Going to Mass With a Cold?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Melodeonist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I won’t give an opinion other than to say I have see a certain priest say mass daily in his 90’s when he couldn’t hardly go, until he was replaced by another priest. He died very soon after his replacement was assigned. He was hanging on by a thread just for the people in the pew and his priestly vows/duties. I have seen other priests so sick and under the weather that I don’t know how they were able to get through Mass. But they did. Just saying…peace.
 
I think it is an act of charity to those around you to stay home from Mass when you have an active cold. My son has asthma and a small cold to someone else puts him through at least 3 nebulizer treatments a day. They are expensive and adversely effect his behavior. I can think of at least 2 separate times that our family changed where we were sitting before Mass because someone around us was coughing quite a bit and we could smell their sore throat lozenge or Vicks or whatever it was. Also think of people like my 80 year old grandmother who has a weak immune system, and not only the elderly but anyone going through chemotherapy.

I don’t know what is causing your cold, but viruses can live outside the body for up to 24 hours. Your hand into the water font. Your hand touching the pew in front of you when you kneel and stand up. Your hands touching the missallettes. And then others will come at a later Mass and touch all these same things. This is why my family & I don’t go to church when we’re sick, as a courtesy & charity to others.
Hi EmeraldOak,

Thank you for this explanation. 🙂

I too have asthma, and I have gotten really ill from people coughing or sneezing right on me.

As someone else said, someone’s mild cold could end up being pneumonia or bronchitis for someone like me who has asthma.

It has happened to me unfortunately, where I had stubborn cases of bronchitis where I was ill for a couple of months from it. The same with pneumonia, where it can hang around for months, too.

It would be better and safer for someone to stay home when they’re ill until they pass the contagious phase of their illness.

That way it would help to prevent them from passing the illness around to others. 🙂
 
I quite agree. In a sense, going to work is irrelevant. What the ill person should ask is ‘Will I spread any germs by going to Mass?’. If the answer is yes, then they shouldn’t go to Mass, it’s as simple a that.

I sometimes think that going to Mass when ill is to avoid the pain of feeling guilty. That is to say, it’s verging on selfishness. What we should ask ourselves is ‘What is charity to our neighbour?’
What a great and thoughtful post, paperwight. 🙂

If we’re ill, we have a perfectly legitimate reason for not attending Mass that day/time. I think that may be what someone might be worried about.
 
I am begging you: if you think there is even a slight possibility you might be contagious, please stay home!!! My Spiritual Director once told me that if I so much as suspected I might be contagious, I was not to attend Mass. You are excused under that condition. Some people have compromised immune systems, and you could end up making someone very ill.
To which I would add, if you are a healthy parent who has a child with a cold, please stay home with the kid and take care of the child. Bringing a child with a cold to church is serious. Childhood colds can be much more severe if given to an adult, especially an older adult or someone healthy but with a compromised immune system.

My :twocents:
 
I quite agree.** In a sense, going to work is irrelevant.** What the ill person should ask is ‘Will I spread any germs by going to Mass?’. If the answer is yes, then they shouldn’t go to Mass, it’s as simple a that.

I sometimes think that going to Mass when ill is to avoid the pain of feeling guilty. That is to say, it’s verging on selfishness. What we should ask ourselves is ‘What is charity to our neighbour?’
Using the comparison of “if you are going to your job, you can go to Mass” doesn’t really work for a gauge of whether you are ill enough to stay home from Mass.

There are many people who will still go to work ill, spreading germs, simply because they cannot afford to miss work. When I say “afford to miss work”, I mean that if they call in, there’s a strong likelihood they will lose their job. Not all people are fortunate to be in the employment of a company or person that offers generous sick days allowances and not all people are blessed with paid sick days.
 
Exactly,. It has nothing to do with your plan to skip work on any given day.
And if you can go to work, you can go to Mass.
Sheesh.
I’d agree, except some people are too sick or at least contagious and SHOULDN’T go to work but their bosses make them go, or else.
 
If people had any idea how far droplets from a cough or sneeze can spread, there would be no question about attending Mass when ill. Even a tissue is not totally effective. And just shaking hands or not taking from the cup is not enough. People touch the back of the pews, they dip their fingers in the holy water, they put the envelopes in the collection basket, they pass the collection basket from person to person, etc., and then others near them or after them are exposed. No big deal maybe for a healthy person, but for the young or elderly or those with immune system problems, it can lead to serious illness.

I went to Adoration once and the guy across the aisle was coughing and sniffling. I wasn’t near enough to touch him. You guessed it–I was laid up for over a week with a severe cold and bronchitis after. I have a somewhat compromised immune system because of diabetes and pick up infection rather easily. My Pastor put it succinctly in the bulletin: If you are sick, stay home. If the weather is bad and the roads are a hazard, stay home. Missing Mass under such circumstances is not a sin.

Telling people it’s no big deal or to suck it up and go and just sit away from people is just plain wrong and bad advice. If you are contagious, stay home.
 
If people had any idea how far droplets from a cough or sneeze can spread, there would be no question about attending Mass when ill. Even a tissue is not totally effective. And just shaking hands or not taking from the cup is not enough. People touch the back of the pews, they dip their fingers in the holy water, they put the envelopes in the collection basket, they pass the collection basket from person to person, etc., and then others near them or after them are exposed. No big deal maybe for a healthy person, but for the young or elderly or those with immune system problems, it can lead to serious illness.

I went to Adoration once and the guy across the aisle was coughing and sniffling. I wasn’t near enough to touch him. You guessed it–I was laid up for over a week with a severe cold and bronchitis after. I have a somewhat compromised immune system because of diabetes and pick up infection rather easily. My Pastor put it succinctly in the bulletin: If you are sick, stay home. If the weather is bad and the roads are a hazard, stay home. Missing Mass under such circumstances is not a sin.

Telling people it’s no big deal or to suck it up and go and just sit away from people is just plain wrong and bad advice. If you are contagious, stay home.
Our Pastor has a cold and said Mass yesterday. He was coughing a lot during his homily and during the Consecration. He was coughing into his sleeve but finally used a cloth (don’t know what it’s called) that is on the altar, to cover his mouth.
Then he handed out Communion. Yuck.
 
If a person is sick and possibly contagious, please stay home from Mass.

At work, I can phone into meetings and avoid close contact with others. That’s not the case at Mass.
Don’t leave the house. There are more sick peole at the store than at Mass. sneezing all over whatever Can of peaches you just picked up. Touching that awesome p(name removed by moderator)ad at checkout after using the restroom? Ever used a public restroom. With men, we wear shoes, walk on urine wetted floors leave the restroom, put those shoes on our car mats, walk in carpet with them and store them in a closet. Not to mention in a room with hundreds of people touching the same cup with thier lips, holding hands and such that you will come into contact with someone carrying a virus or germs not yet active.

Or are leper colonies making a comeback.

I guess sick people should avoid stores, dr offices and hospitals too…
 
Don’t leave the house. There are more sick peole at the store than at Mass. sneezing all over whatever Can of peaches you just picked up. Touching that awesome p(name removed by moderator)ad at checkout after using the restroom? Ever used a public restroom. With men, we wear shoes, walk on urine wetted floors leave the restroom, put those shoes on our car mats, walk in carpet with them and store them in a closet. Not to mention in a room with hundreds of people touching the same cup with thier lips, holding hands and such that you will come into contact with someone carrying a virus or germs not yet active.

Or are leper colonies making a comeback.

I guess sick people should avoid stores, dr offices and hospitals too…
I hope you are not being sacrastic, because that is the proper procedure. either that or wear a mask (Like in Asia)
 
If people had any idea how far droplets from a cough or sneeze can spread, there would be no question about attending Mass when ill. Even a tissue is not totally effective. And just shaking hands or not taking from the cup is not enough. People touch the back of the pews, they dip their fingers in the holy water, they put the envelopes in the collection basket, they pass the collection basket from person to person, etc., and then others near them or after them are exposed. No big deal maybe for a healthy person, but for the young or elderly or those with immune system problems, it can lead to serious illness.

I went to Adoration once and the guy across the aisle was coughing and sniffling. I wasn’t near enough to touch him. You guessed it–I was laid up for over a week with a severe cold and bronchitis after. I have a somewhat compromised immune system because of diabetes and pick up infection rather easily. My Pastor put it succinctly in the bulletin: If you are sick, stay home. If the weather is bad and the roads are a hazard, stay home. Missing Mass under such circumstances is not a sin.

Telling people it’s no big deal or to suck it up and go and just sit away from people is just plain wrong and bad advice. If you are contagious, stay home.
I think that perhaps it’s possible that some people really don’t understand how colds and other viruses/illnesses are transmitted.
 
I think that perhaps it’s possible that some people really don’t understand how colds and other viruses/illnesses are transmitted.
Amen to that. And thank you to all who have the compassion and sense to stay home when sick.

My immune system is down and I am advised to sty away from mass . And I shop early when there are very few folk around.

Last time I broke that rule I was abed 6 weeks and am too old now to risk it .
 
Lots of variables. Garden-variety cold or more serious? How crowded will the church be- will there be empty pews where you can sit by yourself or not? Are there many elderly folks at that mass? There is no single answer that fits all circumstances.
 
Lots of variables. Garden-variety cold or more serious? How crowded will the church be- will there be empty pews where you can sit by yourself or not? Are there many elderly folks at that mass? There is no single answer that fits all circumstances.
Would you even think of taking that risk with the needs of others? THAT is why I agreed happily to stop attending.
 
People will come up with any excuse not to go to Mass.
Tawny, I’m afraid you just don’t get it. What’s “just a cold” and “no big deal” to you could end up killing someone else.

Before I got sick, I attended Mass daily. I was not looking for excuses not to go to Mass. It was at a packed Christmas vigil Mass that my husband picked up the germ that has made me so sick for so long. I too thought that catching his cold would be no big deal, but now I’ve been sick 8 months and have been told by my pulmonologist that I will likely be sick the rest of the year. In addition, my lungs are permanently scarred from the pnuemonia.

If, at this point, I catch another cold, the illness could be catastrophic for me. My priest has told me it is okay for me to stay home if the Mass is likely to be crowded. I will probably miss Christmas Mass this year because of that. I ache from just the thought that I will not get to go, especially because it means I will not receive Jesus in the Eucharist that day. 😦
 
Tawny, I’m afraid you just don’t get it. What’s “just a cold” and “no big deal” to you could end up killing someone else.

Before I got sick, I attended Mass daily. I was not looking for excuses not to go to Mass. It was at a packed Christmas vigil Mass that my husband picked up the germ that has made me so sick for so long. I too thought that catching his cold would be no big deal, but now I’ve been sick 8 months and have been told by my pulmonologist that I will likely be sick the rest of the year. In addition, my lungs are permanently scarred from the pnuemonia.

If, at this point, I catch another cold, the illness could be catastrophic for me. My priest has told me it is okay for me to stay home if the Mass is likely to be crowded. I will probably miss Christmas Mass this year because of that. I ache from just the thought that I will not get to go, especially because it means I will not receive Jesus in the Eucharist that day. 😦
((((HUGS)))) It will get easier, be assured and Jesus will feed you in other ways. I tried all ways, eg standing outside until time for communion, but realised that I was letting my condition rule my life, Now I am at peace about it. It was all such a fuss and a distraction.
 
In that case he shouldn’t go to work either and he shouldn’t go shopping. I caught a “cold” at a grocery store and was sick for three weeks. That person was obviously very sick. I don’t know how sick Melodeonist is or what he means by a cough. But if he is too sick to go to Mass he is too sick to go anyplace else.
Depending on the job as well…I’ve been at a job where an employee had excused herself to go throw up while at work. She was still told it would be written up as an unpermitted absence if she left work. The U.S. considers sick leave a privilege that isn’t extended to all workers. I’ve definitely gone to work on days where I was useless, probably infectious, and sometimes even ended up throwing up at work, because it was that or get a black mark on my file.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top