Help needed on historical question

  • Thread starter Thread starter Clive_Copus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Clive_Copus

Guest
I am in the process of drafting a formal complaint about an anti-Catholic article in a UK newspaper. One of the allegations in the article is that Pope Gregory XV1 declared in 1832 that democracy was sinful, and freedom of the press “heretical”. He also decreed that any Jew who insulted Catholicism should be killed.

I need to be able to respond to this, but know nothing about it. Does anyone know anything that could assist me? If so, please let me know asap.

Thanks very much.
 
Clive Copus:
I am in the process of drafting a formal complaint about an anti-Catholic article in a UK newspaper. One of the allegations in the article is that Pope Gregory XV1 declared in 1832 that democracy was sinful, and freedom of the press “heretical”. He also decreed that any Jew who insulted Catholicism should be killed.

I need to be able to respond to this, but know nothing about it. Does anyone know anything that could assist me? If so, please let me know asap.

Thanks very much.
Not being an historian, and only reading very little about the subject, I would have to know specifically where pope Gregory XVI “declared” these things. Also the statements must be kept in context with the revolutions ongoing throughout Europe during this time period. I would venture to say his remarks were in response to the demand that a “democratic” government be elected from the laity for the governance of the Church matters. In that respect you could hardly disagree with him for denouncing this “democratic” government. Jesus did not establish a democracy. He left His Apostles, and their successors in charge, not the laity. Only my guesses, I’d be interested in what exactly the UK newspaper was referring to.
 
Tom - thanks for your response. You may well be right that it’s all been taken out of context (that would be typical!), but I need to be sure.

Cainem - thanks. It was in The Independent.
 
40.png
Tom:
Not being an historian, and only reading very little about the subject, I would have to know specifically where pope Gregory XVI “declared” these things. Also the statements must be kept in context with the revolutions ongoing throughout Europe during this time period. I would venture to say his remarks were in response to the demand that a “democratic” government be elected from the laity for the governance of the Church matters. In that respect you could hardly disagree with him for denouncing this “democratic” government. Jesus did not establish a democracy. He left His Apostles, and their successors in charge, not the laity. Only my guesses, I’d be interested in what exactly the UK newspaper was referring to.
 
You may want to do a search for “Mirari vos”. This is possibly the letter the newspaper is referring. If so it is evident in it’s first reading he is referring to the administration of the Church. Any denouncement of any government would be in context of the Church, not society.
Mirari vos
“5. We speak of the things which you see with your own eyes, which We both bemoan. Depravity exults; science is impudent; liberty, dissolute. The holiness of the sacred is despised; the majesty of divine worship is not only disapproved by evil men, but defiled and held up to ridicule. Hence sound doctrine is perverted and errors of all kinds spread boldly. The laws of the sacred, the rights, institutions, and discipline–none are safe from the audacity of those speaking evil. Our Roman See is harassed violently and the bonds of unity are daily loosened and severed. The divine authority of the Church is opposed and her rights shorn off. She is subjected to human reason and with the greatest injustice exposed to the hatred of the people and reduced to vile servitude. The obedience due bishops is denied and their rights are trampled underfoot. Furthermore, academies and schools resound with new, monstrous opinions, which openly attack the Catholic faith; this horrible and nefarious war is openly and even publicly waged. Thus, by institutions and by the example of teachers, the minds of the youth are corrupted and a tremendous blow is dealt to religion and the perversion of morals is spread. So the restraints of religion are thrown off, by which alone kingdoms stand. We see the destruction of public order, the fall of principalities, and the overturning of all legitimate power approaching. Indeed this great mass of calamities had its inception in the heretical societies and sects in which all that is sacrilegious, infamous, and blasphemous has gathered as bilge water in a ship’s hold, a congealed mass of all filth.”
7. Indeed you will accomplish this perfectly if, as the duty of your office demands, you attend to yourselves and to doctrine and meditate on these words: "the universal Church is affected by any and every novelty"5 and the admonition of Pope Agatho: "nothing of the things appointed ought to be diminished; nothing changed; nothing added; but they must be preserved both as regards expression and meaning."6 Therefore may the unity which is built upon the See of Peter as on a sure foundation stand firm. May it be for all a wall and a security,a safe port, and a treasury of countless blessings.7 To check the audacity of those who attempt to infringe upon the rights of this Holy See or to sever the union of the churches with the See of Peter, instill in your people a zealous confidence in the papacy and sincere veneration for it. As St. Cyprian wrote: “He who abandons the See of Peter on which the Church was founded, falsely believes himself to be a part of the Church.”
 
thanks clive, good luck with your complaint please let us all know how get on
 
Tom - that’s brilliant. Just what I needed. Thanks for taking the trouble to do the research.

Cainem - cheers. Will do.
 
My complaint was partly upheld and the newspaper have agreed to publish a letter from me addressing two of the main points.

Thanks to Tom and Cainem for their assistance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top