Have you read all of Saint Augustine's "The City of God?"

  • Thread starter Thread starter thephilosopher6
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

thephilosopher6

Guest
Sorry if I placed this in the wrong area. 😊

There are 22 books in all, of which I have read 7. Have you read every book in The City of God?
 
Yes. I’m plugging my way thru all 37 volumes of the Early Church Fathers on my Kindle, and I did the volume that has City of God late last year.
 
I rarely read any book straight through. But yet I come across it very often in my time with spiritual reading. Moreover, Pope Leo XIII particular recommends study of ā€œThe City of Godā€ numerous times in his encyclicals.
 
I couldn’t get past the first page, honestly. It’s great writing, to be sure, but too packed with vocabulary that I didn’t understand.
 
I couldn’t get past the first page, honestly. It’s great writing, to be sure, but too packed with vocabulary that I didn’t understand.
Yeah, having been thru the whole thing, along with a lot of his other writings, my take is that he seriously needed an editor.
 
Yes. I’m plugging my way thru all 37 volumes of the Early Church Fathers on my Kindle, and I did the volume that has City of God late last year.
Wow! That’s a lot of reading!
 
Wow! That’s a lot of reading!
I go thru a volume every quarter (three months). I divide the material into 90 segments by Kindle ā€œlocation,ā€ and read every evening while I’m waiting for my night-time meds to kick in. It amounts to about 20 minutes a day, with text-to-speech set on fast.
 
I go thru a volume every quarter (three months). I divide the material into 90 segments by Kindle ā€œlocation,ā€ and read every evening while I’m waiting for my night-time meds to kick in. It amounts to about 20 minutes a day, with text-to-speech set on fast.
That’s awesome. BTW the Church Fathers wrote a lot more than 37 volumes. That’s just a popular edition of some of their most important works, translated in the 1800s. It’s good though, I’m not trying to discourage you, just clarify because I’ve seen some people assert that All of the Church Fathers’ writings can be read in that 37 volume set, and that’s far from accurate. Good job though! (This is actually supposed to be a positive remark, not a negative one.)
 
That’s awesome. BTW the Church Fathers wrote a lot more than 37 volumes. That’s just a popular edition of some of their most important works, translated in the 1800s. It’s good though, I’m not trying to discourage you, just clarify because I’ve seen some people assert that All of the Church Fathers’ writings can be read in that 37 volume set, and that’s far from accurate. Good job though! (This is actually supposed to be a positive remark, not a negative one.)
You are correct; the 37 volumes is only part of the total body of literature. I’d like to read them all, but 1) I don’t have enough time left in my life, and 2) my knowledge of Greek and Latin is nowhere near good enough.
 
I picked it up and started with the foreword. The foreword said that anyone who was reading ā€œThe City of Godā€ needed to start with the ā€œConfessionsā€ first.
I put it down.
Sigh.
 
I picked it up and started with the foreword. The foreword said that anyone who was reading ā€œThe City of Godā€ needed to start with the ā€œConfessionsā€ first.
I put it down.
Sigh.
I don’t think it’s absolutely necessary to read Confessions first. You could still proceed to read it. I guess you could say that it helps to read Confessions though.
 
I don’t think it’s absolutely necessary to read Confessions first. You could still proceed to read it. I guess you could say that it helps to read Confessions though.
It probably does. Besides, the Confessions, being more personal, are easier to read (and help explain where some of his theological ideas - most notably on sex - come from).
 
It probably does. Besides, the Confessions, being more personal, are easier to read (and help explain where some of his theological ideas - most notably on sex - come from).
Indeed. It’s not an absolute but it helps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top