Help with parents

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheInquisitor
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TheInquisitor

Guest
I am at the moment trying to go towards becoming Catholic. Every step I have been taking is filled with prayer and I really think that God will get me to the truth eventually. However, I am currently 17 and have to field all of my findings with my parents.

My parents are protestant. They are very non judgmental and understand that many protestant churches are very messed up. They still are convinced in sola scriptura and sola fide however and don’t agree with the catholic church. Me and dad originally had some talks but after a few weeks it became fruitless. He just couldn’t see my point of view, and either I’m being stubborn or His point of view is a tad ignorant.

One thing that is different about our family than others is that we are very connected. I never really went through a hardcore rebellion stage because of my love for my family and my faith which I have always tried to stay true to. Somehow, after all of these years of me questioning, My parents and I never truly disagreed on anything. I always thought of this as a blessing. So in consequence of this, we developed a very strong friendship along with our family ties.

I hope then that you all can understand the emotional strain that has been put on my family with this whole catholic thing. Mom has cried twice, thinks I’m in a state of intentional separation from them, and has imagined that I am spitting in the face of their christian life. I am normally very in control of my own emotions but have cried once and been nauseated many times. I also think dad cried for the first time last night. It’s been a horrible emotional experience but I still feel a peace that it will work out in the end.

I have my one chance to start RCIA next week for the year and I had permission to attend since they knew it didn’t mean a for sure fire conversion. However, Dad has had a change of heart. He said that his spirit is very troubled about all of this. So he has asked that as a dad he could hold me back until I am 18 years of age before I do any of this so I could think about it for a longer amount of time. I just turned 17 so that means waiting a year.

My thoughts is that he has read a lot anti catholic things such as the accusations at Justforcatholics.org (Which he recommended). He has it in his head that the Roman Catholic Church is a mafia of sorts that will psychologically box me in forever. He thinks that I will never be able to leave from the crushing guilt that they will heap on my head.

He does try to keep an open mind but I am worried that him at least approving or not worrying just won’t happen. It COULD happen since I’m praying over it, but it’s sort of a 50/50 thing. I just don’t know what to do. I don’t think he’s gonna STOP me if I go, but I also know you’re supposed to honor your parents. Can I get some advice on the situation?

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to spill my guts out. My parents being the only advice figures in my life has created a gap in my life where I haven’t been able to counsel with anyone or bounce ideas off.

Prayers appreciated,
Ryan
 
Ryan, I suggest you talk to the priest at the parish you have been attending. He will guide you.
 
You are still a minor at 17. Why not wait a year until you are an adult and then attend? Nothing says you cannot continue to attend mass, continue to learn about the faith, etc.
 
Ryan, I suggest you talk to the priest at the parish you have been attending. He will guide you.
Well, that’s the problem. I haven’t attended a parish yet. I have called the church and they know I’m on the way to their RCIA class next week. But my dad has asked me not to go. So I won’t be able to get in contact with a priest because they will “Box me in” so to say. Which is where my question is. Do I disobey dad, get in contact with the parish, and attend the RCIA or not?

Also, same problem catholic90. I wouldn’t be able to go. Do I really respect his wishes and just wait a year?
 
Well, that’s the problem. I haven’t attended a parish yet. I have called the church and they know I’m on the way to their RCIA class next week. But my dad has asked me not to go. So I won’t be able to get in contact with a priest because they will “Box me in” so to say. Which is where my question is. Do I disobey dad, get in contact with the parish, and attend the RCIA or not?

Also, same problem catholic90. I wouldn’t be able to go. Do I really respect his wishes and just wait a year?
Well, Ryan, you are in a tough spot here. You know that your father would not physically stop you from attending RCIA, but he has told you that he does not want you to attend. So if you go to the class, you will be disobeying him, and that will cause problems between you. I think if your parents do not want to discuss this with you, you have no option but to wait until you are 18. I would advise you to sit down with your dad and tell him that you will honor his wishes, but that you want his promise that you can attend the class next year, hopefully with his blessing. That way, he can’t weasel out of telling you that you can attend.

I assume that you have not been able to attend Mass? Will they allow you to at least do that, knowing that you will not be receiving any sacraments, or is that “brainwashing” too? Funny how you describe them as being open-minded, yet not toward Catholicism.

😦

Hang in there, Ryan, and welcome home!

🙂
 
One of the things that will be expected when you start RCIA, is to stop attending your Protestant church and start attending Mass on Sundays.

It is also assumed that people starting RCIA have already been to Mass at least a few times.

Given the fact that your parents seem determined to block your progress at every step, it seems wisest to wait a year. There is no rush, really.

And your Dad is right - once you become Catholic, that’s it - there is no going back. This is, in fact, a permanent decision - you can’t change your mind later on.

I happen to consider that a good thing, of course. 🙂
 
Well, Ryan, you are in a tough spot here. You know that your father would not physically stop you from attending RCIA, but he has told you that he does not want you to attend. So if you go to the class, you will be disobeying him, and that will cause problems between you. I think if your parents do not want to discuss this with you, you have no option but to wait until you are 18. I would advise you to sit down with your dad and tell him that you will honor his wishes, but that you want his promise that you can attend the class next year, hopefully with his blessing. That way, he can’t weasel out of telling you that you can attend.

I assume that you have not been able to attend Mass? Will they allow you to at least do that, knowing that you will not be receiving any sacraments, or is that “brainwashing” too? Funny how you describe them as being open-minded, yet not toward Catholicism.

😦

Hang in there, Ryan, and welcome home!

🙂
Well, I already told him I wouldn’t attend if it is what he wants. I’ll do my best to hang in there. I’ll also be talking with him more. Thanks for the welcome 😃

Thanks for the replies guys, looks like I’ll be doing what the original plan was in my mind. That was to wait. Tough thing to do be being a teenager haha. Also, thanks for letting me vent a little bit today everyone. I’ll attempt to update if anything changes.
 
Would the priest allow you to take the RCIA classes with the understanding you cannot come into the Church until you are 18 to honor your parents? If that is not possible, I think you should wait. You have a loving relationship with your Mom and Dad. That is a treasure God wants you to keep. Know you are anxious but youth is like that. Your duty is to make it easier for them which will make it easier and less stressful for you.

In the meantime, do you have a cathecism? Maybe Mom and Dad would feel better if they started reading that. Maybe the priest could talk to them. Have they ever actually talked to a Catholic? This way a door is open so if and when Dad has questions, he could ask the priest.

Another help is EWTN especially THE JOURNEY HOME. Dad might be interested in some of the teachings of other churches and might come to the realization that there are other churches which he would never join…thus making the Catholic Church look better in comparison. Have they ever been in a Catholic Church?

Marcus Grodi also sends out a newsletter through www.chnetwork.org with the stories of other converts. Dad and Mom can subscribe to it on line and read the stories of interest to them.
 
I would do first A then B.

A) Ask your father if instead he would come to RCIA WITH you. So he too can actually learn what is taught. (this is instead of what he assumes will be taught)…

If he doesn’t go for A, Then

B) Wait until next year. Continue to read about the Catholic Church. Read what CATHOLIC’s read. So as not to confuse what we actually believe with what others THINK we believe.

No reason to make an attempt at conversion while fighting your own beloved parents every step of the way.
 
I would do first A then B.

A) Ask your father if instead he would come to RCIA WITH you. So he too can actually learn what is taught. (this is instead of what he assumes will be taught)…

If he doesn’t go for A, Then

B) Wait until next year. Continue to read about the Catholic Church. Read what CATHOLIC’s read. So as not to confuse what we actually believe with what others THINK we believe.

No reason to make an attempt at conversion while fighting your own beloved parents every step of the way.
Oooh, excellent suggestion! Unlikely that his dad would be interested or feel curious enough to do it, but it’s brave, it’s bold, and it just might work!

👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top