Grace can be merited, but merit cannot be earned

  • Thread starter Thread starter thenobes
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

thenobes

Guest
First off, some say that meriting grace is contradictory.

Now to merit something is to receive it as a reward. Thus the result of works. Yet it is not earned by the works. How so?

An example. One lives in a land where under the soil are countless nuggets of Gold, If one works hard, one can gather more of the gold that is there. If one cares not to work, one is impoverished thereby.

Does one earn the Gold? No, it is there for the taking. As is God’s Grace.

Yet by working we get the Gold, and that is the merit, the reward: that we improve oourselves.

In God’s plan, it is He who gives us the works in the first place. They are a gift. But by that gift comes merit to receive more gifts. Not that He is offering us mmore gifts, but that we can partake of more of the gifts He is willing to give us always.

'nuff said?

peace
steve
 
First off, some say that meriting grace is contradictory.

Now to merit something is to receive it as a reward. Thus the result of works. Yet it is not earned by the works. How so?

An example. One lives in a land where under the soil are countless nuggets of Gold, If one works hard, one can gather more of the gold that is there. If one cares not to work, one is impoverished thereby.

Does one earn the Gold? No, it is there for the taking. As is God’s Grace.

Yet by working we get the Gold, and that is the merit, the reward: that we improve oourselves.

In God’s plan, it is He who gives us the works in the first place. They are a gift. But by that gift comes merit to receive more gifts. Not that He is offering us mmore gifts, but that we can partake of more of the gifts He is willing to give us always.

'nuff said?

peace
steve
According to the Scriptures God Himself saves “by grace through faith….” He saves the believer unmeritoriously (apart from works) upon faith in Christ alone. Grace is not a commodity put out there for the “taking.” A completely unbiblical concept. Grace (singular) is the means by which God saves the sinner “through faith” (in Christ). God Himself does the saving “by GRACE,” not by your taking “graces.” No such concept exists in Scripture.
 
According to the Scriptures God Himself saves “by grace through faith…” He saves the believer unmeritoriously (apart from works) upon faith in Christ alone. Grace is not a commodity put out there for the “taking.” A completely unbiblical concept. Grace (singular) is the means by which God saves the sinner “through faith” (in Christ). God Himself does the saving “by GRACE,” not by your taking “graces.” No such concept exists in Scripture.
God rewards us with merits for doing what we are told. Just like He rewards us with the opportunity of Salvation for accepting Christ.

Grace is put out there to understand and Believe
We accept it, and receive the actual Faith to believe (action/reward)
We come to Faith (belief) confess that belief (as well as our sins) and therefore are (temporarily) “saved” (again - action/reward)

This process continues throughout our lives. So long as we continue to act upon the Grace(s) we are offered, we will recieve merits for what we have done. Want Scripture?
1Co 3:10 According to the grace of God that is given to me, as a wise architect, I have laid the foundation: and another buildeth thereon. But let every man take heed how he buildeth thereupon.
1Co 3:11 For other foundation no man can lay, but that which is laid: which is Christ Jesus.
1Co 3:12 Now, if any man build upon this foundation, gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay, stubble:
1Co 3:13 Every man’s work shall be manifest. For the day of the Lord shall declare it, because it shall be revealed in fire. And the fire shall try every man’s work, of what sort it is.
1Co 3:14 If any man’s work abide, which he hath built thereupon, he shall receive a reward.
1Co 3:15 If any mans work burn, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved, yet so as by fire.
Peace

John
 
God rewards us with merits for doing what we are told. Just like He rewards us with the opportunity of Salvation for accepting Christ.

Grace is put out there to understand and Believe
We accept it, and receive the actual Faith to believe (action/reward)
We come to Faith (belief) confess that belief (as well as our sins) and therefore are (temporarily) “saved” (again - action/reward)

This process continues throughout our lives. So long as we continue to act upon the Grace(s) we are offered, we will recieve merits for what we have done. Want Scripture?
That Scripture has to do with a Christian worker’s rewards, not salvation. Works which will be evaluated at the judgment seat of Christ and rewarded if found valuable (gold, silver, precious stones).

Catholicism actually interprets those verses as referring to “purgatory.” Another unbiblical concept.“For by GRACE (not “graces”) you have been saved (not temporarily saved) through faith; and that not of yourselves (all of God), the GIFT of God (relating to “grace”); not as a result of works (unmerited), that no one should boast…” (Eph. 2:8-9)The one who God Himself saves BY grace through faith is then “created in Christ Jesus FOR good works” (vs. 10), not by them (i.e., theosis, another unbiblical concept).
 
According to the Scriptures God Himself saves “by grace through faith…” He saves the believer unmeritoriously (apart from works) upon faith in Christ alone. Grace is not a commodity put out there for the “taking.” A completely unbiblical concept. Grace (singular) is the means by which God saves the sinner “through faith” (in Christ). God Himself does the saving “by GRACE,” not by your taking “graces.” No such concept exists in Scripture.
I don’t think the opening poster was referring to the grace of salvation - but rather to rewards that we can merit. They also are graces/gifts, for they are not something that God had to decide to give us.

There are varying graces/gifts that will come to us in the next life that ARE dependent on the degree to which we cooperated with the graces given to us here on earth. (Read the Sermon on the Mount and note the use of the word “reward”.)

1 Cor 3:8 He who plants and he who waters are equal, and each shall receive his wages according to his labor.
1 Cor 3:14 if the work which any man has built on the foundation survives, he will receive a reward.
Col 3:23-24 Whatever your task, work heartily, as serving the Lord and not men, knowing that from the Lord you will receive the inheritance as your reward;

Nita
 
I don’t think the opening poster was referring to the grace of salvation - but rather to rewards that we can merit. They also are graces/gifts, for they are not something that God had to decide to give us.

There are varying graces/gifts that will come to us in the next life that ARE dependent on the degree to which we cooperated with the graces given to us here on earth. (Read the Sermon on the Mount and note the use of the word “reward”.)

1 Cor 3:8 He who plants and he who waters are equal, and each shall receive his wages according to his labor.
1 Cor 3:14 if the work which any man has built on the foundation survives, he will receive a reward.
Col 3:23-24 Whatever your task, work heartily, as serving the Lord and not men, knowing that from the Lord you will receive the inheritance as your reward
;

Nita
You’re not talking “gifts” here. Nor are you talking “grace” (unmerited favor). Rewards are merited, not “gifted” according to “grace.”
 
You’re not talking “gifts” here. Nor are you talking “grace” (unmerited favor). Rewards are merited, not “gifted” according to “grace.”
What are the rewards that we merit?
Is it different status in heaven, or what?
I have never been quite sure what was meant by that.
(I am looking for moondweller’s reply here, not other catholics…thx.)
 
Col 3:23-24 Whatever your task, work heartily, as serving the Lord and not men, knowing that from the Lord you will receive the inheritance as your reward;

Nita
Paul, in context, is giving instruction to believers who were slaves. I think the NASB gives the best translation:Col 3:23-24 "Whatever you do (i.e., as slaves), do your work heartily, as for the Lord rather than for men, knowing that from the Lord you will receive the reward of the inheritance. It is the Lord Christ whom you serve."The work they did, as slaves, for their masters was to be done heartily as for the Lord rather than for men, with the knowledge that they would receive the reward that consists of the inheritance.

Slaves, being not family members, did not receive an inheritance, but spiritually they are “sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus” (Gal. 3:26), whom they, ultimately, serve.

Paul is saying that though they are slaves without an inheritance in this life, they have an inheritance (eternal life) in Christ. It’s a play on words.

This inheritance is reserved in heaven for the believer - even the slave which has none here: The Apostle Peter concurs:1 Pet 1:3-5 "Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who according to His great mercy has caused us to be born again to a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead, to {obtain} an inheritance {which is} imperishable and undefiled and will not fade away, reserved in heaven for you, who are protected by the power of God through faith for a salvation ready to be revealed in the last time."This is all according to God’s GRACE, unmerited, divine favor, through faith.
 
What are the rewards that we merit?
Is it different status in heaven, or what?
I have never been quite sure what was meant by that.
(I am looking for moondweller’s reply here, not other catholics…thx.)
Scripture does not go into any details as to what the rewards are. And for good reason:Rom 1:16-17 "For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to the Greek. For in it {the} righteousness of God is revealed from faith to faith; as it is written, “But the righteous {man} shall live by faith.”

2 Cor 5:7 "…for we walk by faith, not by sight"According to 1 Cor. 3 each Christian worker who builds upon the foundation (Christ) will receive his reward (or not) at the judgment seat of Christ (2 Cor. 5:10). That rewards will be given at that time, based on the quality of each man’s work, is divinely revealed to us. What those rewards actually are, God has not seen fit to reveal. Nor is He obligated to do so. And anyway, they would have to be personally revealed to each individual - and this is not the time for that.
Is it different status in heaven, or what?
No.Gal 3:26 "For you are all sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus."For now the believer must be content with this Biblical principle:Deut 29:29 “The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things revealed belong to us…”.But Paul’s words are quite comforting and at the same time exciting:Rom 8:18-19 “For I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory that is to be revealed to us. For the anxious longing of the creation waits eagerly for the revealing of the sons of God.”
 
You’re not talking “gifts” here. Nor are you talking “grace” (unmerited favor). Rewards are merited, not “gifted” according to “grace.”
I’m talking all three moondweller, gift/grace/reward.
They are gifts, as I noted in my posts, because there is no inherent compulsion that God must grant certain wages/rewards/benefits for good actions. **It is completely gratuitous on His part that He decided to do so. ** Rewards are merited ONLY in the sense that God, having said He will reward us according to our good deeds, may be said to put Himself under obligation (so to speak) to grant those gifts when we then do those good deeds. God could require all the same acts without offering any reward. The “reward” aspect is itself a gift/grace.

Maybe the following example will express a little more clearly what I’m trying to convey:
Eg. A parent may tell his child to clean up his room and if he does he can have an ice cream cone; and if he does a really good job, mopping and waxing the floor, then he can have a banana split.
Now, there is no obligation on the parent’s part to offer these “gifts/rewards” to the child; that is, there’s nothing about cleaning one’s room that inherently requires the giving of an ice cream cone for justice to be fulfilled. (A parent can require a child to clean his room — period; no gift/reward) Rather, it comes from the parent wanting to give a gift to the child as a reward for a good act.

As a Catholic, I know that everything good is a gift/grace from God. He may have established various ways in which to bestow these gifts, requiring various thoughts, words, or deeds on my part (merit?) in order to receive them (reward?) - but they are always a gift/grace.
 
…
Col 3:23-24 “Whatever you do (i.e., as slaves), do your work heartily, as for the Lord rather than for men, knowing that from the Lord you will receive the reward of the inheritance. It is the Lord Christ whom you serve.”

…
Paul is saying that though they are slaves without an inheritance in this life, they have an inheritance (eternal life) in Christ. It’s a play on words.

This inheritance is reserved in heaven for the believer - even the slave which has none here: The Apostle Peter concurs: 1 Pet 1:3-5 …
This is all according to God’s GRACE, unmerited, divine favor, through faith.
Yes, it is grace/gift - and it is reward also as the Colossians passage notes.

It seems to be another case of the “either/or” way of perceiving things (Protestant) versus the “both/and” (Catholic).
 
I’m talking all three moondweller, gift/grace/reward.
They are gifts, as I noted in my posts, because there is no inherent compulsion that God must grant certain wages/rewards/benefits for good actions. It is completely gratuitous on His part that He decided to do so. Rewards are merited ONLY in the sense that God, having said He will reward us according to our good deeds, may be said to put Himself under obligation (so to speak) to grant those gifts when we then do those good deeds. God could require all the same acts without offering any reward. The “reward” aspect is itself a gift/grace.

Maybe the following example will express a little more clearly what I’m trying to convey:
Eg. A parent may tell his child to clean up his room and if he does he can have an ice cream cone; and if he does a really good job, mopping and waxing the floor, then he can have a banana split.
Now, there is no obligation on the parent’s part to offer these “gifts/rewards” to the child; that is, there’s nothing about cleaning one’s room that inherently requires the giving of an ice cream cone for justice to be fulfilled. (A parent can require a child to clean his room — period; no gift/reward) Rather, it comes from the parent wanting to give a gift to the child as a reward for a good act.

As a Catholic, I know that everything good is a gift/grace from God. He may have established various ways in which to bestow these gifts, requiring various thoughts, words, or deeds on my part (merit?) in order to receive them (reward?) - but they are always a gift/grace.
No Nita, salvation is gifted (Eph. 2:8), justification is gifted (Rom. 3:24), and eternal life is gifted (Rom. 6:23) by God upon faith in Jesus Christ. But those graciously gifted salvation, justification and eternal life, will receive reward (a “wage”) for their works of labor of building upon the foundation of Jesus Christ, if those works prove to have value (1 Cor. 3:10-15).

You’re confounding two different concepts: grace and works.
 
Yes, it is grace/gift - and it is reward also as the Colossians passage notes.
No. You’re misinterpreting the Colossians passage. Paul is saying that those slaves who, in this life, have no inheritance and no wage for their labor, receive a reward (wage), the eternal inheritance they have in Christ. It’s a play on words. Their inheritance in Christ is to be the motivator for faithfully serving their masters. One does not work for an inheritance.
It seems to be another case of the “either/or” way of perceiving things (Protestant) versus the “both/and” (Catholic).
The “both/and” is a false perception which lends itself nicely to the notion of a works (conditioned) salvation: “If you do then I will do.”
 
According to the Scriptures God Himself saves “by grace through faith…” He saves the believer unmeritoriously (apart from works) upon faith in Christ alone. Grace is not a commodity put out there for the “taking.” A completely unbiblical concept. Grace (singular) is the means by which God saves the sinner “through faith” (in Christ). God Himself does the saving “by GRACE,” not by your taking “graces.” No such concept exists in Scripture.
Yes it is. we have the choice to obey or disobey God. i doubt the disobedient will be given grace like the obedient one would. God does not make us do anything we don"t want to. He calls us to obedience but not all will come into obedience.

just one question for you. is the umbeliever also saved? if they are then why are we trying to bring them into obedience to Christ our Lord? do they have to say yes to our Lord before they can receive Grace or not?

**“I should not believe the Gospel except as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church.”
Saint Augustine (354-430), Against the Letter of Mani, 5,6, 397 A.D…

**
 
Yes it is. we have the choice to obey or disobey God. i doubt the disobedient will be given grace like the obedient one would. God does not make us do anything we don"t want to. He calls us to obedience but not all will come into obedience.

just one question for you. is the umbeliever also saved?
Of course not.*“For by grace you have been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, the gift of God; not as a result of works, that no one should boast.”*That excludes the unbeliever.
if they are then why are we trying to bring them into obedience to Christ our Lord? do they have to say yes to our Lord before they can receive Grace or not?
Upon belief in the Lord one is saved by GRACE (unmerited, divine favor). It’s by grace because it’s based on the work of Another: The sacrificial work of Jesus Christ. That’s “the wisdom of God,” "Wisdomseeker."1 Cor 1:21 “For since in the wisdom of God the world through its wisdom did not {come to} know God, God was well-pleased through the foolishness of the message preached to save those who believe.”

1 Cor 1:30-31 "But by His doing you are in Christ Jesus, who became to us wisdom from God, and righteousness and sanctification, and redemption, so that, just as it is written, "Let him who boasts, boast in the Lord."There is the “wisdom of the world” and there is the “wisdom of God.” One must be careful which wisdom one seeks.
 
No Nita, salvation is gifted (Eph. 2:8), justification is gifted (Rom. 3:24), and eternal life is gifted (Rom. 6:23) by God upon faith in Jesus Christ. But those graciously gifted salvation, justification and eternal life, will receive reward (a “wage”) for their works of labor of building upon the foundation of Jesus Christ, if those works prove to have value (1 Cor. 3:10-15).
I agree, and said, they are all gifts. But I believe the “gifting” goes even beyond what you include. I said that “reward” also exists as a “gift”. Giving us the opportunity to merit reward is in itself an “unmerited favor” (grace) from God. We did nothing to merit that opportunity.
You’re confounding two different concepts: grace and works.
No, I’m not confounding them. I just accept the Catholic understanding of the relationship between the two - not the Protestant understanding. Catholics just don’t “compartmentalize” as Protestants do. We don’t isolate various related aspects, ignoring the interconnection and/or interdependence that exists between them.

Nita
 
Catholics just don’t “compartmentalize” as Protestants do. We don’t isolate various related aspects, ignoring the interconnection and/or interdependence that exists between them.
What does that mean?
 
What does that mean?
Do you mean define “compartmentalize” and “isolate”?
Or do you mean how do Protestants do it in regard to the two aspects of grace and merit?

[My statement was a general one, in the sense that I was talking about the difference in the way we look at things, view situations. I think I used the term “mindset” in a post elsewhere. I’ve been groping for the right word both on this thread and the other one, but it seems to keep eluding me. Hate it when that happens! 🙂 Time to get out the dictionary and look for synonyms.]

Edit note: looked up definition of “mindset” and guess that’s the best term – when used with the following meaning (quoted from a dictionary site):
“mentality: a habitual or characteristic mental attitude that determines how you will interpret and respond to situations”

Nita
 
What are the rewards that we merit?
Is it different status in heaven, or what?
I have never been quite sure what was meant by that.
(I am looking for moondweller’s reply here, not other catholics…thx.)
Good luck! Been there, done that here: forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=278926&page=26

You can start on post 390…Here’s some tidbits…
*
MD:
… good works
done for the right reason will not only immediately benefit others and glorify Christ, but** will receive eternal rewards** (1 Cor. 3:11-15). But salvation itself is gifted (upon faith in Christ), not rewarded.
*
*
40.png
Philthy:
These rewards you speak of - do they influence our experience of Heaven? In other words, will the eternal happiness of those with great rewards exceed the eternal happiness of those with less?
Yes or No please.
*
**
MD:
**

Basically, whenever Scripture refers to our actions having an eternal consequence (Christ dividing the sheep and goats; Paul saying we run the race for an “imperishable crown”; etc etc) which one might interpret as influencing our salvation, OSAS adherents dismiss these admonitions as follows:
  • They claim they dont apply to believers; or, as seen above
  • They claim they dont affect our salvation, but merely our heavenly/eternal rewards.
    But when you try to get even a basic understanding of:
  • What are heavenly rewards?
  • Why does Scripture provide admonitions regarding the importance of good works affecting our heavenly reward? - you know, like is it bad not to have any heavenly reward?
    The bottom line - as evidenced above - is that there is no eternal consequence.
    I know Im stupid, but it seems meaningless to me to use the term “heavenly/eternal rewards” and have not the slightest clue what it means. It makes it seem - to me - like it is a convenient excuse to dispense with some verses that simply cannot be dispensed with any other way by the OSAS adherent. Heavenly rewards certainly sound important, but when pressed the OSAS adherent denies that they have any impact on our experience of eternity. Where’s the beef?
 
I agree, and said, they are all gifts. But I believe the “gifting” goes even beyond what you include. I said that “reward” also exists as a “gift”. Giving us the opportunity to merit reward is in itself an “unmerited favor” (grace) from God. We did nothing to merit that opportunity.
No Nita, they’re not all “gifts.” That would be like saying you don’t earn a wage at your place of employment. You’re actually undeserving of a wage because your employer gifts you the chance to work there in the first place. That “mindset” is convoluted, to say the least, and destroys any true concept of “grace” and “works.”
No, I’m not confounding them. I just accept the Catholic understanding of the relationship between the two - not the Protestant understanding. Catholics just don’t “compartmentalize” as Protestants do. We don’t isolate various related aspects, ignoring the interconnection and/or interdependence that exists between them.
Actually, you destroy any inherent dissimilarity between them. You attack language.

I agree with Sandusky who wrote wisely in another thread:“What I have said concerning the Catholic position on grace and faith is that the Church puts works under the umbrella of grace, teaching that the merit for works is derived from grace, and therefore works are not really works but grace.”

"I have never denied that the RC gives a “nod” to grace; however, ISTM that putting works under the umbrella of grace and then claiming that it’s grace that saves by works is trickery.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top