How authoritative is Vatican II?

  • Thread starter Thread starter fish90
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

fish90

Guest
Before I begin, I have no intention of believing in heresy, however, I find this to be a legitimate question.

I was reading an article from scripturecatholic.xanga.com/703978535/3-vatican-ii-%E2%80%93-how-authoritative-is-it/ titled Vatican II-How authoritative is it?

A mattes that comes to mind is:

Vatican II was a pastoral council and is not infallible.

" When Pope John XXIII opened the council, he stated that the council would be “pastoral,” unlike the previous councils. This is why Paul VI said that Vatican II did not issue “any extraordinary statements with a note of infallibility.” So Vatican II is not infallible based upon the first type of teaching, “solemn judgment,” set forth in Vatican I’s Dei Filius." (4th paragraph of response)

Is this true?
 
Ecumenical Councils are always infallible when teaching faith or morals. The infallibility of the Church is not restricted solely to solemn extraordinary definitions of dogmas directly connected to the Deposit of Faith, but it is also infallible when definitively teaching doctrines indirectly connected to the Deposit of Faith in its exercise of the universal ordinary magisterium. An Ecumenical Council represents the voices of all the bishops teaching unanimously with the guidance of the Holy Spirit. This is infallible. It is also infallible when all the bishops though scattered throughout the world definitively teach a doctrine of faith or morals unanimously.
 
The author of the article says that Vatican II did not work through the universal magisterium.

Also, the article also shares the excerpt I posted and the article shares that Vatican II reiterated known doctrine and issued new disciplines.

"Was Vatican II an exercise of the “ordinary and universal Magisterium”? Only insofar as Vatican II’s teachings are restatements of prior infallible teaching like on the divinity of Christ or the sinlessness of the Virgin Mary. Otherwise, the Second Vatican Council was an exercise of the “ordinary Magisterium” only. And insofar it was an exercise of the ordinary, but not universal, Magisterium, its teachings are not infallible and are subject to reform.

Many argue that Vatican II was an act of the Extraordinary Magisterium and thus could not have taught error. This is incorrect. The level of authority in the Church’s teaching is not determined by its “accidents” (that is, the external form or appearance of the teaching) but by its “substance” (what the teaching essentially is). For example, the ecumenical Council of Florence (1438-1445) issued a doctrinal teaching on the matter of the sacrament of Holy Orders that was approved by Pope Eugene IV, declaring that the matter was the tradition of the instruments (the presentation of the chalice and host). Thus, the council (which is an “extraordinary” form for teaching) issued a teaching that (1) was proposed as revealed truth. But was the teaching (2) in accord with Catholic Tradition? Was it believed “by all, always and everywhere”? "

The author’s most interesting point was that Vatican II could teach error.

"This means that the teachings of the Second Vatican Council must be evaluated in light of the constant Tradition of the Catholic Church. I believe it is difficult to find some of Vatican II’s teachings on ecumenism, inter-religious dialogue, ecclesiology, collegiality, and religious liberty in the Church’s ordinary and universal magisterial teaching, as many erudite scholars have demonstrated (not to mention its directive to completely reform the liturgy which also has no precedent in Tradition). On the other hand, this was the first pastoral council that the Church ever convoked. In short, even if one concludes that some of the council’s teachings are novel, we cannot overreact to these teachings, for they are not protected by Christ’s promise of infallibility. This is the problem with the sedevacantists. They cannot accept that an ecumenical council like Vatican II could teach error on matters of the faith. But an ecumenical council can teach error if that teaching is not part of the ordinary and universal Magisterium. "

Taken from:scripturecatholic.xanga.com/703978535/3-vatican-ii-%E2%80%93-how-authoritative-is-it/
 
An interesting fact about Vatican I and II: they’re the only Church councils that weren’t called in response to some heresy or need to clarify a doctrine.

But I support the vast majority of what was said… it’s what happened afterwards, the clergy and lay people taking creative liscence, that I don’t support. It went just a bit overboard. In one of the many VII threads, there’s a link to a THIS ROCK article that talks about the Real Vatican II… standing up for Latin, priests and people both facing the altar, etc. Very interesting stuff… 🙂 We’re definitely living in an interesting time in Church history.
 
Before I begin, I have no intention of believing in heresy, however, I find this to be a legitimate question.

I was reading an article from scripturecatholic.xanga.com/703978535/3-vatican-ii-%E2%80%93-how-authoritative-is-it/ titled Vatican II-How authoritative is it?

A mattes that comes to mind is:

Vatican II was a pastoral council and is not infallible.

" When Pope John XXIII opened the council, he stated that the council would be “pastoral,” unlike the previous councils. This is why Paul VI said that Vatican II did not issue “any extraordinary statements with a note of infallibility.” So Vatican II is not infallible based upon the first type of teaching, “solemn judgment,” set forth in Vatican I’s Dei Filius." (4th paragraph of response)

Is this true?
Vatican II carries the complete weight and authority of the Catholic Church behind it. It is the twenty-first in the line of Ecumenical Councils beginning with Nicea and includes, Chalcedon, Lateran, Trent, Vatican I.
 
Before I begin, I have no intention of believing in heresy, however, I find this to be a legitimate question.

I was reading an article from scripturecatholic.xanga.com/703978535/3-vatican-ii-%E2%80%93-how-authoritative-is-it/ titled Vatican II-How authoritative is it?

A mattes that comes to mind is:

Vatican II was a pastoral council and is not infallible.

" When Pope John XXIII opened the council, he stated that the council would be “pastoral,” unlike the previous councils. This is why Paul VI said that Vatican II did not issue “any extraordinary statements with a note of infallibility.” So Vatican II is not infallible based upon the first type of teaching, “solemn judgment,” set forth in Vatican I’s Dei Filius." (4th paragraph of response)

This is getting kind of old, but Vatican II is just as authoritative as the previous 20 councils of the Church. It did not teach error of any kind. For future references, I would stay away from websites such as the SSPX, SSPV, fisheaters, mostholyfamilymonastery, popeinred.

Is this true?
 
The author of the article says that Vatican II did not work through the universal magisterium.

Also, the article also shares the excerpt I posted and the article shares that Vatican II reiterated known doctrine and issued new disciplines.
The author is in serious doctrinal error. An Ecumenical Council is always an exercise of the universal and ordinary magisterium of the Church in a given time and place. Now, certainly it did re-iterate known doctrine, but it did it in such a way as to clarify and shed light on it so that modern man can comprehend it. This re-iteration in the sense that the Council Fathers intended is also infallible. Certainly, there were new disciplines put in place. The Church has always modified its disciplines and form of the liturgy when ever the circumstances warranted it.
 
An interesting fact about Vatican I and II: they’re the only Church councils that weren’t called in response to some heresy or need to clarify a doctrine.
I completely disagree. Actually, Vatican I was held in response to various heretical philosophies and theologies born of the enlightenment and the scientific age. You can see that by reading the list of anathemas within the council itself and also learning about the various philosophies circulating during that time period.

Now, Vatican II can be said to have been a continuation of Vatican I. Remember that Vatican I never really ended, it was interrupted due to war. So, Vatican II picked up where Vatican I left off. It was in response to the modern offshoots of the heresies that were around in Vatican I’s era. Since all of these heresies were so numerous, so simultaneous, and with countless founders then they had to be answered all at once. Usually in the Early Church the Church dealt with one heresy at a time between centuries. Now, numerous heresies spring up all at once simultaneously.
 
" When Pope John XXIII opened the council, he stated that the council would be “pastoral,” unlike the previous councils. This is why Paul VI said that Vatican II did not issue “any extraordinary statements with a note of infallibility.” So Vatican II is not infallible based upon the first type of teaching, “solemn judgment,” set forth in Vatican I’s Dei Filius." (4th paragraph of response)
So what is said about Pope John refering to the council as “pastoral” is a lie? He never said that? I’ve always wondered about this. If it is true that he said it, why did he say it? Why did he believe it was pastoral?
 
So what is said about Pope John refering to the council as “pastoral” is a lie? He never said that? I’ve always wondered about this. If it is true that he said it, why did he say it? Why did he believe it was pastoral?
Being pastoral does not preclude infallibility. Also, I believe it is better not to speak of a whole Council being infallible. Individual teachings that come out of a Council are infallible, and the Council Fathers were infallible in proclaiming those individual teachings, but documents generally have a lot of sentences which do not meet the criteria of an infallible statement.
 
Before I begin, I have no intention of believing in heresy, however, I find this to be a legitimate question.

I was reading an article from scripturecatholic.xanga.com/703978535/3-vatican-ii-%E2%80%93-how-authoritative-is-it/ titled Vatican II-How authoritative is it?

A mattes that comes to mind is:

Vatican II was a pastoral council and is not infallible.

" When Pope John XXIII opened the council, he stated that the council would be “pastoral,” unlike the previous councils. This is why Paul VI said that Vatican II did not issue “any extraordinary statements with a note of infallibility.” So Vatican II is not infallible based upon the first type of teaching, “solemn judgment,” set forth in Vatican I’s Dei Filius." (4th paragraph of response)

Is this true?
Vatican II has the same authority as all the councils the Catholic Church considers ecumenical. No difference. It was an ecumenical council (as understood by the Catholic Church, though it’s also appropriate to label it as a general council).
 
Vatican II has the same authority as all the councils the Catholic Church considers ecumenical. No difference. It was an ecumenical council (as understood by the Catholic Church, though it’s also appropriate to label it as a general council).
Please explain.
 
I completely disagree. Actually, Vatican I was held in response to various heretical philosophies and theologies born of the enlightenment and the scientific age. You can see that by reading the list of anathemas within the council itself and also learning about the various philosophies circulating during that time period.

Now, Vatican II can be said to have been a continuation of Vatican I. Remember that Vatican I never really ended, it was interrupted due to war. So, Vatican II picked up where Vatican I left off. It was in response to the modern offshoots of the heresies that were around in Vatican I’s era. Since all of these heresies were so numerous, so simultaneous, and with countless founders then they had to be answered all at once. Usually in the Early Church the Church dealt with one heresy at a time between centuries. Now, numerous heresies spring up all at once simultaneously.
Ok, thanks for setting me straight, I’ll look into this. There’s a lot of stuff about VII floating around the internet these days:)
 
How does an ecumenical council be referred to a general council?

Sorry for the ambiguity.
Vatican II, Like Vatican I, Trent and other 18 was called and/or approved by the Pope. The first Councils were not necessarily called by the Pope but were approved by him. Anyway it was a Universal Council, for the Universal Church, All Bishops, Patriarchs, Metropolitans of the East and West were summoned to attend. As opposed to Local, or Regional Councils, who’s decisions could still be applieed to the whole Church by the Pope.
 
How does an ecumenical council be referred to a general council?

Sorry for the ambiguity.
Catholics typically refer to 21 ecuemnical councils, starting with Nicea and the most recent being Vatican II.

However, many Christians do not recognize these same Councils as “ecumenical” as they were not involved with nor participated in them. So…it’s common to refer to many councils following the first seven (which the vast majority of Christians consider authoritative) as “general” rather than “ecumenical.”

Does that help?
 
Vatican II carries the complete weight and authority of the Catholic Church behind it. It is the twenty-first in the line of Ecumenical Councils beginning with Nicea and includes, Chalcedon, Lateran, Trent, Vatican I.
Exactly what does that mean Br. Does it mean that every word and asperation must be held by all Catholics as having the Holy Ghost’s approval? Does it mean that if a Catholic refuses to believe or accept what is says in parts he or she is in sin, heresy, disobedience, excommunicated, or what. The reason I ask this is because there are parts of Vatican II I have no intention of taking seriously. Let me give an example, Gaudium et spes #36:

Consequently, we cannot but deplore certain habits of mind, which are sometimes found too among Christians, which do not sufficiently attend to the rightful independence of science and which, from the arguments and controversies they spark, lead many minds to conclude that faith and science are mutually opposed.(Cf. Msgr. Pio Paschini, Vita e opere di Galileo Galilei, 2 volumes, Vatican Press (1964))

Does anyone believe the Holy Ghost had any hand or part in that slander of previous popes??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top