T
Thal59
Guest
SpringBreeze, Gratias Grace,
I understand your point of view, but I still hold to what I have said. It is ,of course, my opinion and my prerogative. However, while I understand your separate points of view, I cannot help but feel that both of you are defining what it means to be “called” by God in too broad a sense. The examples you have given seem to be too all encompassing. Everything from a spiritual enlightenment from God to the most transitory casual thought in a man’s mind seems to qualify as a potential calling.
While we are all intended to be the children of God, we are not all called to the priesthood, which is what Christus Rex is concerned with.
Being called to the priesthood is no small matter; nor can it be compared to an individual being called to be a child of God. If the individual fails, he perils his soul. If the priest fails, he may endanger the souls of many. Also, the failure of a priest has greater ramifications than does the failure of the parishoner.
I have an uncle who is a retired Carmelite priest. He once told me that when he sins, he wil be punished for it twice as severely than someone who is not a priest because his sins also constitute sacrilege. Therefore, I cannot see a true calling to the priesthood as being something either casual on God’s part, or so shallow that the one being called would struggle with discerning whether or not he is being called at all.
One may resist accepting the call, out of fear or weak faith, but one would certainly know the call was given. But the theme of this thread is not… “God is calling me to be a priest, should I accept?” It is, rather, is God calling me at all?
Once again I offer that if one needs to converse with others about this, it is not a true calling. If it is a true calling, Christus Rex will answer it without our personal opinions, no matter how positive, or how suspicious they are.
Thal59
I understand your point of view, but I still hold to what I have said. It is ,of course, my opinion and my prerogative. However, while I understand your separate points of view, I cannot help but feel that both of you are defining what it means to be “called” by God in too broad a sense. The examples you have given seem to be too all encompassing. Everything from a spiritual enlightenment from God to the most transitory casual thought in a man’s mind seems to qualify as a potential calling.
While we are all intended to be the children of God, we are not all called to the priesthood, which is what Christus Rex is concerned with.
Being called to the priesthood is no small matter; nor can it be compared to an individual being called to be a child of God. If the individual fails, he perils his soul. If the priest fails, he may endanger the souls of many. Also, the failure of a priest has greater ramifications than does the failure of the parishoner.
I have an uncle who is a retired Carmelite priest. He once told me that when he sins, he wil be punished for it twice as severely than someone who is not a priest because his sins also constitute sacrilege. Therefore, I cannot see a true calling to the priesthood as being something either casual on God’s part, or so shallow that the one being called would struggle with discerning whether or not he is being called at all.
One may resist accepting the call, out of fear or weak faith, but one would certainly know the call was given. But the theme of this thread is not… “God is calling me to be a priest, should I accept?” It is, rather, is God calling me at all?
Once again I offer that if one needs to converse with others about this, it is not a true calling. If it is a true calling, Christus Rex will answer it without our personal opinions, no matter how positive, or how suspicious they are.
Thal59
