Guidance on Sacred Tradition

  • Thread starter Thread starter OldeThom
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
He used men to write His word down.
No, Jesus did not. The Scripture were written years after His ascension. Heck, Paul didn’t even convert until six years after Jesus had ascended. The Holy Spirit, in fulfillment of the Words of Jesus to lead His Church to all truth, is who inspired Holy Scripture.
What the church essentially did was to recognize certain books and letters as inspired.
Basically correct, and the authority for them to do that, was established by Jesus in the leadership of His One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church. Without that authority you have no assurance of the inerrancy of His Word. You can only know the Bible is inerrant, (which it certainly is) is the authority of His Catholic church. His Church did not establish the canon of
Scriptures until the 4th century. For over 3 centuries there was no “New Testament” there were groups of writings, some inspired, some not. It took the authority Jesus established in His Church to establish His Word.
 
Are you saying that the church is inspired-inerrant also?
I don’t need to say that, Jesus already did. The only reason we have an inspired Bible is the authority of His Catholic Church. If you deny the authority of His Catholic Church you have NO guarantee that the Bible is truly the inspired Word of God. Think about it. If the Church had not been led by the Holy spirit to all truth, how can you know the Bible is the Word of God? You can’t. Fortunately we know the promise of Jesus to the leadership of His Church is true, therefore the inerrancy of Scripture is assured. Scary thought isn’t it? You need to acknowledge the Catholic Church had such authority or you have no Bible!
 
So I guess I was asking: is my train of thought on this on the right track or have I missed the boat completely? I really do want to see outside the box, as it were. In fact this may be too wide of a subject to discuss in forums such as this. So again my apologies.

Thom
I have only read a few of your posts, but I wanted to stop and commend you for your study, your comtemplation, struggle, curiosity, persistence, and willingness to explore outside the boundaries of your background. It is thrilling to see such seeking here on CAF. It is for people such as yourself that we are here. 👍
 
This does not answer the question. What are these “other signs” that Jesus did not recorded in the Scriptures?
How we should interpret them. 😃
There are all kinds of things that are true. What specifically is Paul referring to here?
Since Jesus is the Way, the Truth, and the Life, would he not mean Jesus?
We know what the written Word of God is. What are these Sacred Traditions?
You have stated before that when you use the word “we” you are talking about “true Christians”, and you define that to mean “bible only Christians”. You have also stated clearly your perspective on Sacred Tradition.
If you can’t find clear support for a doctrine, then what you are left with is speculation. Speculation is not a foundation in which to build a doctrine on. Its like building on sand.

What are the signs that the Holy Spirit is guiding the church?
The scriptures warn of false teachers and their teachings. They both are connected.
It is only the scriptures that are infallible and inerrant. Not the church.
"justasking:
And well they should question. The scriptures warn of false teachers in the church who will decieve many. That is why you should hold your church accountable to what the scriptures teach. When you study the marian doctrines in light of the scriptures you will find that the support is not there. What you must do is be on guard against false teachers in your own church. The scriptures do warn of false teachers in the church itself. There was no promise given by Christ that this would not happen.
40.png
guanophore:
my question to you was, why do YOU want to discuss Sacred Tradition, since you have already rejected the very notion. Why waste your time?
40.png
justasking4:
Engaging for the truth is never a waste of time. Secondly it might get someone who reads these posts to rethink their position.
ja4, you have been clear that you believe all Sacred Tradition to be “false teachings”, speculations, and traditions of men.

This being the case, I can only surmise that you are trying to deter the person inquiring here into becoming a 'bible christian" and eschew Catholicism. 🤷
Then were back to the NT since that is all we know that Jesus revealed to them.
No, you are. It is not appropriate for you to come to CAF and attempt to lead others into your error. YOu are welcome to this belief, but it is wrong for you to discourage others who are interested in getting out of it.
It seems you are saying that the Scriptures and and Sacred Tradition is the same thing. Is the correct?
To the extent that they both reflect the revelation of God of Himself, they are alike. The written and lived Word come from the same Divine Source. They are different in quality and character, however.
Discussed in other threads. Please use the search function.
I took the liberty of saving some of the good ones. 😃
What a strange question for a supposed “Christian” to ask. There is only one truth. He (the truth) is the head of His Catholic Church (the body).
One must keep in mind that ja4 is functioning from the perspective that false teachers have crept into the Church, and are leading the faithful astray.
I believe that the scriptures are the inspired word of God but i don’t always believe what your church or my church teaches is always right. In sense we must pick and choose what we will
believe to be the truth
. I’m would think even you have certain qualms about some issues in your church.
"justasking4:
**is this not
a false teaching **since it cannot be grounded in the scriptures? If not taught in scripture, how would your church know this to be a fact…
If you can’t find clear support for a doctrine, then what you are left with is speculation.
I have seen this claim many times about Sacred Tradition and those things not recorded in the scriptures. The problem is that if its not in the scriptures, its not
inspired-inerrant. Those things not in the scriptures are not binding though. They do not carry apostolic authority. It is true there are other authorties but since the scriptures alone are
inspired-inerrant these authorities are under the authority of the scriptures. Keep in mind that most of these if not all of them are not grounded in the scriptures.
"guanophore:
ja4, you seem to want to lead Catholics into questioning the Magesterium.
40.png
justasking4:
And well they should question. The scriptures warn of false teachers in the church who will decieve many. That is why you should hold your church accountable to what the scriptures teach. When you study the marian doctrines in light of the scriptures you will find that the support is not there.

What you must do is be on guard against false teachers in your own church. The scriptures do warn of** false teachers in the church itself**. There was no promise given by Christ that this would not happen.
40.png
guanophore:
You have already stated they are “speculations of men” and have no validity, since you do not see them in your bible.
jusasking4 said:
** i want to help others see it to**. Engaging for the truth is never a waste of time.
If what you say is true, then this would be a false gospel since Paul was totally unaware of the many doctrines in the catholic church.
It could just as easily be shown in some respects how quickly the church was allowing unbilical teachings into the church at a very early stage.

I would counter Newman with this: To know the Scriptures is to be Protestant.
When you read his posts, keep these foundations in mind, and the questions will not seem so strage. There is a clear agenda here.
 
So I am encouraged. One of the problems I had with the Catholic Church was that they “seemed” to regard the Bible as subordinate, inferior and regard their own traditions as “superior” to it. I am glad to find that is not the case. I have much to learn. I am, after all, working from my own little private “cell” and not yet part of a teaching community, but I am beginning to see where many of the perceptions I have of the Church are skewed, based on ignorance or misinformation and/or downright incorrect.

Respectfully,
Thom
I think this has been the case with many of us here. When the truth of what the Church actually teaches is studied, it causes these misinformations to dissolve into the abyss from which they came. 👍
 
Where is this found in the Scriptures?
“Now we command you, beloved, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, to keep away from believers who are living in idleness and not according to the tradition that they received from us.” 2 Thess 3:6-7

The Sacred Tradition, among other things, is a way of life that is consistent with the Apostolic Teaching that was handed down. It is a Holy way of being in the world, according to what Jesus taught. This is one reason that it does not reduce well to “lists”. 😉

“I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions just as I handed them on to you.”
1 Cor 11:2

The Sacred Traditions are received from an authoritative source, then handed down. This is called “paradosis”. This is the preservation of the Apostolic Teaching.

" So then, brothers and sisters, stand firm and hold fast to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by our letter." 2 Thess 2:14-15

Paul is saying that the Source of the traditions is Apostolic Teaching, and that both the word of mouth, and the letters, carry the same authority.

“We also constantly give thanks to God for this, that when you received the word of God that you heard from us, you accepted it not as a human word but as what it really is, God’s word, which is also at work in you believers.” 1 Thess 2:13-14

Paul commends them for receiving the Word of God by hearing. It is not from a human source, but from God.

It is a mystery to me how anyone can read these scriptures, and still deny the existence of Sacred Tradition, however, I have seen you do this for almost two years now, so I have to confess that there are mysteries in life that are beyone my comprehension. 🤷
Code:
 It is true that we have no record of Jesus writing anything except on the ground. However He did use His apostles and others to write down what He did and what others said about Him in the NT. That's what inspiration is about.
It is very Catholic of you to say this. 👍 What is anti-Catholic is your attitude that these Sacred Teachings, inspired by God, somehow disappeared after they were written. It is as if you think they were no longer written on the hearts of the faithful.
The source of the Scrirptures is Christ. He used men to write His word down. What the church essentially did was to recognize certain books and letters as inspired.
Yes, the Source of the Word is God, but it is more than “used men to write it down”. This is not some sort of automatic writing, but faithful men writing what they believed in their hearts. They did not stop belieiving or teaching it after they wrote it.

Yes, the Church did recognize certain books and letters as inspired. They did this by comparing the content to the Sacred Apostolic Teaching that was handed down through the generations, and preserved by the HS from error. 👍
Code:
Keep in mind that the OT scriptures predate the church and the church in part came about by the ministry of Christ which was first taught orally and then written down.
This is also why the Catholic Bible differs from the Protestant. Catholics use the collection that was used by Jesus and the Apostles, while Protestants tend to use the collection that was composed by those who rejected Christ. 😦
Are you saying that the church is inspired-inerrant also?
Absolutely!

John 20:21-23
s the Father has sent me, so I send you." 22 When he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. 23 If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.”

God breathed.
There are many dimension to truth. I’m asking what specific truth is Paul referring to in the context in which he writes these words.
Well, let’s see. Paul defines the Church as the Body of Christ, and His bride. As His Body, and His Bride, I would think that it is He who is held up by the Church.
 
Not sure if I enjoyed the dismantling of justasking4’s comments, guanophore, but it was informative. I also understood your purpose in doing so. I also want to thank you for your kind words and encouragement. There has really been some good information here and I hope it will continue.

As I have stated, and will continue to state, I am at the beginning of a process. There is a struggle going on right now between what I “know” and what I “believe”, i.e., my quest for spiritual Truth. For me, at any rate, it is not a struggle between “right” and “wrong” or “good” and “evil”. It is a question as to what is the foundation of that Truth. Also, I fully believe that I am a Christian, that there is only One true God, a / the Holy Trinity, that I am saved by God the Father’s Grace through the Death and Resurrection of God the Son, Jesus Christ, and that the Holy Spirit dwells within me being fully baptised by both water and the Spirit. My belief and knowledge of it, is not in question. What is in question is where I rest the authority here on earth for that belief and assuring myself that what I “know” to be the truth is in fact what I “believe.” I honestly don’t know how to describe it any better than that in words. So apologies for my shortcomings (of which I have many.)

Respectfully,
Thom
 
Unfortunately Thom, you’ve seen the Sola Scripturists hijack your thread.

What is sad is that those who hold to that think cannot recognize the error. Luther removed books, when they did not fit his way of thinking - he considered James an epistle of straw, took out Hebrews, Revelations (which is probably why he thought he could remove books).

Highly recommend reading the early church fathers, the Doctors of the faith as you progress and get your head around this. What is excellent is your obvious desire to learn - thinking with the Church is not always an easy process, but so rewarding.

Do I want to trust one man’s judgment, i.e. my own or that of an errant preacher, or can I rest in a body of knowledge centuries old that can be traced back to the source himself.

FYI, there are plenty of verses that say to hold to the traditions handed down to us - 1 Timothy is a good start. It’s like when Paul exclaims “Follow me - as I follow Christ!”. BIG qualifier there.

Bless you my brother.
 
Tom;4091256]
Originally Posted by justasking4
Most of what you write here does not address what Jesus said and did that was not recorded. Most of this if not all is derived from the written Scriptures themselves.
Tom
Most but not all, you’re putting Sacred Tradition coming from Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition came first, all of the new Testament was derived from Sacred Tradition.
Are you saying that Sacred Tradition is oral and not written?
Where, in Scripture, does it say Jesus established Sunday as His day of worship?
He didn’t. However, since the resurrection took place on a Sunday that day became the primary day of worship. We have no record of any church leader declaring Sunday as day of worship.
Where does it say in Scripture the teachings of the communion of Saints?
Not sure what you are referring to here. Can you clarify?
As you’ve argued, the perpetual virginity of Mary comes from Sacred Tradition,
Huh? What do you mean by Sacred Tradition in this context?
I of course say it’s also in Scriptures, you disagree. Not a problem, it does not need to be in Scripture. When in doubt we defer to the leadership of the Church NOT Scripture.
It is a problem if its not in Scripture. That would mean its not a teaching of the apostles. You can defer to church leadership but that still does not mean its true.
Now if you find something specifically said in Scripture which the Church teaches against we can discuss it, but it not being in Scripture does not negate the importance or the authenticity.
It may be important for catholics but the issue of it being true is another matter. If something is to be authentic it must have facts to support it. It is not enough for some church authority to claim something is true and that is enough.
Does Jesus (in Scripture) tell us to bring our questions to Scripture, or to His Church?
I am aware that He did teach that in matters of church discipline it is to be brought before the church. Matters of doctrine though must be grounded in the Scriptures if they are to be apostolic.
Jesus established a Church He did not write a book.
If this is true why did the apostles and those associated with write the NT? Did they on their own determine to write these things down or was the Spirit of Christ also working in them to write these things down for the church?
In other words did the Spirit of Jesus have something to do with the NT being written down?
To me the Sacred Scripture are a third of the equation. We have Sacred Tradition, Sacred Scripture and the magisterium of the Church. None are complete in and of themselves, they are, like the Blessed Trinity itself indivisible. Sacred Tradition can not stand without the magisterium and Scripture; Scared Scripture can not stand without Sacred Tradition and the magisterium; the magisterium can not stand without Sacred Tradition and Scared Scripture. You want one answer. As in the Trinity, three is the one answer.
I’m still trying to understand what this Sacred Tradition is and what exactly it is. It appears that Scripture and Sacred Tradition are 2 different things. This is why i need to see some kind of list of what it is.
Tom
This is why God tells us to follow the Tradition,
Quote:
Originally Posted by justasking4
Where is this found in the Scriptures?
Tom
You’re joking of course? You really know that little Scripture? No, you’re joking…
No joke. Can you show me a list from the Catholic church what these Traditions are?
Tom
this is why Jesus established a Church and didn’t write a book.
Quote:
Originally Posted by justasking4
It is true that we have no record of Jesus writing anything except on the ground. However He did use His apostles and others to write down what He did and what others said about Him in the NT. That’s what inspiration is about.
Tom
Jesus told the leadership of His Church that He would send the Holy Spirit to lead them to all truth. He doesn’t promise you and I, even though we each are filled with the Holy Spirit, that we will be led to all truth. He promises this to a small group, His Apostles.
I agree with this. What He led them to evenually became written down and we call it the NT.
Do you believe there is further “revelation” beyond the NT?
There is no small wonder why there are thousands of differing “truths” out there, each claiming to be Scripture based. .
There may be one truth but people have differing interpretations and understandings of it. Even the apostles had differing understandings. Take the issue of faith and salvation. James as you may know gives one perspective of it while Paul approaches the issue from a different perspective.
There is only one truth, and Jesus only promised one group, the leadership of His Church, that they and they alone would be guaranteed to be led to all truth
The problem is that its not really like this. Jesus never promised that the church could not err. He and others warned that false teachers would bring false teachings into the church and decieve many. Secondly, if you look at Catholic teaching on some issues like salvation you will find contradictory teachings.
 
Tom;4091414]
Originally Posted by justasking4
Are you saying that the church is inspired-inerrant also?
Tom
I don’t need to say that, Jesus already did.
To be inerrant means incapable of mistakes: incapable of making a mistake. If this were true of the Catholic church it would mean it has never made a mistake. There is so much evidence against this claim. Jesus never made such a claim for the church. Even in Revelations 2:12-15 we see Christ rebuking a church for error.
The only reason we have an inspired Bible is the authority of His Catholic Church.
The inspiration of the Scriptures is not derived from the church but from God Himself Who inspires them. The church is but the instrument Christ used to help the church discover what books were inspired-inerrant.
If you deny the authority of His Catholic Church you have NO guarantee that the Bible is truly the inspired Word of God.
Not so. Take the OT. These books were already considered Scripture before the church was born.
Think about it. If the Church had not been led by the Holy spirit to all truth, how can you know the Bible is the Word of God?
How did the church determine which books were inspired and which were not?
You can’t. Fortunately we know the promise of Jesus to the leadership of His Church is true, therefore the inerrancy of Scripture is assured. Scary thought isn’t it? You need to acknowledge the Catholic Church had such authority or you have no Bible!
We already the OT was inspired-inerrant before the church was born. Secondly the church itself does not make the Scriptures themselves inerrant or inspired. It is the Spirit of God that does. It is true that Christ did use the church to determine what the canon of the NT would be by a process that the church used.
 
guanophore;4092149]
Originally Posted by justasking4
It is true that we have no record of Jesus writing anything except on the ground. However He did use His apostles and others to write down what He did and what others said about Him in the NT. That’s what inspiration is about.
guanophore
It is very Catholic of you to say this. What is anti-Catholic is your attitude that these Sacred Teachings, inspired by God, somehow disappeared after they were written. It is as if you think they were no longer written on the hearts of the faithful.
Are you claiming that the “Sacred Teachings” (whatever they are) are inspired by God?

If these “Sacred Teachings” have disappeared then how do you and others know what they are?
 
Are you claiming that the “Sacred Teachings” (whatever they are) are inspired by God?
Sacred Tradition comes from God. It is one component of the entire divine revelation given by God to humanity.
If these “Sacred Teachings” have disappeared then how do you and others know what they are?
Sacred Tradition has not disappeared. It continues to be preserved by the Church with divine protection and thus without error.
 
Sacred Tradition comes from God. It is one component of the entire divine revelation given by God to humanity.

Sacred Tradition has not disappeared. It continues to be preserved by the Church with divine protection and thus without error.
What exactly is it? There must be some kind of list of them so that catholics can know what a Sacred Tradtion is and what is not.

For example; do you know how many Sacred Traditions there are?
 
What exactly is it? There must be some kind of list of them so that catholics can know what a Sacred Tradtion is and what is not.

For example; do you know how many Sacred Traditions there are?
Your question serves no purpose. What matters is the entire deposit of faith, not how much of that deposit is found to what degrees in scripture vs. sacred tradition. That’s like asking how much English literature is contained the first 13 letters of the alphabet. :eek:

Let me ask you, what is taught in the bible? Give me a list of all the teachings found in the bible. How many teachings are in the bible?

Now if you want to know what is contained in the entire deposit of faith, the Catechism is the place to start.
 
Are you saying that Sacred Tradition is oral and not written?
Sacred Tradition comprises the world view of the Apostles, and a manner of living (lifestyle). There is very little of it that has not been written about in some way. And, since the entire NT is produced from Sacred Tradition, it would be hard to say that it is “not written”. 😃
He didn’t. However, since the resurrection took place on a Sunday that day became the primary day of worship. We have no record of any church leader declaring Sunday as day of worship.
This is because you have discounted some of the records. 🤷 There were many factors that were taken into account when the Church exercised the authority of binding and loosing to change the day of observing the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday. It was Jesus who gave this authority to the Church. Does He not seem like a “leader” to you?
Huh? What do you mean by Sacred Tradition in this context?
The paradosis, that which was handed down from the Apostles. It is the message that was entrusted to faithful men, who could teach others also.
It is a problem if its not in Scripture. That would mean its not a teaching of the apostles. You can defer to church leadership but that still does not mean its true.
This is only a problem for those who have embraced the error of Sola Scriptura. Those that have not fallen (or been led) into this error recognize that the Bible does not teach Sola Scriptura, and in fact, teaches the opposite. The Scriptures don’t claim to include all of the apostolic teaching. This was never their purpose.
It may be important for catholics but the issue of it being true is another matter. If something is to be authentic it must have facts to support it. It is not enough for some church authority to claim something is true and that is enough.
I agree with you. What is important to Catholics is that Jesus is the founder of our faith, not the Bible. Therefore, we are not limited to the Bible for the facts. 👍
I am aware that He did teach that in matters of church discipline it is to be brought before the church. Matters of doctrine though must be grounded in the Scriptures if they are to be apostolic.
The passage says nothing about “matters of church discipline”. It says “when your brother harms you”. More sins have been committed by errors in doctrine than any matter of church discipline!

Actually, in terms of being grounded in scripture, this is an artificial imposition, since you are not able to see a great many things that are grounded in scripture due to the anti-Catholic blinders.
If this is true why did the apostles and those associated with write the NT? Did they on their own determine to write these things down or was the Spirit of Christ also working in them to write these things down for the church?
We believe that God led them to commit things to writing. But that does not negate or erase the Source from which it came.
In other words did the Spirit of Jesus have something to do with the NT being written down?
Just as much as the Spirit of Jesus has preserved His teaching without error, both before, during, and after the writing. 👍
I’m still trying to understand what this Sacred Tradition is and what exactly it is. It appears that Scripture and Sacred Tradition are 2 different things. This is why i need to see some kind of list of what it is.
I think it would be better if you focused on the basics first, ja4. It is not possible to understand certain things without a firm foundation.

Besides, I don’ t think this is an accurate representation of yourself. You have already made it clear that you believe the Sacred Tradition is nothing but speculations of men, based in the false teaching of false teachers that have come into the Church to deceive. 🤷
No joke. Can you show me a list from the Catholic church what these Traditions are?
You have been given many lists. I refer you back to them. The content has not changed. If you did not save any, just search “justasking4 and Sacred Tradition”. You will find the efforts of dozens of members, and hundreds of postings trying to enlighten you about Sacred Tradition. In the end, we always ended up in the same place:
"justasking4:
The church has always had the bible, but chose to introduce the traditions of men instead
🤷
I agree with this. What He led them to evenually became written down and we call it the NT.
Do you believe there is further “revelation” beyond the NT?
The NT itself states that everything is not included. It also does NOT state that it is to be an authority over everything. THis is a responsibility Jesus gave to the Church, because the Bible does not have a will, and the power to make decisions the way people do.

The fullness of revelation came through Christ, and since He is God, it is impossible to contain the fullness of His revelation to the text.
There may be one truth but people have differing interpretations and understandings of it. Even the apostles had differing understandings. Take the issue of faith and salvation. James as you may know gives one perspective of it while Paul approaches the issue from a different perspective.
But the same Truth, and all in unity. This is why no teaching is based on any one person’s perspective, but on the revelation of God.
The problem is that its not really like this. Jesus never promised that the church could not err.
Well, we read it differently. 😃
He and others warned that false teachers would bring false teachings into the church and decieve many. Secondly, if you look at Catholic teaching on some issues like salvation you will find contradictory teachings.
Its ok, ja4, we know you are here, and we are watching you! :knight2:
 
Just to throw another monkey wrench into the discussion, Benedict XVI in a book that records his teachings on “Jesus, The Apostles, and the Early Church” (available from Amazon) makes the point that Sacred Tradition is not a dead and completed work of Jesus and the Apostles, but is the working of the living presence of Jesus and the Holy Spirit, both of which were promised to be with the Church, the Church being the Catholic Church, until the end of time.

The presence of Jesus and the Holy Spirit results in a continuing “unpacking” of the Old and New Testaments as well as other things which Jesus taught the Apostles, which were recorded and commented on by the Early Church Fathers in their writing. So while we hold that divine revelation stopped with the death of the last apostle, with the assistance of Jesus and the Holy Spirit, the Pope and Bishops in union with him continue to authoratively bring us new and expanded understandings of that revelation.
In a manner of speaking the Church continues to mine that “mother lode” of material.

Someone in an earlier post made the comment that in Revelation some churches were reproved for making mistakes. Those churches were geographic parts of, but not the whole Church which is constituted of the whole Church militant led by the Pope and Bishops. When catholics talk about “the Church” we are not speaking of an individual diocese or parish, but the whole organization. Individual diocese and parishes can, on their own, go astray for a time.

I hope this does not cause even more confusion . 🙂
 
Ouch! reading through this thread now, with it’s lengthy opting of quotes and answers, re-quotes and retorts … for me it is like to trying to read through bathroom scrawl written on reams of toilet paper. Don’t get me wrong, they are informative and illuminating - and my statement here is not about it’s content or commentary, but on how it “looks” to me in a humorous way. 😉

Thank you rwoehmke and beans - I am following the works and words of Benedict XVI just as closely as I followed (and still read) the works of John Paul II. Pope John Paul II, his life and work, has been a monumental influence in my life and a very LARGE reason I am on the journey I now find myself. Also, my personal library has a number of works from the early church fathers and I am well aware of what the Bible says about tradition in both the Old and New Testaments - but always I appreciate the reminders and guidance to that effect. 🙂

Someday I hope to see the Church use and read the Bible more, as many Church leaders have wanted since Gregory XVI, and protestant churches to accept Tradition and use it in their daily lives. The implications here are far reaching and would do much to heal the rift between Christians all over the world. That is my prayer and hope.

Respectfully,
Thom
 
Someday I hope to see the Church use and read the Bible more…
Thom, are you aware that there is far more scripture in the Catholic Mass than in most Protestant worship services? Not just in the readings, but in the prayers themselves. A number of converts to Catholicism have pointed out how surprised they were to discover this.
 
Thom, are you aware that there is far more scripture in the Catholic Mass than in most Protestant worship services? Not just in the readings, but in the prayers themselves. A number of converts to Catholicism have pointed out how surprised they were to discover this.
Mike, in my experience here in my community, that is not the case. Experiences vary from individual to individual, community to community, culture to culture. However, I understand your emphasis. The protestant church in which I was a member (still am actually) at one time was heavily Bible oriented and with almost every aspect of the service using scripture, within our prayers, songs, readings and responses. It called itself a “Bible Church” and it lived up to it’s name. The parish here only follows the missal which does have it’s Scripture as well obviously. Where our parish shines is in the pastors homilies which are outstanding! But yes there have been a few in my experience that rarely cracked the Bible open, much less use in the service, usually only within the minister’s message. Nice thing about the Catholic Church is you know exactly what scripture is being used as well as when and how. (It did take me some time to figure out how to use the missal though. :o )

Besides, it is not volume, it is content and purpose that counts. 🙂

Respectfully,
Thom
 
I am going to have to rest now, but those Papal references and my own were not actually addressed to the Church’s service, the liturgy itself, but rather to the Church community, as least as I understood it and as I meant it.

I will in a future post recant a story of a debate between lay people from 5 different congregations in our community: Baptist, Lutheran, Catholic, Unitarian and LDS. I think you can guess who sponsored it. It turned out to be a three hour long session on who knew their Bible best. Hint it wasn’t the LDS church. :hmmm:

Respectfully,
Thom
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top