Hewlett-Packard support worldwide abortion

  • Thread starter Thread starter dad2seven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is not the purpose of your purchase. It is called a side-effect. Moral theology teaches us that a side-effect must be weighed as to whether it is acceptable.

The foundations that fund abortions probably don’t own more than about 20% of HP and not all of the money that they receive go towards abortion. So perhaps 2% to 5% (just a very rough guess) of the profit they would make from a purchase would go to abortion. Note that’s the profit. So if they make 25% profit on the sale of items then perhaps about 1% of the purchase price would actually go to abortion. Given 1%, if a person spent $5,000, $50 would go to abortion and perhaps would end up having a net effect of funding one abortion. Again these are just very rough-guess hypotheticals.

So, if a person’s purchase of $5000 results in funding one abortion would this be an acceptable side-effect? Well there may be even more involved. The cooperation would be somewhat remote and so the culpability may be minimal.

My reasoning on such a situation is this. A pro-life person does not want to help those who destroy life even if that is not the purpose of the purchase. So, they seek to avoid it.

I do not claim to know that someone is sinning by buying an HP. However, I would not be so sure that there is no sin involved either. We are referring to God’s children.

It’s a miserable situation we have in today’s world where you can’t just buy something and shop freely without worrying about inadvertently supporting abortion. We can pray for an end to this situation.
If we were to really stick to the ridiculous notion of sideeffect then we would have to crawl under a rock and not do any business with the world at all. Since that i simpossible I’ll just ignore the whole side effect reasoning and know that I am doing what I can to combat abortion but also doing practical business as well.
 
Hi Jim,
If we were to really stick to the ridiculous notion of sideeffect then we would have to crawl under a rock and not do any business with the world at all.
Consider the U.S. government for example. Why were Cuban imports banned? They were banned because of the side-effect of supporting a communist regime not becase of the products themselves. We don’t expect our government to crawl under a rock and you don’t have to either. So far, I haven’t seen anything like the HP issue with Gateway or Dell (for example) so it’s not as if there are no options.
If we were to really stick to the ridiculous notion of side-effect…
It’s an important part of Catholic moral theology. Suppose your neighbor had a dog that barked all the time and woke you up at night. Suppose you called them to ask them to stop the dog and they told you: “Oh the dog’s not barking to wake you up, that is just a side-effect so we’re not going to do anything about it.” What would you think of that?
we would have to…not do any business with the world at all.
Not really, it’s just a matter of selecting whom you buy from sometimes. If all Catholics did this, it would affect the world for the better and I think it would help bring God’s kingdom to this earth. In the Our Father we pray “thy kingdom come”. Jesus tells us to carry our cross. So we have a small cross of being selective.
 
Hi Jim,

Consider the U.S. government for example. Why were Cuban imports banned? They were banned because of the side-effect of supporting a communist regime not becase of the products themselves. We don’t expect our government to crawl under a rock and you don’t have to either. So far, I haven’t seen anything like the HP issue with Gateway or Dell (for example) so it’s not as if there are no options.

It’s an important part of Catholic moral theology. Suppose your neighbor had a dog that barked all the time and woke you up at night. Suppose you called them to ask them to stop the dog and they told you: “Oh the dog’s not barking to wake you up, that is just a side-effect so we’re not going to do anything about it.” What would you think of that?

Not really, it’s just a matter of selecting whom you buy from sometimes. If all Catholics did this, it would affect the world for the better and I think it would help bring God’s kingdom to this earth. In the Our Father we pray “thy kingdom come”. Jesus tells us to carry our cross. So we have a small cross of being selective.
Sorry but if I find an HP product at a better price I will buy it. No sin in sticking to a budget.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top