simply wrong and embraces evils.
👍 Very well thought out and very true.
 
I am disgusted with modern feminism in that it counts abortion as one of its sacraments. That said, my grandmother and her sister were suffragettes who campaigned for the right of women to vote.
I believe that that form of feminism is to be applauded, commended and supported. You have to agree, however, that this form of feminism is all but dead, and has been replaced by a counterfeit that worships death.
I think that the chief characteristic that distinguishes women from men is femininity and not motherhood. There are a lot of women who are not mothers but that does not make them less of a woman.
I don’t distinguish the two (Femininity and maternity… not men and women, I definitely distinguish there :p). Maternity is the highest form of femininity, as it is the greatest of God’s gift to women. That being said, I agree that a woman who is not a mother is not less of a woman for it; however, you cannot separate femininity from maternity, as modern feminists would seek to do, and I don’t think you should classify them separately.
👍 Very well thought out and very true.
Glad you liked it ^^
 
When I was growing up in the Diocese of Saginaw, we would often pronounce the “Saginaw Blessing” on people who were celebrating special occasions. The blessing was the blessing given in Numbers (May the LORD bless and keep you, etc.), but was sung twice through. The first time through, all the pronouns were given as masculine, the second time through, all the pronouns were given as feminine. Apparently, this was promoted by the bishop at the time, Most Rev. Kenneth Untener. The reasoning the diocese used for using the blessing in that manner was because “John Paul I stated that God is both a mother and a father to us”. Of course, the diocese also decided that the line “and became man” in the Nicene Creed should be stated “and became human”.

I honestly believe that this has more to do with trying to be “Politically Correct” than anything.
That is exactly it! God has no gender. The author was just trying hard to be PC.
 
Such would yes be quite contrary to the Teachings of the Church. God is not a “herself”
 
I believe that that form of feminism is to be applauded, commended and supported. You have to agree, however, that this form of feminism is all but dead, and has been replaced by a counterfeit that worships death.

I don’t distinguish the two (Femininity and maternity… not men and women, I definitely distinguish there :p). Maternity is the highest form of femininity, as it is the greatest of God’s gift to women. That being said, I agree that a woman who is not a mother is not less of a woman for it; however, you cannot separate femininity from maternity, as modern feminists would seek to do, and I don’t think you should classify them separately.

Glad you liked it ^^
Thank you for your well reasoned post.

There is such a thing as spiritual motherhood
 
We just received an email from the author of this article and it turns out that he is a priest although not our parish priest. That is very disappointing to me but at least he did try to explain. Turns out he often speaks with atheists, pagans and Hindus and uses this female pronoun approach to talk about God. It is sadly not obvious to him that this approach is not fair to them because it is not revealing the truth. And to use this in a Catholic bulletin for Catholic parishioners is inappropriate at best and disobedient at worst. The parish priest is ultimately responsible for what goes into his bulletin and he has yet to reveal his opinion. The priest who wrote it did back pedal and said he was misunderstood which is a stretch. He wrote in two bulletins that God could be referred to as a “she”. Enough said. The whole thing begs the question “if God has a feminine nature then why aren’t women being ordained?”. And the bottom line is with such poor catechesis being given the past forty years does the average parishioner really need to know that God is feminine? There are so many more pertinent topics to draw from in Catholicism such as morality and all its aspects where people are failing miserably. I am so very upset that this happened and the priest doesn’t seem to care.
 
All women are called to be spiritual mothers, even if they never become biological mothers for whatever reason (infertility, joining a religious order, a single person who is open to marriage but never meets the right person, etc.)

No, God is not a “she.” God doesn’t have gender and Jesus referred to Him as “Father” which is definitely male. He could have said “Mother” for female or “Parent” for gender neutral but God revealed Himself as Father.
 
I attended a community where this kind of thing was pervasive among the faithful and apparently condoned by the priests. Everywhere in the liturgy where God was referred to as “Him” or “His” was replaced by “God” and “God’s”. Members of the attached lay order made reference in my earshot to God as “she”. This was not the only symptom of problems there. The diocese soon came in to take over administration of the community and the religious order left. Many people were of course upset at this, but I was vaguely satisfied. The priests were very good men and well-meaning, but all the liturgical abuse was so frustrating to me personally that it was a firm roadblock in my faith journey. As it is said, save the liturgy, save the world.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top