How do Catholics keep from putting Mary above Christ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tommy999
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah I think the important thing is to understand the context. The only way you can understand the context is to live and experience the life of the Church. No amount of reading will ever make you understand. Only personal experience can do that.
 
Perhaps you should join an adult Catholic educational course, available at any Catholic Church for people who have in depth questions about the Christian Church, which was established by one of our Lord’s Disciples.
 
Agree to all previous comments above. We Catholics remind ourselves that the Blessed Virgin Mary is only a human who has received God’s ultimate grace of bearing His Son.

Personally every time I venerate Mary in prayer I always remind myself of Jesus since she is His Mother. This keeps me from worshiping her and focus more on Jesus.
 
When I lived in Calcutta, India, the Assembly of God put out a leaflet where they claimed that they asked a Catholic Bishop why he made Mary into a god when she did not die for our sins and how did she redeem the world. According to the leaflet, the bishop started trembling and realised what a terrible mistake he was making and immediately joined the Assembly of God. I told the woman who gave me this leaflet that she was ignorant and if the bishop was trembling then he would have to be a very stupid bishop as even I knew that such a thing was totally contrary to Catholic teaching.
 
It’s not a perfect analogy, but Catholics can spend a lot of time on Mary for much the same reason that protestants would spend a lot of time on their preacher. She’s like our ringleader and spokesperson. She was the proto (first) Christian. It is her and her seed versus Satan and his seed. She’s our mother, commissioned by Christ to the apostles on the cross and given to us for all generations, as an Ark of the New Covenant that leads us into battle.

We believe there is profound theological depth in all the gospels. When Jesus, shortly before dying, gave John to her to be his mother, we don’t believe this was just some nice sentimental act that we are reading about, and then move on to the next passage. No. You have to back up. He was doing something here. This was yet another sacrifice of Christ. This was him handing over his flesh & blood mother into our care, we - his crucifiers - to be our spiritual mother. Mary is an inevitable product of the infinite love of Christ.

There is more to it than that, with how it ties into the important role of family in Catholic theology and the honoring of the father and mother and how it relates to the perfection of Christ’s life. It’s something you just have to read about in depths if you want to gain a better understanding of it.
 
Bible Christians, and no offense to the original poster, have a very hard time wrapping their heads around the fact God PERSONALLY chose Mary. I’ve heard them say “He could’ve picked any girl”. BUT HE DIDN’T. He chose Mary for the 1 purpose.

To the OP, welcome and may God bless.🙂
 
The Mass. The Eucharist. Eucharistic Adoration. The Divine Office.

That is only the beginning. But I do hear what you are saying. Some people and many cultures do venerate Mary so highly I could see why you wonder and ask that question. 🙂
Yes, the questioner has a point. Some people seem to go overboard with veneration of Mary and saints. That’s why we have the Church to reign us in. The Catechism makes it very clear how we should worship. If you step outside of certain borders you don’t follow the rules of the Catholic Church anymore.
 
Timothy,
I did not mean any disrespect. I respect Catholicism very much. I apologize if I did not communicate my point as well as I would have liked, but it is a genuine question.

I assume that most Catholics do differentiate between them and keep them in their proper status. From the outside looking in, though, it seems confusing to me because it appears at times like Mary is right up there in status with the others but then again I am not Catholic. Once again, I apologize if I offended anyone because that was not my intent.
Hi Tommy,

It is what the teaching authority of what the Catholic Church teaches that counts as truth, not what individuals may or may not do who are Catholic.

I personally have not met a Catholic who thinks our Blessed Mother is competing with our Lord Jesus Christ. She is a creature like us, but very highly privileged. She also grew in faith and trust during her time on this earth. We believe she is our mother in the order of grace, and that our Saviour gave her to us at the foot of the Cross.

I can understand your concern that a statue of our Blessed Mother was larger than Jesus’ statue., but, as I explained in my first sentence above, the Catholic Church does not teach that she is above Jesus.

I heard a priest explain that Blessed Mother is like a clear pane of glass that allows the Light of the Holy Trinity to shine through. No smudges.

The Lord created her for Himself, and for us!!! The perfect disciple, the one who said “…all generations shall call me blessed.”

Thank you for asking…feel free to ask other questions if you like.
 
Hi, there…Tommy…well, understanding the Mary from a catholic mindset is one of the most difficult you face in studying the catholic faith.

However, let me borrow the words of a convert named Scott Hahn, in trying to answer your question:

*A friend of mine who had heard I was thinking about the Catholic Church called up one day and said: “Do you worship Mary like those Catholics do?” I said, “They don’t worship Mary; they honor Mary.” “Well, what’s the difference?” I said, “Let me explain. When Christ accepted the call from His Father to become a man, He accepted the responsibility to obey the law, the moral law which is summarized in the Ten Commandments. There’s a commandment which reads, ‘Honor your father and mother.’” I said, “Chris, in the original Hebrew, that word “honor,” kaboda, that Hebrew word means to glorify, to bestow whatever glory and honor you have upon your father and mother. Christ fulfilled that law more perfectly than any human by bestowing His glory upon His heavenly Father and by taking His own divine glory and honoring His Mother with it. All we do in the rosary, Chris, is to imitate Christ who honors His Mother with His own glory. We honor her with Christ’s glory.”
*

And another explanation from this thread, which I borrow, and explain the catholic mindset:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=11012687#post11012687

In hierarchical terms, Mary (human) is higher than us, but infinitely lower than Christ (God and man).

Since the ancients understood their lowlinness in relation to God much better than we do, they naturally were attracted to the 100% human mother, whereby Christ could be accessed through her compassion and lowliness. Men knew they were lowly and unworthy. Mary was a human being, sharing in our lowliness. Yet she was also the Mother of God, and she had her son’s ear! Thus, many were instinctively drawn to approach God through His mother.

Hope this helps.
Hi Pablope,
Yes, that helps very much. I read the link in forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=11012687#post11012687
which helped a lot, too. I would recommend it to any protestant inquirer like me who has a similar questions. I appreciate it a lot! 🙂
 
As Catholic author and evangelical convert Mark Shea puts it: “Mary looks much bigger from outside of the Church than she does from the inside.”.

…The problem for most bible Christians, as I see it, is that they have been exposed only to a very simplified theology. It may be a mile wide, but it is only an inch deep. Catholic and Orthodox liturgy and theology, is like the ocean as compared to the bible Christian river. Really.
I find it interesting that you mention Mark Shea. I just bought his book, ‘By What Authority’
and plan to read it soon.

Compared to Catholicism, I am beginning to think of my church tradition as more like a Motel Six. Thanks, po18guy. Much appreciated, as usual.
 
It’s not a perfect analogy, but Catholics can spend a lot of time on Mary for much the same reason that protestants would spend a lot of time on their preacher. She’s like our ringleader and spokesperson. She was the proto (first) Christian. It is her and her seed versus Satan and his seed. She’s our mother, commissioned by Christ to the apostles on the cross and given to us for all generations, as an Ark of the New Covenant that leads us into battle.

We believe there is profound theological depth in all the gospels. When Jesus, shortly before dying, gave John to her to be his mother, we don’t believe this was just some nice sentimental act that we are reading about, and then move on to the next passage. No. You have to back up. He was doing something here. This was yet another sacrifice of Christ. This was him handing over his flesh & blood mother into our care, we - his crucifiers - to be our spiritual mother. Mary is an inevitable product of the infinite love of Christ.

There is more to it than that, with how it ties into the important role of family in Catholic theology and the honoring of the father and mother and how it relates to the perfection of Christ’s life. It’s something you just have to read about in depths if you want to gain a better understanding of it.
Thanks for the analogy and other insights,TK421.
 
Bible Christians, and no offense to the original poster, have a very hard time wrapping their heads around the fact God PERSONALLY chose Mary. I’ve heard them say “He could’ve picked any girl”. BUT HE DIDN’T. He chose Mary for the 1 purpose.

To the OP, welcome and may God bless.🙂
I realize that Mary had to be a very special and godly girl for God to have chosen her to be the mother of Christ out of all the girls in the world at the time. It is level of attention and devotion that some Catholics pay to her that concerned me. Many of you have helped put that more into perspective. Thanks for the greeting, by the way. 🙂
 
Can you explain how you keep from putting Mary in a higher position than Christ in your life? To me, that sounds like it could be a challenge for Catholics.
Hi Tommy999,

A great question! Thanks for asking!

I suppose the quickest way to answer that is to recognize that honor and veneration of Mary is also worship of God. There’s no way you can separate the two.

Allow me to elaborate: We ask Mary to pray for us. That’s the crux of what Catholic veneration to Mary is. It cannot harm us, in any way, to ask for prayers. Therefore we know that anytime we ask for intercession, either by someone here on Earth or someone up in Heaven, that we are ultimately worshiping God at the same time. Because it is by God’s Holy Spirit that such intercession is even possible.

Hope that helps!
 
Hi Tommy,

It is what the teaching authority of what the Catholic Church teaches that counts as truth, not what individuals may or may not do who are Catholic.

I personally have not met a Catholic who thinks our Blessed Mother is competing with our Lord Jesus Christ. She is a creature like us, but very highly privileged. She also grew in faith and trust during her time on this earth. We believe she is our mother in the order of grace, and that our Saviour gave her to us at the foot of the Cross.

I can understand your concern that a statue of our Blessed Mother was larger than Jesus’ statue., but, as I explained in my first sentence above, the Catholic Church does not teach that she is above Jesus.

I heard a priest explain that Blessed Mother is like a clear pane of glass that allows the Light of the Holy Trinity to shine through. No smudges.

The Lord created her for Himself, and for us!!! The perfect disciple, the one who said “…all generations shall call me blessed.”

Thank you for asking…feel free to ask other questions if you like.
Thanks, Dorothy, for your thoughtful reply. Your analogy makes a lot of sense.
 
Hi everyone,
I was just listening to my local Catholic radio station where I listen to Catholic Answers Live. However, I missed it and tuned in to hear a half hour of continuous Rosary recitations. It was beautiful but troubling to me in a way because it brought back an unpleasant old memory that I will describe below. The way they alternated from men praying the Rosary to women while intejecting music at times was mesmerizing and pretty. However, it made me wonder the following:

How do good Catholics draw the line between venerating Mary and uplifting her so high that her importance equals and competes with that of Christ, God the Father, and the Holy Spirirt?

Unpleasant memory:
Several years ago I was traveling in South America. I remember visiting a prominent park situated on a big hill in Santiago, Chile, (or at least I believe it was Santiago). Toward the bottom of the hill, there was a section of small statues of some saints. About half-way up the hill there was a big statue of Jesus, which I thought was very nice. However, when we got to the top of the hill, there was a gigantic statue of the Virgin Mary with lots of candles and other stuff adorning it.

It made me wonder and I thought to myself, “These folks love Mary more than Christ”.

Having been on this forum for almost a month, I know there are a lot of Catholics who venerate Mary and love and serve God and Christ strongly and sincerely with their whole hearts. I’ve interacted with many of you.

Can you explain how you keep from putting Mary in a higher position than Christ in your life? To me, that sounds like it could be a challenge for Catholics.
For Me and every Catholic I know that is have for what ever reason had to have a discussion of this sort with it is easy. The Blessed Virgin is an example of the way we should all live in response to God. Prayer to her is always directed in asking her to Pray to God with and for us. Just as I may do the same with you.
 
Hi Tommy999,

A great question! Thanks for asking!

I suppose the quickest way to answer that is to recognize that honor and veneration of Mary is also worship of God. There’s no way you can separate the two.

Allow me to elaborate: We ask Mary to pray for us. That’s the crux of what Catholic veneration to Mary is. It cannot harm us, in any way, to ask for prayers. Therefore we know that anytime we ask for intercession, either by someone here on Earth or someone up in Heaven, that we are ultimately worshiping God at the same time. Because it is by God’s Holy Spirit that such intercession is even possible.

Hope that helps!
It *does *help. Thanks!
 
For Me and every Catholic I know that is have for what ever reason had to have a discussion of this sort with it is easy. The Blessed Virgin is an example of the way we should all live in response to God. Prayer to her is always directed in asking her to Pray to God with and for us. Just as I may do the same with you.
Thanks, Ed.
 
Also there is another analogy in the Bible that foretells the role of Mary. Jesus is the King, and his kingdom is not of this world, and Mary is the mother of the King, the Queen. In the time of King Solomon, people would often go to his mother the Queen to make requests of the King. Similarly at the Wedding of Cana they came to the Queen Mary and she interceded on their behalf to ask of Jesus to perform a miracle. This is the analogy that we have in making requests of Mary, the highest of which is to ask her to bring us closer to Christ.
 
Catholics may consider Martin Luther’s advice that we honor the “Queen of Heaven” and trust in Mary’s intercession as the very symbol of holy Mother Church. Luther taught that the holy virgin Mother of God is mentioned right after the Holy Trinity. Urging Christians to maintain personal devotion to Mary but understand that perpetual virginity and assumption are also personal beliefs not necessary for salvation in Christ.
 
Thanks for the additional analogy, AggieCatholic86. It really helps. Thanks for your insights also, EvangelCatholic.

I get the impression that the Lutherans may be one of the closest protestant churches to Catholicism in terms of rites and practices.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top