God Save the Queen at Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter agp2176
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Rather incestuous: “Your Excellency, I come to you for your permission to prorogue Parliament and as Prime Minister I would advise you to give it.”
Thank you for contributing to this discussion with such a helpful and insightful contribution.
 
Rather incestuous: “Your Excellency, I come to you for your permission to prorogue Parliament and as Prime Minister I would advise you to give it.”
Well, it’s rubberstamping, not incest. Something heads of state often do when they occupy a distinct role from heads of government.

It’s the same thing that happens before elections - ‘Your excellency, I come to you asking you graciously to exercise your power to dissolve parliament and to call an election, and as Prime Minister I tell you it must happen now, whether you like it or not, and the date I’ve chosen for it is xyz …’

And afterwards - ‘Your excellency, I come to you asking you to graciously exercise your power and invite someone to form a government … and as leader of the majority party in the lower house I tell you you can’t choose anyone but me, because no-one else has enough support to pass any legislation’.

Or declaring war - officially our Aussie Governor-General is head of the armed forces, but it’s not like he (or she, as it is currently) ever makes the official announcement that a war has begun or ceased, and it’s not like he or she has any real power over how, when or where those troops are deployed. 🤷
 
When I was in England, I never heard “God Save The Queen” at mass.

If I did I would of sat down.

My personal opinion, is that Danny Boy should be the national anthem of England. 👍

I do not think alot of Catholic’s are patriots of the English Queen, from my perspective of England.

But us Irish love her and Maggie Thatcher! :rolleyes:
 
When I was in England, I never heard “God Save The Queen” at mass (sic).
Mass is spelt with a capital ‘M’.
If I did I would of sat down.
Why? Because it’s the UK national anthem or because a national anthem was performed during Mass.
My personal opinion, is that Danny Boy should be the national anthem of England. 👍
Urm, another silly comment that adds nothing to the thread.
I do not think alot (sic) of Catholic’s are patriots of the English Queen(sic), from my perspective of England.
Then your perspective is wrong. That is a stance frequently taken by Protestants. That you cannot be a loyal Catholic and loyal to Britain. If you’re a Catholic you must somehow be a spy for the Vatican. It’s absolutely ridiculous. She’s The Queen of the UK not England.
But us Irish love her and Maggie Thatcher! :rolleyes:
You’re welcome to Maggie Thatcher.
 
Why? Because it’s the UK national anthem or because a national anthem was performed during Mass.
It’s the “English” national anthem, not the UK national anthem, and not the “Amhrán na bhFiann” which is my national anthem. Why would I sing God save the Queen?
Then your perspective is wrong. That is a stance frequently taken by Protestants. That you cannot be a loyal Catholic and loyal to Britain. If you’re a Catholic you must somehow be a spy for the Vatican. It’s absolutely ridiculous. She’s The Queen of the UK not England.
You know that a Catholic can’t marry into the Queen’s family, if he or she are Catholic. You got to reject being a Catholic, that’s the law in the UK.
She’s The Queen of the UK not England.
Scotland want independance,Wales are not so far behind.

Majority N.Ireland want her dead.
 
It’s the “English” national anthem not the UK national anthem …
England does not have a national anthem. It is not an independent sovereign state. The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is an independent sovereign state and “God save the Queen” is its national anthem.
Why would I sing God save the Queen?
Out of respect? I suspect you would be quite indignant if someone showed disrespect to the national anthem of the Republic of Ireland. I would respect any national anthem
You know that a Catholic can’t marry into the Queen’s family, if he or she are Catholic. You got to reject being a Catholic, that’s the law in the UK.
Your first statement is factually incorrect (in addition to being tautologous). Members of the Royal Family can marry Catholics. HRH Prince Michael of Kent is married to a Catholic. If a member of the Royal Family marries a Catholic they lose their place in the line of succession because the sovereign cannot be a Catholic. Members of the Royal Family can, and do, marry Catholics. I do not know what your second statement means. Who has to reject being a Catholic?
Scotland want independance (sic),Wales are not so far behind.
I presume you mean the majority of Scots and Welsh people want their respective nations to be independent from the UK. Do you have statistics to back this up? I know that when Wales was given the vote on devolution it was only a narrow majority that voted in favour. Until 18 months ago I worked in Wales for eight years. Most people I spoke to didn’t want devolution let alone independence.
Majority N.Ireland want her dead.
That may be your unchristian opinion but that is not necessarily representative of the Northern Irish people. The few Northern Irish people I have had the good fortune to know did not take sides but were actually ashamed of what happened and to some extent still happens in Northern Ireland.
 
Your first statement is factually incorrect (in addition to being tautologous). Members of the Royal Family can marry Catholics. HRH Prince Michael of Kent is married to a Catholic. If a member of the Royal Family marries a Catholic they lose their place in the line of succession because the sovereign cannot be a Catholic. Members of the Royal Family can, and do, marry Catholics. I do not know what your second statement means. Who has to reject being a Catholic?.
And the fact that a person who is, or is married to, a Catholic loses their right to inherit the throne of their own country, when there there are absolutely no such restrictions against them being (or being married to) a Jew, Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist, pagan, or indeed atheist, doesn’t strike you as being a very calculated slap in the face against our faith? Doesn’t peeve you off just a little?

Put it this way - you don’t name your home town, but imagine the law was changed, and instead of being Catholic the law was that if a member of the Royal Family married someone from your home town they had to give up their right to the throne. What would you think of that? Or that if a member of the Royal family married someone whose income was below a certain level, or something equally discriminatory.

It certainly should upset you. No-one should be forced to give up a chance to the throne or any other inheritance to which they may be entitled due to their religion or the religion of the person they choose to marry.
 
And the fact that a person who is, or is married to, a Catholic loses their right to inherit the throne of their own country, when there there are absolutely no such restrictions against them being (or being married to) a Jew, Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist, pagan, or indeed atheist, doesn’t strike you as being a very calculated slap in the face against our faith? Doesn’t peeve you off just a little?

Put it this way - you don’t name your home town, but imagine the law was changed, and instead of being Catholic the law was that if a member of the Royal Family married someone from your home town they had to give up their right to the throne. What would you think of that? Or that if a member of the Royal family married someone whose income was below a certain level, or something equally discriminatory.

It certainly should upset you. No-one should be forced to give up a chance to the throne or any other inheritance to which they may be entitled due to their religion or the religion of the person they choose to marry.
I take your point. But, first let me clarify what I was saying. The poster I was replying to said that members of the Royal Family cannot marry Catholics. Several members of the Royal Family have married Catholics. So, what he said was wrong.

I didn’t go on to say it was wrong. In fact I do not quite understand it. Current UK law requires the sovereign to be a communicant member of the Church of England. I do not think it says anything about the sovereign’s spouse. So I’m not sure why marrying a Catholic removes you from the line of succession. If a member of the Royal Family marries a Catholic but they do not change to Catholicism I cannot see the problem.

I don’t know if a member of the Royal Family married a person from a different religion whether they would lose their place in the line of succession.

I think The Queen is now the only office in the UK from which Catholics are excluded.

I have never said I agree with this. However, I do think that this will change.
 
I take your point. But, first let me clarify what I was saying. The poster I was replying to said that members of the Royal Family cannot marry Catholics. Several members of the Royal Family have married Catholics. So, what he said was wrong.

I didn’t go on to say it was wrong. In fact I do not quite understand it. Current UK law requires the sovereign to be a communicant member of the Church of England. I do not think it says anything about the sovereign’s spouse. So I’m not sure why marrying a Catholic removes you from the line of succession. If a member of the Royal Family marries a Catholic but they do not change to Catholicism I cannot see the problem.

I don’t know if a member of the Royal Family married a person from a different religion whether they would lose their place in the line of succession.

I think The Queen is now the only office in the UK from which Catholics are excluded.

I have never said I agree with this. However, I do think that this will change.
I’ll return the compliment and state that I too see where you’re coming from - you are correct that members of the Royal Family aren’t actually prevented by law from marrying Catholics.

However, the Bill of Rights and the Act of Settlement of 1701 do state explicitly that members of the Royal Family who MARRY Catholics, as well as those who are themselves Catholic, lose their right to succeed to the throne.

For example, Prince Michael of Kent didn’t himself convert to Catholicism, but definitely lost his place in line to the throne when he married a Catholic. A fact which his own official website notes: princemichael.org.uk/the-prince/marriage-and-family/ Although oddly enough his children, having been brought up in the Church of England, are still in the succession.

While no-one in closer proximity to the throne than Prince Michael has ever been disbarred from the succession by operation of this law, this is only because none closer than he have ever legally been married to Catholics.

George IV came close, but his marriage to the Catholic Maria Fitzherbert was not legally valid because his marriage required the permission of his own father, King George III, and the Privy Council, which he didn’t seek, and it was annulled. Had the marriage occurred validly (although it never would have, they would never have given permission for it), George would indeed not have been able to succeed to the throne.
 
When I was in England, I never heard “God Save The Queen” at mass.

If I did I would of sat down.
I was not familiar with the lyrics so I looked them up. I would not sit down during Mass if people began singing God Save the Queen, but as an American descendant of Irish immigrants, I could never, ever sing or speak the following words:

O Lord, our God, arise,
Scatter her enemies,
And make them fall.
Confound their politics,
Frustrate their knavish tricks,
On Thee our hopes we fix,
God save us all.

I personally would opt to stand with my lips pressed tightly shut.

(…and here I was, just getting ready to go to bed, and now I am worked up and won’t be able to sleep. This will teach me to read these posts late at night :D)
 
I was not familiar with the lyrics so I looked them up. I would not sit down during Mass if people began singing God Save the Queen, but as an American descendant of Irish immigrants, I could never, ever sing or speak the following words:

O Lord, our God, arise,
Scatter her enemies,
And make them fall.
Confound their politics,
Frustrate their knavish tricks,
On Thee our hopes we fix,
God save us all.

I personally would opt to stand with my lips pressed tightly shut.

(…and here I was, just getting ready to go to bed, and now I am worked up and won’t be able to sleep. This will teach me to read these posts late at night :D)
You’ve found an obsolete verse. The words of the UK national anthem are:

God save our gracious Queen!
Long live our noble Queen!
God save the Queen!
Send her victorious,
Happy and glorious,
Long to reign over us,
God save the Queen.

Thy choicest gifts in store
On her be pleased to pour,
Long may she reign.
May she defend our laws,
And ever give us cause,
To sing with heart and voice,
God save the Queen.
 
Out of respect? I suspect you would be quite indignant if someone showed disrespect to the national anthem of the Republic of Ireland. I would respect any national anthem
I would not disrespect it, but I would not sing it. Im Irish, singing the “God Save The Queen” would be insulting my own Great-Grandfather who died trying to win independance for Ireland, and those who died willingly to make Ireland independant.
Your first statement is factually incorrect (in addition to being tautologous). Members of the Royal Family can marry Catholics. HRH Prince Michael of Kent is married to a Catholic. If a member of the Royal Family marries a Catholic they lose their place in the line of succession because the sovereign cannot be a Catholic. Members of the Royal Family can, and do, marry Catholics. I do not know what your second statement means. Who has to reject being a Catholic?
Your right sorry I was mistaken. I thought Catholics were not aloud to join the Queen’s family, I thought the Bill of Rights stopped Catholic’s joining the Queen’s family,but it stops them from succeeding to the Throne, but still a Catholic cannot become the King/Queen by the country’s law, that’s diabolical?
That may be your unchristian opinion but that is not necessarily representative of the Northern Irish people. The few Northern Irish people I have had the good fortune to know did not take sides but were actually ashamed of what happened and to some extent still happens in Northern Ireland.
I tell you what is unchristian, what Brits have done to Ireland over the last 800 years.

That is unchristian.

And for the record, I do not support what the Irish in north are doing. The “new” IRA in N.Ireland have wrecked the good image of the IRA, who won independance for Ireland.
 
I would not disrespect it, but I would not sing it. Im Irish, singing the “God Save The Queen” would be insulting my own Great-Grandfather who died trying to win independance for Ireland, and those who died willingly to make Ireland independant.
Perhaps then I should take the same attitude to the Irish national anthem in respect of all British persons killed by Irish persons. Perhaps we should tear up the Good Friday agreement and return to the past. I will be the first to admit that atrocities were carried out by both sides. However, I prefer to move forward.
Your right sorry I was mistaken. I thought Catholics were not aloud to join the Queen’s family, I thought the Bill of Rights stopped Catholic’s joining the Queen’s family,but it stops them from succeeding to the Throne, but still a Catholic cannot become the King/Queen by the country’s law, that’s diabolical?
I agree the sovereign should be able to be a Christian of any type, or belong to a non-Christian belief, or be an atheist. Until the church and state are separated this will never happen. May be it might under Prince Charles he has already hinted that he doesn’t agree with this situation. But, as the Royal Family are mainly Anglicans its likely that most will remain Anglicans and so future monarchs will be Anglican. I think the law should be changed so that any one of any faith or none can become monarch and that marrying a Catholic shouldn’t remove you from the line of succession. I could live with an Anglican monarch providing that the throne wasn’t reserved solely for Anglicans.
I tell you what is unchristian, what Brits have done to Ireland over the last 800 years. That is unchristian. And for the record, I do not support what the Irish in north are doing. The “new” IRA in N.Ireland have wrecked the good image of the IRA, who won independance for Ireland.
I think we are getting into dangerous territory here. The British did many bad things in Ireland. But the Irish weren’t lily white. Many bad things were done in colonies throughout the world and not just by the English. Irish, Scots, and Welsh all went oversees and participated in colonialism. I cannot say the IRA in any guise or any other nationalist/republican or unionist terrorist or any type of terrorist organisation does any good, anywhere or at anytime, whether in the name of religion or otherwise. The blame for things in Northern Ireland cannot be laid solely at the door of those north of the border. We have to contend with the situation as it now is and hope we can all move forward in peace. Isn’t that what Christians should do?

I for one wish there was a referendum in Northern Ireland to let the people decide whether to remain part of the UK or become part of a united Ireland. I doubt it will happen because both sides fear losing.

Pax Christi:signofcross:
 
I for one wish there was a referendum in Northern Ireland to let the people decide whether to remain part of the UK or become part of a united Ireland. I doubt it will happen because both sides fear losing.
The problem is that less than half of the population in the north is Catholic. A referendum would simply result in a lot of blood shed without any potential for reunification. Most people who desire reunification still believe that maintaining a continued, lasting peace in the north should be the first priority at all times.

Personally, I don’t have a problem with people singing God Save the Queen during other functions, but it has no place in the Mass. Unlike American the Beautiful, or O Canada, which are hymns for all people in our respective countries, God Save the Queen asks specifically for God’s support for a single, unelected person with a clearly political (and historically controversial) governmental function.

The problem with the song is that it is too specific. I wouldn’t support singing a hymn specifically for the President of the United States during Mass either, and not because I don’t support the office of the president as our governmental leadership position, but because the Mass should (with the occasional exception of the homily) transcend local politics and focus solely on God.
 
The problem is that less than half of the population in the north is Catholic. A referendum would simply result in a lot of blood shed without any potential for reunification. Most people who desire reunification still believe that maintaining a continued, lasting peace in the north should be the first priority at all times.

Personally, I don’t have a problem with people singing God Save the Queen during other functions, but it has no place in the Mass. Unlike American the Beautiful, or O Canada, which are hymns for all people in our respective countries, God Save the Queen asks specifically for God’s support for a single, unelected person with a clearly political (and historically controversial) governmental function.

The problem with the song is that it is too specific. I wouldn’t support singing a hymn specifically for the President of the United States during Mass either, and not because I don’t support the office of the president as our governmental leadership position, but because the Mass should (with the occasional exception of the homily) transcend local politics and focus solely on God.
I think we need to make a decision regarding whether we sing national anthems at Mass or not. Personally I’m against it. In a certain way I see the Church giving us a lead in this matter. At funerals the Church says we should only place Christian symbols on coffins rather than national or military symbols. However, I believe that if we allow one national anthem to be sung at Mass then we must allow all national anthems. You cannot exclude one and allow others.
 
I think we are getting into dangerous territory here. The British did many bad things in Ireland. But the Irish weren’t lily white. Many bad things were done in colonies throughout the world and not just by the English. Irish, Scots, and Welsh all went oversees and participated in colonialism. I cannot say the IRA in any guise or any other nationalist/republican or unionist terrorist or any type of terrorist organisation does any good, anywhere or at anytime, whether in the name of religion or otherwise. The blame for things in Northern Ireland cannot be laid solely at the door of those north of the border. We have to contend with the situation as it now is and hope we can all move forward in peace. Isn’t that what Christians should do?
We are getting into dangerous territory I think we should drop this little feud of ours. 👍
We have to contend with the situation as it now is and hope we can all move forward in peace. Isn’t that what Christians should do?
Sadly enough, alot of people in the Northern Ireland become brainwashed by fanatical groups, and moving forward in peace looks distant. Although we must keep our hopes up, for everything is possible for God.
 
We are getting into dangerous territory I think we should drop this little feud of ours. 👍
I always saw it as a frank exchange of views rather than a feud.
Sadly enough, alot of people in the Northern Ireland become brainwashed by fanatical groups, and moving forward in peace looks distant. Although we must keep our hopes up, for everything is possible for God.
Yes, I realise this. I used to work with a lady who’s mother was Northern Irish. Her family was presbyterians. She said that one’s views (if that is the appropriate word) are indoctrinated from birth. She said that despite all the changes that have occurred the older members in her family still living in Northern Ireland would never associate with Catholics.
 
Yes, I realise this. I used to work with a lady who’s mother was Northern Irish. Her family was presbyterians. She said that one’s views (if that is the appropriate word) are indoctrinated from birth. She said that despite all the changes that have occurred the older members in her family still living in Northern Ireland would never associate with Catholics.
Yes, it’s so true. My family is half Irish and half English. Family functions were always tense and occasionally explosive. I once watched my father and my maternal grandfather (who happened to be a retired Episcopalian priest) come to blows over the troubles in the North.

So that was the end of the family vacation 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top