Homosexuality is illogical?

[BobCatholic]

3)**But if two peole love each other shouldn’t they be allowed marry and have sex. **
The short answer is sometimes. Not everyone everyone who loves each other should have sex. (Ex. child and parent, sister and brother, Married man and unwed coworker etc.) In the same token, Love does not equal marriage and sex. Love should be part of sex and marriage, but you can love someone without having sex with them or marrying them.

True. We don’t allow polygamy, does this mean we are bigoted against the FLDS? Of course not.

1. Gays aren’t hurting anyone
   True having homosexual urges doesn’t hurt anyone, agreed. Promoting Gay lifestyles may. For one, no one knows if homosexuality is genetic, environmental, or both. If it is wholly or in part environmental, promotion of Gay lifestyles can actually entice one to be Gay and thus hurt their chances of reproducing and furthuring the species. Many people will say that the Church is against science and appeal to science to back up a claim, but if this is the case so are proponent of the Gay lifestyle. Being Gay would be completely against any Darwinian theory. So for the time being, since no one is clear on whether homosexuality has an environmental component, shouldn’t we avoid advocating the Gay lifestyle so as not to predispose children to it an thus hurt their chances at having a heterosexual disposition and reproducing.

There is more reasons why the homosexual lifestyle is not good:.

corporateresourcecouncil.org/white_papers.html

Also, there is also another argument about why the homosexual lifestyle is not good. Let’s use the “what is good for the goose is good for the gander” argument. If I were to snap my finger and magically transform the entire human race into 100% homosexuals, and they practiced their lifestyle, the human race would be extinct in less than 100 years. If I were to do the same and make the human race 100% heterosexual and they practiced their lifestyle, the human race continues on.

So yeah, based on all of these arguments, homosexuality is illogical.

 

[v3orb]

Fact: the catholic church has NEVER been “sola scriptura” (bible only) so throwing the “bible doesn’t say so” comment out is a joke because tradition from the beginning has condemned homosexuality as well (read the early church fathers).

the early church fathers weren’t too keen on heterosexuality either.

 

[Mea_Culpa]

My Baronius Roman Missal (1962) is really cool. Has a neat section in the front with 10 Commandments, 4 Cardinal Virtues, 7 Deadly Sins, etc. One of these is

Sins Crying to Heaven for Vengeance

Wilful murder - The sin of Sodom - Oppression of the poor - Defrauding labourers of their wages.

True then, true now, true forever.

 

[Exalt]

Also, there is also another argument about why the homosexual lifestyle is not good. Let’s use the “what is good for the goose is good for the gander” argument. If I were to snap my finger and magically transform the entire human race into 100% homosexuals, and they practiced their lifestyle, the human race would be extinct in less than 100 years. If I were to do the same and make the human race 100% heterosexual and they practiced their lifestyle, the human race continues on.

So yeah, based on all of these arguments, homosexuality is illogical.

That’s the most retarded thing I’ve ever read. Is this what passes as reasoning on these forums?

 

[Exalt]

My Baronius Roman Missal (1962) is really cool. Has a neat section in the front with 10 Commandments, 4 Cardinal Virtues, 7 Deadly Sins, etc. One of these is

		 				Sins Crying to Heaven for Vengeance

Wilful murder - The sin of Sodom - Oppression of the poor - Defrauding labourers of their wages.

True then, true now, true forever.

“Which one of these is not like the others!”

It’s a game we used to play in elementary school. I suggest you sit in on the class. Murder and oppression certianly do “cry for vengeance” - and justly so - but homosexuality? That doesn’t make any sense at all.

 

[Mea_Culpa]

“Which one of these is not like the others!”

It’s a game we used to play in elementary school. I suggest you sit in on the class. Murder and oppression certianly do “cry for vengeance” - and justly so - but homosexuality? That doesn’t make any sense at all.

Seemed to make sense to God - ask the people in Sodom and Gomorrah!