Habitual sin is NOT mortal!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert_Scott_Co
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it’s much safer in most cases to look at it as grave mortal sin and perhaps in a few cases it’s disorder that cannot be controlled. I think it’s much worse if a married man (or woman) is habitually doing this because they are depriving their spouse of intimacy and jepordizing their spiritual life with God when most of the time they could be intimate with their spouse. In most cases of habitual masturbation there is more than likely fantasy of other woman or men or poronography involved fueling the fire.

Bring everything to light with your priest, every root pull out and rid yourself of everything that is feuling the problem, drastically deal with and find a good friend to hold you acccountable, I think a spiritual advisor is very beneficial.

St. Faustina was told by Jesus when temptation comes cry out for Mary and make the sign of the cross, DO NOT FIGHT IT YOURSELF because that is what the devil wants and we will almost always lose. Mary also attached gifts of purity to those who would sincerely pray the rosary daily, it was one of her 15 promises. *This is the hardest and most horrible battle for men because of the way we are wired and the way that folks in society dress and this battle will be intense until the end. *

One more thing to consider is what you eat and drink. Cafffiene for instance is a stimulant, if you are addicted to masturbation, cut out caffeine and lots of acidic foods. Drink more fresh water, fresh fruits and veggies, cut way back on carbs and up your akeline based foods. Too much adic in your body causes inflamation, pain, headaches and often times masturbation can be a way of dealing with pain or not feeling well. Anyhow, that my two cents.

Oh and of course exercise, get out that pent up energy and the O2 and endorphines flowing as well:)
 
Considering that priests are not suppose to speak about what they hear in confession, I’m guessing that there was no poll to back up the statement. But I’m willing to guess that its true.
 
I key thing to remember is, that even if a person has a sinful habit the reduces culpability in many cases, this does not automatically apply in all cases. It is possible for a person to have a very strong habit, and yet at times still have sufficient free will to be culpable in that particular instance.

Also, a habit involving a grave act does not necessarily begin as mortal sin. It could well be that by the time in life the individual recognized the nature of what they were doing, they had already developed a habit. It is also quite likely they may have been deceived (or at least self-deceived) with the aid of the culture and peers.

If one combines a degenerate secular culture, bad peer pressure, hormones, poor catechism instruction, lax moral teaching, and natural temptation it is quite possible a grave habit could be formed in such a way that it may not have ever been subjectively a mortal sin in the original instances.

These statements are derived from a combination of what I have learned from my studies, my personal experiences, and what I have learned from others.
 
Michael Howard:
I think it’s much worse if a married man (or woman) is habitually doing this because they are depriving their spouse of intimacy and jepordizing their spiritual life with God when most of the time they could be intimate with their spouse.
I read one case file years ago of a man who handled he and his wifes sexual problem of their unequal libidos by mastubating once during the week. By the time the weekend had arrived and she returned home from a distant job during the week, his level was at a manageable level for both to be satisfied. To her the problem seemed to fix itself and he never told her.

I have also heard that it can be a safety valve for those who are a sexual danger to society. Here an example of choosing a lessor evil.

AndyF
 
Michael Howard:

I read one case file years ago of a man who handled he and his wifes sexual problem of their unequal libidos by mastubating once during the week. By the time the weekend had arrived and she returned home from a distant job during the week, his level was at a manageable level for both to be satisfied. To her the problem seemed to fix itself and he never told her.

I have also heard that it can be a safety valve for those who are a sexual danger to society. Here an example of choosing a lessor evil.

AndyF
Uh-uh. No sir. It’s not an option for a Christian to choose a lesser evil. God never puts us in a position where we* must *choose one evil or another.

It’s the devil that sometimes tries to convince us that this is the case. We must trust in God, and must always search for the way to choose a path that involves no evil. Even if it’s inconvenient to ourselves.
 
Considering that priests are not suppose to speak about what they hear in confession, I’m guessing that there was no poll to back up the statement. But I’m willing to guess that its true.
I’ll retract my statement about it being #1 because I can’t find the article where I thought I read it. It’s been awhile and my memory is a bit fuzzy so you are all welcome to speculate. The context was a single priest talking about his particular experiences in the confessional and what sins were prevalent and I believe he was speaking of MB in particular. This isn’t breaking confidentiality because he’s not speaking of any single person. I think the statistic might have been prevalence of pornography and MB among adult catholic men. Perhaps he didn’t say that confession of masturbation was #1 or maybe it was for single teenagers, I can’t recall. In either case, I don’t really see how it’s extremely relevant. Surely we would all agree that this would be one of the most prevalent “sins” among catholic men that they would struggle with during their lifetime, no? In which case, it’s certainly going to be on the top 10 list of sins being regularly confessed.

The point is that it’s a common sin among men and moralist theologians approach a slippery slope when attempting to classify all acts of masturbation as a “mortal sin” which is why we have terms of “reduced culpability” nowadays when discussing the subject.
 
Keikiolu;2118599:
but the simple fact is that “habit” is not a sufficient excuse to demote acts of mortal sin into lesser sin.

QUOTE]

agree that habits should be worked on…however, what you say here goes against the catechism.
Hmmm… how’s that?

Would (could) “habitual murder” be a non-mortal sin?

Actually, if the person WITH the habit really CAN’T help themself, and those around them DON’T constrain them such that the “addict” can’t exercise that habit, then those people are commiting a sin of the same quality as the addict, which makes the addict “scandalous”, which would be another sin for the addict, and well as for the “potential constrainers”.

I agree,… The question is one of the amount of “free will” of the addict, but I contend that it’s extraordinarily rare for people to be stripped of “that much” free will.

But that’s the difference between a “Christian” and everyone else. You don’t have to be worried about your “accumulated” sins, and can’t use them as an excuse to commit further sins, because you can get rid of all of them at once, regardless of the quantity.

Mahalo ke Akua…!
E pili mau na pomaikai ia oe. Aloha nui.
 
agapewolf;2118617:
Hmmm… how’s that?

Would (could) “habitual murder” be a non-mortal sin?

Actually, if the person WITH the habit really CAN’T help themself, and those around them DON’T constrain them such that the “addict” can’t exercise that habit, then those people are commiting a sin of the same quality as the addict, which makes the addict “scandalous”, which would be another sin for the addict, and well as for the “potential constrainers”.

I agree,… The question is one of the amount of “free will” of the addict, but I contend that it’s extraordinarily rare for people to be stripped of “that much” free will.

But that’s the difference between a “Christian” and everyone else. You don’t have to be worried about your “accumulated” sins, and can’t use them as an excuse to commit further sins, because you can get rid of all of them at once, regardless of the quantity.

Mahalo ke Akua…!
E pili mau na pomaikai ia oe. Aloha nui.
How is it against the catechism? Read the catechism quote above. (I didn’t quote it here, someone else did. We are not talking about murder, we are talking about the issue of masturbation, and accountability in regards to habit. Pleaes read the quote, then re-read your statement. That is why I said what you said went against the catechism.
 
*Catechism:
2352 By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. “Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action.” “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of “the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved.”

To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. (CCC) *

and YOU SAID:
but the simple fact is that “habit” is not a sufficient excuse to demote acts of mortal sin into lesser sin.

QUOTE]
 
Catechism:

*2352 By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. “Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action.” “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of “the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved.” *

To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. (CCC)

and YOU SAID:
Keikiolu;2118599:
but the simple fact is that “habit” is not a sufficient excuse to demote acts of mortal sin into lesser sin.
"…one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. (CCC)"
“To reduce to a minimum” does not equal “remove”.

What is a “teeny tiny little bit of mortal sin”?

Is it rather like a “teeny tiny little bit pregnant”?

In my opinion ANY mortal sin is mortal sin, which stains as mortal sin, which shows up as mortal sin.

…and since it’s so ludicrously easy to get rid of mortal sin, what possible excuse is there to “minimize” one’s culpability, other than to assuage the “guilt” of someone who refuses to do what is necessary to PREVENT the “habitual” sinner (addict) from mortally sinning?

For the “helper” to assuage their guilt by allowing the addict to THINK that their sin is “minimized” is in fact mortally sinning himself by scandalization.

So the answer is,… every Christian involved needs to find a way to have the addict NOT DO their mortal sin.

If that’s not possible,… then the sinner is doomed to hell, for the period of time that they can stand being in mortal sin, or die.

Harsh?

Not really. Because mortal sin is supposed to be a “pressure” that motivates one to correct a disordered condition, and is never a “final sentence” until death occurs.

So quit trying to “spare the feelings” of those who should MOST feel the pressure…!

Of course,… if being “mean” pushes the sinner into despair, then you’ve made a boo-boo,… and should get a little better at the “pastoral” thing before experimenting on anyone else.

Mahalo ke Akua…!
E pili mau na pomaikai ia oe. Aloha nui.
 
I was simply making a point against your point. You asked how it went against the catechism, and clearly it did.

The catechism states very clearly, its possible that culpability is lessened.

You argue that it can’t be lessened.

I am in no way making excuses for a person to not feel guilty, or to continue bad habits. This is a completley seperate arguement.

I am with the catechism on this one.
 
I was simply making a point against your point. You asked how it went against the catechism, and clearly it did.

The catechism states very clearly, its possible that culpability is lessened.

You argue that it can’t be lessened.

I am in no way making excuses for a person to not feel guilty, or to continue bad habits. This is a completley seperate arguement.

I am with the catechism on this one.
Oooo… you win then…! If winning is not answering the question such that the question seems to be answered.

You haven’t answered the question of whether “lessening” a mortal sin is “eliminating” it?

You’re answer almost HAS to be, No.

If a mortal sin is not eliminated, what is it’s practical effect?

It’s practical effect is that it needs to be removed, and nothing else.

To lessen a mortal sinner’s culpability simply shifts some measure of the responsibility onto the “noticer of the lessening” (the witness who decides that the sinner is less than fully culpable).

…in other words, now TWO people are “somewhat” culpable of mortal sin!

Like a bad stain, we should use the right “product” in the right “place” in the right “way” to keep the stain from just spreading around the garment.

Don’t get into that nasty habit of taking “verses” out of context, be they in scripture or elsewhere.

Mahalo ke Akua…!
E pili mau na pomaikai ia oe. Aloha nui.
 
Don’t get into that nasty habit of taking “verses” out of context, be they in scripture or elsewhere.
Interesting you should say that. I believe the words chosen by the writers of the Catechism were carefully selected.

The Catechism specifically calls them:
… factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability.
Not, as you imply:
… factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum a mortal sin.
You seem to be perpetrating the same argument you warn against.

Moral culpability of a sin helps determine whether or not it is a mortal or venial sin. It is a sin to kill another human being. Are there not circumstances where it is less of a sin? Certainly. And the CCC tells us so CCC 2263-2265]… as it does here in this section specifically dealing with the sin of masterbation.

All this being said someone other than the sinners ourselves needs to examine the act, and it’s circumstances, to determine the extent of the sin. The best qualified for that is your parish priest.
 
Ok… That is not my thought. It was the thought of a priest that my friend went to confession with. He stated that because it was a habitual sin… the culpability was not present, so he said it was not mortal. This sin was masturbation? So… to a young male that would be easy for him to hear. Hey don’t worry is’t not mortal… you can’t control your self. Is there any truth to this?

Dang self theorists! I’m ok your ok! No it’s not ok!
 
The Catechism specifically calls them:

Quote:
… factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability.
Not, as you imply:

Quote:
… factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum a mortal sin.
You seem to be perpetrating the same argument you warn against.

Moral culpability of a sin helps determine whether or not it is a mortal or venial sin. It is a sin to kill another human being. Are there not circumstances where it is less of a sin? Certainly. And the CCC tells us so CCC 2263-2265]… as it does here in this section specifically dealing with the sin of masterbation.

All this being said someone other than the sinners ourselves needs to examine the act, and it’s circumstances, to determine the extent of the sin. The best qualified for that is your parish priest.
CCC:

1859 Mortal sin requires full knowledge and complete consent. It presupposes knowledge of the sinful character of the act, of its opposition to God’s law. It also implies a consent sufficiently deliberate to be a personal choice. Feigned ignorance and hardness of heart do not diminish, but rather increase, the voluntary character of a sin.If the sinner doesn’t have “complete consent”, then we’re not talking about “mortal sin” at all.

If there is NO WAY that a particular sin can be anything BUT a mortal sin, then “complete consent” is not a factor.

So,… is masterbation ALWAYS a mortal sin, or not?

If it’s not, then if the sinner hasn’t “completely consented”, and we’re not talking about commiting a mortal sin, so we don’t have to worry about the effects of mortal sin on the situation.

If it IS (always a mortal sin), then “complete consent” is not part of the “equation”.

Which is it?

EDITED IN SLIGHTLY LATER:

CCC:

**2352 **By *masturbation *is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. “Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action.” “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of “the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved.”

To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability.

It’s seems it’s NOT always mortal,… therefore, it’s most likely NOT mortal, unless it is due to the “culpability” of the sinner.

But, if it WERE mortal, for whatever reason,… it wouldn’t be “diminishable” to the point of less that being mortal, and would always be “absolvable” only as every other mortal sin is.

So we agree.

…I love 'ya, dude…!! 🙂

Mahalo ke Akua…!
E pili mau na pomaikai ia oe. Aloha nui.
 
Put it in this context:

Would masturbation be more likely to be mortal in the 13th century or the 21st century? Considering that the typical American male in the 21st century could be earnestly trying to break a habit that the Sodom and Gomorrah like society encourages, I would say it’s more likely to be venial. Did a male in the 13th century have so much noise? I don’t think so. You have to take the times we live in into context. I HOPE.
 
Keikiolu seems to be saying that any addiction is easy to fix. Are you saying this?

Maybe you’ve never met an addict before. Addicts are generally very very sensitive individuals who are racked with pain over their addictions. They feel guilty. They feel worthless. Many times they are not rational. They may fail a thousand times before they finally are able to get their addiction under control. And even then, nobody EVER speaks of being “cured” of an addiction. They speak of being clean for however many days they are clean, but they know that in the blink of an eye they could be right back into it.

I really don’t think you know what addiction is, Keikiolu. Even though Catholic addicts know that their addictions are sins, that does not give them more strength to control it. And if you know anything about the families of addicts, you know that little they do can have any influence on the addict, either.

Alanon is extremely helpful to families of addicts, but many many people who go to Alanon never see any change in the addict’s behavior at all. They go to Alanon to help themselves, not the addict.

There is no simple answer to rid people of habits with which they are painfully struggling. Whether or not you believe masturbation can be an addiction, you must not be callous toward people who are struggling with something. We don’t know the interior sufferings of other people; we only know about our own, and we should never presume something is “easy to fix” if the person only tries hard enough.

This, of course, is why the Catechism entry on masturbation reads as it does.

Peace,
Meeshy
 
The reason why I am skeptical of this ever being a mortal sin is who in their right mind would trade the unspeakable glory of heaven and theosis for a few minutes of relatively paltry pleasure? Only those who are unsure as to whether it is mortal sin I would imagine. Anyone who was certain it was a mortal sin would avoid it like the plague as much as they would avoid sleeping with a prostitute with AIDS no matter HOW attractive she may be.
 
This article by Fr. John Harvey gives an exhaustive treatment of the whole issue of masturbation. One of his very interesting points is the difference between habitual and compulsive sin. I commend the article to all.

Betsy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top