Horoscopes and a High School Newspaper

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kqrtam05
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Kqrtam05

Guest
I’m not sure if this should go in this forum, but I’ll put it down anyways.

This year I signed up for a Newspaper class at my High School. The class works on articles and publishes the newspaper monthly for the school. Anyways, we were discussing writing topics for the paper these first few days of school, and the teacher mentioned publishing horoscopes. Everyone else thought it was a great idea, and they decided to publish them.

I argued, however, and in the end I only managed to get them to put a little “warning” label on the horoscopes column, which reads that the column is just for fun and not to be taken seriously. While I wasn’t satisfied, there really wasn’t much more I could do.

Now, what I want to know is, should I switch out of the Newspaper class, or stay? I won’t be publishing the horoscopes directly but I think that’s something I don’t want to be a part of. Ideas? Opinions? Advice? Help…

P.S.( I did ask on AAA but it wasn’t answered… maybe my post was too long? 😊)
 
Also a high schooler:D

Good for you for speaking up. In the end it was the teacher’s fault. Just post again on AAA in a few days… I couldn’t help you with format though.

Which section do you cover? Perhaps you can run a satire piece on astrology, or some kind of interest piece on how people can be brainwashed, or on this and new age stuff in general and how they put our vast complex personalities, religions and beliefs into little boxes.

Not sure if you should do this or switch out however… you should pray about it.
 
I think you should be fine so long as the disclaimer is there.
 
I would try asking them (AaA) again, but rephrase it and get right down to the point. Also, it may take a few days for them to get to your question.

As for my opinion, your staying or going depends on how upset you are about it. You might try and stay but if it upsets you that much you may end up leaving eventually anyway. On the other hand, if you left, you’d still not be able to do anything about it and it would still publish with the disclaimer.

Is this a Catholic High School? Because perhaps you needed to specify that in your original “ask an apologist” question. If it were a public HS, I’d leave; but staying and defending your point in a Catholic HS gives you a chance to “fight the good fight”.

Just my 2 cents.
Snert
 
I’m not sure if this should go in this forum, but I’ll put it down anyways.

This year I signed up for a Newspaper class at my High School. The class works on articles and publishes the newspaper monthly for the school. Anyways, we were discussing writing topics for the paper these first few days of school, and the teacher mentioned publishing horoscopes. Everyone else thought it was a great idea, and they decided to publish them.

I argued, however, and in the end I only managed to get them to put a little “warning” label on the horoscopes column, which reads that the column is just for fun and not to be taken seriously. While I wasn’t satisfied, there really wasn’t much more I could do.

Now, what I want to know is, should I switch out of the Newspaper class, or stay? I won’t be publishing the horoscopes directly but I think that’s something I don’t want to be a part of. Ideas? Opinions? Advice? Help…

P.S.( I did ask on AAA but it wasn’t answered… maybe my post was too long? 😊)
Best Practices (or whatever the term is for newspapers) is that horoscopes are ALWAYS published with a disclaimer that it’s for entertainment purposes only. I don’t even think the New York Times publishes horoscopes. So, you have journalistic standards on your side.

Also, if there’s other stuff that has the same number of “column inches,” I would suggest having comparable filler that has the same number of column inches - at a time when h.s. newspapers need to be ahead of the curve insofar as mass media, you’ll look more informed and knowledgeable if you can have “better” filler to use.

Hope that helps.
 
just dont read that part of the newspaper if it bothers you. horoscopes are not based off of any fact anyway
id ignore it. their fake anyway
 
Also a high schooler:D

Which section do you cover? Perhaps you can run a satire piece on astrology, or some kind of interest piece on how people can be brainwashed, or on this and new age stuff in general and how they put our vast complex personalities, religions and beliefs into little boxes.
Haha, that would be useful except I cover sports. I never thought of that though, thanks.

Thanks to everyone else too. Good advice.

BTW, its not a Catholic HS.
 
Haha, that would be useful except I cover sports. I never thought of that though, thanks.

Thanks to everyone else too. Good advice.

BTW, its not a Catholic HS.
I wonder if public schools can endorse astrology. Tell them you want equal time to talk about Scientology or Jehovah’s Witnesses and I bet they will scratch the whole idea fast.
 
I wonder if public schools can endorse astrology. Tell them you want equal time to talk about Scientology or Jehovah’s Witnesses and I bet they will scratch the whole idea fast.
I think the problem with this tract is they can make the case that all, or at least the vast majority of, professional news papers publish horoscopes so they are simply giving the student’s real world experience. The same cannot be said for Scientology or Jehovah’s Witnesses – unless something newsworthy involving those churches happens.

I would say to look at it this way. Why did you take the newspaper class? Why did you want to be involved in the newspaper? Based on the answers to these questions you’ll be able to determine if you should bite the bullet and stay or climb on your horse and ride into the sunset.
 
I think the problem with this tract is they can make the case that all, or at least the vast majority of, professional news papers publish horoscopes so they are simply giving the student’s real world experience. The same cannot be said for Scientology or Jehovah’s Witnesses – unless something newsworthy involving those churches happens.

I would say to look at it this way. Why did you take the newspaper class? Why did you want to be involved in the newspaper? Based on the answers to these questions you’ll be able to determine if you should bite the bullet and stay or climb on your horse and ride into the sunset.
That’s a good point. But, it only makes things worse for them because my papers (and I imagine many cities papers are simillar) have a Religion section!

I really can’t imagine this is a mortal sin issue either way for a catholic. Is it?:confused:
 
That’s a good point. But, it only makes things worse for them because my papers (and I imagine many cities papers are simillar) have a Religion section!

I really can’t imagine this is a mortal sin issue either way for a catholic. Is it?:confused:
I wouldn’t think that it is. Yes, my City’s paper has a religion section. That section of the paper covers news worthy things going on within the local churches. It is not used as a vehicle for espousing the beliefs of a particular faith or denomination.
 
I wonder if public schools can endorse astrology. Tell them you want equal time to talk about Scientology or Jehovah’s Witnesses and I bet they will scratch the whole idea fast.
I did origninally tell them that publishing horoscopes was comparable to publishing a catholic or islamic column. They then said that horoscopes aren’t a religion. I said they could become a doctrine. That’s when they decided to put the disclaimer.

But thx anyways:shrug:
 
I did origninally tell them that publishing horoscopes was comparable to publishing a catholic or islamic column. They then said that horoscopes aren’t a religion. I said they could become a doctrine. That’s when they decided to put the disclaimer.

But thx anyways:shrug:
Oh, well I think I need to investigate this with a friend of mine who would know more about the astrology thing. She claims it is divine guidance. So, let me get back to you after I investigate this more.

Best to you in all you do, and don’t ignore this tug at your conscience. If you feel uncomfortable about this, with or without a stamp of approval from a good catholic source, that clearly defines this for you, I would use the conscience that christians believe God gave them.

You sound like a very honest and dilligent believer. Don’t worry about this too much, but perhaps if I were a believer and in your shoes I would pray like crazy now.

While seeking guidance, of course.

Peace and good wishes for you in this,

Liz
 
A couple of things.
I worked on my high school newspaper. I was the editor, actually. 😃
There are a couple of points you might want to bring up. Horoscopes serve no pedagogical purpose. They edify neither the audience nor the author. Horoscopes have no place in a school paper for that reason alone.
Furthermore, I recall, when I was editor of the paper, that we always struggled with what to cut. There was more good stuff that we could put in than we had space for. Why waste space on fluff like horoscopes when you’ve got good stuff you can put in?
Maybe encourage your teacher and the other students to think a little more outside of the box. They thought of horoscopes because, well, that’s what they see in papers, and so that’s what they’re trying to mimic.
But, what about something ELSE? Maybe suggest something more relevant to their lives. I’m assuming you are looking to ahve a recurring section, right?
Maybe a weekly interview with a local person of interest.
Maybe a column about some other high school aged people in other places doing amazing things.
Maybe a column about what high school is like in different places of the world.
Maybe high school yearbook pics from ten, twenty, thirty years ago. A ‘then and now’ type of piece. It could be a contest. Guess the year correctly that the pics are from (maybe even add in a few facts of what was going on locally) and whoever submits the right answer first to the newspaper office wins a t-shirt or a snickers bar or something. (We had contests where the prize was a snickers bar all the time. My word, you would think these people had never seen a snickers bar. They would do ANYTHING for that stupid candy bar. Never mind they could just buy one in the vending machine behind them for 85 cents. THey wanted to WIN it. But I digress)

I mean, seriously, there are WAY more interesting things to publish than horoscopes and maybe they need a clever go-getter such as yourself to suggest it. And they can be fun and light fluffy items, but still serve SOME purpose of educating whoever is writing the piece and educating your readership. Again, this is skool. You’re here to get smarte. 😃
When I went on to college, I was also editor at that paper. We had a horoscope section there. The horoscopes were written by Celeste. People marveled at Celeste’s horoscopes. They were SPOT ON. I know of several students who planned their week based on what Celeste put in the paper. Celeste got more letters, emails and phone messages than everyone else at the paper combined. At least once a week someone would stop by the office in person asking to see Celeste. They had a question about their boyfriend, or were having problems in a class, or conflict with their parents.
No one could ever get a hold of her.
Cuz she wasn’t real.
‘Celeste’ was actually us, the editorial staff of the paper. Every Friday, we would get together at the local pub (which never seemed to notice that we were way under 21) and we would eat greasy burgers and drink Milwaukee’s Best (What’s Milwaukee’s Worst?) and we would write the horoscopes and be snarky and tell dumb jokes. Not one word, not one letter not one tittle (that’s the dot over the ‘i’) was written sober. Ans the students drank up those horoscopes like they were, well, like they were Milwaukee’s Best.🙂

Best of luck to you in your journalism class. I always had alot of fun in mine. I hope yours is as good to you.🙂
 
While believing in horoscopes as a rule to go by, or as somehow predicting the future or whatever is obviously wrong, I think it is bad to say that God never uses such things to speak to people. Same thing goes with fortune cookies. You should not take them literally most of the time, but God uses everything to speak to people, not just things that are obviously for His glory.
 
While believing in horoscopes as a rule to go by, or as somehow predicting the future or whatever is obviously wrong, I think it is bad to say that God never uses such things to speak to people. Same thing goes with fortune cookies. You should not take them literally most of the time, but God uses everything to speak to people, not just things that are obviously for His glory.
you are serious?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top