Holiday Meal Clean up

  • Thread starter Thread starter MissRose73
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Follow my FMIL’s advice… “Okay kids, adults cooked so you’re on cleaning”

Kids consisting of 25yr old me, my 26yr old FH, his 30yr old sister who is 7months pregnant & her 31yr old DH.

We all rolled our eyes, sighed but got up and did it anyway!!
 
Follow my FMIL’s advice… “Okay kids, adults cooked so you’re on cleaning”

Kids consisting of 25yr old me, my 26yr old FH, his 30yr old sister who is 7months pregnant & her 31yr old DH.

We all rolled our eyes, sighed but got up and did it anyway!!
👍
 
I will speak to the kids when my mother and sister are not in earshot about helping a bit more at X-mas so that the sooner the work is done, sooner presents can be exchanged and enjoyed by all. The kids do listen to me as I do not yell at them nor act in a overly bossy manner. My mother doesn’t like me asking the kids to do stuff nor does my sister as they think their word overrules mine but I do not wish to see myself and my parents burdened with most of the cleanup work when a few extra hands can get things done faster so all may relax.
Depending upon how often and how much you speak to the kids without your sister being around, I too would tell you to butt out. If you’re just asking them to help clean up, I probably wouldn’t be upset. BUT if you are consistently asking them to do things without their mother being around, you are overstepping your boundaries and I have to wonder if some other family dynamics are at play in this situation that goes beyond cleanup at your mother’s house.
 
Depending upon how often and how much you speak to the kids without your sister being around, I too would tell you to butt out. If you’re just asking them to help clean up, I probably wouldn’t be upset. BUT if you are consistently asking them to do things without their mother being around, you are overstepping your boundaries and I have to wonder if some other family dynamics are at play in this situation that goes beyond cleanup at your mother’s house.
This is what I was thinking. She is actively planning on asking her niece and nephew to do something when she knows their mother doesn’t want her asking them to do it. I’d be peeved if I were her sister. She needs to ask her sister to help and leave the kids out of it.
 
My mother doesn’t like me asking the kids to do stuff nor does my sister as **they think their word overrules mine **but I do not wish to see myself and my parents burdened with most of the cleanup work when a few extra hands can get things done faster so all may relax.
The mother and the grandmother (who is also the one hosting and whose kitchen it is) have more say than an aunt IMHO. To go against their wishes would be disrespectful of their authority IMHO.
 
Guess we are odd. We are family, so, when all the nieces and nephews and grand nieces and great nephews are around, they are expected to participate in the family work. They are also expected to obey their grandparents, aunts and uncles. 🤷
 
Guess we are odd. We are family, so, when all the nieces and nephews and grand nieces and great nephews are around, they are expected to participate in the family work. They are also expected to obey their grandparents, aunts and uncles. 🤷
It just depends on what the family consensus is. In some families, the consensus is that the kids will get their turn when they are older…you see this more when the family is so huge that the aunties can hardly all get their elbows into the kitchen, even half at a time. These also tend to be the families where those who have not risen to the “worker” class are stuck at the “kids” table or tables, sometimes well into adulthood.

In some other families, the “kids” have a limited role: fetching to fill the table and clearing it afterward, that kind of thing. In others, the kids are very active. In some families, one person may even be happy to do everything, in exchange for the favor that everyone else stay out of his or her way and let him or her control how things are done!

It all works. The problems only come in when there is no consensus, not even the consensus to go to a restaurant, to let each nuclear family have their own Thanksgiving with their own chosen guest list, or to rotate whose idea of the “right” way to do things prevails.

IOW, it is when two or more parties dig into mutually-exclusive versions of the “Right” way to handle things that there is resentment, strife, and all the sorts of aggressions that families come up with. When the whole family is willing to be flexible and to submit one to the other, though, a peaceable arrangement can usually be found.

In the current case, the solution might be that one sister handle helping Mom at one annual gathering (Thanksgiving), while the other handles another (like Christmas). When Mom tries to “eye” the sister who is “off” for that holiday, the two sisters join in telling her that her help has been selected for the day. That way, the little sister is never in the position of being told what to do by the older, and the older gets a holiday where she sits and has an ally in telling Mom that it is her turn for the “better part.”

Probably, though, the answer here is for the sisters to sit down and decide what works best for them, and then to tell Mom what they’ve worked out. I get the feeling the the little sister would much rather be totally off the hook for one holiday and then on the hook with everything and given her own way to handle just the relationship with Mom, without having to navigate emotions when it is the three of them handling a task together. That’s just a guess, though.

The OP will do well to ask her sister what there is about the current arrangement that she likes and doesn’t like, and to brainstorm how to come up with something agreeable. It will be good practice for the day when the two of them have medical and long-term care issues to deal with…like who gets to take Mom to which doctor, who will monitor the refrigerator and groceries, who will do the bills and how, and so on. You can’t get the lines of communication in place for that too soon or too transparently.
 
how can you “hint” at wanting help cleaning a kitchen? Just say that you need help. Hinting so seldom works that it causes much more trouble than not saying anything at all
 
My mother doesn’t like me asking the kids to do stuff nor does my sister as they think their word overrules mine…
Depending upon how often and how much you speak to the kids without your sister being around, I too would tell you to butt out. … if you are consistently asking them to do things without their mother being around, you are overstepping your boundaries and I have to wonder if some other family dynamics are at play in this situation that goes beyond cleanup at your mother’s house.
She is actively planning on asking her niece and nephew to do something when she knows their mother doesn’t want her asking them to do it. I’d be peeved if I were her sister. She needs to ask her sister to help and leave the kids out of it.
The mother and the grandmother (who is also the one hosting and whose kitchen it is) have more say than an aunt IMHO. To go against their wishes would be disrespectful of their authority IMHO.
Grandma does not want you asking them. Sister does not want you asking them. Grandmother’s house and Sister’s kids, so YES, their word DOES overrule yours! Have your sister help. And get those disposable plates and utensils!😉
 
I see no reason why the children should not assist with the cleanup. I remember being asked and sometimes even forced into helping clean up after dinners at my grandparents’ homes as a child then as a teen, and as a young adult. I was just as much of a guest as the rest at the table but that did not stop my mother from making me help out with the cleanup. I was more willing to help if someone other than my mother did the asking, and to this day that seems to be the norm for me.

I see no reason why both boys and girls should help out in some way with doing things like setting the table, help clear the table and help the adults in some way with the clean up efforts at large holiday gatherings. I will speak to the kids when my mother and sister are not in earshot about helping a bit more at X-mas so that the sooner the work is done, sooner presents can be exchanged and enjoyed by all. The kids do listen to me as I do not yell at them nor act in a overly bossy manner. My mother doesn’t like me asking the kids to do stuff nor does my sister as they think their word overrules mine but I do not wish to see myself and my parents burdened with most of the cleanup work when a few extra hands can get things done faster so all may relax.
They are not your children, it is not your house. Your mother is “burdaned” with the work, but that’s HER decision. Why are you griping?

If you feel that your mother is incapable of doing this work you need to have a serious conversation with your sister about what your mom is not capable of.

As far as the children. Yes, children are good at helping. Any children I have will be taught to help out, although I will likely do most of the work myself when it comes to cooking and my future hubby will be responsible for the cleaning. Weither or not either of us use our OWN children to help out, well, it’s really up to us. If I am a guest at someone’s house and they demanded my (future) childen helped I’d be furious.
 
They are not your children, it is not your house. Your mother is “burdaned” with the work, but that’s HER decision. Why are you griping?

If you feel that your mother is incapable of doing this work you need to have a serious conversation with your sister about what your mom is not capable of.

As far as the children. Yes, children are good at helping. Any children I have will be taught to help out, although I will likely do most of the work myself when it comes to cooking and my future hubby will be responsible for the cleaning. Weither or not either of us use our OWN children to help out, well, it’s really up to us. If I am a guest at someone’s house and they demanded my (future) childen helped I’d be furious.
May I ask any of you here if you are an adult child guest of your parents in their home for a holiday dinner, and one of them asks you to always help with clean up, and pressures you to do so but does not enforce the same rule on the younger adult child, would you feel resentful & jealous? I can imagine most people would feel that way no matter how many times they may voice an opinion openly or night that there should be more equitable division of work.

I was raised from a young age to help out adults (like grandparents, aunts, uncles) in some way with doing things like set or clear the table after meals at their homes. I know I had to be prompted at times to do so but I was not given the choice growing up by my mother. I don’t recall many times where my mother did the same to my younger sister.

I know I need to confess this in confession (the jealousy, resentment, the 4th commandment), and good thing I am going this week. Then I will feel unburdened after that in a way.
 
May I ask any of you here if you are an adult child guest of your parents in their home for a holiday dinner, and one of them asks you to always help with clean up, and pressures you to do so but does not enforce the same rule on the younger adult child, would you feel resentful & jealous? I can imagine most people would feel that way no matter how many times they may voice an opinion openly or night that there should be more equitable division of work.

I was raised from a young age to help out adults (like grandparents, aunts, uncles) in some way with doing things like set or clear the table after meals at their homes. I know I had to be prompted at times to do so but I was not given the choice growing up by my mother. I don’t recall many times where my mother did the same to my younger sister.

I know I need to confess this in confession (the jealousy, resentment, the 4th commandment), and good thing I am going this week. Then I will feel unburdened after that in a way.
Thanks for the psycoanalysis :rolleyes:

I actually an an adult child who dosn’t do much clean up OR cooking. My mother, my grandma, my aunts and myself are all the same way. We are queens of our kitchen. We help when asked and if not we back off. Food is laid out on a counter and we buffet style eat. People bus their own plates, put them in the sink/dishwasher. People refill their own drinks and ask around if others need more.

When it comes to the big stuff everyone goes around and makes doggie bags for themselves. What’s left the hostess puts away. Usually a guy will debone the turkey. The hostess will ask for a little help, but not much.

When events are at my parent’s house (as opposed to my aunts) I’m expected to help keep an eye on the peperoni and cheese tray, but that’s the extent of my duties.

When I host an event at my house my guests are just that, GUESTS and no matter how big or extravagant the meal is I do the cooking and cleaning. People offer to help and that’s good, but I find more often they get underfoot.

I have three brothers and my mom, dad, and one of my brothers and I would take turns cooking (one burned everything and the other saved up and baught take out on his nights). We would cook the entire meal, everyone would bus their own plate, and the meal maker would clean up.

Like I said before I’m teaching my boyfriend how to cook, and I love sharing the task. Still I don’t forsee him on Iron Chef. When we’re married he’ll be on dish duty because he feels bad that I cook. I hate doing dishes so that works out well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top