God's wrath on David's child

  • Thread starter Thread starter ni8_shadow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

ni8_shadow

Guest
Reading 2Sam 12:13 and it worries me a bit. God punishes David for his sin by killing David’s child. The kid suffers a sickness for 7 days before it dies.

David did need to be punished and taking away all he had, including all his women, was just, but killing an innocent child? How does one reconcile a “just and loving God” with this? I know for a fact that athiests would LOVE to point this out.

Thanks in advance for the help!! 👍
 
We all die at some time and in some fashion. And death is quite simply the wages of sin - original sin if no other - for the entire human race. Babies included.

That’s the problem with sin, its ill effects usually aren’t confined to the sinner alone. A father squanders the family fortune on alcohol, his children and their children suffer poverty for that. Uriah also suffered for David’s sin.

Is God unjust for taking some of us younger or more painfully than others?

Well, we simply don’t know what the child’s life would’ve been like if it had survived that particular illness, so it is not for us to judge that the child would have been better off alive, which is an unjustified presumption that your question is based on.
 
Reading 2Sam 12:13 and it worries me a bit. God punishes David for his sin by killing David’s child. The kid suffers a sickness for 7 days before it dies.

David did need to be punished and taking away all he had, including all his women, was just, but killing an innocent child? How does one reconcile a “just and loving God” with this? I know for a fact that athiests would LOVE to point this out.

Thanks in advance for the help!! 👍
Your question is defective…and due to the defect, is invalid…and, therefore, any attempt to answer the question will only result in the propogation of error.

To address your use of “innocent:” We are not born innocent of sin, but rather guilty and condemned. We are ALL born “children of wrath.” It is only by the Sacrament of Baptism that we are able to become “children of God.” (Read the Council of Trent on Justification (Session VI))

And…questions for you: How better to judge what is “just” than by Justice (i.e., God)? How can one presume to judge that which was before by that which came after? If God is the standard of justice and love, then why not use this example by which to define what is “just” and what is “love?”

– Nicole
 
The child was killed as a punishment for another’s sin, David’s. That is what I meant by “innocent.” The child was not involved in David commiting his sin of adultery.

This event happened prior to Jesus instituting baptism, so the council of Trent does not apply here.

"And…questions for you: How better to judge what is “just” than by Justice (i.e., God)? How can one presume to judge that which was before by that which came after? If God is the standard of justice and love, then why not use this example by which to define what is “just” and what is “love?”

I am not sure what your point is with that. I take it to mean that we must judge what is “just” by looking at God, since He is Justice. Does that mean killing one who had nothing to do with someone else’s sin, as a punishment for that person, is “just?”
 
An alcoholic father hurts his own kids by his mistakes. It is he that hurts his kids, not God. The child in the scenerio was killed directly by God for David’s sin.
We all die at some time and in some fashion. And death is quite simply the wages of sin - original sin if no other - for the entire human race. Babies included.

That’s the problem with sin, its ill effects usually aren’t confined to the sinner alone. A father squanders the family fortune on alcohol, his children and their children suffer poverty for that. Uriah also suffered for David’s sin.

Is God unjust for taking some of us younger or more painfully than others?

Well, we simply don’t know what the child’s life would’ve been like if it had survived that particular illness, so it is not for us to judge that the child would have been better off alive, which is an unjustified presumption that your question is based on.
 
An alcoholic father hurts his own kids by his mistakes. It is he that hurts his kids, not God. The child in the scenerio was killed directly by God for David’s sin.
Like I said, death is the wages of sin, humanity has brought those wages upon itself by its own sin. God certainly didn’t make us sin, therefore God never does really kill us, as death is utterly contrary to His plan for us.

On the contrary, He so doesn’t want us to die that He sent Jesus to repair the damage caused by our sin and give us eternal life. It’s our sin, properly speaking, kills us and others.

God in this instance is just like the doctor who tells you that your child is going to die of cancer from your subjecting it to passive smoking. In such a case the doctor doesn’t kill the child, directly or indirectly.
 
Like I said, death is the wages of sin, humanity has brought those wages upon itself by its own sin. God certainly didn’t make us sin, therefore God never does really kill us, as death is utterly contrary to His plan for us.

On the contrary, He so doesn’t want us to die that He sent Jesus to repair the damage caused by our sin and give us eternal life. It’s our sin, properly speaking, kills us and others.

God in this instance is just like the doctor who tells you that your child is going to die of cancer from your subjecting it to passive smoking. In such a case the doctor doesn’t kill the child, directly or indirectly.
I understand the smoking scenerio you present. But I believe it is not a fair comparison in scenerios. God, in that scenerio, did not strike the child with cancer, the child’s father did by smoking. In 2 Sam. God directly intervenes and strikes the child with sickness.

Perhaps one can interpret this as David having some disease from his sinning, and therefore passed it to his child, resulting in the child’s death. But the text states that God Himself struck the child with the illness.

Thank you for your replies. I am not trying to be stubborn, I just know that some of the people I dialouge with will present the points that I am presenting.
 
I understand the smoking scenerio you present. But I believe it is not a fair comparison in scenerios. God, in that scenerio, did not strike the child with cancer, the child’s father did by smoking. In 2 Sam. God directly intervenes and strikes the child with sickness.

Perhaps one can interpret this as David having some disease from his sinning, and therefore passed it to his child, resulting in the child’s death. But the text states that God Himself struck the child with the illness.

Thank you for your replies. I am not trying to be stubborn, I just know that some of the people I dialouge with will present the points that I am presenting.
If these people you are dialoguing with believe in an all-powerful God who has power of life and death, then they certainly must believe that God struck the child of the passive smoker with cancer, since most children who are equally exposed to passive smoking don’t develop cancer at all, so clearly someone, that someone being God, ultimately determines that this one gets cancer and the others don’t. 🤷

And these people you are dialoguing with, assuming they accept the Bible which states clear as clear that death is the wages of sin and that all have sinned, therefore all are liable to death, have no comeback at all.

If they don’t, then dialoguing with them makes no sense since you’re effectively speaking different languages altogether.
 
They are athiests. Maybe one is an agnostic but I dialouge to explain and defend why I believe what I do. Maybe through God’s grace if I have a good reply they might start down a journey of faith.
 
Reading 2Sam 12:13 and it worries me a bit. God punishes David for his sin by killing David’s child. The kid suffers a sickness for 7 days before it dies.

David did need to be punished and taking away all he had, including all his women, was just, but killing an innocent child? How does one reconcile a “just and loving God” with this? I know for a fact that athiests would LOVE to point this out.

Thanks in advance for the help!! 👍
The penalty in Mosaic law for murder (unjustly spilling the blood of another - Uriah the Hittite in this case) was blood. Davids. God would have been perfectly just to kill David in response to that murder, let alone the coveting and lusting after Uriah’s wife. Had God struck David dead, in sin, David would have lost his eternal life. God did not; He struck David’s newborn son in David’s place, achieving the just price of blood for Uriah’s murder and allowing David the opportunity to repent and turn away from his sin. Forgiveness of sin does not mandate foregoing of punishment.

We have no way to know what happened to the soul of David’s son, but we have good reason to think it quite possible that since he served as God’s instrument to get David’s mind (and soul) right, and gave his blood for the life of another (his father), that God in His infinite mercy might consider that justification enough to overlook the baby’s original sin and grant him eternal life.

So what appears on its face as a horrible injustice and lack of love from a human perspective might in an eternal sense be a win-win situation.
 
Your question is defective…and due to the defect, is invalid…and, therefore, any attempt to answer the question will only result in the propogation of error. …
Can any question be defective?

Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect …

(1 Peter 3:15)
 
Reading 2Sam 12:13 and it worries me a bit. God punishes David for his sin by killing David’s child. The kid suffers a sickness for 7 days before it dies.

David did need to be punished and taking away all he had, including all his women, was just, but killing an innocent child? How does one reconcile a “just and loving God” with this? I know for a fact that athiests would LOVE to point this out.

Thanks in advance for the help!! 👍
Shadow:

I hear what you are saying. David gives us a clue to the answer, for he says after his infant dies:
“While the child was still alive, I fasted and wept. I thought, ‘Who knows? The LORD may be gracious to me and let the child live.’ But now that he is dead, why should I fast? Can I bring him back again? I will go to him, but he will not return to me.”

(2 Samuel 12:22-23)
By the words, “I will go to him” i gather he was speaking of meeting his child in heaven. Death is tragic, but even in death there is hope. Maybe God was looking beyond David. Perhaps God was looking to people like you or me, who would read of David’s tragedy and learn about hope.
 
The penalty in Mosaic law for murder (unjustly spilling the blood of another - Uriah the Hittite in this case) was blood. Davids. God would have been perfectly just to kill David in response to that murder, let alone the coveting and lusting after Uriah’s wife. Had God struck David dead, in sin, David would have lost his eternal life. God did not; He struck David’s newborn son in David’s place, achieving the just price of blood for Uriah’s murder and allowing David the opportunity to repent and turn away from his sin. Forgiveness of sin does not mandate foregoing of punishment.

We have no way to know what happened to the soul of David’s son, but we have good reason to think it quite possible that since he served as God’s instrument to get David’s mind (and soul) right, and gave his blood for the life of another (his father), that God in His infinite mercy might consider that justification enough to overlook the baby’s original sin and grant him eternal life.

So what appears on its face as a horrible injustice and lack of love from a human perspective might in an eternal sense be a win-win situation.
Sounds valid enough:thumbsup:. Looking at it from the devil’s advocate position, I can see one possible “comeback” from the athiest pov. If the law states that it must be David’s blood, why does God cut him slack? God did not do that for everyone else.

"*Shadow:

I hear what you are saying. David gives us a clue to the answer, for he says after his infant dies: *
*“While the child was still alive, I fasted and wept. I thought, ‘Who knows? The LORD may be gracious to me and let the child live.’ But now that he is dead, why should I fast? Can I bring him back again? I will go to him, but he will not return to me.”

(2 Samuel 12:22-23)
*By the words, “I will go to him” i gather he was speaking of meeting his child in heaven. Death is tragic, but even in death there is hope. Maybe God was looking beyond David. Perhaps God was looking to people like you or me, who would read of David’s tragedy and learn about hope."

Interesting pov. 🙂
 
Can any question be defective?

Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect …

(1 Peter 3:15)
Yes, questions can be defective. One can call a question defective that fails to fulfill the ultimate requirement of speech, which would in effect make the question invalid. To be a valid question (which means to fulfill the ultimate requirement of speech) a question must not contain any references that are contrary either to themselves or to reality. An attempted answer to a question formed on either contrary or unrealistic premises will either answer in such a way that error will be confirmed as true, or give the appearance of certitude to speculations. This outcome will render void the answer, even if the answer is attempted to convey truth with certitude, and will only serve to confuse or deceive any person that hears both the answer and question. Since the primary purpose of speech is to convey the truth with certitude, an answer to an invalid question will void the primary purpose of speach, leaving the person who gives the answer guilty of vain or deceptive speech, a violation of the eight commandment.

Being prepared to give a reason for one’s hope is different than trying to answer invalid questions.

– Nicole
 
Reading 2Sam 12:13 and it worries me a bit. God punishes David for his sin by killing David’s child. The kid suffers a sickness for 7 days before it dies.

David did need to be punished and taking away all he had, including all his women, was just, but killing an innocent child? How does one reconcile a “just and loving God” with this? I know for a fact that athiests would LOVE to point this out.

Thanks in advance for the help!! 👍
According to Jewish law, the firstborn son of a widow inherited the estate of the mother’s deceased husband. If that son could not receive the inheritance, it would pass to the nearest eligible relative. In addition to this factor, one must be mindful of the effects on the Nation it may have had. Sometimes it is better to sacrifice one for the Nation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top