After reading the CARM dialogue examples, it seems attempting to discuss issues there would be akin to arguing with a brick wall (or a tape recorder). I guess it’s not all that uncommon, but nontheless a constant source of aggravation to me. The same old comments over and over again. Example:
Illogical “Apologist”: Do you ask Mary to pray for you (or do you believe in the sacrifical nature of the Eucharist? Or do you believe in Baptismal Regeneration? Or do you believe in the necessity of aurical confession for forgiveness of mortal sin? Etc.)?
Me: Yes
Illogical “Apologist”: Where is that in the Bible?
Me: First of all, why does it have to be in the Bible? Secondly, if I find evidence of it there, what do you have to say to that?
Illogical “Apologist”: I’d say that you must be misinterpreting the Bible.
Me: OK, but why are you able to interpret the Bible correctly, but I am not?
Illogical “Apologist”: Because the Holy Spirit is “enlightening” me.
Me: But how do you know the Holy Spirit is “enlightening” you and not me (and about 2 billion other Catholics, not to mention millions of other Protestants)?
Illogical “Apologist”: Because I’m interpreting the Bible correctly.
Me: OK, but why are you able to interpret the Bible correctly, but I am not?
Illogical “Apologist”: Because the Holy Spirit is “enlightening” me.
Etc, etc., etc. With the circular arguments continuing ad nauseum. Trying to reason with someone incapable of understanding reason and logic is frustrating beyond belief. Any other sites anyone knows of?