Historical Spanish Inquisition information?

  • Thread starter Thread starter k5thbeatle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

k5thbeatle

Guest
Hi. Where can I find a good source for historically correct information regarding the (Spanish) Inquisition? While I’m sure it was not a good thing I am skeptical that “hundreds of thousands and even millions” may have perished as a consequence of it as recently suggested to me by some anti-catholic people I know.

I’d like to get the facts for myself so was hoping someone my suggest some references that are historically accurate, good or bad.

Thanks,

K
 
The Protestants of the time were getting their tails kicked on the battlefield, so they made up lies about the Inquisition with outlandish numbers that, if true, would’ve required the Spanish government to kill every man, woman, and child in Spain, then import many more from other countries to kill.

Here’s a really good talk by Steve Kellmeyer on the history of the Church during that period. He hits many of the high points and puts things in proper historical perspective:

alabamacatholicresources.com/Downloads/Church_History_1325-1650AD.mp3
 
Ah yes, the Spanish Inquisition is like the “Inquisition to end all Inquisitions”. :rolleyes:

If you’re just looking for some basic (correct) background info, Catholic Educator’s Resource Center has some helpful articles on the subject:
The Crusades, the Inquisition, and Galileo form the trifecta of misinformation in regards to Church History. 😛 Not that the Church (or particular Catholics) comes out smelling like roses, but it certainly get overblown. There is lots of misleading and downright false information about these things floating around.

EDIT: I recall reading somewhere (maybe it was in “The Da Vinci Hoax”?) that the actual numbers of those killed during the Inquisition (who were, incidentally, killed by the government, not the Church) actually averages out to about the number of people killed in Texas via the death penalty every year. Not that this justifies it, but it gives one a more accurate perspective.

That reminds me, “The Da Vinci Code” is just one of the more recent forums for disseminating this gross exaggeration that “millions” of people were burned at the stake as witches by the Catholic Church during the Inquisition. Most books that address the historical foibles of Brown’s book (like “The Da Vinci Hoax”) necessarily address the Inquisition.
 
I found the following succint summary at another apologetics site. The poster is only identified by an alias, but he covers all the salient points.

The Inquisition​

Modern historians have long known that the popular view of the Inquisition is a myth. The Inquisition was actually an attempt by the Catholic Church to stop unjust executions.

Heresy was a capital offense against the state. Rulers of the state, whose authority was believed to come from God, had no patience for heretics. Neither did common people, who saw heretics as dangerous outsiders who would bring down divine wrath.

When someone was accused of heresy in the early Middle Ages, they were brought to the local lord for judgment, just as if they had stolen a pig. It was not to discern whether the accused was really a heretic. The lord needed some basic theological training, very few did. The sad result is that uncounted thousands across Europe were executed by secular authorities without fair trials or a competent judge of the crime.

The Catholic Church’s response to this problem was the Inquisition, an attempt to provide fair trials for accused heretics using laws of evidence and presided over by knowledgeable judges.

From the perspective of secular authorities, heretics were traitors to God and the king and therefore deserved death. From the perspective of the Church, however, heretics were lost sheep that had strayed from the flock. As shepherds, the pope and bishops had a duty to bring them back into the fold, just as the Good Shepherd had commanded them. So, while medieval secular leaders were trying to safeguard their kingdoms, the Church was trying to save souls. The Inquisition provided a means for heretics to escape death and return to the community.

Most people tried for heresy by the Inquisition were either acquitted or had their sentences suspended. Those found guilty of grave error were allowed to confess their sin, do penance, and be restored to the Body of Christ. The underlying assumption of the Inquisition was that, like lost sheep, heretics had simply strayed.

If, however, an inquisitor determined that a particular sheep had purposely left the flock, there was nothing more that could be done. Unrepentant or obstinate heretics were excommunicated and given over to secular authorities. Despite popular myth, the Inquisition did not burn heretics. It was the secular authorities that held heresy to be a capital offense, not the Church. The simple fact is that the medieval Inquisition saved uncounted thousands of innocent (and even not-so-innocent) people who would otherwise have been roasted by secular lords or mob rule.

Where did this myth come from? After 1530, the Inquisition began to turn its attention to the new heresy of Lutheranism. It was the Protestant Reformation and the rivalries it spawned that would give birth to the myth. Innumerable books and pamphlets poured from the printing presses of Protestant countries at war with Spain accusing the Spanish Inquisition of inhuman depravity and horrible atrocities in the New World.
 
Wiki is of sometimes questionable orientation, but I did find some potentially useful dates:

Historians distinguish four different manifestations of the Inquisition:
the Medieval Inquisition (1184–1230s)
the Spanish Inquisition (1478–1834)
the Portuguese Inquisition (1536–1821)
the Roman Inquisition (1542 – c. 1860
 
What England did to Catholics during Henry Tudor and his illegitimate daughter Elizabeth was far worse than the Inquisition.

What England did under Cromwell to Catholics in Ireland was far worse than the Inquisition.

The French Revolution was worse than the Inquisition.

The concentration camps and gulags of Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union, Communist China and Vietnam were far worse than the Inquisition - but there are always apologists for Communists.
 
I found the following succint summary at another apologetics site. The poster is only identified by an alias, but he covers all the salient points.

The Inquisition​

Modern historians have long known that the popular view of the Inquisition is a myth. The Inquisition was actually an attempt by the Catholic Church to stop unjust executions.

Heresy was a capital offense against the state. Rulers of the state, whose authority was believed to come from God, had no patience for heretics. Neither did common people, who saw heretics as dangerous outsiders who would bring down divine wrath.

When someone was accused of heresy in the early Middle Ages, they were brought to the local lord for judgment, just as if they had stolen a pig. It was not to discern whether the accused was really a heretic. The lord needed some basic theological training, very few did. The sad result is that uncounted thousands across Europe were executed by secular authorities without fair trials or a competent judge of the crime.

The Catholic Church’s response to this problem was the Inquisition, an attempt to provide fair trials for accused heretics using laws of evidence and presided over by knowledgeable judges.

From the perspective of secular authorities, heretics were traitors to God and the king and therefore deserved death. From the perspective of the Church, however, heretics were lost sheep that had strayed from the flock. As shepherds, the pope and bishops had a duty to bring them back into the fold, just as the Good Shepherd had commanded them. So, while medieval secular leaders were trying to safeguard their kingdoms, the Church was trying to save souls. The Inquisition provided a means for heretics to escape death and return to the community.

Most people tried for heresy by the Inquisition were either acquitted or had their sentences suspended. Those found guilty of grave error were allowed to confess their sin, do penance, and be restored to the Body of Christ. The underlying assumption of the Inquisition was that, like lost sheep, heretics had simply strayed.

If, however, an inquisitor determined that a particular sheep had purposely left the flock, there was nothing more that could be done. Unrepentant or obstinate heretics were excommunicated and given over to secular authorities. Despite popular myth, the Inquisition did not burn heretics. It was the secular authorities that held heresy to be a capital offense, not the Church. The simple fact is that the medieval Inquisition saved uncounted thousands of innocent (and even not-so-innocent) people who would otherwise have been roasted by secular lords or mob rule.

Where did this myth come from? After 1530, the Inquisition began to turn its attention to the new heresy of Lutheranism. It was the Protestant Reformation and the rivalries it spawned that would give birth to the myth. Innumerable books and pamphlets poured from the printing presses of Protestant countries at war with Spain accusing the Spanish Inquisition of inhuman depravity and horrible atrocities in the New World.
I would agree with a lot of that.

However, it leaves out a lot. Like torture, which was used to extract confessions, as well as the names of other heretics in the community… who also faced torture so that they could generouosly acknowledge their waywardness.

In Spain, under the Spanish Inquisition (granted, which was run by Spanish authorities), the Inquisitorial fervor led to the pressuring of Jews to be baptized. Of those who refused, 150,000 were forced to leave Spain. Moors were regulated.

Granted, the inflated numbers that some people thriw around are inaccurate and can reflect either ignorance or anti-Catholic bigotry. But that summation above is just way too eager to whitewash killing, anti-semitismn and torture, as being “honest mistakes”.
 
While I’m not going to discuss the problem myself you should really just look it up on Wikipedia. The information is, in my opinion, surprisingly accurate and unbiased. Another good book if you want to read it is “Characters of the Inquisition” by William Thomas Walsh. While it may seem apologetic in some places, he also is surprisingly accurate.
 
Joseph Perez, “The Spanish Inquisition” (Yale, 2005).

Perez specializes in the time period; it is well written (in this case, well translated too) and researched; and it is a fairly entertaining read. You can find a copy cheap on Amazon, if your library doesn’t have it.
 
Read Henry Kamen’s, The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision. Also the BBC ran a documentary a few years ago on the Spanish Inquisition that pretty much demolished all of the myths and exaggerations associated with the Inquisition.
 
The Spanish Inquisition was the fault of the Jews, not the Catholics.

Every 15th Century Catholic in Spain knew and understood three unequivocal truths concerning the Jews:

a) God rewards those who believe in Him and follow Him. The Jews rejected God and committed Deicide. For this they are cursed by God, forced to wander the world like Cain, and God causes them to suffer.
b) Jews and Judaism are a malignant and negative influence on Christians and Christianity.
c) Jews remain Jews through blindness and flaws in their character. They can only find salvation and get to the world to come if they become Christians.

The Jews of Spain at this time were prosperous, educated and influential. This to the Catholic of that time was an anomaly. Christians are rewarded and Jews are cursed. The world had gone askew.

The usual solution to put things back in their rightful place was to bring suffering to the Jew. This was begun on March 15th, 1391. From city to city and town to town, wild Catholic mobs killed thousands of Jews with the cry “convert or die”. This should have placed things back in perspective. Jews for all their prosperity are not to be envied. They are attacked and killed. There is no need for jealousy and no need to ponder how a Jew, those who rejected God and are rejected by God, could possibly be better off than a God fearing faithful Christian.

The Jews of Spain, however, did not bear these attacks with the stoicism and the faith that have guided the Jews for thousands of years. They began to abandon their eternal covenant with God and to convert to Christianity. It is irrelevant that for most, certainly for the children of these converts, the conversion was sincere. To the Gentile, these were merely Jews masquerading as Christians. Worst of all, the world can not be set right again if these Jews are protected under the cloak of their “false” Christianity. The jealousy and incongruity of the prosperous and influential Jew remained burning. The only solution was to expose these false Christians, reveal the Jew underneath and make the Jew suffer. If not, the world could not be put back in its proper place.

By the end of the Spanish Inquisition every single one of the three hundred to four hundred thousand Jews of the Iberian peninsula will be converted, murdered or expelled. A thousand years of Jewish communal life is terminated.

May I suggest for those who wish to learn about the historical background of the Spanish Inquisition:
The Origins of the Inquisition in Fifteenth Century Spain (second edition), by Benzion Netanyahu.
 
The Spanish Inquisition was the fault of the Jews, not the Catholics.
I wondered how you would respond to this thread. 😉
May I suggest for those who wish to learn about the historical background of the Spanish Inquisition:
The Origins of the Inquisition in Fifteenth Century Spain (second edition), by Benzion Netanyahu.
An odd coincidence is that I am in the middle of reading a lengthy article in magazineThe Atlantic. It makes a passing reference to the author and the book you mentioned.
The Atlantic article:
Ben-Zion Netanyahu - his first name means “son of Zion”—is the world’s foremost historian of the Spanish Inquisition and a onetime secretary to Vladimir Jabotinsky, the founder of the intractable, “revisionist” branch of Zionism. He is father to a tragic Israeli hero, Yonatan Netanyahu, who died while freeing the Jewish hostages at Entebbe in 1976; and also father to Benjamin (current prime minister of Israel), who strives for greatness in his father’s eyes but has, on occasion, disappointed him, notably when he acquiesced, in his first term as prime minister in the late 1990s, to American pressure and withdrew Israeli forces from much of the West Bank city of Hebron, Judaism’s second-holiest city.
The Atlantic article:
Ben-Zion Netanyahu’s most important work, The Origins of the Inquisition in 15th-Century Spain, upended the scholarly consensus on the roots of that bleak chapter in Jewish history. He argued that Spanish hatred of Jews was spurred by the principle of limpieza de sangre, or the purity of blood; it was proto-Nazi thought, in other words, not mere theology, that motivated the Inquisition. Ben-Zion also argued that the Inquisition corresponds to the axiom that anti-Semitic persecution is preceded, in all cases, by carefully scripted and lengthy dehumanization campaigns meant to ensure the efficient eventual elimination of Jews. To him, the lessons of Jewish history are plain and insistent.
Oh… and a funny quote, which took place at Ben-Zion 100th birthday party earlier this year.
The Atlantic article:
After a brief debate between Ben-Zion and another prominent academic about competing interpretations of the Inquisition—“It is an unusual 100th-birthday commemoration when a debate about the Inquisition breaks out,” said Menachem Begin’s son, Benny
😃

Here is a book review of The Origins of the Inquisition in 15th-Century Spain.
ihr.org/jhr/v16/v16n1p-2_Chalmers.html

The book review summarizes a fair amount of Spanish history regarding the origins of the Spanish Inquisition, and its conduct. And, of course, takes a critical look at the historiography.
 
If you want accurate information about the inquisition I would imagine you should try to find secular historical sources. You are going to find a lot of mis information with either Catholic sources or anti Catholic sources because both are going to be biased.
 
There is a good book written on the history of the Catholic Church that covers some time on the inquisition. It is called: Triumph: The Power and Glory of the Catholic Church; A 2,000 year history by H.W. Crocker III

He sites all his sources. I would look up the sources here for you now, but I gave it to someone else to read and haven’t gotten it back yet.

The Inquisition was more about excommunicating heretics from the Church than anything else! Most secular history books will fill you full of lies about the middle ages because they want the world to be ‘secular’ and will cut down the Church any chance it can get.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top