I didn’t think you would be violent based on anything you said. You sound frustrated and sad. Your message to me was: I want a better relationship. How can I do it?
You are right about the pointlessness of arguing. Neither of you will change the other’s mind!
I will take exception to your statement that you can’t choose to love your dad because he “makes you feel” a certain way and that you are powerless over that. In fact I disagree ENTIRELY!
Our feelings are, by and large, a result of the messages we tell ourselves. For example, I drop a glass and it shatters all over the floor.
Thought A: I am soooo stupid and clumsy! Why do I always mess up!
Thought B: Oh well! I guess I’ll just clean it up. I can always get another glass.
Can you see how your feelings would be different based on these inner messages?
Another example: A man and his wife are driving down the road when they pull up to stop for an approaching car. To their horror they see a little old man in his old jalopy driving down the railroad tracks headed straight for the train! The couple jump out of their car and race to him. They pull him out of his car and get off the rail bed just in time!
The man starts screaming at them! What do you mean pulling me out of my car? Are you carjackers? How dare you?
SITUATION: Train traveling towards crossing.
Man and Woman: Oh my! There is a train! He’ll be killed!
Feelings: Fear, Anxiety, Love, Responsibility
Man: Nice day for a drive! Hey! Look at that train! I sure love to watch them!
Feelings: Calm, Relaxed, Confused
The situation was the same for all of them. But the old man, due to dementia, told himself a different message about the event and his feelings followed his thoughts. Afterwards the couple was relieved and a bit proud that they saved the man, but he was FURIOUS? He wanted to see that train!
NOTE: True story! One of the founders of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy had this experience. I think it was Beck, but idk.
Listen to your inner voices. What are you saying to yourself?
—Oh no! Not another joke. They’re so cheesy and irritating!
—There he goes again thinking he’s always right. How can he be so arrogant! What a pain!
—Well, he just shot me down again. He just doesn’t care about me!
What if you told yourself:
—He so loves telling those silly jokes. I guess it makes him happy.
—He sure has strong feelings about that. I guess he just wants someone to listen
—He doesn’t know what I need. I wish we understood each other better.
I GUARANTEE IT WORKS! You CAN control your emotions to some degree in situations like the ones you describe. It takes time and practice, but eventually telling yourself positive or neutral messages does change your perception and thereby your feelings.