If every denomination believes that they have the truth on any given issue because they are guided by the Holy Spirit when interpreting the bible, why is it that they have contradictory doctrines?
How do they reconcile that?!
That’s one of the main reasons I’m now Catholic instead of Protestant. I was a member of the “Christian Church” (Congregationalists, originally founded by Campbell and Stone). The original object of this denomination was the unity of all Christians (I don’t think the founders considered Catholics Christians) – that’s why it was started. At the time I attended there were three major branches, the churches that normally went by the name Disciples of Christ (we can considered them liberal, they had women preachers, etc), the Christian Church (the branch I was in) and the Churches of Christ (the “antis” as we called them – because they were “anti” many things, like musical instruments in church). Sometimes the “anti” churches were called “Christian Church” as well as the Disciples, but usually this was how you could tell them apart. We basically had nothing to do with the Disciples – in our opinion they had become as liberal as the “mainstream” Protestant churches. Those in the “anti” branch didn’t have much to do with us because, if they saw an organ or piano in the church building they wouldn’t worship with us. But, those in the Christian Church branch would attend services in an “anti” church if there were no others around. My Dad attended an “anti” church for several years until a new preacher came in and demanded that he “renounce” musical instruments in church. They’re kind of legalistic that way.
Now this has been many years ago. When I left this Campbellites (for a lack of a better word) charismaticism (Pentecostalism) was just showing up. Now, apparently, many of these churches have “traditional” services as well as “spirit-filled” ones.
In our Bible studies Baptists would often come to study with us and try to get us to accept their “once saved always saved” doctrine – which we rejected – and it made for some nice arguments. We also baptized for the same reason Catholics baptize, for the remission of sins and so that the Holy Spirit could enter – although we did not believe in infant baptism. At any rate, we definitely rejected Baptist doctrines – there was a saying that we could “beat any Baptist (in an argument) using two axes and and a .38” – referring to Acts 2:38. “Repent and be baptized everyone of you for the remission of sins…”
So, since most evangelicals were “once saved, always saved,” and believed in the rapture and the future rule of Christ on Earth (which most of us didn’t) – the Christian Church was separated from them. We considered Lutherans and Anglicans and other “mainstream” denominations to have never really broken away from the Catholic Church – they had reformed the Church (in our opinion) but we were going to “restore” it. Although “restore” became a touchy word because some of our teachers rightly brought up the fact that the Church could never fail (the gates of hell could not prevail) – so “restoration” didn’t logically fit.
At any rate, I’ll quit rambling. Even though we used to say “We’re Christians only, but not the only Christians” we also spoke a lot about how “narrow is the road to salvation and few there are who find it.” We also had a saying (which I didn’t realize at the time was basically taken from St. Francis) “In essentials unity, In non-essentials liberty and in all things charity.” Of course we basically figured that mostly applied to members of our three branches and the many splinter groups. I knew of one church that actually split over the color of the carpets in the new church building.
And I said I was going to stop rambling… At any rate, lack of doctrinal unity is the main reason why I left the “Christian Church.” It took many, many years before I finally came to the Catholic Church – even though, intellectually, I believed it was the One, True, Catholic and Apostolic Church for years.