We have six Masses over the weekend. We have torchbearers at two of them.
In the Tridentine Rite, Mass was a procession. The priest stood at the altar at the head of the queue with the deacon and subdeacon one step behind, followed by the MC and the altar servers in various degrees of importance inside the locked gate of the altar rails. Then followed the congregation led by a line of torchbearers - presumably to keep the great unwashed away from the clergy. The EF keeps this arrangement and I can see a point to having torchbearers ahead of the congregation.
The modern rite is a gathering around God’s altar. The role of torchbearers is confused. With no altar rails between the congregation and sanctuary what is the function of torchbearers? (they don’t even have an altar rail to lean on like we had in the 1950s). If we are going to have them, I think they should be at the back of the sanctuary facing the altar.
My fellow MCs who have torchbearers at their Masses say that it gives the kids something to do. It certainly gives them an opportunity to faint and fall over. I’m not given to military drill during Mass and we don’t have torches when I’m MC.