Greek translation of the word aionion

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholictiger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Tell me who Made the idea that Our Father is the Most Masculine…?

Who makes all the ideas, in the first place?

I love a challenge =)
When you get an idea from Scripture, you get an idea on the authority of the Holy Spirit. He inspired the Scriptures to express exactly what He wanted, and He always referred to Himself and the other Persons as masculine… Hmmm…
 
When you get an idea from Scripture, you get an idea on the authority of the Holy Spirit. He inspired the Scriptures to express exactly what He wanted, and He always referred to Himself and the other Persons as masculine… Hmmm…
If you’re not sure Why I said something, then it probably wasn’t meant for you, no worries =)

And God inspires us Every Day. Why would you used the word “inspired” as if it’s expired? “wanted”, “reffered”… these are all past tense… Does Scripture trump the Book of Life?

~V~
 
please get back on topic if you don’t I will repot the off topic posts and asked the thread to be closed.
 
carm.org/look-word-aionion can give you a little more direction.

Quoting from the above link:
To get around the problem of the English Bibles translating Greek words into “eternal,” “forever,” and forevermore" when describing fire (Matt. 18:8) or torment (Rev. 20:10), the universalists go to the Greek.
aionion.

It’s a word that means a lot of things to a lot of people. What do you think it means?
 
carm.org/look-word-aionion can give you a little more direction.

Quoting from the above link:

aionion.

It’s a word that means a lot of things to a lot of people. What do you think it means?
you are missing the point in my original post I asked a question about the word αιὼνιον and how it translates into english most biblical translations when it deals with this word it says eternal or eternity. An example passage would Christ’s parable about serving the least of these means serving Christ and those who did something for them will inherit αιὼνιον life and those who don’t will be thrown into the αιὼνιον fire.

αιὼνιον has a certain translation depending on context, you can’t just throw around random meanings into this word.

It would be like saying how does the word Bible translate into Latin, and someone came in there are multiple translation what ever it means to you is how you should translate it.
 
please note I was wrong about the word used in Matthew 25 the greek word is transliterated like aionios or in greek αιὼνιοζ

second note: the word actually at issue is aion or in greek αιὼν

Third note: the Church uses the word aionios or αιὼνιοζ to explain everlasting

it is in the phrase and life everlasting. (I’m guessing it could also be translated life eternal)
 
you are missing the point in my original post
Actually I’m not missing the point at all. I’m a Natural Language Programer, and I write AI for a living. There’s no such thing as “random” (another good word to add to the discussion)… at least not the way most people use it… Even in Chaos, there are patterns that people can see the first time, because it just looks like a mess, doesn’t mean you should get scared and run away.
It would be like saying how does the word Bible translate into Latin, and someone came in there are multiple translation what ever it means to you is how you should translate it.
And that is the point of a discussion, to see how other people see, think and feel, about words. How do ~you~ think? That’s a pertinent question as well
 
Actually I’m not missing the point at all. I’m a Natural Language Programer, and I write AI for a living.

And that is the point of a discussion, to see how other people see, think and feel, about words. How do ~you~ think? That’s a pertinent question as well.
I’m talking about the translation of a specific greek word not how that word makes you feel.

when a translator sits down and translates something he doesn’t care about how something makes him feel, what he does is he looks at words and context and tries to extract the meaning. Depending on what philosophy of translation he uses. If literal equivalence he will translated the passage word for word, if dynamic equivalence he will translate the passage keeping close to the meaning, if formal he will be as literal as possibly only if translating literally changes the meaning of the passage.

I don’t think a translator would let feelings affect his translation.
 
I don’t think a translator would let feelings affect his translation.
As a translator, I put everything I am, into my work. You started a discussion, but want to leave it, when it doesn’t fit your preconceived notions about what a discussion is. I’m trying to share my perspectives with you, which is what I thought was the original point of the thread.

I’ve given you a Lot of information to deal with, with regards to the correct translations of aionion. There’s a Lot more to talk about, if you wanna take some time and come back to it later.

Kyrie Eleison,

~V~

P.S.
We hear of the conversion of water into wine at the Marriage in Cana as of a miracle. But this conversion is, through the goodness of God, made every day before our eyes. Behold the rain which descends from heaven upon our vineyards; there it enters the roots of the vines, to be changed into wine; a constant proof that God loves us, and loves to see us happy.

~Ben Franklin

P.P.S
It’s cyclical, and finite, at the same time.

P.P.P.S.
Are you familiar with the Buddhist concepts of the Multiverse? There’s another joke that goes along with that. Did you think you were the only one?

P.P.P.P.S. Lighten up, dude. We’re just tryin to have a chat with you =)
 
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

***Over 21 posts have been removed or edited as off topic.

Please remain on topic which is the meaning of the Greek word aionion.

Further derailing posts may result in infractions as per the Forum Rules**. *
 
I’m talking about the translation of a specific greek word not how that word makes you feel.
As a translator, I Do think about how I feel about the words I’m translating. It’s important to do so, so you get the translations right, in the contexts they were given. That’s why, even though it’s nice to go back and look at the original Greek or Latin, phrases, it doesn’t make much sense to get stuck there. We can’t go back and ask those folks, what they meant, when they said it, and why.

English is the most Beautifully constructed language that I know, and it’s a lot easier to provide a more complete description of a word, when you have a lot more words to use to describe it.

aionion: Everlasting and Finite, at the same time. Are there other words you had in mind to describe it?
 
greetings anyone who has a good background in greek and can explain to me why aionion when used in the scripture (sometimes aionios) should be translated as eternal or everlasting?
When given multiple meanings of a word (some scholars think A (eternal) is closer to the actual meaning of the word (aionion) while others think B (everlasting) is closer) isn’t it possible that the true meaning is somewhere in between and there is no exact 1-1 translation into English? Or simply create an English word that has the characteristics, such as we did for the word “benedicere” (literally translated as “speak well of,”) which we know today as “bless.”

As I’ve stated before, English is a great analytic tool and I agree with Viktoria to a point where sometimes more than one word, perhaps a phrase, is necessary to convey the original meaning. I too have done translations, mostly in the dental labs where I worked. Also consider that the Greek itself may be a translation from Hebrew or Aramaic or even Latin (there was a Vetus Latina after all) so as we keep translating we are becoming more and more removed from the original. In many cases it is probably better to leave a word or phrase untranslated or develop some kind of English cognate, as we did with the word “consubstantial.” It may not be understandable to many, but any errors in translation are at least kept to a minimum.
 
When given multiple meanings of a word (some scholars think A (eternal) is closer to the actual meaning of the word (aionion) while others think B (everlasting) is closer) isn’t it possible that the true meaning is somewhere in between and there is no exact 1-1 translation into English? Or simply create an English word that has the characteristics, such as we did for the word “benedicere” (literally translated as “speak well of,”) which we know today as “bless.”

As I’ve stated before, English is a great analytic tool and I agree with Viktoria to a point where sometimes more than one word, perhaps a phrase, is necessary to convey the original meaning. I too have done translations, mostly in the dental labs where I worked. Also consider that the Greek itself may be a translation from Hebrew or Aramaic or even Latin (there was a Vetus Latina after all) so as we keep translating we are becoming more and more removed from the original. In many cases it is probably better to leave a word or phrase untranslated or develop some kind of English cognate, as we did with the word “consubstantial.” It may not be understandable to many, but any errors in translation are at least kept to a minimum.
Yes sorry I should have been clearer

let’s examine

Matthew 25:46 in greek

καὶ ἀπελεύσονται οὗτοι εἰς κόλασιν αἰώνιον, οἱ δὲ δίκαιοι εἰς ζωὴν αἰώνιον.

biblehub.com/interlinear/study/matthew/25.htm

taken from the above link I don’t know about the reliability of the greek.

the RSVCE translates this as

And they will go away into** eternal **punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.

the word eternal is how RSV translates that greek word I bolded

but there are those who say that this is an incorrectly translated.

My question remains, can anyone explain in this passage why the best translation into english is eternal or eternity, in context of this passage. (I would ask you to treat this like a piece literature and forget about Catholic Teaching)
 
I also like the phrase “in perpetuity”

It has a nice legal sound to it, and it has a lot of definition that you can find pretty easy with a web search =)

It can also be pluralized =D

~V~
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top