How do angelic beings see if they dont have eyes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter WannabeSaint
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

WannabeSaint

Guest
I’m not saying they CANT see because they dont have eyes, but find it very confusing how one sees without eyes.

How do angelic beings perceive visual stimuli?
 
Probably because angels aren’t composed of physical matter (according to St. Thomas Aquinas). They don’t need eyes to see because they aren’t confined to a physical Body.
 
Also, consider that “see” is simply a metaphor for the way angels know things, in language we can understand.
 
We are limited by our senses. Something can be inside the box, but our eyes aren’t able to perceive beyond the box. A box can have existed for a thousand years, but we only perceive the box as it is at this moment in time.

So a spiritual entity is more likely to not only perceive the box, but also perceive what’s inside the box, and where the box came from, where it’s been before it got to this point, and perhaps even where the box is likely to end up in the future.

They perceive things in a way that is better than our eyes.
 
How could God “see” before the Incarnation?

Because we see with our eyes, it can be difficult both to imagine someone being able to see without them, and imagining how someone could be aware of their surroundings without having vision. But the Creator of the universe managed to fashion this creation without them.
 
We don’t know how but we know with God many things are possible. Also, consider reports of near death experiences. People report ‘seing’ without eyes or a whole body. Consciousness without brain activity.
 
I believe they see and are portrayed as seeing … even though they don’t have physical eyes.

Not a problem for me to believe … as I sometimes have my eyes closed, and am even asleep … yet
see things … with my eyes closed. Dreams.

Angels see real things. How they do it I haven’t seen recorded in theology.

HOW … can be too big a question to answer completely with our limited human knowledge.

For example: “How can God … ?”

whatever else comes next in the question …

the answer

"We don’t know all the details of HOW … but we do know that He CAN. "

is not far behind. 😉
 
Seeing, if you think about it - even for mortals - implies a sense of movement. This is because we exist in space and time, and it takes us time to do things while transitioning from one point to the next. To see one thing (A) and then look to another (B) requires a movement in time and space from A to B.

But that is how humans move, not angels, although humans can have a sense of how angels move.

According to Thomas Aquinas, angels move by making decisions, although their decisive process is somehow different because they don’t exist in the same time and space.

Their perception of God is immediate and eternal. They aren’t separated in space by a body, so it seems like they are somehow just “everywhere” at once. Similarly, their decisions (motions) wouldn’t exist in time as we think of it, like when we spend a lot of time deliberating over one thing and then another. Their understanding is simply “right there”.

To make such a decision seems to require knowledge of what one is deciding upon. So how do angels see? It’s probably just by knowing God somehow. I once heard angel’s “compete to do good”. I imagine such competition must be something like burning with charity as they constantly move toward (i.e. decide in favor of and bless) God.

But that’s also probably why, when the bad angels fell from grace, it happened all at once at the very the beginning of creation. They saw God’s entire plan all at once and forever, disagreed with it, and that was that… or, in other words, since what they decided against was eternal, they made an eternal choice, and they couldn’t repent… their “movements” (decisions) seem like they could only be from one bad idea to another…

That’s about the best I can do given what little I know. It may not make much sense, but I hope it helps though.
 
Last edited:
We limit ourselves when we think corporeally, carnally. If we enter the transcendent and think spiritually, it opens doors of contemplation.
 
Angels come in many forms. My angels, as I have seen 4 of them come in the form of ordinary humans.

The feeling you get from them is unusually comforting, you don’t feel fear or as if they are “weird”. You’ll know
 
I’m not saying they CANT see because they dont have eyes, but find it very confusing how one sees without eyes.
What i don’t understand is why experiences such as seeing necessarily needs to be the result of physical operations alone. If you accept that physical reality is artificial, then any qualitative effect it has needn’t be the result of it’s laws; it just so happens to be the case that we see with eyes, not that we necessarily need eyes to see.
 
Last edited:
I’m not saying they CANT see because they dont have eyes, but find it very confusing how one sees without eyes.

How do angelic beings perceive visual stimuli?
Angels who are pure spirits with intelligence and will know and see or perceive the material/physical creation with their spiritual intellects as God does who is also a pure Spirit. Angels have a stronger intellectual power than human beings do. By their one intellectual power, angels know and see the material/physical creation which human beings know and see through a couple of soul powers, namely, intellect and sensory powers, and bodily organs such as the eyes as well as the medium of light such as from the sun. Angels know and ‘see/perceive’ physical light and darkness but they don’t need physical light to ‘see’ the material creation as we do and animals. It’s know of hard for us to ‘imagine’ or think how this is so because we are a soul in a body and see things according to our own human nature.

An analogy might be that if we close our eyes we can picture the world outside us, the sun shinning, etc., in our imagination which is seated in a bodily organ such as in the brain. Our imagination is not as vivid as opening our eyes and seeing the world around us. But the angels with their very strong intellectual power ‘see’ the material/physical creation with their intellect such as we do in our imagination or by opening our eyes.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top