Help me out: Jesus the only child

  • Thread starter Thread starter LordHaveMercy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

LordHaveMercy

Guest
Okay, I am debating with some people about Jesus being an only child. They always go back to the same claims about his “brothers” and “sisters” mentioned in the gospels.

I searched through the forum but I can’t seem to find the arguments I’m looking for.

So, can anybody help me with sources or information to help show that Jesus did not have siblings?

Thanks and God bless.
 
Okay, I am debating with some people about Jesus being an only child. They always go back to the same claims about his “brothers” and “sisters” mentioned in the gospels.

I searched through the forum but I can’t seem to find the arguments I’m looking for.

So, can anybody help me with sources or information to help show that Jesus did not have siblings?

Thanks and God bless.
Its not only the gospels which seem to be under the illusion that Jesus had brothers and sisters. The first century historian Josephus seems to think so too. So maybe he did!
 
The guy you allude to, James, was a step-brother (son of Joseph) according to the earliest traditions. Ask our Orthodox posters. And James is clearly the most senior and important of the brethren - he’s mentioned first, and Peter and the others made him the bishop of Jerusalem. If James wasn’t a uterine sibling, no one else was.
 
There’s no stronger evidence that Mary had no other children than that, after Jesus’ death, that she went to live in the home of an unrelated man for the rest of her days. Had Mary had other sons they would never have allowed her to do this. Further, it would have been an awful thing for Jesus to tear his mother away from her other children, especially in such a time of need.
 
The guy you allude to, James, was a step-brother (son of Joseph) according to the earliest traditions. Ask our Orthodox posters. And James is clearly the most senior and important of the brethren - he’s mentioned first, and Peter and the others made him the bishop of Jerusalem. If James wasn’t a uterine sibling, no one else was.
**No where in the bible does it state that James was the blood brother of Jesus. If that were true, then the writer(s) would have specified that he was by “son of Joseph and brother of Jesus” and that doesn’t appear anywhere either. The gospels also do not state that James was the “son of Mary, mother of Jesus.”

But we know that James the younger’s mother was named Mary. Look at the descriptions of the women standing beneath the cross: “among whom were Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James and Joseph, and the mother of the sons of Zebedee” (Matt. 27:56); “There were also women looking on from afar, among whom were Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James the younger and of Joses, and Salome” (Mark 15:40).

Then look at what John says: “But standing by the cross of Jesus were his mother, and his mother’s sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene” (John 19:25). If we compare these parallel accounts of the scene of the crucifixion, we see that the mother of James and Joseph must be the wife of Clopas.**
 
Okay, I am debating with some people about Jesus being an only child. They always go back to the same claims about his “brothers” and “sisters” mentioned in the gospels.

I searched through the forum but I can’t seem to find the arguments I’m looking for.

So, can anybody help me with sources or information to help show that Jesus did not have siblings?

Thanks and God bless.
I think everyone knows by now that the word “brothers” used in Scripture means something other than children of the same mother. I don’t think anyone can creditably claim that Mary had any children other than Jesus.

Even the founders of Protestantism: Luther, Calvin and Zwingili all believed in the perpetual virginity of Mary.

Also have a look at this site:

scripturecatholic.com/blessed_virgin_mary.html
 
Its not only the gospels which seem to be under the illusion that Jesus had brothers and sisters. The first century historian Josephus seems to think so too. So maybe he did!
Assertions with no supporting evidence are cannot be given any credibility.
 
Its not only the gospels which seem to be under the illusion that Jesus had brothers and sisters. The first century historian Josephus seems to think so too. So maybe he did!
Where does the Jewish Historian Josephus claim this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top