How do Protestants reconcile this incongruous issue?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LaSalle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

LaSalle

Guest
If every denomination believes that they have the truth on any given issue because they are guided by the Holy Spirit when interpreting the bible, why is it that they have contradictory doctrines?

How do they reconcile that?!
 
The answer I’ve always heard (well, except for the crazies who actually believe that anybody-Catholic or Protestant-who believes differently is wrong not actually Christian or “saved”) is that the points on which they disagree are not “essential doctrines.” But it’s still kind of a cop-out, because some of these so-called “nonessential doctrines” are things like Baptism: infant vs. believers’, efficacious (sp?) vs. symbolic, necessary vs. not. That seems pretty essential to me 🤷 Then of course, there’s the question of how ones decides what is an essential doctrine and what is not. I’ve never heard an answer to that one that made any sense to me. 🤷

In Christ,

Ellen
 
I’ve heard ALLGIRLS’ response. I’ve also heard the question-dodge response which attempts to claim not all Catholics have “agreed” on all doctrines throughout history. First, by giving this response, the Protestant validates Catholicism as equal to themselves because they try to say “you do the same as us.” Secondly, they not only evade the question, but they neglect to acknowledge that from the times of Acts 15 or any council, that doctrines can be resolved in the Church authoritatively. The Holy Spirit will sort such diversity in the corporate Church on matters of faith or morals through the authentic successors of the Apostles. In Protestantism, there is no “authority” but the individual reading the Bible for himself—at least that’s the teaching of the Westminster Confession of Faith, which in practice is followed by just about every Protestant I know.

You can see the ineffectiveness of this in practice. From the dawn of the Reformation, views on such matters of faith like Baptism or the Eucharist have never been resolved. Lutherans said they confer grace. Zwingli went so far as to say: “I know that all the sacraments are so far from conferring grace that they do not even convey or dispense it.” Rather than the matter resolved conciliarly, they have been instead sifted like wheat with even more diverse opinions, further demonstrating that they do not bear the teaching guarantee of the Holy Spirit in faith or morals.
 
If every denomination believes that they have the truth on any given issue because they are guided by the Holy Spirit when interpreting the bible, why is it that they have contradictory doctrines?

How do they reconcile that?!
My experience as a Protestant was that we simply ignored the existence of other Protestant churches. If they contradicted our teachings, they were just obviously wrong, and that was that. At the same time, on controversial issues where different church members held different ideas, or when our leadership would make an abrupt departure from previous teachings, we would say, “we are not Catholics. We don’t claim to be infallible.”

I don’t think I actually noticed any contradictions in that until the summer of 2000, when at a General Council assembly, it seemed to me that the Holy Spirit abruptly changed His mind three times in the space of about half an hour. Evolution of spirituality over time - some things the Holy Spirit deemed “correct” for previous generations but not for ours - I got. That, though, was inexplicable. 🤷

That’s about the same time I started surfing the Internet looking for answers about the Catholic Church, and I received my First Reconciliation, Confirmation and First Holy Communion in April of 2001. 😃
 
I have been the chairman of my churches Sunday School commitee for a good number of years. We as a commitee reveiw the teaching materal used in our Sunday School. I along with the commitee have over the years conclued that of all the Protestant materal published could be used by any protestant demonation and the end results would be the same
 
I have been the chairman of my churches Sunday School commitee for a good number of years. We as a commitee reveiw the teaching materal used in our Sunday School. I along with the commitee have over the years conclued that of all the Protestant materal published could be used by any protestant demonation and the end results would be the same
All protestant publications are can be used in any denomination? Respectfully, I think that is impossible. Some churches (yours may or may not be among them) believe that if you give a one time profession of faith you are saved no matter what you do later. It is called the “once saved always saved” doctrine. Most Christians do not subscribe to this, yet the mainly American evangelicals who have come up with this doctrine in the last 100 years or so insist that it is true (and many are convinced that their beliefs are in the majority, rather than the minority of Christianity). They are supposedly led by the Holy Spirit to interpret a few isolated texts to come up with this unbiblical doctrine, while the rest of Christianity says that you have to persevere in faith until the end-- which, of course, is affirmed by the Catholic Church and by scripture. How could materials affirming OSAS be used in a church that does not subscribe to that?

Many other issues divide protestant denominations, some are seemingly minor, some are not. Some believe in intercessory prayer, some don’t, some believe that Jesus is present in their communion in some way, others believe communion is purely symbolic, some believe in original sin, some don’t. In my humble opinion, it seems impossible that all the denominations are being led by the Holy Spirit.
 
Where I’m from the idea is the same as has been posted above; if you actually accept Jesus, you will have the Holy Spirit moving in you… which will teach you everything you need to know. Although we definitely fall in protestantism, we simply say that the RCC/Orthodox position could be right and can be proven right if my spiritual journey agrees with their teachings, regardless of whether or not they accept me.

There are several issues that make this form of “religion” difficult: there is little inheritance of ideas as opposed to having a denomination doctrine, finding “ecumenical” communities that are still serious about their faith, and the fact that you personally are forced with encountering all doctrinal issues…

An example would be that I’m the only Protestant I know that believes in the mendicant orders… I don’t believe in them because I followed along with RCC doctrine but because that is the course that God has set for my life. At the same time, not practicing the sacrament of foot washing, as was set by Jesus in John, seems as strange to me as the veneration of icons in the Orthodox Church seems to Protestants…

Make sense???

Ninja Edit (to better address something posted while I was writing this):
"Many other issues divide protestant denominations, some are seemingly minor, some are not. Some believe in intercessory prayer, some don’t, some believe that Jesus is present in their communion in some way, others believe communion is purely symbolic, some believe in original sin, some don’t. In my humble opinion, it seems impossible that all the denominations are being led by the Holy Spirit. "

The majority of Spirituality is at best a facade… I personally find it nearly impossible to believe that a person who has truly humbled himself before God has the ability to openly state that a person is condemned for all eternity because they believed that Genesis was symbolic… after everything in a person’s life… In many ways, such as this, have I seen the leadership of churches corrupted. Whether communion is symbolic or not, just ask God if it bothers you so much… it isn’t like he stopped answering honest prayers.
 
I have been the chairman of my churches Sunday School commitee for a good number of years. We as a commitee reveiw the teaching materal used in our Sunday School. I along with the commitee have over the years conclued that of all the Protestant materal published could be used by any protestant demonation and the end results would be the same
I strongly doubt that Whole People of God, a liberal Protestant publication, would be considered suitable for most Evangelical-style churches. Likewise, there would be issues with some of the work of David C. Cook at most liberal Protestant churches. There may be a certain amount of overlap in ideas, but taken as a whole, I think most Sunday School programs are best suited to churches that subscribe to the same schools of theology that produced them.
 
Where I’m from the idea is the same as has been posted above; if you actually accept Jesus, you will have the Holy Spirit moving in you… which will teach you everything you need to know. Although we definitely fall in protestantism, we simply say that the RCC/Orthodox position could be right and can be proven right if my spiritual journey agrees with their teachings, regardless of whether or not they accept me.
I am confident that everyone who sincerely loves Jesus is being led to become a Catholic. It’s equally obvious that not everyone is answering the call.
There are several issues that make this form of “religion” difficult: there is little inheritance of ideas as opposed to having a denomination doctrine, finding “ecumenical” communities that are still serious about their faith, and the fact that you personally are forced with encountering all doctrinal issues…
One person cannot live long enough to solve them all, which is why God gave us the Holy Tradition. 😉
An example would be that I’m the only Protestant I know that believes in the mendicant orders… I don’t believe in them because I followed along with RCC doctrine but because that is the course that God has set for my life.
I have no idea what this means. Are you a member of a mendicant order, without being Catholic? :confused:
At the same time, not practicing the sacrament of foot washing, as was set by Jesus in John, seems as strange to me as the veneration of icons in the Orthodox Church seems to Protestants…
In the Catholic Church, we have the footwashing every Holy Thursday. I have never heard of it called a “sacrament” before, though.
Whether communion is symbolic or not, just ask God if it bothers you so much… it isn’t like he stopped answering honest prayers.
Be careful what you pray for - everyone I know who prayed sincerely about it, has ended up Catholic. 🙂
 
I am confident that everyone who sincerely loves Jesus is being led to become a Catholic. It’s equally obvious that not everyone is answering the call.
I have no problem with that. Have you heard some of the Protestant preachers proclaim “prosperity doctrine”? They say that God hates poverty and that poverty is a curse, more or less. I’ve had people tell me that is the true church and I will eventually join them… I’ll just keep doing what I feel God is calling me to do and see where I end up.
One person cannot live long enough to solve them all, which is why God gave us the Holy Tradition. 😉
Na, the thief on the cross lived long enough to get it right.
I have no idea what this means. Are you a member of a mendicant order, without being Catholic? :confused:
Monasticism exists in all forms of the true Church.
In the Catholic Church, we have the footwashing every Holy Thursday. I have never heard of it called a “sacrament” before, though.
Wasn’t it ordained by Jesus? Why isn’t it a “sacrament” to YOU (don’t want copy from RCC catechism)? How does your Parish do this, I believe it isn’t real clear in the catechism, do you wash the person to your right’s feet or do you say that the priest is Jesus and have him wash everyone’s feet?
Be careful what you pray for - everyone I know who prayed sincerely about it, has ended up Catholic. 🙂
I have no problem with the RCC if it is True… maybe the priests I met were corrupted, hey “wherever the body is, there the vultures will gather.”
 
I have no problem with that. Have you heard some of the Protestant preachers proclaim “prosperity doctrine”? They say that God hates poverty and that poverty is a curse, more or less. I’ve had people tell me that is the true church and I will eventually join them… I’ll just keep doing what I feel God is calling me to do and see where I end up.
I think a quick scan through Matthew 25 dispels that one.
Na, the thief on the cross lived long enough to get it right.
He had the advantage of being crucified with Christ in a somewhat more literal way than most of us get - also, he wasn’t comparing thousands of Protestant doctrines with each other and with Catholic doctrine to try to figure out which set is correct.
Monasticism exists in all forms of the true Church.
Yes. Which leaves you with Catholicism and Orthodoxy. 🙂
Wasn’t it ordained by Jesus?
No. When Jesus said “Do this in remembrance of Me” He was referring to the Eucharist.
Why isn’t it a “sacrament” to YOU (don’t want copy from RCC catechism)?
Because the Apostles were never commanded to repeat the ritual for others.
How does your Parish do this, I believe it isn’t real clear in the catechism, do you wash the person to your right’s feet or do you say that the priest is Jesus and have him wash everyone’s feet?
Neither. We re-enact the scene by having 12 men come forward and have their feet washed by the priest.
I have no problem with the RCC if it is True… maybe the priests I met were corrupted, hey “wherever the body is, there the vultures will gather.”
🙂
 
I think a quick scan through Matthew 25 dispels that one.
Sounds crazy to me to, but many people believe it.
He had the advantage of being crucified with Christ in a somewhat more literal way than most of us get - also, he wasn’t comparing thousands of Protestant doctrines with each other and with Catholic doctrine to try to figure out which set is correct.
Exactly, because “comparing thousands of Protestant doctrines with each other and with Catholic doctrine to try to figure out which set is correct” isn’t what is going to save you.
Yes. Which leaves you with Catholicism and Orthodoxy. 🙂
I’m sure you’ve offended more than one Protestant out there, you should apologize. 😛
Don’t worry, most Protestants don’t even realize that some denominations have monasteries and convents. I’ve had fun conversations with ministers who didn’t know it about their own denomination.
No. When Jesus said “Do this in remembrance of Me” He was referring to the Eucharist. Because the Apostles were never commanded to repeat the ritual for others.
Read John 13: 14-17 from your preferred version… tell me what it says. Then pray for guidance.
 
I have been the chairman of my churches Sunday School commitee for a good number of years. We as a commitee reveiw the teaching materal used in our Sunday School. I along with the commitee have over the years conclued that of all the Protestant materal published could be used by any protestant demonation and the end results would be the same
As a Lutheran I taught Sunday School and VBS. I can tell you that this is simply not true.

Annie (former LCMS) now, by His grace, Catholic
 
Exactly, because “comparing thousands of Protestant doctrines with each other and with Catholic doctrine to try to figure out which set is correct” isn’t what is going to save you.
The thief on the cross did everything he could to follow Christ after his conversion. This included a confession of Christ, which included the act of publicly defending Christ, and included suffering for the Gospel as best as he could for the remainder of his life. We should do the same and follow Christ as best we can for the remainder of our lives. Paul of course taught to adhere to sound doctrine, so of course, doctrine is important and related to our journey with Christ. Paul even taught us how to identify false doctrine and how to identify sound doctrine. After all, Christ Himself is Truth. And we must strive to know Christ if we are His children.

If we dismiss sound doctrine as unimportant, we necessarily dismiss Jesus Christ.
 
If every denomination believes that they have the truth on any given issue because they are guided by the Holy Spirit when interpreting the bible, why is it that they have contradictory doctrines?

How do they reconcile that?!
That’s one of the main reasons I’m now Catholic instead of Protestant. I was a member of the “Christian Church” (Congregationalists, originally founded by Campbell and Stone). The original object of this denomination was the unity of all Christians (I don’t think the founders considered Catholics Christians) – that’s why it was started. At the time I attended there were three major branches, the churches that normally went by the name Disciples of Christ (we can considered them liberal, they had women preachers, etc), the Christian Church (the branch I was in) and the Churches of Christ (the “antis” as we called them – because they were “anti” many things, like musical instruments in church). Sometimes the “anti” churches were called “Christian Church” as well as the Disciples, but usually this was how you could tell them apart. We basically had nothing to do with the Disciples – in our opinion they had become as liberal as the “mainstream” Protestant churches. Those in the “anti” branch didn’t have much to do with us because, if they saw an organ or piano in the church building they wouldn’t worship with us. But, those in the Christian Church branch would attend services in an “anti” church if there were no others around. My Dad attended an “anti” church for several years until a new preacher came in and demanded that he “renounce” musical instruments in church. They’re kind of legalistic that way.

Now this has been many years ago. When I left this Campbellites (for a lack of a better word) charismaticism (Pentecostalism) was just showing up. Now, apparently, many of these churches have “traditional” services as well as “spirit-filled” ones.

In our Bible studies Baptists would often come to study with us and try to get us to accept their “once saved always saved” doctrine – which we rejected – and it made for some nice arguments. We also baptized for the same reason Catholics baptize, for the remission of sins and so that the Holy Spirit could enter – although we did not believe in infant baptism. At any rate, we definitely rejected Baptist doctrines – there was a saying that we could “beat any Baptist (in an argument) using two axes and and a .38” – referring to Acts 2:38. “Repent and be baptized everyone of you for the remission of sins…”

So, since most evangelicals were “once saved, always saved,” and believed in the rapture and the future rule of Christ on Earth (which most of us didn’t) – the Christian Church was separated from them. We considered Lutherans and Anglicans and other “mainstream” denominations to have never really broken away from the Catholic Church – they had reformed the Church (in our opinion) but we were going to “restore” it. Although “restore” became a touchy word because some of our teachers rightly brought up the fact that the Church could never fail (the gates of hell could not prevail) – so “restoration” didn’t logically fit.

At any rate, I’ll quit rambling. Even though we used to say “We’re Christians only, but not the only Christians” we also spoke a lot about how “narrow is the road to salvation and few there are who find it.” We also had a saying (which I didn’t realize at the time was basically taken from St. Francis) “In essentials unity, In non-essentials liberty and in all things charity.” Of course we basically figured that mostly applied to members of our three branches and the many splinter groups. I knew of one church that actually split over the color of the carpets in the new church building.

And I said I was going to stop rambling… At any rate, lack of doctrinal unity is the main reason why I left the “Christian Church.” It took many, many years before I finally came to the Catholic Church – even though, intellectually, I believed it was the One, True, Catholic and Apostolic Church for years.
 
The thief on the cross did everything he could to follow Christ after his conversion. This included a confession of Christ, which included the act of publicly defending Christ, and included suffering for the Gospel as best as he could for the remainder of his life. We should do the same and follow Christ as best we can for the remainder of our lives. Paul of course taught to adhere to sound doctrine, so of course, doctrine is important and related to our journey with Christ. Paul even taught us how to identify false doctrine and how to identify sound doctrine. After all, Christ Himself is Truth. And we must strive to know Christ if we are His children.

If we dismiss sound doctrine as unimportant, we necessarily dismiss Jesus Christ.
I whole heartily believe in sound doctrine and please forgive me if I appeared to denounce it. My point was, as you stated, “we should do the same and follow Christ as best we can for the remainder of our lives.” Remember that I’m replying to, “One person cannot live long enough to solve them all, which is why God gave us the Holy Tradition.”

That clarify everything?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top