How close can a same sex relationship get?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jtwp5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That post could not have misrepresented and twisted what Prodigal wrote any more if you’d tried!
And how do you think of it as a symptom but not as a disease
Just as behaviours are often symptomatic of life experiences though we would not apply “disease” to the situation/person. A headache might be a symptom of stress, or of a bump on the head, etc. Here we use “symptom” without having a disease in sight, but there is a cause or many possible causes. One day - in a particular headache sufferer, we might discover a tumor - then we have something fitting our meaning of “disease”.
And if it’s…usually as inconsequential as the hiccups…
He said nothing like this. He said it doesn’t “help anyone” (as is the case with the hiccups).
why should anyone care if they have same-sex attraction?
He said nothing at all which you could reasonably lead you to ask this question.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Thorolfr:
And if it’s…usually as inconsequential as the hiccups…
He said nothing like this. He said it doesn’t “help anyone” (as is the case with the hiccups).
What do you mean by saying that being gay doesn’t “help” anyone or as Prodigal says, it’s “not oriented toward human flourishing”? Every person probably has characteristics that, depending on the circumstances, might either “help” them or “hurt” them or do neither. Being very smart and having a high IQ might help some quite a bit in terms of succeeding in college, having a successful career and making a good living. Being a short, overweight, bald man, on the other hand, might hurt someone’s dating prospects when compared to someone who’s conventionally tall and handsome. There are definitely things that a tall man can do that a short one can’t, that a smart one can do that a less intelligent one can’t, and that a handsome one can do that a plainer one can’t. But we wouldn’t normally talk about someone’s short height or weight or lack of hair or having an average intellect as opposed to being intellectually gifted as thing that are not “oriented towards human flourishing.”

Being gay doesn’t necessarily impede someone’s ability to “flourish” unless not being able to have biological children with their spouse or partner is so important to them that they feel miserable and unhappy. Otherwise, a gay man can live a perfectly happy and fulfilled life. And there are lots of straight people who are not cut out or able to have children because of their vocation or temperament, or for some other reason. Would we say that they are therefore not “flourishing”? And there are ways for gay men to have children if they want and I know some who have.
 
Last edited:
The language you used is seemingly contradictory, but I think I get what your trying to say.

in this particular case, I meant an attraction where one finds themselves with a compulsive fixation on a man/or a mans features, which has the potential to turn sexual.

Your right, you can’t be friends with someone who just is someone you find attractive, you also have to see if a friendship is actually possible or a good idea.
 
Last edited:
Ask Father. To this stupid layman, it seems that contact with this fellow is most certainly a near occasion of sin. Is this other person also SSA? That would seem to increase your flirtation with sin, and the heart is fickle and dangerous - not the source of our self-control. That is left to the force of our human will. This situation would be the same for a non-SSA person with the opposite sex, and is a very frequent area of great human difficulty.

What we must avoid doing is entertaining the illicit feelings we may have toward others, whether they are of our own sex or not. Sexual attraction is extremely strong, therefore you know what your cross to bear is. You may not have asked for the cross, but you do need to ask for the grace to carry it. God will never refuse a sincere, struggling heart.

Asking for the intercession of our Blessed Mother is powerful, as she is the model of chastity for the entire world. I am offering prayers that you will receive the grace necessary to avoid sin.
 
IF we are speaking of “gay” as, “a desire to have sex with the same sex”, which is what a homosexual attraction is… just to be clear that is distinct from, “some affection for the same sex”
from many people’s point of view, especially alot of christians, sex is not supposed to happen outside of natural marital relations, with an openess to life. So homosexual activity, along with masturbation, premartial sex, and a slew of other things, impede someones ability to flourish. They see sex as something that is meant to be self giving and sacraficial, exclusive and sacramental, so there are essentially two ways to flourish, 1. glorify God by renouncing marriage for the kingdom of heaven, or 2. glorify God, and your spouse, by saving your sexuality for them and only them, in accordance with its design, and open to life. So Chastity is for everyone. Failing to live chastely is not our definition of “human flourishing”, and so logically from thathomo sexual desires obviously do not point us in a flourishing direction. Whether gay couples are pefectly happy and fulffilled is up to debate.

It sounds like what you are really starting to debate is not what causes homosexual attractions, which is less of an essential issue, but whether homosexual activity is a sin or not.

I don’t think a sexual relationship with someone of the same gender is fulfilling at all. We are biologically designed to connect with the opposite sex sexually. This isn’t the best analogy, but say someone is sexually attracted to their pet, and lets say sex is anatomically possible in some way, we don’t encourage that, even though it would be apparently fullfilling for them and the animal, insomuch as they get pleasure out of it, cause we know something is wrong and abnormal with two incompatible species having sex, and so it most likely won’t be ultimately fulfilling for them even though they have the attraction. Likewise, we can recognise that something is wrong with homosexual activity, because we see two incompatible genders(in their body parts and biological design) having sex. Just because you get sexual pleasure out of it doesn’t mean its natural and good.

This page introduces alot of the catholic understanding and thought if you want to look into it: Homosexuality | Catholic Answers
 
Last edited:
Whether gay couples are pefectly happy and fulffilled is up to debate.

It sounds like what you are really starting to debate is not what causes homosexual attractions, which is less of an essential issue, but whether homosexual activity is a sin or not.

I don’t think a sexual relationship with someone of the same gender is fulfilling at all. We are biologically designed to connect with the opposite sex sexually. This isn’t the best analogy, but say someone is sexually attracted to their pet, and lets say sex is anatomically possible in some way, we don’t encourage that, even though it would be apparently fullfilling for them and the animal, insomuch as they get pleasure out of it, cause we know something is wrong and abnormal with two incompatible species having sex, and so it most likely won’t be ultimately fulfilling for them even though they have the attraction. Likewise, we can recognise that something is wrong with homosexual activity, because we see two incompatible genders(in their body parts and biological design) having sex. Just because you get sexual pleasure out of it doesn’t mean its natural and good.
When someone says that they are “heterosexual,” does that mean nothing more than “a desire to have sex with the opposite sex”? Are heterosexual relations only about a “desire for sex”? In my own case, there’s a lot more to my relationship with my partner than just sex. And your implication that all same-sex relationships are only about “getting pleasure” betrays a rather shallow and superficial understanding of the lives of most gay people.

And in what way is it up to debate whether gay couples are perfectly happy and fulfilled? I’m gay and have been with my partner for almost 20 years. Are you going to tell me that you know better than I do whether I’m perfectly happy and fulfilled? If you don’t feel that having a sexual relationship with someone of the same gender is fulfilling, then don’t have one. But you obviously can’t speak for how happy or fulfilled someone else is.

And you’re right. Your analogy comparing consensual sexual relations between two adult humans to non-consensual sexual relations between humans and animals is not a very good analogy (animals can’t give informed consent). The part about consent is very important, although considering all the recent scandals in this country involving powerful men sexually harassing women, I’m aware that a lot of people don’t take consent very seriously.
 
Last edited:
Ok, I’ll change my analogy, say its two siblings who are taking appropriate measures to prevent pregnancy.

yes heterosexual means “a desire(or attraction) to have sex with the opposite sex” basically. I’m not saying “being heterosexual”, is what lifes about.

And no, I’m not trying to imply that the all same sex relationships are all about sex. I’m just pointing out that even though something seems to bring some apparent benefits or happiness, it doesn’t mean it’s healthy and good. So even though homosexual activity seems to have some apparent benefits, one pleasure, and it forms a close emotional bond, and can be an intended expression of love/affection, and seems to bring both people happiness, does not prove that is is healthy and rightous. All of these things could be applied two a case of incest. Now If you think incest is ok, then yeah this argument doesn’t hold up, but it opens the door to a lot of weird stuff.
 
So even though homosexual activity seems to have some apparent benefits, one pleasure, and it forms a close emotional bond, and can be an intended expression of love/affection, and seems to bring both people happiness, does not prove that is is healthy and rightous.
I don’t have time to delve into this conversation at length right now, but let me just say that if Thorolfr could substantiate the claim that homosexual activity forms a close emotional bond, I would all but stop opposing homosexual activity. I think that, in fact, it does no such thing, and I have seen absolutely no evidence it does any such thing. Surely many people who have gay sex also HAVE a close and meaningful emotional bond, but this is something that many people of the same gender can have without having sex. Indeed, if gay sex forms such a close emotional bond, then why are so many partnered gay men promiscuous?
 
How long is a piece of string? Asking a forum of stangers about this will, in all honesty, get you nowhere. This is really a discussion for you to have with a trusted spiritual director who knows you and whom you can speak freely with.
The CCC states “Homosexual persons are called to chastity. By the virtues of self-mastery that teach them inner freedom, at times by the support of disinterested friendship, by prayer and sacramental grace, they can and should gradually and resolutely approach Christian perfection.”
You need to discern with someone knowledgeable and trustworthy exactly how this relates to your circumstances.
 
And here is another question. Regardless of same sex or opposite sex, the question might be, ‘How long, or how many years, do I really plan on spending with this ‘other’?’ If the answer is not ‘for life’, then it is the same as any hetero or homo sexual ‘fornication’ or ‘flings’.

The divorce rate among married heterosexuals is around 50 percent. What is to prevent the same divorce rate among homosexual marriages?

So the question of sexuality is not one of the immediate present time but is a question for life tenure with another significant ‘other’.

Polygamy is rarely practiced among those who take their ‘sexual’ relationship, or marriage, seriously.
 
Last edited:
And here is another question. Regardless of same sex or opposite sex, the question might be, ‘How long, or how many years, do I really plan on spending with this ‘other’?’ If the answer is not ‘for life’, then it is the same as any hetero or homo sexual ‘fornication’ or ‘flings’.
Huh? This topic is not about exclusive relationships of any sort, but about ordinary friendships.
 
40.png
Joe_73:
So even though homosexual activity seems to have some apparent benefits, one pleasure, and it forms a close emotional bond, and can be an intended expression of love/affection, and seems to bring both people happiness, does not prove that is is healthy and rightous.
I don’t have time to delve into this conversation at length right now, but let me just say that if Thorolfr could substantiate the claim that homosexual activity forms a close emotional bond, I would all but stop opposing homosexual activity. I think that, in fact, it does no such thing, and I have seen absolutely no evidence it does any such thing. Surely many people who have gay sex also HAVE a close and meaningful emotional bond, but this is something that many people of the same gender can have without having sex. Indeed, if gay sex forms such a close emotional bond, then why are so many partnered gay men promiscuous?
So are you claiming that heterosexual activity can form a close emotional bond between a man and a woman but homosexual activity can’t form a close emotional bond between two men? And if so, what evidence do you have for this claim? Can you cite some scientific study that shows that emotions between two gay men are qualitatively different from emotions between a man and a woman?
 
Last edited:
So are you claiming that heterosexual activity can form a close emotional bond but homosexual activity can’t? And if so, what evidence do you have for this claim? Can you cite some scientific study that shows that emotions between two gay men are qualitatively different from emotions between a man and a woman?
Not really. I don’t think sex makes me and my wife closer. Maybe it does, but I see no reason to believe it does. It serves other purposes, though.
 
I would say that it manifests our closeness, because it is an act in which we are both most fully ourselves. I don’t think there are any gay lovemaking activities that are similar, in that respect.
 
And your implication that all same-sex relationships are only about “getting pleasure” betrays a rather shallow and superficial understanding of the lives of most gay people.
Same sex relationships can be as good as any other. The only problem is same sex sexual relationships.
 
You didn’t, but when you said you missed socializing I just assumed partying. 😔 My own college years must be haunting me down so I was lost in my self. 😔
How do you know how deep are the friendships you see in the majority of people?
The type of friendship you define (that I haven’t found either) seems to be very rare not only in my eyes but what I have been told by elder people. It’s not the type of friendship where you just know who to call on Friday night if you wanna chill and have some beer. It’s more like… if you’re lucky enough to meet someone who can just be friends with you (regardless of gender) like that. Like siblings.
I wish you find someone like that to be your friend. But I really don’t see nor do I believe that is something most people. Most people don’t have that and it is possible that many of them aren’t even looking for that in a friend.
 
Even if it’s not that close it’ll be nice to have people to hang out with regardless. I just don’t want to put a mask on, so tired of trying to live up to some ideal standard. Why can’t I just be accepted for me? Seems like I’ve been fighting with myself for so long.
 
Me too. I guess it’s my pride. Indifference and/or rejection hurts, while people with many friends, the ones I met, handle disagreement and rejection really well. Maybe it’s a vibe I send like a childish vibe when i am no longer supposed to be that clingy and people can feel like they can depend on me without me turning into their mother hen, trying to please them all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top