God's Will in our Past

  • Thread starter Thread starter tersteegen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

tersteegen

Guest
Hello!

As I have written in my first thread here, I have some substantial hurts from the past, which I have so far not tackled in any way.

In the first thread, I have received great orientation by learning about practical steps I can take together with God on my healing path.

I have come to realize, that in order to heal the past, it’s vital to understand what REALLY (meaning “in God’s eyes”) happened. - And not what happened in my opinion, a family member’s opinion a psychologist’s opinion or anyone else’s - always more or less distorted, sometimes even dangerous - opinion.
So if I want to learn something from my past (which I believe God wants me to, so I can find peace with it and go on with valuable insights from it into the future), I better find out what God thinks happened and not be misguided by wrong conclusions I draw from looking at the past through untruthful eyes.

Now, because I want to see the truth in my past, I have some general questions about God’s Will (in our past) with regard to those events that have happened to us and have harmed us. So I am not talking about sins that we ourselves have commited, but about things that have happened to us and harmed us (emotionally and/or physically): From small things like insults, slander to big things like physical abuses, rape and everything in between.

I sat down yesterday and - trying to understand what God’s, the devil’s, other people’s and my own role are when it comes to such events - wrote down some of my thoughts, which I would like to share here, hoping to learn from you, since I myself have never before concerned myself with these questions. So I’m sorry if the answers to these questions should be obvious to most of you…to me they are just not.

Here are my thoughts:
  • When something bad happens to me via someone else (in other words someone is sinning against me), I would tend to think that God did NOT want this to happen to me. I guess it can be agreed, that God did certainly not want the other person to sin. - Just because he wants noone to ever sin. And if he did not want the other person to sin, it could be concluded he did not want this to happen to me.
So it might be said that the other person misused his free will by deciding to do the will of the devil and not God’s will.

So following the reasoning above, any assumption that God wanted this to happen to me - because he wanted me to become humble, grow in faith or for whatever other (maybe hidden) reason - would have to be dismissed. So it would not be along the lines: “Yes, it’s tough…, but that’s what God wanted”. No, it would be the complete opposite, along the lines: “Yes, it’s tough…and it’s what the devil wanted and he got it”. - What a HUGE difference!
What do you think…?
  • I also had another thought - which might be rather wrong - but since I am not sure about it, I wanted to share it:
Could it be - as outlined above - that God does not want sins to happen against us, but God being realistic and knowing that man is sinfull, has a word to speak in regard to WHO will be afflicted by the sin, a sin He does not want to happen in the first place, but if it happens he has influence on who it happens against.
In other words: God does not want Peter to punch Michael. Because he does not ever want anyone to punch someone else. But Peter misuses his free will and punches Michael. Why is exactly Michael the victim of the punch and not Gabriel? Is God’s Will at play here? Could there be a reason for God to either actively put Michael as the victim or passively no to protect Michael?
Or is God’s will not at play here at all (regarding the victim)?
  • Ok, leaving the question behind what God’s, the devil’s, the other person’s (sinner’s) role was in past events, it’s important to find out what God wants us to do now, that this has happened. Because we can react to such bad events in more God-pleasing (and ultimately better for our own good) ways or decide to react less so. So it’s all about how we react.
    Here are just some things that I can imagine God wants us to do:
  • Become aware of the fact that we ourselves have little control. Become humble
  • Forgive the other person
  • Ask God and others for help
  • Not complain, but carry our cross patiently
  • Grow in faith
  • Also do you believe that bad things happen to us for sins that we ourselves have committed. In other words someone who commits more sins will have more bad things happen to him (in this life already), than someone who does not sin so much. - I don’t necessarily think so.
  • Is there a punishing Father?
Thank you to all who have read this post. I am looking forward to any answers and hope I can shed some light onto these questions.
I hope it didn’t sound too theoretical. I am actually not so much interested in (maybe irrelevant) theory, but I really have the feeling that finding answers to these questions will help me understand and heal my past.
Maybe there are no definite answers to my questions, because what do we humans know about God’s will. However I believe we can get to know parts of God’s will through the teachings of the Bible, Saints, Church, Prayer. And that’s what I am trying to do.

God bless you all,
Jon
 
God does not will the malice of sin that comes against you, but he does will (permissively) that you suffer the effects of the malice/sin that comes against you. Many saints have taught this. God is the First Cause of all that happens to you; the devil and others are just Secondary Agents in all that happens to you. God bless you.
 
@ready,

thank you for your succinct answer. It’s making me think.
God does not will the malice of sin that comes against you, but he does will (permissively) that you suffer the effects of the malice/sin that comes against you
I think I understand this and it makes sense to me.
God does not want the malice of sin to come against me, but if sin does happen (against His will) due to the misuse of someone else’s free will, than he (permissively) wills that I suffer the effects.
God is the First Cause of all that happens to you; the devil and others are just Secondary Agents in all that happens to you. God bless you.
Unfortunately I cannot grasp this second part of your answer yet, but I would really like to. Can I ask you to explain in a few more words?
By saying “God is the First Cause of all that happens to me” do you mean: Since God decided to create me, he has thereby made it possible that bad things can happen to me? -That’s how it would make sense to me.

And by the word “Agents” you most likely mean it in the sense of “cause” as opposed to “mediator”. So the Devil being the (evil) cause and not a mediator (which sounds like something positive) of bad things.
 
Greetings and welcome!
I sat down yesterday and - trying to understand what God’s, the devil’s, other people’s and my own role are when it comes to such events - wrote down some of my thoughts, which I would like to share here, hoping to learn from you, since I myself have never before concerned myself with these questions. So I’m sorry if the answers to these questions should be obvious to most of you…to me they are just not.
I have thought upon this myself though from a slightly different angle. I think it’s something many people try to understand.
Here are my thoughts:
  • When something bad happens to me via someone else (in other words someone is sinning against me), I would tend to think that God did NOT want this to happen to me. I guess it can be agreed, that God did certainly not want the other person to sin. - Just because he wants noone to ever sin. And if he did not want the other person to sin, it could be concluded he did not want this to happen to me.
So it might be said that the other person misused his free will by deciding to do the will of the devil and not God’s will.
I agree.
So following the reasoning above, any assumption that God wanted this to happen to me - because he wanted me to become humble, grow in faith or for whatever other (maybe hidden) reason - would have to be dismissed. So it would not be along the lines: “Yes, it’s tough…, but that’s what God wanted”. No, it would be the complete opposite, along the lines: “Yes, it’s tough…and it’s what the devil wanted and he got it”. - What a HUGE difference!
What do you think…?
I think God does not normally (miracles being the exception) interfere directly with anyone’s free will or the outcomes of that action. His angels, a person’s conscience, etc will attempt to prevent a person from doing evil against another - but it is ultimately that person choosing to do the evil. Regarding the consequences of that evil - I believe God simply uses that to turn it to good in the life of the victim. It is an opportunity - not sought, not wanted, not desired - by either the victim or God - but still an opportunity to become better, to learn, to grow, to become closer to God. That’s my fundamental take - God does not cause bad things - but will use bad things to bring more good into the world - if we let Him.
  • Also do you believe that bad things happen to us for sins that we ourselves have committed. In other words someone who commits more sins will have more bad things happen to him (in this life already), than someone who does not sin so much. - I don’t necessarily think so.
  • Is there a punishing Father?
Yes I do think bad things happen to us for sins that we ourselves have committed because first they make it harder to know and hear God who is the source of all goodness and second they result in natural negative consequences. Let’s say I commit the sin of gluttony repeatedly - that leads to obesity that leads to health problems that lead to job loss that leads to money problems that leads to gambling that leads to addiction that leads to loss of friends and family and so on…all natural consequences of my decision to sin in the first place. (Note - this is intended to be a theoretical example - I fully understand real life is much more complex, people have differing degrees of culpability and resources, etc.)

But no, I do not see God as a punishing Father who decides to send a tornado (or a drunk driver) to destroy your house because you skipped mass.
Thank you to all who have read this post. I am looking forward to any answers and hope I can shed some light onto these questions.
Thank you for the questions. I do not know if I have helped you, but it has helped me to reflect a bit on this as I’ve tried to respond.

Peace.
 
Hello CradleJourney,

Thank you so much for taking the time to read my post and making the effort to respond to all of my questions. Your answers have been very helpful.
Regarding the consequences of that evil - I believe God simply uses that to turn it to good in the life of the victim. It is an opportunity - not sought, not wanted, not desired - by either the victim or God - but still an opportunity to become better, to learn, to grow, to become closer to God. That’s my fundamental take - God does not cause bad things - but will use bad things to bring more good into the world - if we let Him.
This is also what I am coming to believe more and more and I am encouraged to read that you think the same way.
So God does not want bad things to happen to us. But if they do happen, there is a potential in them to create far more good than would have been possible without them happening. So it could be said that the attack of the devil, who already thinks he has won, can be fired back with 100 times the force of his attack. The plan of the devil totally worked against himself, because now there’s even more good in the victim’s life/the world than would have been without his attack. - All provided that the victim will take the necessary steps together with God.
Yes I do think bad things happen to us for sins that we ourselves have committed because first they make it harder to know and hear God who is the source of all goodness
I agree

I also agree with your example of gluttony.
But I was also thinking of other incidents, when for example someone steals. - Povided there are not going to be natural consequences (prison), because the thief is clever enough not to get caught, I was wondering if there can be SUPERNATURAL consequences IN THIS LIFE already. For example the thief finds himself severely sick 20 years after his theft…could it possible be a consequence wanted and sent by God?

So the question is if those bad things that happen in our lifes, can also have their cause in (seemingly) UNRELATED sins that we have commited. Is God (at least sometimes) “sending us justice” already in this life? (In order to make us aware and repent)?

Thank you again, your answers have made me think…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top