Help! faith in Fatima shaking!

  • Thread starter Thread starter fireproofpoodle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

fireproofpoodle

Guest
Hi.

I have always believed in the Fatima appiritions and considered the sun miracle miraculous. But some facts have troubled me about this recently. Not wishing to slur the characters of almost undoubtedly saintly visionaries, their mother did think that they were lying, and the first two secrets, inc. the WWII prophesy, was written down in 1941. Another issue is the difference in the descriptions of the miracle of the sun, and that it can be somewhat explained by a lot of people staring at the sun for a long time until eventually it looks to them like it’s moving.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Miracle_of_the_Sun

Any thoughts? The church has recognised this appirition, so there must be a sollution.

God bless.
 
Do not ever use wickapedia for information. It is extremelly anti Catholic tsay the least.
 
Well, I would dig into the record and see what people who say the miricle thought. This miricle converted a multitude, including many who went specifically to be “disappointed” by a non-miricle. I wouldn’t let a secularists attempts to rationalize every miricle under the sun (including of the sun) shake your faith.

I remember watching once on history some “scientist” claimed that the red sea just periodically naturally parts due to strong wind :rolleyes:

Then when that became passe, it switched to the israelites crossed the reed sea :rolleyes:
 
Do not ever use wickapedia for information. It is extremelly anti Catholic tsay the least.
It is true, though, that Lucia’s 4th memoir, which contained the secrets,was published in the 40s. Of course, I wouldn’t insinuate any wrongdoing on her part, and I suppose the children’s extreme devoutness renders them relaible witnesses. Thanks for the tip, btw.
 
Well, I would dig into the record and see what people who say the miricle thought. This miricle converted a multitude, including many who went specifically to be “disappointed” by a non-miricle. I wouldn’t let a secularists attempts to rationalize every miricle under the sun (including of the sun) shake your faith.

I remember watching once on history some “scientist” claimed that the red sea just periodically naturally parts due to strong wind :rolleyes:

Then when that became passe, it switched to the israelites crossed the reed sea :rolleyes:
Yes, the exodus is another thing I am having trouble with, even though I know it happenned, I find it hard tobelieve. I think I may be having several crises of faith about major religious events - brothers and sisters, please pray for me!
 
*Help! faith in Fatima shaking! *

So? Doesn’t affect you as a Catholic. Believe it or not. Doesn’t matter. “Approved” is not “required”.
 
Why should these questions and doubts about this or that shake your faith in Christ? Fear not he is with you. I for one think it’s okay to have doubts, questions, and even disagreements. Our Faith is alive!! Take heart, pray and let the holy Spirit speak to you.
 
Yes, the exodus is another thing I am having trouble with, even though I know it happenned, I find it hard tobelieve. I think I may be having several crises of faith about major religious events - brothers and sisters, please pray for me!
How is it you find it so hard to believe that the creator of the entire known universe could part the red sea if he wanted to?

Edit
I guess more usefully, why is it you’re having issues with the parting of the red sea? At that point we’ve already seen a host of miricles performed by moses including turning the nile to blood. Oh yes, I’m well aware of all the so called “natural” explanations for all this… But how do you explain all these pleges happening at the same time? More over the so called natural explanations don’t even make sense… A fog of noxious gas just happend to kill every single first born of egypt? Not missing even a single one? And just happend to not kill a single person who wasn’t a first born son of egypt? Really?

There’s being rational, then there’s being a rationalist.
 
If God can turn water into wine, bread into His Body, raise Lazarus from the dead, raise Himself from the dead, and calm a sea storm, could He not also part the sea for His Children, make the Sun spin and dance in the sky, give the waters of Lourdes miraculous properties?
 
How is it you find it so hard to believe that the creator of the entire known universe could part the red sea if he wanted to?

Edit
I guess more usefully, why is it you’re having issues with the parting of the red sea? At that point we’ve already seen a host of miricles performed by moses including turning the nile to blood. Oh yes, I’m well aware of all the so called “natural” explanations for all this… But how do you explain all these pleges happening at the same time? More over the so called natural explanations don’t even make sense… A fog of noxious gas just happend to kill every single first born of egypt? Not missing even a single one? And just happend to not kill a single person who wasn’t a first born son of egypt? Really?

There’s being rational, then there’s being a rationalist.
You’re right. It is just hard sometimes to blieve these things without historical evidence, and things like Fatima, to me, count as evidence.
 
You’re right. It is just hard sometimes to blieve these things without historical evidence, and things like Fatima, to me, count as evidence.
And I know, of course, that Fatima is not defined dogma but I still foster a devotion to it and see in it vindication (if it was needed) of the whole New Testament.
 
Perhaps you need to spend some time in contemplative prayer? Ask the Lord to guide you? I just spent some time at adoration last friday (I only get to first friday of the month, ugh). It was a terrific experience.
 
… Another issue is the difference in the descriptions of the miracle of the sun, and that it can be somewhat explained by a lot of people staring at the sun for a long time until eventually it looks to them like it’s moving…
Why would 70,000 people stare at the sun for a long time?

I’d recommend you don’t stare at the sun for any amount of time; It is blinding.

Anyway, Catholics don’t have to believe in Fatima. We can use our intellect to study it and decide. It’s unfortunate for Protestants; They have to deny Fatima. For a Protestant to believe in Fatima is to turn their faith upside down.
 
Hi.

I have always believed in the Fatima appiritions and considered the sun miracle miraculous. But some facts have troubled me about this recently. Not wishing to slur the characters of almost undoubtedly saintly visionaries, their mother did think that they were lying, and the first two secrets, inc. the WWII prophesy, was written down in 1941. Another issue is the difference in the descriptions of the miracle of the sun, and that it can be somewhat explained by a lot of people staring at the sun for a long time until eventually it looks to them like it’s moving.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Miracle_of_the_Sun

Any thoughts? The church has recognised this appirition, so there must be a sollution.

God bless.
RESPONSE:

If you would like to read a current book on the topic which is not devotional but rather a well documented history and scientific study, you might like to read Fr. Stanley Jaki’s “God and the Sun at Fatima.”

Father Jaki is a Benedictine priest and has doctorates in both physics and theology. He is, I believe, a Professor Emitus in physics at Seton Hall University. He has written a number of books on scientific subjects.

The book is somewhat lengthy because he is so thorough in his interviews and investigations.

A few interesting facts. The “dancing sun” phenomena which occurred on Saturday, 17 October, occurred again the following day. It happened again two weeks later, and this time the bishop of the dioceses was among the witnesses.

The phenomena appears to be metrological and involves ice crystal distortion of the sun’s image. In the final analysis, the sun did not “fall” to the earth. It was only a local sighting.

However, the question remains. Did they children have any foreknowledge that this would happen?
 
Do not ever use wickapedia for information. It is extremelly anti Catholic tsay the least.
Wikipedia may not be the world’s most accurate source of information, but how is it “extremelly anti-Catholic”?
 
Your faith in Christ, not Fatima is what your very salvation lies in from what your catholic sources I have investigated seem to repeat over and over. No where, do I see where your faith must lie in Fatima or any other apparition- approved or not.
If you will let an appartition shake your faith, you make me wonder what it was based on as an agnostic learning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top