How could original sin cause physical death?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Fleeting_Shadow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks fhansen. I knew the Catechism referred to this somewhere but I couldn’t remember where when starting this thread. The Catechism, like St. Athanasius quoted by Ghosty above, clearly presents the teaching that death in the physical sense in the result of original sin.

Some of the previous posters may have misunderstood me - this teaching does not really appeal to me! I would really struggle with it intellectually. My understanding is that the Church rarely pronounces dogmatically on the ‘exact’ meaning of Scriptural passages. The metaphorical approaches above are all valid and, I think, more convincing. Yet, leaving Scripture aside, there is still the issue of Church teaching as outlined in the Catechism.

So then, the relevant question may be: what magisterial category does this teaching fall under? i.e. Are Catholics expected to assent to this particular teaching?

If, as has been written above, cardinals and bishops have disputed the point, it would seem the answer is ‘No’…
Why does this teaching bother you so? It doesn’t contradict human biology at all. In fact, the whole point is that without the Original Grace we fall back to our biology; the immortality of Adam and Eve would have been supernatural in origin. Our natures did not “become mortal” from the Fall, they simply fell to their natural state.

Peace and God bless!
 
Why does this teaching bother you so? It doesn’t contradict human biology at all. In fact, the whole point is that without the Original Grace we fall back to our biology; the immortality of Adam and Eve would have been supernatural in origin. Our natures did not “become mortal” from the Fall, they simply fell to their natural state.

Peace and God bless!
Thanks Ghosty. And thanks for clarifying the teaching earlier. I do understand it better now thanks to responses on this thread.

The teaching seems pretty important to me as it touches on a number of really fundamental religious and existential issues at once: sin, death, the relationship between supernatural grace and natural life, scriptural interpretation, etc. So I wanted to get my head around it.

I think perhaps the teaching troubled/s me a little because:

a) It relies on a strictly literalistic interpretation of a foundational passage in Sacred Scipture which seems inappropriate to the literary genre of those passages (sacred myth/ spiritual allegory). I say this while remaining open to the possibility that the Adam and Even story may poetically describe a primal historical ‘event’.

b) It seems that there is a clear choice between this interpretation on the one hand and the metaphorical approach outlined, for example, in posts 10;14;19 of this thread. The latter style seems to do more justice to the early passages of Scripture.

Either way, ye’ve all given me some food for thought so I’ll chew it over!
 
In original grace, our first parents had preternatural gifts which were withdrawn after the Fall.
👍

Yes death can be present in creation prior to them and around them…but they can be preserved by special gift of God from death.

We too will know this and more in the resurrection!
 
I understand it this way.
Man had a certain condition, exactly as it is today.
And every man thought: “Why we suffer? Why we die? Why do good people do bad things? Why it seems that babies are not born good, for, as you say, they seem angels and sometimes they become devils, kill, assault etc.?”
And they found as we find today that evil comes in families, that if the son is a thief, it is because he was educated by a father who was a thieve already.
And then God (I think no one could give this extraordinary thought to men but God) inspired men to think: “This is not natural. THIS SHOULD NOT BE THIS WAY”. It is an extraordinary idea, for we could think that animals suffer and die like us.
But no. Humankind understood that there is something wrong with this situation, and it is not only me and you and she and he, but EVERYBODY. Men started realizing that this was general
But I jumped one step. God inspired men to realize that we are more than body. Animals are bodies too and I never saw my dog with anguisehd thoughts on whether he would be more than a dog. He is a dog, he is happy to be a dog. Period.
Not men. Men across the Globe, and not only in the Bible, know that men is not from here. Men know that when the beloved ones depart, they are not like the dogs, cows or the beloved horse, who die and finish. They know that they go on and on and on. They pray to the spirits, they go and visit the tombs, they venerate the spirits (and for not understanding this, the Cathlics were expelled from China a few centuries ago, for the Dominicans). The biggest migration on Earth if on the Chinese New Year, when 100 million (!!!) go to their ancestors home to venerate (not aodre as the dominicans transmited to the Pope, which caused Him to abolish the Chinese Rites and the subsequente expulsion from China). They do not venerate the tom of the beloved dog or horse!!!
So, as Plato would put it, men, when they die, go to where they come from. And so if they came from somewhere, this somewhere they put a name on it. The Bible called 2 names: Yaweh and Elohim, thenames of only one God. And they realized that, buy God’s inspiration, the dead were better than here. so, if they were better thean here, before they were born they were better for they went where they came from to. thus the Idea of God as the origin of Happiness and to be away from God the cause of suffering, temporal suffering inthis world, eternal suffering in the other.

I amd saying this in abstract terms and I guess, few people will read this text.
But If I told in a story, everybody would read for it ismuch more intersting. Jesus, the supreme Teacher taught everything in parables. He could do otherwise, buthe knew man.

Hence, the writers of the Bible told everthing is in a story that everyone understood with some errors (remember the idea of the jesus that if someone is sick then he sinned or then it was his father and Jesus said NO?).

My interpretation.
I would agree with this. The Bible is not a historical document, it is a collection of books that are meant to teach us about faith and how to live our lives. There are parts of the Bible that are historically accurate, and there are parts that get fuzzy. There are even passages that are borrowed from ancient Sumerian texts. That does not discredit the Bible, unless you are taking it as a 100% literal historical document.
 
Some good insights here. However, I think it’d be more in line with Catholic thought, as well as with the thoughts of St Athanasius in post #12, to say that, since the beginning of human history, there was never a time when man did not “walk with God”, never a time when man did not know Him, until innocence was somehow lost at a later date. Some might speculate that the story of the Fall is an allegory for innocence lost in the transition from childhood to adulthood, that mans’ perspective inevitably changes-and fear and mistrust set in- as self-consciousness blossoms, but, in any case, the general idea is that at one time all was well, harmony and integrity existed within man, and then he lost it.
Plato said that we came form the World of Ideas and in this world we are imprisoned in the Body and longing to go back where we came form.

I would go for that.

We were created by God. There was that initial moment where we were (mataphorically) in god’s right hand. That woulc be Heaven, Paradise.

And then, we are we. Each one was created in the moment the spermatozoa (?) united to the ovula (?). Then, the Hand of God Created us and we were there, in God’s hand. Of sure, if we were there, we were there. In Heaven, in Paradise.

And we are 9 months in mother’s womb, and we are born to a life of pain.

But we never forget that explosion of happiness when we were in God’s Hand. And we want to go back there.

Call it Heaven, Paradise, God,'s Hand, God’s lap…
 
I think that when something like this bothers you so much, that you should simply remember what a wise man once said:
“Every follower of Christ should have a mental file labelled ‘Awaiting Further Light’”.
I have found it very helpful on all kinds of topics. Although I admit that this is not one of those which has bothered me–but then, **my **mental file and your mental file need not match. (:)Not this side of eternity, that is).
 
I think that when something like this bothers you so much, that you should simply remember what a wise man once said:
“Every follower of Christ should have a mental file labelled ‘Awaiting Further Light’”.
👍
 
Plato said that we came form the World of Ideas and in this world we are imprisoned in the Body and longing to go back where we came form.

I would go for that.

We were created by God. There was that initial moment where we were (mataphorically) in god’s right hand. That woulc be Heaven, Paradise.

And then, we are we. Each one was created in the moment the spermatozoa (?) united to the ovula (?). Then, the Hand of God Created us and we were there, in God’s hand. Of sure, if we were there, we were there. In Heaven, in Paradise.

And we are 9 months in mother’s womb, and we are born to a life of pain.

But we never forget that explosion of happiness when we were in God’s Hand. And we want to go back there.

Call it Heaven, Paradise, God,'s Hand, God’s lap…
This is way off-topic, but what you’re describing is more akin to deism than Catholic teaching. In theism, God is in constant “contact” with us or else we wouldn’t exist. God didn’t just create us and set us afloat, but constantly and from the moment of our creation holds in being since we are fundamentally “of nothing”; without this contact we would literally cease to exist.

Furthermore we have a deeper and more profound contact with God through the Sacraments then we ever do at the moment of our creation, so it can’t be a kind of circle as you propose.

Peace and God bless!
 
Since my reversion about a year ago I’ve come to terms with aspects of the faith that previously troubled me. For example, I see there is no conflict between the reality of biological evolution on the one hand and the scriptural creation narrative properly understood, on the other. I’m even willing to assent (and I never thought I’d say this) to the traditional teaching that the ‘Adam’ and ‘Eve’ figures refer to the first human beings properly understood (they possessed the imago Dei) and that Genesis 2 is historical, albeit presented in a certain literary form.

But I’ve hit a something of a stumbling block… The teaching that original sin brought death into the world is one I’ve always interpreted as refering solely to spiritual death. But it seems that Church teaching is in fact that there would have been no physical death without original sin! This is flatly contradicted by our knowledge of human biology.:confused:

There is definitely an ontological discontinuity between human beings and animals. This is spiritual. But is it not accepted that our material bodies are subject to the same laws as those of our biological ancestors, i.e. death?

I’m a little sheepish asking about this. Maybe I’m interpreting it all far too literalistically - but I don’t think so. The idea is confirmed in the Catholic study Bible I use, in the writings of Augustine, etc.

Could someone please clarify or explain?
Fleeting:

Above you have received some excellent answers along with some not so excellent ones. Please read the following treatise on this subject (it’s short). It is from The Teaching of the Catholic Church, Vol II, particularly Sec. 8. This treatise is but one of two that deal with this subject, in these volumes, but, the other treatise is not available on the internet. If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to ask them.

marys-touch.com/Teaching/X.htm

God bless,
jd
 
Thank you JDaniel for the link, and to all who have posted - this continues to be a fascinating thread for me as it ties into a writing project I am continually researching these theological topics for background for.
 
I like this Custance guy’s essays even though he wasn’t Catholic. He was a Canadian scientist, and wrote some lovely stuff on things like the programmed eternality of the cell. I can’t do justice to this but invite you to pore over the Custance archives.

custance.org/old/seed/ch18s.html

I recall Custance mentioning cells that have been kept alive in laboratories for decades; and the pre-visioning, pre-imagining, pre-conceiving the idea of genetics by one Catholic saint before Catholic monk Gregor Mendel from back-engineering God. Custance led me to imagine that there was a literal toxin or metabolism-changing substance that activated when Adam (not the Woman) ate of the “Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil.” Because Custance says we actually were made to be pretty industrial-grade; and need have only eaten of the Tree of Life to live forever. So I wouldn’t let tunnel vision or a closed mind or lack of imagination or shallow grounding in science dismiss your faith. Sin, after all, isn’t merely a moral failing but one that can entail offenses against one’s Temple of the Holy Spirit that could be called science sins. Gluttony is a science sin, in a way. Moses’ rules included forbidding unsanitary slaughter, and so forth. Original Sin was a breaking of…something. In a larger sense, God’s directives were contravened. That’s sin in itself. But the sin against creation means we had to get recycled through death into eternal life and not make the transition in some other way. Thanks, Jesus Christ.
 
Ummmmmmm, not so sure though. This quote from para 400 of the Catechism seems problematical:
Finally, the consequence explicitly foretold for this disobedience will come true: man will “return to the ground”,285 for out of it he was taken. Death makes its entrance into human history.286
I agree with it all.
But these raises a lot of problems…
 
This is way off-topic, but what you’re describing is more akin to deism than Catholic teaching. In theism, God is in constant “contact” with us or else we wouldn’t exist. God didn’t just create us and set us afloat, but constantly and from the moment of our creation holds in being since we are fundamentally “of nothing”; without this contact we would literally cease to exist.

Furthermore we have a deeper and more profound contact with God through the Sacraments then we ever do at the moment of our creation, so it can’t be a kind of circle as you propose.

Peace and God bless!
No I believe in what you believe: without Christ, we are like the leaves of a tree without the tree. I am not deist.
 
…So then, the relevant question may be: what magisterial category does this teaching fall under? i.e. Are Catholics expected to assent to this particular teaching?

If, as has been written above, cardinals and bishops have disputed the point, it would seem the answer is ‘No’…
*The Catechism of the Catholic Church has been given to us for the purpose of providing
“a full, complete exposition of Catholic doctrine, enabling everyone to know what the Church professes, …” …
“The Church now has at her disposal this new, authoritative exposition of the one and perennial apostolic faith, and it will serve as a …;and as a sure norm for teaching the faith,’ as well as a ‘sure and authentic reference text’ for preparing local catechisms.” *
(From the Apostlic Letter,Laetamur Magnopere, by Pope John Paul II in announcing the approval and promulgation of the Catechism.

Have you read the section in the Catechism section on Original Sin? Here is a link to that section.
vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P1C.HTM

If anyone (cardinal, bishop, or just someone here on the forum) says something that contradicts what is written in the Catechism, then they are not presenting Church teaching, but their own erroneous personal opinion. It’s up to you to read/learn what the Catechism says so you can judge the accuracy of what you hear or read.
 
Catechism on “Death”

**CCC 1008 **Death is a consequence of sin. the Church’s Magisterium, as authentic interpreter of the affirmations of Scripture and Tradition, teaches that death entered the world on account of man’s sin.569 Even though man’s nature is mortal God had destined him not to die. Death was therefore contrary to the plans of God the Creator and entered the world as a consequence of sin.570 “Bodily death, from which man would have been immune had he not sinned” is thus “the last enemy” of man left to be conquered.571

vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P2I.HTM
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top