Does the “Depart from me, for I never knew you” follow from the judgment situation referring to what we have done for others, we have done for Jesus? In that case, the loving presence of Jesus is present to both the sheep and the goats before their death.
I agree with this. On a non-Catholic forum we were debating whether or not God loves everyone. There’re many theological perspectives that believe He only loves the “elect” while the rest are “vessels of wrath” (Rom 9:22), destined for damnation. brb3 was probably referring to Rom 3:23 where St Paul tells us that “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God”, and in the same chapter, quoting from various OT passages with similar sentiments including the following, he also tells us that,
“There is no one righteous, not even one;
11 there is no one who understands;
there is no one who seeks God”.
And many people like to quote Isaiah 64:6:
All of us have become like one who is unclean,
and all our righteous acts are like filthy rags;
we all shrivel up like a leaf,
and like the wind our sins sweep us away.
But are these words meaning to describe Gods’ hatred for sin and evil, or of His hatred for sinners themselves who He’s predestined to hell? I wouldn’t find much justice in the latter possibility. However, supporters of this concept often counter that, being sinners, all men are deserving of hell-and it’s only due to Gods’ mercy, which He can mete out as He wishes, that any of us may escape its fires. There are also a few instances in the OT where man is referred to as a worm, or which otherwise emphasize his infinite inferiority as compared to God.
While there are truths to be gleaned from these sentiments, we attain a much fuller-orbed understanding of Gods attitude towards man in the NT. Here Gods unconditional love is demonstrated in no uncertain terms. He even demonstrates
humility, lowering himself to our level, to live, suffer, and die as one of us, actually sanctioning the value of human life in the process by this Incarnation, by this intimate identification with us. He shows His power and compassion by miraculous healings and his truth and holiness by always opposing pride and hypocrisy. He then performs the ultimate act of love on the cross, dying for the undeserving, and then resurrecting to prove that mans hope is not in vain, eternal life is an authentic promise of an authentic reality. By the Atonement God proves what He shouldn’t have to prove, that He loves man and is trustworthy beyond measure-always having man’s best interest at heart. And all of this can be looked upon as God revealing something of man’s worth, from His perspective, not only showing how much He expects from us, but, more importantly, how much He wants *for *us.
I think part of the differences come from a notion, mainly from certain non-Catholic theological circles, of God as being much sterner, exercising justice above all else, angry at man but condescendly merciful to a few He chooses to save. The Reformers taught that man fell from a naturally elevated state, which God created him in, to a corrupted state. Many understand this to mean that fallen man is just plain bad.
Catholicism teaches that man fell to a “natural” state , the state he’s in when he lacks the grace of God to enable Him to be who God intends him to be, or, to put it another way, the state he’s in when He lacks
God, no longer “walking” with Him, as a consequence of man effectively rejecting Him at the Fall. Looked at in this way, man is still good, as all Gods’ creation is, but weakened, darkened in understanding, born turned away from God, subject to falling into sin.