Holy Communion, Where Is The Blessing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Logan5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Logan5

Guest
Hi, my third thread here. I was raised Catholic, I took communion age seven… and was not blessed, or cursed that I could see. I fell into sin, in my adverse and difficult circumstances. I repented the humble way from fear of dying, I needed God.

I returned to communion… but as a man and trusting, praying… I found no blessing and saw nothing in others, no blessing no curse, no falling asleep… even after I fell into some sins and confusion and took communion, after confession or the next day or week.

1Co 11:26 This means that every time you eat this bread and drink from this cup you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes.
1Co 11:27 It follows that if one of you eats the Lord’s bread or drinks from his cup in a way that dishonors him, you are guilty of sin against the Lord’s body and blood.
1Co 11:28 So then, you should each examine yourself first, and then eat the bread and drink from the cup.
1Co 11:29 For if you do not recognize the meaning of the Lord’s body when you eat the bread and drink from the cup, you bring judgment on yourself as you eat and drink.
1Co 11:30 That is why many of you are sick and weak, and several have died.
1Co 11:31 If we would examine ourselves first, we would not come under God’s judgment.
GNB

Why is that now this does not happen, unlike in the early church?
 
With all respect, how do you know it is not happening? We cannot see into another soul to judge them worth or not. If someone dies, we may be able to say that it was a heart attack or a stroke, but that is just the physical reason they died.

Just because you cannot see it, does not mean it is not there. You cannot reach out and touch God (except in the Eucharist), but you have faith that He is there. I always pray that when I receive the Lord that I am in a state of grace and worthy to receive Him. But, even though I do that, I could still not be in a state of grace. I don’t drop dead because of it, but I may die in other ways. I like to go to confession once a month just to make sure that I am ‘current’ with God.

I am familiar with the passage you quoted, but I am not as familiar with the history of it. When Paul says ‘sick’, ‘weak’ and that some have died, don’t presume that he is speaking in a physical sense. Can we not be spiritually sick or dead?

In the other posts I have seen, you strike me as someone very similar to my formerly Catholic friends. Very poorly catechized (though no fault of your own), in the 20-mid thirty age group and left the Church because some showed you the ‘truth’. You were very dedicated to the Church, but were frustrated because you couldn’t find the answers you needed. You wanted something you could hear and see and feel as a physical church. You wanted God to be in your face.

I too had fallen away and was tossed back a forth with every wind of doctrine. It was only through the graces of God (though I didn’t know or feel it then) that was brought back. I am sensing that there is a deeper frustration you have, something personal and painful, a betrayal.

At the very least you know that God loves you and I know you love Him too. Keep asking, knocking and seeking. Remember that God is in the gentle whistling of air.
 
You are only half way through the book. The results are in the last chapter.
 
You identify yourself as a Pentacostal. I presuppose that you have nothing against Paul’s writings in Corinthians. He teaches against bringing judgment against one self by receiving unworthily.

A problem that I have sometimes experienced when dealing with Pentacostals is the belief that feeling determines outcome. If I don’t feel it, it isn’t there. We often do not understand the spiritual warfare going on around us.

I have noted in my life that when I stray from God, I sometimes seem to have fewer problems. I believe that it is because I have chosen to be lost, that there is no real need for Satan to put roadblocks in my way. It is when I stand with God that I find I often have the hardest time in this life.

I have frequently been deceived by my feelings. They bring us in wrong relationships, wrong actions against God, and others.

It is nice that the Church does not use altar calls. They are emotional. They feel good. But frequently, the decision you make with education, understanding, and deliberation is the mature and proper decision.

There are those that think great music, and great speaking, bring more people to Christ. But God frequently takes those that appear to have less, and makes greatness.

It isn’t what I feel or want, but what God wants.

Receiving Christ through the Eucharist is a tremendous blessing. It, with the Sacrament of Confession, are gifts of tremendous value. See them for the blessings that they are. Don’t under value them.
 
Where Christians and unbelievers see spiritual needs being met, and the wants, they come. The church swells.

Altar calls value should not be considered but a little, for the speakers do educate, encourage, speak insights into people’s secret thoughts, there is love in their words, they often exceed the graduated seminarian in wisdom and revelation, of God’s goodness and power. They hold the answers promising and testifying of more than most of us, who were Catholic, found in the mass.

Paul mentions guilty takers of the body and blood, falling asleep, this means they did not wake up and become conscious.

Peter made three thousand converts in one day, and that day they were baptized in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.

Fast conversion pleases God and He needs it for his death and resurrection to come to fruition as much as possible. Without the harvest, the Gospel is without it’s heart and life.

We are to be “fishers of men” like Peter. Fast or slow many must come, if possible, not one must let be missed. For God loves him, her.

Feelings, we should feel peace and joy. It is good to feel the Holy Spirit, His presence, loss of fear, love, refreshing in living water, a clear conscience!!!

After a confession, you should have a clear conscience.

At an altar call some people are convicted in their hearts, not only their minds, and they at that moment can be “pricked in their hearts” as in Acts that they have sinned and are in danger, and turn to God without delay. If they do they may never return, or may later only mentally ascent to Jesus.

Altar calls and the Holy Spirit are for life.
 
Want to know where the blessing is?

It’s in the fact that God in His infinite mercy has let you live so that you may have the opportunity to repent and come home.

You received the body and blood, soul and divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ while in grave sin and now you have further sinned by abandoning the faith that He made sure that you were born into for the modern new winds of doctrines of men and you want to ask where is the blessing?

If I was you, I would count myself blessed that I can draw breath and repent and come home while you still have time.

1] O come, let us sing to the LORD;
let us make a joyful noise to the rock of our salvation!
2] Let us come into his presence with thanksgiving;
let us make a joyful noise to him with songs of praise!
3] For the LORD is a great God,
and a great King above all gods.
4] In his hand are the depths of the earth;
the heights of the mountains are his also.
5] The sea is his, for he made it;
for his hands formed the dry land.
6] O come, let us worship and bow down,
let us kneel before the LORD, our Maker!
7] For he is our God,
and we are the people of his pasture,
and the sheep of his hand.
O that today you would hearken to his voice!
8] Harden not your hearts, as at Mer’ibah,
as on the day at Massah in the wilderness,
9] when your fathers tested me,
and put me to the proof, though they had seen my work.
10] For forty years I loathed that generation
and said, “They are a people who err in heart,
and they do not regard my ways.”
11] Therefore I swore in my anger
that they should not enter my rest.
(Psalm 95)

Take the hint…
 
What is the blessing, impartation from the bread of life, isn’t it strength to live before God in high justice, salvation from sin, that we walk with God, not needing confess to the same sins, experiencing a clear conscience, and authority over our bodies and unclean spirits?

Jesus promised life in the bread of life, and freedom in the truth, instead of bondage… Living water to the woman at the well, for her release from constant sexual sins and bonds according to the flesh.

There should be something for those who take the bread of life that is not found in non believers, like Buddhists and Hindus and in African Ubuntu…

But mass is somber, church growth is by child bearing, many don’t join the mass as they get older, where is the testimony, the joy, the strength, the freedom, and authority, and the lovingness?

Life is better than alcohol, but young ones like getting drunk or fornicating, or simply social drinking, work and parties…
 
But mass is somber, church growth is by child bearing, many don’t join the mass as they get older, where is the testimony, the joy, the strength, the freedom, and authority, and the lovingness?
Logan, maybe its just me, but I’m having a bit of a hard time following what your concerns are. I think there are several things going on at once. Depending on what branch of Pentecostolism you have been involved with. it is going to take time to unravel or unteach certain notions you apparently have about the Catholic Church, the Mass, the Eucharist.
I do want to zero in on this paragraph however. The Mass is not somber, it is respectful (or should be) and formal. It is not a rock concert, it is approaching the throne of God. The other areas you are talking about have to do with others. This was an area I also had to shift my thinking in. Being a Catholic is intensely personal. It is not exclusive, but it ultimately is focused on ME, not OTHERS. It is not about fellowship, although that is important. The bad behavior of other Catholics is between them and God. I am to focus on MY right relationship, not others. Church growth is the work of the Holy Spirit, not gimmicks and programs.
Now, back to the OP.
It is the Eucharist that is the center of Catholic life and worship. When the Eucharist is removed from a Christian’s life, they are forever trying to find something to replace it with. Some (like me) try Bible study. But no amount of knowledge, memorization, or meditation on the Sacred Scriptures can give me what the Eucharist gives me. Some try music. Emotional music can make my toe tap or bring me to tears. But as good as music is, it can never give me what can give me what the Eucharist gives me. Others, (like Pentecostols) look for ‘miracles and manifestations’. They at least know there is something more, an encounter with the Divine. But there is no greater miracle or manifestation greater than that which is found in the Eucharist.
Jesus said “lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world.” This is made real through the Eucharist as we connect with the Risen Christ through the power of the Holy Spirit.
In the Holy Eucharist we have the one sacrament whose principal purpose is to increase sanctifying grace, repeatedly and often, through personal union with the Giver of grace Himself.
That is why the Holy Eucharist is preeminently the sacrament of spiritual growth, of increase in spiritual stature and strength.
That is why the soul already must be in the state of sanctifying grace when we receive Holy Communion—in other words, free from mortal sin.
Physical food cannot benefit a dead body, and the Holy Eucharist cannot benefit a dead soul.
Since I have returned to the Church, I have seen more spiritual growth than I ever dreamed possible. Things have become clearer to me than they were before.
In the arena, before they went out to die, Christians would partake of the Eucharist. And mystically, but also in reality, they went out stronger human beings to face whatever there was to face.
No amount “holy” laughter or “jumping and dancing” in the Spirit can replace that.
Catholics have the “manifest presence of God” in the Eucharist.
Hope that helps.
🙂
 
What is the blessing, impartation from the bread of life, isn’t it strength to live before God in high justice, salvation from sin, that we walk with God, not needing confess to the same sins, experiencing a clear conscience, and authority over our bodies and unclean spirits?

Jesus promised life in the bread of life, and freedom in the truth, instead of bondage… Living water to the woman at the well, for her release from constant sexual sins and bonds according to the flesh.
So then you are saying that you are now sinless Logan?

Confession of sins is not the unscriptural affair that many modern new winds of doctrines of men have portrayed it to be and for all those who assert themselves to adhere to the errant doctrine that the Bible is their sole and ultimate authority it is surprising to us Catholics that they choose to ignore or reinterpret what it says as I lay out in my blog articles,Catholic Confession and Scriptures About Penance.
There should be something for those who take the bread of life that is not found in non believers, like Buddhists and Hindus and in African Ubuntu.
:yawn: There is. Your own blessing is that you are still alive.
But mass is somber,
Hogwash! Not where I am. It is beautiful and reverent and full of worship and the intense and very personal presence of God.
church growth is by child bearing,
Further hogwash. I’d wager that my own parish grows by at least the same amount (and very likely more than), than any of the Pentecostal churches I was part of did.
many don’t join the mass as they get older,
I suspect that I am “older” and I’m spot in the middle of it every time, and most of those around me are too.
where is the testimony,
All over the place! And far more scriptural faithful than any of the new winds of doctrines of the modern men.
the joy, the strength, the freedom, and authority, and the lovingness?
Raging around us. Obviously you haven’t seen the inside of the life of faithful Catholics since your deception led you into your present errors.
Life is better than alcohol, but young ones like getting drunk or fornicating, or simply social drinking, work and parties…
Drinking is not condemned by the Word of God. Drunkeness is and so we avoid it.

Parties are not condemned by the Word of God. What do you think feasts were in the Bible? See Luke 15 for example and John 2.

I don’t seee faithful Catholic youth fornicating, so I’d say that your inference is nothing more than anti-Catholic polemic and propaganda.

I’m sure you wish that all you have said was true…but that’s all it is…wishful thinking.
 
No amount “holy” laughter or “jumping and dancing” in the Spirit can replace that.
Catholics have the “manifest presence of God” in the Eucharist.
The bread of life is for any that ask, with the right motive, without doubt. Sometimes with help from someone who knows God and is a seasoned charismatic. Both Catholic and Evangelical’s can ask and receive, from a Father who gives bread and not stone. Matt 7:9.

Holy laughter is the “oil of joy”. Jumping and dancing are expressions of joy. Isaiah 61:3, Thessalonians 1:6.
So then you are saying that you are now sinless Logan?
No brother, I am saying that I have experienced a clear conscience, after repenting. It is my goal.

Affectung, pardon my spelling, is Luther’s description of his efforts to be right with God, and have a clear conscience. Confession, prayer, self flagellation… left him sick, but never coming away forgiven, having something. It is the root of the protest and why we debate.

Sinlessness is my aim.
There is. Your own blessing is that you are still alive.
You miss my point, we should have more than the unbelievers.
Hogwash! Not where I am. It is beautiful and reverent and full of worship and the intense and very personal presence of God.
God is present everywhere… The music helps a lot, I prefer Catholic worship. I actually cannot go with Hillsong’s styles of worship. I dislike guitars and drums. And I heard the pope also is like this, having said they should not be used. I can believe you worship well there. My description of reverent worship is somber, but really it is alright. I mean some admirable Korean brothers are like that. I caught it from them. That was the second time I repented. Isaiah 11:2. Excellent.

I worship with Catholics often, I want to really worship from my heart. I need to be set free for this. Or really, try harder. I worshiped in a small Catholic group, and they gave me words from the Spirit, like “I will be your God and you will be my person.”

Later I saw a Pentecostal girl worshiping with her mouth wide open no longer in song. She was receiving.

There are different types of praise in the Bible, I think one means bowing, another hands raised, one is slap stickish, we sing Alleluia, from Hallelu. Hebrew scholars know the words for the types.

I have often seen Catholics dancing and bearing flags in worship.

In Catholic and Evangelical community I tried talking about this with the young worship player. There music is with drums, guitars, not like Hillsong though, a fair bit better. I mentioned Taize, but rightly he said the young ones love the contemporary music, end of story.

The Servant of Jesus. A strong community, reputable, charismatic, missionary, youth group success, theologians, live worship and marriages. Approved by the Pope.
Further hogwash. I’d wager that my own parish grows by at least the same amount (and very likely more than), than any of the Pentecostal churches I was part of did.
The Pentecostal church I was part of grew by fifty new churches planted, in one year. They started with attendances like eighty.

From a church of about one hundred we have grown into over six hundred million in one hundred years.
Raging around us. Obviously you haven’t seen the inside of the life of faithful Catholics since your deception led you into your present errors.
Joy strength, freedom, authority lovingness. As a Catholic I only heard of authority over spirits. As a Pentecostal I saw it. And it is available and expected of us. Loving Catholics, yes there are nice people, we can love each other, but I never saw it raging. One can see it as the fruit of the Spirit Gal 5:22, in the face of someone praying for you Only charismatics do this.

“The blessing of the Father’s heart” a revival beginning in Toronto in 1994, was open to all, and I know Catholics took it and give it. TACF, is their name in Toronto.

Can you give me an example of love in the masses?

I think Linda Shubert had it more right in 1 to 1 prayer, that “there are so many hurting people.” I saw a lot of bondage in my youth days.

I was happier as when a young Catholic, sin and sickness, sent me searching for more power over sin, and for healing. So I looked at what others had.
I suspect that I am “older” and I’m spot in the middle of it every time, and most of those around me are too.
Older fellows are at church, but you notice that Christmas mass shows a lot who normally do not attend.
All over the place! And far more scriptural faithful than any of the new winds of doctrines of the modern men.
Testimonies are reports, in praise of God, for what He has done in them, or others. Charismatics are best for this! Whichever church.
I don’t see faithful Catholic youth fornicating, so I’d say that your inference is nothing more than anti-Catholic polemic and propaganda.
I’m sure you wish that all you have said was true…but that’s all it is…wishful thinking.
We look for praise reports, we should see them, but we don’t look for fornication, of course we don’t see it. We sadly do hear about it, I recall.

Also outside the church at my Catholic high schools, no names.

Few Catholic young ones are chaste, “The big C word.”

So many on dating sites are Catholic. It is also true for Evangelicals.

A report I heard was alarming as to how few school leavers attend church after the compulsory attendance is over.

This is not my wish, I don’t want to find fault, I would prefer if all had much grace and love, and sure truth, in one church.
 
Hi, my third thread here. I was raised Catholic, I took communion age seven… and was not blessed, or cursed that I could see. I fell into sin, in my adverse and difficult circumstances. I repented the humble way from fear of dying, I needed God.

I returned to communion… but as a man and trusting, praying… I found no blessing and saw nothing in others, no blessing no curse, no falling asleep… even after I fell into some sins and confusion and took communion, after confession or the next day or week.
…

Why is that now this does not happen, unlike in the early church?
In this and subsequent posts you are actually showing in spades the signs of a person in spiritual decline and loss.

In participating in Eucharist you receive grace to the degree that you are disposed to receive grace. Carelessness, lack of preparation, or lack of thanksgiving can be harmful. Pope John Paul II, in his very first Encyclical, Redemptor hominis #20, said that if one does not constantly try to grow spiritually, receiving the Eucharist would “lack its full redeeming effectiveness” and there could even be a spiritual loss. To receive out of mere routine, with no special care, no thanksgiving, is more apt to cause spiritual loss than gain. Or to receive with a mental mindset that its some kind of magical pill or ambrosia is sacrilegious.

Holy Communion, if we are rightly disposed, produces an increase in sanctifying grace - the ability to take in the vision of God in the life to come - plus a special claim to actual graces as needed, forgiveness of venial sin for which one is repentant, help to keep from mortal sin, and an increase in the virtue of love.

We must of course have the state of grace. Without it it would be sacrilege, and an added mortal sin to receive. Right intention is also needed, i.e., to please God, to be more closely united with Him, to gain a remedy for our weaknesses.

For fullest benefits, we should be free from all attachment to anything sinful. If you have an unresolved commitment to The Lord and think you can commit some venial sins now and then (and affection to venial sin) then you have limited your heart in its potential to receive full grace and have set limits on how far you will follow the Lord. This will limit your spiritual growth. When you partook of communion (Presumably as a Catholic?) at an early age you were in a fledgling love relationship and while likely innocent of grave sin, you may not have really had a vibrant early spiritual zest and your heart might have been set more on the things we all had as children (baseball, fishing, adventure etc.). This would have constrained your uptake of sanctifying grace and instead perhaps afforded you more of the actual grace variety that benefit you in staying out of trouble or abuse or protected you from harm, or gave you temporal benefits (good schools, friends, bright mind or creative etc.). One can never know.

By returning to communion later in life as a fallen away Catholic with the knowledge that you should not receive without going to confession (much less probably doing the 1 hr fasting) means you were not properly “dressed” to come to the wedding so to speak. Yo disgraced yourself in the presence of The Lord and committed sacrilege. This is grave Logan and you should at least attempt right now to make a perfect act of contrition to apologize to God and ask His forgivness. He will hear prayers of sincere repentance but to be forgive of grave sin required perfect contrition which is very hard and impossible without grace (you must be intensely spiritually sorry out pure love for God without regard to the fears of punishment of hell). This is why sacramental confession that only an apostolic bishop or priest can give is so vital to one’s salvation. Please go talk to a priest or go to confession. If you were baptised Catholic you are still Catholic (once Catholic always Catholic) and are entitled to receive the sacraments.

Please do not test the Lord’s Mercy or delay in this. Normally the way sin works is that it sets one on a path to self-destruction. This is actually a mercy since God will let this deprivation drive one to their knees and repent and come back. But make no mistake about it you are very likely gravely wounded and among the walking dead if you consciously received the Eucharist knowing you were in a state of grave sin. It is only God’s patience and Mercy that you are here. You MUST get back on a path of holiness ASAP - but do not expect that there will not still be latent consequences for being on the wrong path for so long.

I’ll pray for you.

More Here: Holy Communion

Pax,
James
 
Holy Communion, if we are rightly disposed, produces an increase in sanctifying grace - the ability to take in the vision of God in the life to come - plus a special claim to actual graces as needed, forgiveness of venial sin for which one is repentant, help to keep from mortal sin, and an increase in the virtue of love.
What about repentance from grave sin, and then after some days, confession and communion?
Please do not test the Lord’s Mercy or delay in this. Normally the way sin works is that it sets one on a path to self-destruction. This is actually a mercy since God will let this deprivation drive one to their knees and repent and come back. But make no mistake about it you are very likely gravely wounded and among the walking dead if you consciously received the Eucharist knowing you were in a state of grave sin. It is only God’s patience and Mercy that you are here. You MUST get back on a path of holiness ASAP - but do not expect that there will not still be latent consequences for being on the wrong path for so long.
I’ll pray for you.
Thanks, and I will tell you, after grave sin, over a year away from church, and sincere days and days long turning to the Father in prayer, the Our Father, the Hail Mary, “don’t let me die”. Rejecting old thought patterns, doing discipline, live worded prayers, detachment from bad friends, seeing thing more anew, in a different environment from the one familiar to sinful habits, respectful of the GNB and references to God, positive thought, motivating self assertion over habits, because I hated the thought and sense of unknowing regarding Hell being so it seemed for sure, near to death. And saw God as my hope, and that I must lead a new life asking for His mercy, I turned fully to Jesus from all known sin, all halted.

I fell one morning to my knees and I sensed Jesus presence, I knew He was there. It was like He passed His hand through my heart and cleaned it, and my conscience was clear, from weight, like dog poo, built up on my soul slowly over years, so I didn’t quite notice, but when it was gone, it was a clear difference, I was exuberant, and told a friend.

I knew things in my spirit. I did not want to look back it did not give me peace. But I went to confession, but this made me feel stress, looking back. Nevertheless I was confident in the church and went to communion, in trust and prayer and meditation.

I did not experience anything like forgiveness in communion as mentioned just before. But I went regularly to confession, Saturdays, with a list of anything I did that I thought was sin or accidents that may have been disrespectful.

For some months my standards were quite good, and I took communion.

My priest even said, you are too stressed, maybe one a fortnight.

I really tried hard!

I gained a reputation in my youth group, Antioch. These brother, were the best days of my life!

But due to school, problem verses in Ben Sirach I tried to hold to, really it was “Hold in abhorrence all that is foul.” Visualizer trouble, dog poo, fear of blaspheming the Holy Spirit, foul mouthed shouts at school, hate from some boys for being religious, anger at home with my faith, studying Hitler and Stalin, I started to lose contact with Jesus, had trouble even thinking of Him. Also I did not get enough Bible reading and prayer.

After school finished, I was sickened, then fell away again, while attending Antioch, confession and taking communion.

If only I had not gone back to school to redo the last year! For I then discovered a better thing, Fr Kevin English, and his healing mass. I began to receive impartation and blessing. And words from God for me. New friends…At the tail end of my zeal.

As years went on, I did receive living water. Jesus blood, and personal words from God…

But the traditions did not seem rich in blessing to me. Also finding it difficult to shake sin, I told my parish priest, not Kevin, that I think I should not take communion, but he said I should, to help with overcoming sin. I thought I should be blessed or ill effected, seven years after first repenting.

It was very hard to find teaching such as studies in the Gospel, things I did not understand, even after years, hidden meaning.

Also the Pope’s letters and I asked for more and Thomas Aquinas, but it was far off.

The priests were economic, “you don’t need it.” Needs only sense.

Then I left Catholic practice and attended as a test a few Pentecostal churches, and found a great spiritually gifted church and powerfully anointed church.

God began to do things in my life, this was another high time.

That is not exhaustive.

How does this testimony effect your application of the PJP2’s letter to my situation? .
 
What about repentance from grave sin, and then after some days, confession and communion?
…

How does this testimony effect your application of the PJP2’s letter to my situation?
You can’t go into communion with the idea of confessing sins later. That is like going to the altar to get married while still having an illicit affair ongoing with another person with the intention of breaking it off after having some more good-bye hugs and kisses. You can’t have a foot in and out of a relationship anymore so than you can with His Church.

It sounds to me like you are getting a bit emotionally caught up in “feelings” and such. You have a conscience and know right from wrong and this is causing you some anxiety since you are going against your better conscience but trying to rationalize it all away through “feelings”. It is often the case that feelings have nothing at all to do with one’s spiritual state - the mind can do all manner of things to trick one into believing what it wants to believe. If you want to feel good clapping hands and singing hymns and being in fellowship with ostensibly good and uplifting people - then you are likely going to achieve that and “feel good”. But spiritually, if you are not in a state of grace and you are in reality drunk on sin then its a false euphoria in most cases. I feel that one of the biggest lies ever to be propagated on the planet was this notion of “sola fide” since I feel it leads to a false sense of euphoric “feel good” easy-believism. Luther was a man who had a very active conscience as you do. As best I can tell from history he led a very sinful life and did not have a developed discipline of grace (drinking, womanizing etc.) but suffered from a condition called scrupulosity which was quite common with children raised by very overbearing and strict parents who always threatened every misdeed with hell fire. Luther had such a bad childhood and so saw sin in everything he did and felt a victim to it. So to quite his mind he invented this notion of “forensic salvation” - a one time “salvation” where one no longer had to worry about sinning since “once saved always saved”. That was more of a mental illness remedy through a sort of power-of-positive thinking approach than it was anything else - this new theology was never before taught by The Church or the apostles. The concept of being holy is necessary for salvation and that is a daily rejection of sin and striving to follow the Lord and do obey Him. But God being merciful knows we will fall a lot (as all the apostles did at one time or another) so gave us the means to be forgiven of grave post-baptismal sins through apostolic confession. As mentioned previously one can also be forgiven through perfect act of contrition (which implies a strict repentance as well) - but few saints can attain this as it takes a lot of spiritual pain and sufffering and special grace to achieve - and one never knows unless God reveals it.

Anyway, I think you are having some emotional challenges, perhaps from a past sinful life or abuse of evil from others and are in need of some help. God works through grace and through others who he gives grace (actual or sanctifying). So I’d recommend some counseling with a priest and ask him of he can recommend a social councilor or somone that can help you get to closure on some things of your past that I think are still causing you harm and conflict.

I am not going to say you did not encounter Jesus in a special way when you got down on your knees. But I will say that if you did He would want you to come home to the Catholic Church where we have all the sacraments to help heal you and keep you in grace.

Pax,
James
 
Why is that now this does not happen, unlike in the early church?
Probably for the same reason that God does not regularly strike liars down dead, like Ananias and Sapphira. (Acts 5:1-11) God does not delight in the death of the wicked but rather that they turn from their wickedness and live. (Ezekiel 18:23) Those Corinthian Christians who died or became sick after receiving the Eucharist unworthily, like Ananias and Sapphira, were punished so manifestly for our edification. The reason all liars and those who receive the Eucharist unworthily are not similarly punished is because God is merciful. Your death for receiving the Eucharist unworthily might have helped others but it would not have done you much good.

Though spiritual gifts are sometimes accompanied by physical or emotional gifts from God, the notion that spiritual gifts, such as are received when the Eucharist is worthily received, must be accompanied by physically or emotionally discernible gifts is the attitude of an unspiritual man, as St. Paul said, "The unspiritual man does not receive the gifts of the Spirit of God, for they are folly to him, and he is not able to understand them because they are spiritually discerned. (1 Cor 2:14) Jesus Christ himself seems to intimate that those who receive spiritual gifts without accompanying physical or emotional gifts are even more blessed than those receive them with accompanying physical or emotional gifts: “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe.” (John 20:29)
 
to God. His blood will purify our consciences from useless rituals, so that we may serve the living God.
GNB

Heb 9:25 The Jewish high priest goes into the Most Holy Place every year with the blood of an animal. But Christ did not go in to offer himself many times,
Heb 9:26 for then he would have had to suffer many times ever since the creation of the world. Instead, now when all ages of time are nearing the end, he has appeared once and for all, to remove sin through the sacrifice of himself.
Heb 9:27 Everyone must die once, and after that be judgeQUOTE]You can’t go into communion with the idea of confessing sins later.
No actually, I never in my life did confession after communion.

I believe emotions are powerful and important. Just as important as the mind or will, the heart is first.

The inner state must not be, “non evident, yet understood”, for we can see others behaviour and hear their testimony, we should also have what they have, and experience it. As the word says.“Taste and see that the Lord is good.” Psalm 34:8.

The conscience, just think of people who don’t have them, psychopaths, sociopaths. Our conscience is our friend. Hebrews writes about the conscience, the blood is for the conscience, and the old system did not clear it like the new, with yearly sacrifices and reminders of past sins. St Francis taught, discern by what gives you peace.

Heb 9:9 This is a symbol which points to the present time. It means that the offerings and animal sacrifices presented to God cannot make the worshiper’s heart perfect,
Heb 9:10 since they have to do only with food, drink, and various purification ceremonies. These are all outward rules, which apply only until the time when God will establish the new order.
GNB

Heb 9:14 Since this is true, how much more is accomplished by the blood of Christ! Through the eternal Spirit he offered himself as a perfect sacrificed by God.
Heb 9:28 In the same manner Christ also was offered in sacrifice once to take away the sins of many. He will appear a second time, not to deal with sin, but to save those who are waiting for him.
GNB

Heb 10:2 If the people worshiping God had really been purified from their sins, they would not feel guilty of sin any more, and all sacrifices would stop.
GNB

Heb 10:22 So let us come near to God with a sincere heart and a sure faith, with hearts that have been purified from a guilty conscience and with bodies washed with clean water.
Heb 10:23 Let us hold on firmly to the hope we profess, because we can trust God to keep his promise.
GNB

Heb 13:18 Keep on praying for us. We are sure we have a clear conscience, because we want to do the right thing at all times.
GNB

1Jo 1:1 We write to you about the Word of life, which has existed from the very beginning. We have heard it, and we have seen it with our eyes; yes, we have seen it, and our hands have touched it.
1Jo 1:2 When this life became visible, we saw it; so we speak of it and tell you about the eternal life which was with the Father and was made known to us.
1Jo 1:3 What we have seen and heard we announce to you also, so that you will join with us in the fellowship that we have with the Father and with his Son Jesus Christ.
1Jo 1:4 We write this in order that our joy may be complete.
1Jo 1:5 Now the message that we have heard from his Son and announce is this: God is light, and there is no darkness at all in him.
1Jo 1:6 If, then, we say that we have fellowship with him, yet at the same time live in the darkness, we are lying both in our words and in our actions.
1Jo 1:7 But if we live in the light—just as he is in the light—then we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus, his Son, purifies us from every sin.
1Jo 1:8 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and there is no truth in us.
1Jo 1:9 But if we confess our sins to God, he will keep his promise and do what is right: he will forgive us our sins and purify us from all our wrongdoing.
1Jo 1:10 If we say that we have not sinned, we make a liar out of God, and his word is not in us.
GNB

After repenting, then closer to God we confess and our sins are washed away and we have a clear conscience. We need receive it by faith and then we experience it. W e have joy and peace, hope of glory. Acceptance, heart, mind will emotions. It is a major reason for why Moses installed blood sacrifice and Jesus exceeded it by the cross.

Todd, Acts 5:1-11 and 1 Cor 2:14 are misquoted here.
People in such a thick presence of God as Peter’s presence, even today, if they lie to God, may drop dead.

Spiritual gifts in the first place are not physical or emotional. They are gifts of knowledge, which must then be discerned. Secret thoughts revealed leading men to repent in respect of God and his love.

The unspiritual man is sensual, after pleasures… or ambition, or malicious.
Jesus Christ himself seems to intimate that those who receive spiritual gifts without accompanying physical or emotional gifts are even more blessed than those receive them with accompanying physical or emotional gifts: “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe.” (John 20:29)
Jesus was Messiah and Isaiah 11:2 applies. Jesus gave them powerful spiritual words.

They heard, and discerned, and though they did not see Him alive after His death and referring to us in that case, He said that as a matter of faith over evidence, that we can be happier for believing having only heard and not seen. Faith not knowing.

If you know, it is done, you do not need faith.

Isaiah 11:2 today and now since Pentecost the vocal gifts and the other gifts, are in aid of faith and being spiritual, and being saved and sanctified.

You are not happier without them. Nor more spiritual.
 
You can’t go into communion with the idea of confessing sins later.
No actually, I never in my life did confession after communion.

I believe emotions are powerful and important. Just as important as the mind or will, the heart is first.

The inner state must not be, non evident, yet understood, for we can see others behaviour and hear their testimony, we should also have what they have, and experience it. As the word says.“Taste and see that the Lord is good.” Psalm 34:8.

The conscience, just think of people who don’t have them, psychopaths, sociopaths. Our conscience is our friend. Hebrews writes about the conscience, the blood is for the conscience, and the old system did not clear it like the new, with yearly sacrifices and reminders of past sins. St Francis taught, discern by what gives you peace.

Heb 9:9 This is a symbol which points to the present time. It means that the offerings and animal sacrifices presented to God cannot make the worshiper’s heart perfect,
Heb 9:10 since they have to do only with food, drink, and various purification ceremonies. These are all outward rules, which apply only until the time when God will establish the new order.
GNB

Heb 9:14 Since this is true, how much more is accomplished by the blood of Christ! Through the eternal Spirit he offered himself as a perfect sacrifice to God. His blood will purify our consciences from useless rituals, so that we may serve the living God.
GNB

Heb 9:25 The Jewish high priest goes into the Most Holy Place every year with the blood of an animal. But Christ did not go in to offer himself many times,
Heb 9:26 for then he would have had to suffer many times ever since the creation of the world. Instead, now when all ages of time are nearing the end, he has appeared once and for all, to remove sin through the sacrifice of himself.
Heb 9:27 Everyone must die once, and after that be judged by God.
Heb 9:28 In the same manner Christ also was offered in sacrifice once to take away the sins of many. He will appear a second time, not to deal with sin, but to save those who are waiting for him.
GNB

Heb 10:2 If the people worshiping God had really been purified from their sins, they would not feel guilty of sin any more, and all sacrifices would stop.
GNB

Heb 10:22 So let us come near to God with a sincere heart and a sure faith, with hearts that have been purified from a guilty conscience and with bodies washed with clean water.
Heb 10:23 Let us hold on firmly to the hope we profess, because we can trust God to keep his promise.
GNB

Heb 13:18 Keep on praying for us. We are sure we have a clear conscience, because we want to do the right thing at all times.
GNB

1Jo 1:1 We write to you about the Word of life, which has existed from the very beginning. We have heard it, and we have seen it with our eyes; yes, we have seen it, and our hands have touched it.
1Jo 1:2 When this life became visible, we saw it; so we speak of it and tell you about the eternal life which was with the Father and was made known to us.
1Jo 1:3 What we have seen and heard we announce to you also, so that you will join with us in the fellowship that we have with the Father and with his Son Jesus Christ.
1Jo 1:4 We write this in order that our joy may be complete.
1Jo 1:5 Now the message that we have heard from his Son and announce is this: God is light, and there is no darkness at all in him.
1Jo 1:6 If, then, we say that we have fellowship with him, yet at the same time live in the darkness, we are lying both in our words and in our actions.
1Jo 1:7 But if we live in the light—just as he is in the light—then we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus, his Son, purifies us from every sin.
1Jo 1:8 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and there is no truth in us.
1Jo 1:9 But if we confess our sins to God, he will keep his promise and do what is right: he will forgive us our sins and purify us from all our wrongdoing.
1Jo 1:10 If we say that we have not sinned, we make a liar out of God, and his word is not in us.
GNB

After repenting, then closer to God we confess and our sins are washed away and we have a clear conscience. We need receive it by faith and then we experience it. We have joy and peace, hope of glory. Acceptance, heart, mind will emotions. It is a major reason for why Moses installed blood sacrifice and Jesus exceeded it by the cross.

Todd, Acts 5:1-11 and 1 Cor 2:14 are misquoted here.
People in such a thick presence of God as Peter’s presence, even today, if they lie to God, may drop dead.

Spiritual gifts in the first place are not physical or emotional. They are gifts of knowledge, which must then be discerned. Secret thoughts revealed leading men to repent in respect of God and his love. 1Cor 14:25.

The unspiritual man is sensual, after pleasures… or ambition, or malicious.
Jesus Christ himself seems to intimate that those who receive spiritual gifts without accompanying physical or emotional gifts are even more blessed than those receive them with accompanying physical or emotional gifts: “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe.” (John 20:29)
Jesus was Messiah and Isaiah 11:2 applies. Jesus gave them powerful spiritual words.

They heard, and discerned, and though they did not see Him alive after His death and referring to us in that case, He said that as a matter of faith over evidence, that we can be happier for believing having only heard and not seen. Faith not knowing.

If you know, it is done, you do not need faith.

Isaiah 11:2 today and now since Pentecost the vocal gifts and the other gifts, are in aid of faith and being spiritual, and being saved and sanctified.

You are not happier without them. Nor more spiritual.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top