We have to avoid trying to be “more Catholic than the pope”. Respect is certainly the right thing to do. However, respect is for the person and his office. If we focus on the office and ignore the person, then we’re acting contrary to charity.
In the USA, we have two high profile friars who are bishops: Archbishop Chales Chaput and Cardinal Sean O’Malley. I don’t think that either man has ever said anything to the people of their dioceses or to their religious community, but their appearance says it all.
The Cardinal wears his habit even when he visits the pope. He is not the only one. There is a Carmelite and a Dominican who also wear their habits. They want to be treated and acknowledged as religious. Cardinal Sean’s greeting to the people of Boston was, “The Lord has sent you a different kind of bishop.” His priests and seminarians see him very much as the Brother or the Friar.
Archbishop Chaput goes for the middle of the road. He wears a business suit and Roman collar. Priests, deacons, religious brothers and many seminarians all wear the same suit and the same Roman collar. The Roman collar does not set him apart from his Franciscan brothers, from the secular clergy, the permanent deacons or the religious brothers. Cardinal George, who is an Oblate, does the same thing.
When we (brothers) are with the Cardinal or the Archbishop, we don’t kiss their rings and we refer to them by their names: Charlie and Sean. It would make them uncomfortable to have the men who are their brothers act differently toward them. It does not mean that the friars don’t love them and respect them. Part of respect is also kindness for the person.
If the bishop is very formal, kindness dictates that you be formal. If the bishop is less formal and simply likes a handshake, kindness dictates that you respond that way. We don’t make someone uncomfortable, because they occupy an office.
There is a cute story about Pope Benedict and the camera. He did not have much experience before the cameras. Shortly into his pontificate, some TV station was going to film him. The story goes that he became slightly nervous and asked the cameraman for guidance on how to stand and what to do in front of the camera. The point is, these are human beings. They find some things more comfortable than other things.
The right thing to do is whatever communicates respect and affection without making him feel uncomfortable.
Fraternally,
Br. JR, OSF
